Diphosphadiboretanes

Last updated
General structure of diphosphadiboretane where R is a substituent group Diphosphadiboretane.png
General structure of diphosphadiboretane where R is a substituent group
Diphosphadiboretane
Names
IUPAC name
1,3-diphosphonia-2,4-diboranuidacyclobutane
Identifiers
3D model (JSmol)
PubChem CID
  • InChI=1S/B2H8P2/c1-3-2-4-1/h1-4H2
    Key: SVSGFPJVCAXIEE-UHFFFAOYSA-N
  • [BH2-]1[PH2+][BH2-][PH2+]1
Properties
B2H8P2
Molar mass 91.64 g/mol
Except where otherwise noted, data are given for materials in their standard state (at 25 °C [77 °F], 100 kPa).

1,3-Diphospha-2,4-diboretanes, or B2P2, is a class of 4-member cyclic compounds of alternating boron and phosphorus atoms. They are often found as dimers during the synthesis of boraphosphenes (RB=PR'). [1] Compounds can exhibit localized singlet diradical character (diradicaloid) between the boron atoms in the solution and solid state. [2]

Contents

Synthesis

The first suggested synthesis of a diphosphadiboretane compound was with phosphinoarylboranes dimerization in 1961. [3] Concurrently, a diphosphadiboretane was determined to be produced from the reaction with phosphinosilanes and boron halides. [4] [5] The following thermolysis treatment formed boraphosphenes by cleavage of the σ P-Si bonds. Dimerization of these compounds are highly favored (upward to 90 kcal mol−1), which results in isolated diphosphadiboretanes. [1] Alternative routes of synthesis utilizing facile leaving groups have also been discovered including hydrogen halide and organylphosphane elimination to obtain the monomer precursors. Treatment with boron halides with lithium phosphides have also been found to lead to monomers which then dimerize into the diphosphadiboretanes. [6]

Thermolysis of facile silyl halide leaving group forms boraphosphane from silylphosphine and tribromobromide. Boraphosphane dimerizes, leaving diphosphadiboretane. Synthesis of Diphosphadiboretane from Silyl Halide Elimination.png
Thermolysis of facile silyl halide leaving group forms boraphosphane from silylphosphine and tribromobromide. Boraphosphane dimerizes, leaving diphosphadiboretane.

In 2002, a direct synthesis to a diphosphadiboretanediyl, a diphosphadiboretane derivative, was accomplished using 1,2-dichlorodiborane and a lithium phosphide reagent. [2]

Formation of singlet diradical diphosphaboretanediyl using 1,2-dichloro-1,2-di(tert-butyl)diborane with lithium diisopropylphosphide reagent. Direct Synthesis of Stable Singlet Diphosphadiboretane.png
Formation of singlet diradical diphosphaboretanediyl using 1,2-dichloro-1,2-di(tert-butyl)diborane with lithium diisopropylphosphide reagent.

In 2021, it was found that the phosphination of diboryne using diphosphate would slowly convert to diphosphadiboretane in solution. [7]

Synthesis of diphosphadiboretane using reactive diboryne precursor with tetraethyldiphosphine (Dep = 2,6-diethyl phenyl). Synthesis of Diphosphadiboretanes from Diboryne Precursor.png
Synthesis of diphosphadiboretane using reactive diboryne precursor with tetraethyldiphosphine (Dep = 2,6-diethyl phenyl).

Structure and bonding

Structural range of diphosphadiboretanediyl (phosphorus = orange; boron = pink, R = white). General Diphosphadiboretane Structural Isomerisation.png
Structural range of diphosphadiboretanediyl (phosphorus = orange; boron = pink, R = white).

X-ray crystallography

Diphosphadiboretanes can be isolated as single crystals suitable for x-ray crystallography. [1] [5] [6] [7] The structure is found to be planar, with a near-square geometry. The B-B distance is found to be ranging from 2.57-2.71 Å, indicating a long B-B single bond. The phosphorus atoms adopt pyramidal geometries, which are preferred over a planar geometry and prevents π-bonding with the boron atoms. [2] [6]

Planar and bicyclic structure

The diphosphadiboretanediyl derivatives have a wider structural range, adopting planar and bicyclo[1.1.0] geometries, similar to diphosphacylobutanediyls. [8] These geometries can be modulated by changing the substituents on the boron or phosphorus atoms. This conversion is accompanied by lengthening and shortening of the B-B bond, respectively. Addition of more steric, protecting groups on the boron atoms and less steric groups on the phosphorus atoms favor the bicyclo[1.1.0] structure. The latter is due to reduction of 1,3-diaxial strain. Coplanar π-bonding to the boron atom and addition of aromatic groups to the ring favors the bicyclo[1.1.0] structure with a B-B bond length shorten down to 1.83 Å. [1] [8]

Diradical

2D contour plot of electron localization function of hydrogen-substituted diphosphadiboretanediyl. Displayed plane contains both B-H bonds and is perpendicular to plane of B2P2 ring. Contour lines between B atoms indicates through-space interactions. 2D Contour Plot of Electron Localization Function of Diphosphadiboretane Without Frame.png
2D contour plot of electron localization function of hydrogen-substituted diphosphadiboretanediyl. Displayed plane contains both B-H bonds and is perpendicular to plane of B2P2 ring. Contour lines between B atoms indicates through-space interactions.

In the planar, diphosphadiboretanediyl structures, the substantially long B-B bond can be considered to experience homolytic cleavage to form a localized singlet diradicaloid between the boron atoms. [8] The singlet state energy can be up to 20-35 kcal mol−1 more stabilized than the triplet state. [9] Addition of π-donors on the boron atom is found to increase the singlet-triplet gap, while π-acceptors decrease it. The bicyclo[1.1.0] structure, with a shorter B-B bond, is considered to have less diradical character and more of a closed-shell system. [8]

Frontier orbitals

The HOMO of these diphosphadiboretanediyls consists of a π-orbital with strong boron p-orbital character. [2] This orbital is stabilized by the presence of π-overlap between the trans-boron atoms (through-space interactions) as well as through-bond contributions by the σ* P-R orbitals. Due to the presence of the through-space interaction, computational studies have determined these compounds to have significantly less diradical character than traditional organic diradicals. [10] [11] The LUMO is the antibonding π* B-B orbital. [7]

Frontier orbitals of hydrogen-substituted diphosphadiboretanediyl compound in square/diradical geometry. HOMO-LUMO of Diphosphadiboretane (Planar).png
Frontier orbitals of hydrogen-substituted diphosphadiboretanediyl compound in square/diradical geometry.

Reactivity

Transition metals

Diphosphadiboretanes have been shown to behave as ligands to metal-carbonyl complexes, forming boron-mononuclear, boron-binuclear, η3, and η4 architectures with displacement of CO ligands. [12] If steric, amino-containing substituents on the boron are used, then a cycloreversion reaction happens. This results in the production of metal-stabilized boraphosphene. Cage compounds (B2P2M, M = Pd, Pt) have also be reported with η2 coordination to the P atoms. [13]

Coordination of diphosphadiboretanetetradyl derivative by chromium(0) pentacarbonyl tetrahydrofuran results in the cycloreversion of the dimer to boraphosphene, stabilized by mono-coordination to the phosphorus atom. Cycloreversion of Diphosphadiboretane with Chromium Carbonyl Complexes Corrected.png
Coordination of diphosphadiboretanetetradyl derivative by chromium(0) pentacarbonyl tetrahydrofuran results in the cycloreversion of the dimer to boraphosphene, stabilized by mono-coordination to the phosphorus atom.

Oxidation

Synthesis of diphosphadiboretane from diboryne offers a two electron-rich compound, compared to diphosphadiboretanediyls. [7] These electrons can be readily oxidized, affording the radical cation compound and diphsophadiboretanediyl compound. The radical cation is found to exhibit triplet state by electronic paramagnetic resonance, accompanying with a shortening of the B-B bond (2.63 Å) and slight perturbance of planar, square structure. The diphosphadiboretanediyl compound is found to have a B-B bond of 2.12 Å and the transition to the bicyclo[1.1.0] structure. Natural bond orbital analysis of phosphadiboretanediyl compound indicates a bent B-B bond with a small 3 kcal mol−1 stabilization energy compared to the planar structure.

One and two electron oxidation of diphosphadiboretane synthesized from diboryne offers radical cation and dication species. The dication exhibits a butterfly-type structure (Dep = 2,6-diethyl phenyl). Diphosphadiboretane Oxidation Structure Change Corrected.png
One and two electron oxidation of diphosphadiboretane synthesized from diboryne offers radical cation and dication species. The dication exhibits a butterfly-type structure (Dep = 2,6-diethyl phenyl).

Diradical activity

Diphosphadiboretanediyls exhibits reactivity similar to radicals, behaving as diradical intermediates. [8] The compounds have been shown to perform chloride abstraction from deuterated chloroform, trans-addition of trimethyl tin hydride, and formation of bicyclo[1.1.1] structure with selenium. Reactivity is displayed towards bromotrichloromethane where radical activity induces formation of boron-containing spiro-compound from the tert-butyl group. This cyclic formation maintains the diphosphadiboretane ring structure.

Reaction between di(diisopropylphospha)-di(tert-butyl)boretanediyl with bromotrichloromethane leads to bromine atom addition on a boron atom, boron spiro-complex formation, and trichloromethane byproduct. Diphosphadiboretane Reactivity with BrCCl3.png
Reaction between di(diisopropylphospha)-di(tert-butyl)boretanediyl with bromotrichloromethane leads to bromine atom addition on a boron atom, boron spiro-complex formation, and trichloromethane byproduct.

Related Research Articles

<span class="mw-page-title-main">Conjugated system</span> System of connected p-orbitals with delocalized electrons in a molecule

In theoretical chemistry, a conjugated system is a system of connected p-orbitals with delocalized electrons in a molecule, which in general lowers the overall energy of the molecule and increases stability. It is conventionally represented as having alternating single and multiple bonds. Lone pairs, radicals or carbenium ions may be part of the system, which may be cyclic, acyclic, linear or mixed. The term "conjugated" was coined in 1899 by the German chemist Johannes Thiele.

<span class="mw-page-title-main">Ring strain</span> Instability in molecules with bonds at unnatural angles

In organic chemistry, ring strain is a type of instability that exists when bonds in a molecule form angles that are abnormal. Strain is most commonly discussed for small rings such as cyclopropanes and cyclobutanes, whose internal angles are substantially smaller than the idealized value of approximately 109°. Because of their high strain, the heat of combustion for these small rings is elevated.

<span class="mw-page-title-main">Cycloheptene</span> Chemical compound

Cycloheptene is a 7-membered cycloalkene with a flash point of −6.7 °C. It is a raw material in organic chemistry and a monomer in polymer synthesis. Cycloheptene can exist as either the cis- or the trans-isomer.

<span class="mw-page-title-main">Homoaromaticity</span> Organic molecular structure

Homoaromaticity, in organic chemistry, refers to a special case of aromaticity in which conjugation is interrupted by a single sp3 hybridized carbon atom. Although this sp3 center disrupts the continuous overlap of p-orbitals, traditionally thought to be a requirement for aromaticity, considerable thermodynamic stability and many of the spectroscopic, magnetic, and chemical properties associated with aromatic compounds are still observed for such compounds. This formal discontinuity is apparently bridged by p-orbital overlap, maintaining a contiguous cycle of π electrons that is responsible for this preserved chemical stability.

<span class="mw-page-title-main">Boroxine</span> 6-sided cyclic compound of oxygen and boron

Boroxine is a 6-membered heterocyclic compound composed of alternating oxygen and singly-hydrogenated boron atoms. Boroxine derivatives such as trimethylboroxine and triphenylboroxine also make up a broader class of compounds called boroxines. These compounds are solids that are usually in equilibrium with their respective boronic acids at room temperature. Beside being used in theoretical studies, boroxine is primarily used in the production of optics.

<span class="mw-page-title-main">Phosphinidene</span>

Phosphinidenes are low-valent phosphorus compounds analogous to carbenes and nitrenes, having the general structure RP. The "free" form of these compounds is conventionally described as having a singly-coordinated phosphorus atom containing only 6 electrons in its valence level. Most phosphinidenes are highly reactive and short-lived, thereby complicating empirical studies on their chemical properties. In the last few decades, several strategies have been employed to stabilize phosphinidenes, and researchers have developed a number of reagents and systems that can generate and transfer phosphinidenes as reactive intermediates in the synthesis of various organophosphorus compounds.

Boroles represent a class of molecules known as metalloles, which are heterocyclic 5-membered rings. As such, they can be viewed as structural analogs of cyclopentadiene, pyrrole or furan, with boron replacing a carbon, nitrogen and oxygen atom respectively. They are isoelectronic with the cyclopentadienyl cation C5H+5(Cp+) and comprise four π electrons. Although Hückel's rule cannot be strictly applied to borole, it is considered to be antiaromatic due to having 4 π electrons. As a result, boroles exhibit unique electronic properties not found in other metalloles.

<span class="mw-page-title-main">Borylene</span>

A borylene is the boron analogue of a carbene. The general structure is R-B: with R an organic moiety and B a boron atom with two unshared electrons. Borylenes are of academic interest in organoboron chemistry. A singlet ground state is predominant with boron having two vacant sp2 orbitals and one doubly occupied one. With just one additional substituent the boron is more electron deficient than the carbon atom in a carbene. For this reason stable borylenes are more uncommon than stable carbenes. Some borylenes such as boron monofluoride (BF) and boron monohydride (BH) the parent compound also known simply as borylene, have been detected in microwave spectroscopy and may exist in stars. Other borylenes exist as reactive intermediates and can only be inferred by chemical trapping.

<span class="mw-page-title-main">Digermyne</span> Class of chemical compounds

Digermynes are a class of compounds that are regarded as the heavier digermanium analogues of alkynes. The parent member of this entire class is HGeGeH, which has only been characterized computationally, but has revealed key features of the whole class. Because of the large interatomic repulsion between two Ge atoms, only kinetically stabilized digermyne molecules can be synthesized and characterized by utilizing bulky protecting groups and appropriate synthetic methods, for example, reductive coupling of germanium(II) halides.

<span class="mw-page-title-main">Phosphirenium ion</span> Series of chemical compounds

Phosphirenium ions are a series of organophosphorus compounds containing unsaturated three-membered ring phosphorus (V) heterocycles and σ*-aromaticity is believed to be present in such molecules. Many of the salts containing phosphirenium ions have been isolated and characterized by NMR spectroscopy and X-ray crystallography.

<span class="mw-page-title-main">Diphosphagermylene</span>

Diphosphagermylenes are a class of compounds containing a divalent germanium atom bound to two phosphorus atoms. While these compounds resemble diamidocarbenes, such as N-heterocyclic carbenes (NHC), diphosphagermylenes display bonding characteristics distinct from those of diamidocarbenes. In contrast to NHC compounds, in which there is effective N-C p(π)-p(π) overlap between the lone pairs of planar nitrogens and an empty p-orbital of a carbene, systems containing P-Ge p(π)-p(π) overlap are rare. Until 2014, the geometry of phosphorus atoms in all previously reported diphosphatetrylenes are pyramidal, with minimal P-Ge p(π)-p(π) interaction. It has been suggested that the lack of p(π)-p(π) in Ge-P bonds is due to the high energetic barrier associated with achieving a planar configuration at phosphorus, which would allow for efficient p(π)-p(π) overlap between the phosphorus lone pair and the empty P orbital of Ge. The resulting lack of π stabilization contributes to the difficulty associated with isolating diphosphagermylene and the Ge-P double bonds. However, utilization of sterically encumbering phosphorus centers has allowed for the isolation of diphosphagermylenes with a planar phosphorus center with a significant P-Ge p(π)-p(π) interaction.

A phosphetane is a 4-membered organophosphorus heterocycle. The parent phosphetane molecule, which has the formula C3H7P, is one atom larger than phosphiranes, one smaller than phospholes, and is the heavy-atom analogue of azetidines. The first known phosphetane synthesis was reported in 1957 by Kosolapoff and Struck, but the method was both inefficient and hard to reproduce, with yields rarely exceeding 1%. A far more efficient method was reported in 1962 by McBride, whose method allowed for the first studies into the physical and chemical properties of phosphetanes. Phosphetanes are a well understood class of molecules that have found broad applications as chemical building blocks, reagents for organic/inorganic synthesis, and ligands in coordination chemistry.

<span class="mw-page-title-main">Silylone</span> Class of organosilicon compounds

Silylones are a class of zero-valent monatomic silicon complexes, characterized as having two lone pairs and two donor-acceptor ligand interactions stabilizing a silicon(0) center. Synthesis of silylones generally involves the use of sterically bulky carbenes to stabilize highly reactive Si(0) centers. For this reason, silylones are sometimes referred to siladicarbenes. To date, silylones have been synthesized with cyclic alkyl amino carbenes (cAAC) and bidentate N-heterocyclic carbenes (bis-NHC). They are capable of reactions with a variety of substrates, including chalcogens and carbon dioxide.

Boron porphyrins are a variety of porphyrin, a common macrocycle used for photosensitization and metal trapping applications, that incorporate boron. The central four nitrogen atoms in a porphyrin macrocycle form a unique molecular pocket which is known to accommodate transition metals of various sizes and oxidation states. Due to the diversity of binding modes available to porphyrin, there is a growing interest in introducing other elements into this pocket.

<span class="mw-page-title-main">Phosphenium</span> Divalent cations of phosphorus

Phosphenium ions, not to be confused with phosphonium or phosphirenium, are divalent cations of phosphorus of the form [PR2]+. Phosphenium ions have long been proposed as reaction intermediates.

<span class="mw-page-title-main">Triboracyclopropenyl</span>

The triboracyclopropenyl fragment is a cyclic structural motif in boron chemistry, named for its geometric similarity to cyclopropene. In contrast to nonplanar borane clusters that exhibit higher coordination numbers at boron (e.g., through 3-center 2-electron bonds to bridging hydrides or cations), triboracyclopropenyl-type structures are rings of three boron atoms where substituents at each boron are also coplanar to the ring. Triboracyclopropenyl-containing compounds are extreme cases of inorganic aromaticity. They are the lightest and smallest cyclic structures known to display the bonding and magnetic properties that originate from fully delocalized electrons in orbitals of σ and π symmetry. Although three-membered rings of boron are frequently so highly strained as to be experimentally inaccessible, academic interest in their distinctive aromaticity and possible role as intermediates of borane pyrolysis motivated extensive computational studies by theoretical chemists. Beginning in the late 1980s with mass spectrometry work by Anderson et al. on all-boron clusters, experimental studies of triboracyclopropenyls were for decades exclusively limited to gas-phase investigations of the simplest rings (ions of B3). However, more recent work has stabilized the triboracyclopropenyl moiety via coordination to donor ligands or transition metals, dramatically expanding the scope of its chemistry.

<span class="mw-page-title-main">Nontrigonal pnictogen compounds</span>

Nontrigonal pnictogen compounds refer to tricoordinate trivalent pnictogen compounds that are not of typical trigonal pyramidal molecular geometry. By virtue of their geometric constraint, these compounds exhibit distinct electronic structures and reactivities, which bestow on them potential to provide unique nonmetal platforms for bond cleavage reactions.

<span class="mw-page-title-main">9-Borafluorene</span> Class of chemical compounds

9-borafluorenes are a class of boron-containing heterocycles consisting of a tricyclic system with a central BC4 ring with two fused arene groups. 9-borafluorenes can be thought of as a borole with two fused arene rings, or as a trigonal planar boron atom with an empty p orbital bridging two biphenyl rings. However, 9-borafluorenes are generally less reactive than boroles due to less antiaromatic character and Lewis acidity. Containing highly conjugated π systems, 9-borafluorenes possess interesting photophysical properties. In addition, 9-borafluorenes are good Lewis acids. This combination of properties enables potential uses such as in light-emitting materials, solar cells, and sensors for some molecules.

<i>N</i>-Heterocyclic carbene boryl anion Isoelectronic structure

An N-heterocyclic carbene boryl anion is an isoelectronic structure of an N-heterocyclic carbene (NHC), where the carbene carbon is replaced with a boron atom that has a -1 charge. NHC boryl anions have a planar geometry, and the boron atom is considered to be sp2-hybridized. They serve as extremely strong bases, as they are very nucleophilic. They also have a very strong trans influence, due to the σ-donation coming from the boron atom. NHC boryl anions have stronger electron-releasing character when compared to normal NHCs. These characteristics make NHC boryl anions key ligands in many applications, such as polycyclic aromatic hydrocarbons, and more commonly low oxidation state main group element bonding.

Heteroatomic multiple bonding between group 13 and group 15 elements are of great interest in synthetic chemistry due to their isoelectronicity with C-C multiple bonds. Nevertheless, the difference of electronegativity between group 13 and 15 leads to different character of bondings comparing to C-C multiple bonds. Because of the ineffective overlap between p𝝅 orbitals and the inherent lewis acidity/basicity of group 13/15 elements, the synthesis of compounds containing such multiple bonds is challenging and subject to oligomerization. The most common example of compounds with 13/15 group multiple bonds are those with B=N units. The boron-nitrogen-hydride compounds are candidates for hydrogen storage. In contrast, multiple bonding between aluminium and nitrogen Al=N, Gallium and nitrogen (Ga=N), boron and phosphorus (B=P), or boron and arsenic (B=As) are less common.

References

  1. 1 2 3 4 Kölle, Peter; Linti, Gerald; Nöth, Heinrich; Wood, Gary L.; Narula, Chaitanya K.; Paine, Robert T. (May 1988). "Contributions to the chemistry of boron, 188. Synthesis and Structures of New 1,3,2,4‐Diphosphadiboretanes". Chemische Berichte. 121 (5): 871–879. doi:10.1002/cber.19881210510. ISSN   0009-2940.
  2. 1 2 3 4 Scheschkewitz, David; Amii, Hideki; Gornitzka, Heinz; Schoeller, Wolfgang W.; Bourissou, Didier; Bertrand, Guy (2002-03-08). "Singlet Diradicals: from Transition States to Crystalline Compounds". Science. 295 (5561): 1880–1881. Bibcode:2002Sci...295.1880S. doi:10.1126/science.1068167. ISSN   0036-8075. PMID   11884750. S2CID   11482396.
  3. Coates, G. E.; Livingstone, J. G. (1961). "203. Aminodiarylboranes and their phosphorus and arsenic analogues". Journal of the Chemical Society (Resumed): 1000–1008. doi:10.1039/jr9610001000. ISSN   0368-1769.
  4. Nöth, Heinrich; Schrägle, Wolfgang (1961-07-01). "Notizen: Über eine neue Methode zur Darstellung von Bor-Phosphor-Verbindungen". Zeitschrift für Naturforschung B. 16 (7): 473–474. doi:10.1515/znb-1961-0715. ISSN   1865-7117. S2CID   94179759.
  5. 1 2 Nöth, Heinrich; Schrägle, Wolfgang (February 1965). "Beiträge zur Chemie des Bors, XXXII. Zur Synthese dimerer und trimerer Phosphino‐borane". Chemische Berichte. 98 (2): 352–362. doi:10.1002/cber.19650980205. ISSN   0009-2940.
  6. 1 2 3 Arif, Atta M.; Cowley, Alan H.; Pakulski, Marek; Power, John M. (1986). "Diphospha- and diarsa-diboretanes. Four-membered rings containing boron and phosphorus or arsenic". Journal of the Chemical Society, Chemical Communications (11): 889–890. doi:10.1039/c39860000889. ISSN   0022-4936.
  7. 1 2 3 4 Brückner, Tobias; Fantuzzi, Felipe; Stennett, Tom E.; Krummenacher, Ivo; Dewhurst, Rian D.; Engels, Bernd; Braunschweig, Holger (2021-06-07). "Isolation of Neutral, Mono‐, and Dicationic B 2 P 2 Rings by Diphosphorus Addition to a Boron−Boron Triple Bond". Angewandte Chemie International Edition. 60 (24): 13661–13665. doi:10.1002/anie.202102218. ISSN   1433-7851. PMC   8252364 . PMID   33844394.
  8. 1 2 3 4 5 Rodriguez, Amor; Präsang, Carsten; Gandon, Vincent; Bourg, Jean-Baptiste; Bertrand, Guy (2005-12-01). "Stable Singlet Diradicals Based on Boron and Phosphorus". In Lattman, Michael; Kemp, Richard A. (eds.). Modern Aspects of Main Group Chemistry. ACS Symposium Series. Vol. 917. Washington, DC: American Chemical Society. doi:10.1021/bk-2005-0917.ch006. ISBN   978-0-8412-3926-5.
  9. Schoeller, Wolfgang W.; Rozhenko, Alexander; Bourissou, Didier; Bertrand, Guy (2003-08-04). "On the Electronic Structures of the 1,3-Diboracyclobutane-1,3-diyls and Their Valence Isomers with a B2E2 Skeleton (E=N, P, As)". Chemistry - A European Journal. 9 (15): 3611–3617. doi:10.1002/chem.200204508. PMID   12898688.
  10. Jung, Yousung; Head-Gordon, Martin (2003-09-01). "Controlling the Extent of Diradical Character by Utilizing Neighboring Group Interactions". The Journal of Physical Chemistry A. 107 (38): 7475–7481. Bibcode:2003JPCA..107.7475J. doi:10.1021/jp034467i. ISSN   1089-5639.
  11. Cheng, Mu-Jeng; Hu, Ching-Han (2003-05-10). "B 2 P 2 rings: through-space π bond or stable diradical? A theoretical study". Molecular Physics. 101 (9): 1319–1323. Bibcode:2003MolPh.101.1319C. doi:10.1080/0026897031000092995. ISSN   0026-8976. S2CID   98739709.
  12. Kaufmann, Bernhard; Nöth, Heinrich; Paine, Robert T.; Polborn, Kurt; Thomann, Martina (October 1993). "Carbonyl-Metal Complexes of Diphosphadiboretane (mesB-P t Bu) 2 and of Triphosphatriborinanes (mesBP t Bu) 3". Angewandte Chemie International Edition in English. 32 (10): 1446–1448. doi:10.1002/anie.199314461.
  13. Chen, Tuqiang; Duesler, Eileen N.; Paine, Robert T.; Nöth, Heinrich (1998-02-01). "Formation of Cage Compounds Containing Boron, Phosphorus, and Transition Metal Atoms". Inorganic Chemistry. 37 (3): 490–495. doi:10.1021/ic970965s. ISSN   0020-1669. PMID   11670299.