Plum pudding model

Last updated
A 1905 diagram by J. J. Thomson illustrating his proposed arrangements of electrons in an atom, ranging from one to eight electrons. Thomson atom electron arrangements.jpg
A 1905 diagram by J. J. Thomson illustrating his proposed arrangements of electrons in an atom, ranging from one to eight electrons.
An atom with seven electrons, arranged in a pentagonal dipyramid, as imagined by Thomson in 1905. Thomson atom seven electrons.svg
An atom with seven electrons, arranged in a pentagonal dipyramid, as imagined by Thomson in 1905.

The plum pudding model is an obsolete scientific model of the atom. It was first proposed by J. J. Thomson in 1904 [1] following his discovery of the electron in 1897, but before Ernest Rutherford discovered the atomic nucleus in 1911. The model tried to account for two properties of atoms then known: that there are electrons and that atoms have no net electric charge. Logically there had to be a commensurate quantity of positive charge to balance out the negative charge of the electrons, but having no clue as to the source of this positive charge, Thomson tentatively proposed it was everywhere in the atom, the atom being in the shape of a sphere. Following from this, Thomson imagined that the balance of electrostatic forces in the atom would distribute the electrons in a more or less even manner throughout this hypothetical sphere. [2]

Contents

Thomson's model is popularly referred to as the "plum pudding model" with the notion that the electrons are distributed with similar density as raisins in a plum pudding. Neither Thomson nor his colleagues ever used this analogy. [3] It seems to have been a conceit of popular science writers to make the model accessible to the layman. The analogy is perhaps misleading because Thomson likened the sphere to a liquid rather than a solid since he thought the electrons moved around in it. [4]

Overview

Thomson used this analogy to visualize the arrangement of electrons in his model of the atom. There are magnetized needles floating in water, oriented such that they repel each other, but are simultaneously attracted to the electromagnet suspended above the center of the pool. This analogy is limited because it is two-dimensional. Thomson corpuscular theory of matter fig25.jpg
Thomson used this analogy to visualize the arrangement of electrons in his model of the atom. There are magnetized needles floating in water, oriented such that they repel each other, but are simultaneously attracted to the electromagnet suspended above the center of the pool. This analogy is limited because it is two-dimensional.

It had been known for many years that atoms contain negatively charged subatomic particles. Thomson called them "corpuscles" (particles), but they were more commonly called "electrons", the name G. J. Stoney had coined for the "fundamental unit quantity of electricity" in 1891. [5] It had also been known for many years that atoms have no net electric charge. Thomson held that atoms must also contain some positive charge that cancels out the negative charge of their electrons. [6] [7] Thomson published his proposed model in the March 1904 edition of the Philosophical Magazine , the leading British science journal of the day. In Thomson's view:

... the atoms of the elements consist of a number of negatively electrified corpuscles enclosed in a sphere of uniform positive electrification, ... [8]

Thomson's model was the first to assign a specific inner structure to an atom, though his original description did not include mathematical formulas. [3] [9] He had followed the work of William Thomson (later Lord Kelvin) who had written a paper proposing a vortex atom in 1867, [10] J.J. Thomson abandoned his 1890 "nebular atom" hypothesis, based on the vortex theory of the atom, in which atoms were composed of immaterial vortices and suggested there were similarities between the arrangement of vortices and periodic regularity found among the chemical elements. [11] Thomson based his atomic model on known experimental evidence of the day, and in fact, followed Lord Kelvin's lead again as Kelvin had proposed a positive sphere atom a year earlier. [12] [13] Thomson's proposal, based on Kelvin's model of a positive volume charge, served to guide future experiments.

The main objective of Thomson's model after its initial publication was to account for the electrically neutral and chemically varied state of the atom. [8] Electron orbits were stable under classical mechanics. When an electron moves away from the center of the positively charged sphere it is subjected to a greater net positive inward force due to the presence of more positive charge inside its orbit (see Gauss's law ). Electrons were free to rotate in rings that were further stabilized by interactions among the electrons, and spectroscopic measurements were meant to account for energy differences associated with different electron rings. As for the properties of matter, Thomson believed they arose from electrical effects. He further emphasized the need of a theory to help picture the physical and chemical aspects of an atom using the theory of corpuscles and positive charge. [14] Thomson attempted unsuccessfully to reshape his model to account for some of the major spectral lines experimentally known for several elements. [15] After the scientific discovery of radioactivity, Thomson decided to address it in his model by stating:

... we must face the problem of the constitution of the atom, and see if we can imagine a model which has in it the potentiality of explaining the remarkable properties shown by radio-active substances ... [16]

Thomson's model changed over the course of its initial publication, finally becoming a model with much more mobility containing electrons revolving in the dense field of positive charge rather than a static structure. Despite this, the colloquial nickname "plum pudding" was soon attributed to Thomson's model as the distribution of electrons within its positively charged region of space reminded many scientists of raisins, then called "plums", in the common English dessert, plum pudding. [3]

Refutation

Between 1908 and 1913, Ernest Rutherford, Hans Geiger, and Ernest Marsden collaborated on a series of experiments in which they bombarded metal foils with a beam of alpha particles so as to study how the foils scattered said beam. Gold was their preferred material because gold is very malleable and can therefore be made into an especially thin foil. The found that the gold foil could scatter alpha particles by more than 90 degrees. This should not have been possible according to the Thomson model. The scattering should have been negligible. The positive charge in the Thomson model is too diffuse to produce an electric field of sufficient strength to cause such scattering. Rutherford deduced that the positive charge of the atom, along with most of the atom's mass, was concentrated in a tiny nucleus at the center of the atom. Only such an intense concentration of charge, anchored by its high mass, could have scattered the alpha particle beam so dramatically.

As an important example of a scientific model, the plum pudding model has motivated and guided several related scientific problems.

Mathematical Thomson problem

A particularly useful mathematics problem related to the plum pudding model is the optimal distribution of equal point charges on a unit sphere, called the Thomson problem. The Thomson problem is a natural consequence of the plum pudding model in the absence of its uniform positive background charge. [17] [18]

Origin of the nickname

Not Thomson's preferred analogy. Jersey Christmas pudding podin d'flieu.jpg
Not Thomson's preferred analogy.

The first known writer to compare Thomson's model to a plum pudding was an anonymous reporter who wrote an article for the British pharmaceutical magazine The Chemist and Druggist in August 1906.

While the negative electricity is concentrated on the extremely small corpuscle, the positive electricity is distributed throughout a considerable volume. An atom would thus consist of minute specks, the negative corpuscles, swimming about in a sphere of positive electrification, like raisins in a parsimonious plum-pudding, units of negative electricity being attracted toward the centre, while at the same time repelling each other. [19]

The analogy was never used by Thomson nor his colleagues. It seems to have been a conceit of popular science writers to make the model easier to understand for the layman. [3]

Related Research Articles

<span class="mw-page-title-main">Atom</span> Smallest unit of a chemical element

Atoms are the basic particles of the chemical elements. An atom consists of a nucleus of protons and generally neutrons, surrounded by an electromagnetically bound swarm of electrons. The chemical elements are distinguished from each other by the number of protons that are in their atoms. For example, any atom that contains 11 protons is sodium, and any atom that contains 29 protons is copper. Atoms with the same number of protons but a different number of neutrons are called isotopes of the same element.

<span class="mw-page-title-main">Atomic orbital</span> Function describing an electron in an atom

In quantum mechanics, an atomic orbital is a function describing the location and wave-like behavior of an electron in an atom. This function describes the electron's charge distribution around the atom's nucleus, and can be used to calculate the probability of finding an electron in a specific region around the nucleus.

<span class="mw-page-title-main">History of atomic theory</span> History of atomic physics

Atomic theory is the scientific theory that matter is composed of particles called atoms. The definition of the word "atom" has changed over the years in response to scientific discoveries. Initially, it referred to a hypothetical concept of there being some fundamental particle of matter, too small to be seen by the naked eye, that could not be divided. Then the definition was refined to being the basic particles of the chemical elements, when chemists observed that elements seemed to combine with each other in ratios of small whole numbers. Then physicists discovered that these particles had an internal structure of their own and therefore perhaps did not deserve to be called "atoms", but renaming atoms would have been impractical by that point.

<span class="mw-page-title-main">Cathode ray</span> Beam of electrons observed in vacuum tubes

Cathode rays or electron beams (e-beam) are streams of electrons observed in discharge tubes. If an evacuated glass tube is equipped with two electrodes and a voltage is applied, glass behind the positive electrode is observed to glow, due to electrons emitted from the cathode. They were first observed in 1859 by German physicist Julius Plücker and Johann Wilhelm Hittorf, and were named in 1876 by Eugen Goldstein Kathodenstrahlen, or cathode rays. In 1897, British physicist J. J. Thomson showed that cathode rays were composed of a previously unknown negatively charged particle, which was later named the electron. Cathode-ray tubes (CRTs) use a focused beam of electrons deflected by electric or magnetic fields to render an image on a screen.

<span class="mw-page-title-main">Electron</span> Elementary particle with negative charge

The electron is a subatomic particle with a negative one elementary electric charge. Electrons belong to the first generation of the lepton particle family, and are generally thought to be elementary particles because they have no known components or substructure. The electron's mass is approximately 1/1836 that of the proton. Quantum mechanical properties of the electron include an intrinsic angular momentum (spin) of a half-integer value, expressed in units of the reduced Planck constant, ħ. Being fermions, no two electrons can occupy the same quantum state, per the Pauli exclusion principle. Like all elementary particles, electrons exhibit properties of both particles and waves: They can collide with other particles and can be diffracted like light. The wave properties of electrons are easier to observe with experiments than those of other particles like neutrons and protons because electrons have a lower mass and hence a longer de Broglie wavelength for a given energy.

<span class="mw-page-title-main">Electric charge</span> Electromagnetic property of matter

Electric charge is the physical property of matter that causes it to experience a force when placed in an electromagnetic field. Electric charge can be positive or negative. Like charges repel each other and unlike charges attract each other. An object with no net charge is referred to as electrically neutral. Early knowledge of how charged substances interact is now called classical electrodynamics, and is still accurate for problems that do not require consideration of quantum effects.

<span class="mw-page-title-main">Nuclear physics</span> Field of physics that studies atomic nuclei

Nuclear physics is the field of physics that studies atomic nuclei and their constituents and interactions, in addition to the study of other forms of nuclear matter.

<span class="mw-page-title-main">J. J. Thomson</span> British physicist (1856–1940)

Sir Joseph John Thomson was a British physicist and Nobel Laureate in Physics, credited with the discovery of the electron, the first subatomic particle to be found.

Le Sage's theory of gravitation is a kinetic theory of gravity originally proposed by Nicolas Fatio de Duillier in 1690 and later by Georges-Louis Le Sage in 1748. The theory proposed a mechanical explanation for Newton's gravitational force in terms of streams of tiny unseen particles impacting all material objects from all directions. According to this model, any two material bodies partially shield each other from the impinging corpuscles, resulting in a net imbalance in the pressure exerted by the impact of corpuscles on the bodies, tending to drive the bodies together. This mechanical explanation for gravity never gained widespread acceptance.

<span class="mw-page-title-main">Rutherford scattering experiments</span> Experiments proving existence of atomic nuclei

The Rutherford scattering experiments were a landmark series of experiments by which scientists learned that every atom has a nucleus where all of its positive charge and most of its mass is concentrated. They deduced this after measuring how an alpha particle beam is scattered when it strikes a thin metal foil. The experiments were performed between 1908 and 1913 by Hans Geiger and Ernest Marsden under the direction of Ernest Rutherford at the Physical Laboratories of the University of Manchester.

<span class="mw-page-title-main">Hantaro Nagaoka</span> Japanese physicist

Hantaro Nagaoka was a Japanese physicist and a pioneer of Japanese physics during the Meiji period.

Corpuscle or corpuscule, meaning a "small body", is often used as a synonym for particle. It may also refer to:

Quantum mechanics is the study of matter and its interactions with energy on the scale of atomic and subatomic particles. By contrast, classical physics explains matter and energy only on a scale familiar to human experience, including the behavior of astronomical bodies such as the moon. Classical physics is still used in much of modern science and technology. However, towards the end of the 19th century, scientists discovered phenomena in both the large (macro) and the small (micro) worlds that classical physics could not explain. The desire to resolve inconsistencies between observed phenomena and classical theory led to a revolution in physics, a shift in the original scientific paradigm: the development of quantum mechanics.

The objective of the Thomson problem is to determine the minimum electrostatic potential energy configuration of N electrons constrained to the surface of a unit sphere that repel each other with a force given by Coulomb's law. The physicist J. J. Thomson posed the problem in 1904 after proposing an atomic model, later called the plum pudding model, based on his knowledge of the existence of negatively charged electrons within neutrally-charged atoms.

<span class="mw-page-title-main">Rutherford model</span> First atomic structure proposal to include a nucleus and electron orbits

The Rutherford model was devised by Ernest Rutherford to describe an atom. Rutherford directed the Geiger–Marsden experiment in 1909, which suggested, upon Rutherford's 1911 analysis, that J. J. Thomson's plum pudding model of the atom was incorrect. Rutherford's new model for the atom, based on the experimental results, contained new features of a relatively high central charge concentrated into a very small volume in comparison to the rest of the atom and with this central volume containing most of the atom's mass; this region would be known as the atomic nucleus. The Rutherford model was subsequently superseded by the Bohr model.

<span class="mw-page-title-main">Atomic nucleus</span> Core of an atom; composed of nucleons (protons and neutrons)

The atomic nucleus is the small, dense region consisting of protons and neutrons at the center of an atom, discovered in 1911 by Ernest Rutherford based on the 1909 Geiger–Marsden gold foil experiment. After the discovery of the neutron in 1932, models for a nucleus composed of protons and neutrons were quickly developed by Dmitri Ivanenko and Werner Heisenberg. An atom is composed of a positively charged nucleus, with a cloud of negatively charged electrons surrounding it, bound together by electrostatic force. Almost all of the mass of an atom is located in the nucleus, with a very small contribution from the electron cloud. Protons and neutrons are bound together to form a nucleus by the nuclear force.

<span class="mw-page-title-main">Alpha particle</span> Ionizing radiation particle of two protons and two neutrons

Alpha particles, also called alpha rays or alpha radiation, consist of two protons and two neutrons bound together into a particle identical to a helium-4 nucleus. They are generally produced in the process of alpha decay but may also be produced in other ways. Alpha particles are named after the first letter in the Greek alphabet, α. The symbol for the alpha particle is α or α2+. Because they are identical to helium nuclei, they are also sometimes written as He2+
or 4
2
He2+
indicating a helium ion with a +2 charge. Once the ion gains electrons from its environment, the alpha particle becomes a normal helium atom 4
2
He
.

The rms charge radius is a measure of the size of an atomic nucleus, particularly the proton distribution. The proton radius is about one femtometre = 10−15 metre. It can be measured by the scattering of electrons by the nucleus. Relative changes in the mean squared nuclear charge distribution can be precisely measured with atomic spectroscopy.

The vortex theory of the atom was a 19th-century attempt by William Thomson to explain why the atoms recently discovered by chemists came in only relatively few varieties but in very great numbers of each kind. Based on the idea of stable, knotted vortices in the ether or aether, it contributed an important mathematical legacy.

<span class="mw-page-title-main">History of subatomic physics</span> Chronological listing of experiments and discoveries

The idea that matter consists of smaller particles and that there exists a limited number of sorts of primary, smallest particles in nature has existed in natural philosophy at least since the 6th century BC. Such ideas gained physical credibility beginning in the 19th century, but the concept of "elementary particle" underwent some changes in its meaning: notably, modern physics no longer deems elementary particles indestructible. Even elementary particles can decay or collide destructively; they can cease to exist and create (other) particles in result.

References

  1. "Plum Pudding Model". Universe Today . 27 August 2009. Retrieved 19 December 2015.
  2. J. J. Thomson (1907). The Corpuscular Theory of Matter, p. 103: "In default of exact knowledge of the nature of the way in which positive electricity occurs in the atom, we shall consider a case in which the positive electricity is distributed in the way most amenable to mathematical calculation, i.e., when it occurs as a sphere of uniform density, throughout which the corpuscles are distributed."
  3. 1 2 3 4 Giora Hon; Bernard R. Goldstein (6 September 2013). "J. J. Thomson's plum-pudding atomic model: The making of a scientific myth". Annalen der Physik. 525 (8–9): A129–A133. Bibcode:2013AnP...525A.129H. doi:10.1002/andp.201300732.
  4. J. J. Thomson, in a letter to Oliver Lodge dated 11 April 1904, quoted in Davis & Falconer (1997):
    "With regard to positive electrification I have been in the habit of using the crude analogy of a liquid with a certain amount of cohesion, enough to keep it from flying to bits under its own repulsion. I have however always tried to keep the physical conception of the positive electricity in the background because I have always had hopes (not yet realised) of being able to do without positive electrification as a separate entity and to replace it by some property of the corpuscles."
  5. O'Hara, J. G. (March 1975). "George Johnstone Stoney, F.R.S., and the Concept of the Electron". Notes and Records of the Royal Society of London . 29 (2): 265–276. doi:10.1098/rsnr.1975.0018. JSTOR   531468. S2CID   145353314.
  6. "Discovery of the electron and nucleus (article)". Khan Academy . Retrieved 9 February 2021.
  7. Alviar-Agnew, Marissa; Agnew, Henry (4 April 2016). "4.3: The Nuclear Atom". Introductory Chemistry. LibreTexts . Retrieved 9 February 2021.
  8. 1 2 Thomson, J. J. (March 1904). "On the Structure of the Atom: an Investigation of the Stability and Periods of Oscillation of a number of Corpuscles arranged at equal intervals around the Circumference of a Circle; with Application of the Results to the Theory of Atomic Structure". Philosophical Magazine . Sixth series. 7 (39): 237–265. doi:10.1080/14786440409463107. Archived (PDF) from the original on 2022-10-09.
  9. Thomson, J. J. (December 1899). "On the masses of the ions in gases at low pressures". The London, Edinburgh, and Dublin Philosophical Magazine and Journal of Science . 48 (295): 547–567. doi:10.1080/14786449908621447.
  10. Thomson, William (1869). "On Vortex Atoms". Proceedings of the Royal Society of Edinburgh . 6: 94–105. doi:10.1017/S0370164600045430.
  11. Kragh, Helge (2002). Quantum Generations: A History of Physics in the Twentieth Century (Reprint ed.). Princeton University Press. pp. 43–45. ISBN   978-0691095523.
  12. Models of the Atom, Michael Fowler, University of Virginia https://galileo.phys.virginia.edu/classes/252/more_atoms.html#Plum%20Pudding
  13. Kumar, Manjit, Quantum Einstein, Bohr and the Great Debate, ISBN   978-0393339888, 2008.
  14. E. R. (1908). "The Corpuscular Theory of Matter". Nature . 77 (2005): 505–506. Bibcode:1908Natur..77..505R. doi:10.1038/077505a0. S2CID   36356538.
  15. Models of the Atom, Michael Fowler, University of Virginia https://galileo.phys.virginia.edu/classes/252/more_atoms.html#Plum%20Pudding
  16. Thomson, J. J. (1904). Electricity and Matter. Mrs. Hepsa Ely Silliman Memorial Lectures. New Haven: Yale University Press. ISBN   978-0-686-83533-2.
  17. Levin, Y.; Arenzon, J. J. (2003). "Why charges go to the Surface: A generalized Thomson Problem". Europhys. Lett. 63 (3): 415–418. arXiv: cond-mat/0302524 . Bibcode:2003EL.....63..415L. doi:10.1209/epl/i2003-00546-1. S2CID   250764497.
  18. Roth, J. (2007-10-24). "Description of a highly symmetric polytope observed in Thomson's problem of charges on a hypersphere". Physical Review E. 76 (4): 047702. Bibcode:2007PhRvE..76d7702R. doi:10.1103/PhysRevE.76.047702. ISSN   1539-3755. PMID   17995142. Although Thomson's model has been outdated for a long time by quantum mechanics, his problem of placing charges on a sphere is still noteworthy.
  19. "What is Matter?". The Chemist and Druggist. 69 (8): 329–330. 25 August 1906.

Bibliography