1902 cholera outbreak of the Philippines

Last updated

The 1902 cholera outbreak of the Philippines began in Manila in March 1902 and the first wave ended in February 1903. [1] This was followed by a second wave from May 1903 to April 1904. [2] [3] Cholera, a disease familiar to both Filipinos and American medical officers, spread throughout the archipelago during the aftermath of the Philippine–American War. [3] [1] The cholera epidemic reappeared again in 1908. [3]

Contents

Burning of lighthouse infected with cholera at Tondo district, Manila (c. 1902) Burning of cholera district in Manila 1902.jpg
Burning of lighthouse infected with cholera at Tondo district, Manila (c.1902)

Epidemic

First cases

On March 3, 1902, the Insular Government at Manila was notified of an "Asiatic cholera" found in Canton, China. On March 8, the spread of the disease reached Hongkong. On March 20, the board of health which consists of U.S. Army medical officers, was notified that two patients at the San Juan de Dios Hospital was showing symptoms of this Asiatic cholera. [4]

Due to the worrying cases of the patients, Lieutenant General Adna Romanza Chaffee, Military Governor of the Philippines at the time, conducted an armed patrol near the Marikina River. Chaffee shared information that the Marikina River could pose "danger" to the inhabitants living there, especially to the estimated 14,000 inhabitants in Montalban. He informed that the water from the river are used for drinking, bathing, and other domestic uses. Due to the pollution of the river, infection soon broke out in the Marikina Valley. [5]

Spread

Cholera infections occur when contaminated water is consumed, often due to "fecal matter". This was the case of worries on contaminated bodies of waters by American officials. An alleged outbreak in the Philippines were also suspected to began when locals consumed cabbage washed ashore from an infected Chinese trading ship. Although the origin is contested, Charles E. Woodruff, a U.S. Army surgeon noted that uncooked vegetables can harbor bacteria from infectious diseases, contributing to their spread when eaten. [6]

The aftermath of the war with Filipino revolutionaries further exacerbate the spread of cholera. [6] As the number of infections grew in Manila, the disease began to spread in other Philippine provinces. [7]

#ProvinceDate
Reported first appearance of Asiatic cholera in Filipino provinces [7]
Luzon
1 Bulacan March 23, 1902
2 Cavite March 27, 1902
3 Bataan March 28, 1902
4 Ambos Camarines April 2, 1902
5 Rizal April 2, 1902
6 Laguna April 7, 1902
7 Pampanga April 13, 1902
8 Pangasinan April 24, 1902
9 Tarlac April 28, 1902
10 Nueva Ecija May 8, 1902
11 Batangas May 24, 1902
12 Mindoro June 10, 1902
13 Tayabas June 13, 1902
14 Zambales July 1, 1902
15 Marinduque July 1, 1902
16 Benguet July 4, 1902
17 Sorsogon October 15, 1902
18 Romblon October 30, 1902
Visayas
19 Leyte May 9, 1902
20 Samar May 29, 1902
21 Cebu July 14, 1902
22 Western Negros August 26, 1902
23 Iloilo August 28, 1902
24 Capiz September 8, 1902
25 Eastern Negros September 29, 1902
26 Antique October 2, 1902
Mindanao
27 Surigao September 5, 1902
28 Misamis October 2, 1902

Response

Philippine Military Governor, Adna R. Chaffee Gen. Adna R. Chaffee, half-length portrait, facing left, in uniform LCCN97508364 (cropped).jpg
Philippine Military Governor, Adna R. Chaffee
Board of Health for the Philippine Islands and Presidents of Provincial Boards of Health at the time of the 1902 cholera outbreak Board of Health for the Philippine Islands and Presidents of Provincial Board of Health.png
Board of Health for the Philippine Islands and Presidents of Provincial Boards of Health at the time of the 1902 cholera outbreak

Under Chaffee, certain measures were taken to combat a cholera outbreak in Manila. It was divided into sanitary districts, and medical officers were assigned to each. The sale of certain foods was prohibited, and strict inspections of markets and restaurants were implemented. Cholera cases were isolated in hospitals, and contacts were detained. Cholera houses were quarantined and disinfected. Autopsies were performed to confirm cholera cases and avoid unnecessary detention. It was conducted by American doctors such as Richard P. Strong, James Wesley Jobling, J. B. Thomas, and assisted by Norman Williams. Bodies of cholera victims were cremated if not claimed within twenty-four hours. [8]

In the provinces, some American army medical officers observed the lack of competency among Filipino physicians in handling and control of the disease. [6] According to J. C. Perry, Surgeon General and Chief Quarantine Officer in the Philippines:

The provincial and municipal boards of health, composed of Filipino physicians, have proved to be entirely incompetent to meet the emergency of dealing with an epidemic...

J.C. Perry, Reports from Manila-Cholera in the islands (1902) [9] [6]

Perry further added that most of the disease control of cholera were done by U.S. army surgeons. [6]

To prevent infectious diseases entering the islands, American authorities would check if a watercraft such as boats or ships are permissible to land. [10] Since the Americans were preoccupied before the epidemic during the Philippine-American War, they failed to enforce the necessary precautional procedures throughout the islands. Additionally, Filipinos are banca drivers who knew the local geographical locations of beaches, some of them even avoided docks guarded by authorities. There were also the threat of smugglers who would try to bypass precautionary measures before landing. [6]

In Manila, Chaffee was disappointed by the opposition from Filipinos and Spanish physicians. Although they agreed to provide the board of health assistance, they neglected to report them the number of cholera cases while some resort to falsification. [7] Although, there were some exceptions such as Manuel Gomez, who provided immense work on investigating cholera cases in the islands, and Luis Arbella, a medical inspector. [11]

Medical treatment

Richard P. Strong, American army surgeon and doctor StrongRichardPearson AMedD1898.jpg
Richard P. Strong, American army surgeon and doctor

U. S. Army surgeons began conducting research for prevention and treatment of cholera in the islands. Richard P. Strong tried to develop a cholera vaccine for civilian capacity. Questions aroused regarding its safety and Strong admitted that it might take years to produce a strain of the suffieciently weakened organism suitable for safe use. [3]

In 1903, Japan created a vaccine solely for the prevention of cholera and an antitoxin for its treatment. As tests were given, the U.S. Army was impressed but the vaccines were not for sale and unobtainable. [3]

In Manila, a medical officer informed George Miller Sternberg, an American army surgeon, that he was using a normal salt solution to the vein. According to the officer, the solution "in collapse, gave the most gratifying results". Attempts at curing cholera became successful using a saline solution to be injected under the skin through the veins. [3]

Casualties

After the first wave epidemic in 1903, official records from the board of health made a total of 103,076 reported cases and 66,387 deaths in the provinces. In Manila, there are 4,174 cases and 3,146 deaths. [12] Most of the cases and deaths occured were underreported by Filipino physicians due to cultural taboos and fear of property loss from American authorities. [6] J.C. Perry commented in August 1902:

They [Filipinos] will adopt every measure to conceal the cases and throw every obstacle in the way of the authorities in their attempt to suppress the disease.

J.C. Perry, Philippine Islands. Reports from Manila-Cholera in the islands (1902) [9] [6]

American authorities further requested the cremation of infected bodies but was met with opposition from Filipinos and Spanish residents. [6] During the epidemic, there had been a growing anti-American sentiment among residents resulting in civil disobedience. Some believed that the cholera outbreak was a "hoax" and others propagated that Americans intentionally put poisonous powders on wells to kill unsuspecting villagers. [13] By May 1903, the second wave of the epidemic commenced and cholera cases increased. [2] In March 8, 1904, it increased to 166,252 reported cases resulting in 109,461 deaths. [14]

From March 8, 1904 to August 23, 1905, there were no reported cases in cholera. [14] In April 27, 1904, the epidemic was declared to have ended. [3] Another cholera epidemic occurred in 1908. It was treated using intravenous injections in hospitals, [3] despite sporadic Filipino rebellions until 1911. [6]

Cholera Squad in the Philippines (between c. 1915 and c. 1920) Cholera Squad, Philippines.jpg
Cholera Squad in the Philippines (between c.1915 and c.1920)

The Tropical Disease Board and American army surgeons made additional campaigns to suppress the infection in the islands. Although historian Ken de Bevoise acknowledges the lack of education and poverty of Filipinos as the cause of spread, it was also acknowledged that reconcentration policies by American authorities made the infection easier. The knowledge of Americans that Filipinos were uneducated and poor added complications in handling the disease. [3]

Related Research Articles

<span class="mw-page-title-main">Cholera</span> Bacterial infection of the small intestine

Cholera is an infection of the small intestine by some strains of the bacterium Vibrio cholerae. Symptoms may range from none, to mild, to severe. The classic symptom is large amounts of watery diarrhea lasting a few days. Vomiting and muscle cramps may also occur. Diarrhea can be so severe that it leads within hours to severe dehydration and electrolyte imbalance. This may result in sunken eyes, cold skin, decreased skin elasticity, and wrinkling of the hands and feet. Dehydration can cause the skin to turn bluish. Symptoms start two hours to five days after exposure.

<span class="mw-page-title-main">Philippine–American War</span> Armed conflict (1899–1902)

The Philippine–American War, known alternatively as the Philippine Insurrection, Filipino–American War, or Tagalog Insurgency, emerged following the conclusion of the Spanish–American War in December 1898 when the United States annexed the Philippine Islands under the Treaty of Paris. Philippine nationalists constituted the First Philippine Republic in January 1899, seven months after signing the Philippine Declaration of Independence. The United States did not recognize either event as legitimate, and tensions escalated until fighting commenced on February 4, 1899 in the Battle of Manila.

<span class="mw-page-title-main">George Miller Sternberg</span> US Army general and physician (1838–1915)

Brigadier General George Miller Sternberg was a U.S. Army physician who is considered the first American bacteriologist, having written Manual of Bacteriology (1892). After he survived typhoid and yellow fever, Sternberg documented the cause of malaria (1881), discovered the cause of lobar pneumonia (1881), and confirmed the roles of the bacilli of tuberculosis and typhoid fever (1886).

<i>Cordon sanitaire</i> (medicine) Quarantine of a geographic area

A cordon sanitaire is the restriction of movement of people into or out of a defined geographic area, such as a community, region, or country. The term originally denoted a barrier used to stop the spread of infectious diseases. The term is also often used metaphorically, in English, to refer to attempts to prevent the spread of an ideology deemed unwanted or dangerous, such as the containment policy adopted by George F. Kennan against the Soviet Union.

<span class="mw-page-title-main">Dean Conant Worcester</span> American zoologist and ornithologist

Dean Conant Worcester, D.Sc., FRGS was an American zoologist, public official, and authority on the Philippines. He was born at Thetford, Vermont, and educated at the University of Michigan. Worcester's involvement with the Philippines began in 1887 when he joined a scientific expedition to the region as a junior member. This experience laid the groundwork for his controversial career in the early American colonial government, which commenced in 1899. He held firm beliefs in the colonial mission and vehemently opposed Philippine independence. Worcester's influence extended as he served as the Secretary of the Interior of the Philippine Islands until 1913. Afterward, he shifted his focus to business endeavors, particularly in coconut farming and processing, cattle raising, and maritime shipping lines. He died in the Philippines, leaving behind a legacy of both public service and entrepreneurial success.

<span class="mw-page-title-main">Taft Commission</span> Legislature of the Insular Government of the Philippine Islands

The Taft Commission, also known as the Second Philippine Commission, was established by United States President William McKinley on March 16, 1900, following the recommendations of the First Philippine Commission, using presidential war powers while the U.S. was engaged in the Philippine–American War.

<span class="mw-page-title-main">Arlie Pond</span> American baseball player and doctor (1873–1930)

Dr. Erasmus Arlington "Arlie" Pond was an American Major League Baseball pitcher for the Baltimore Orioles from 1895 to 1898, as well as a doctor in the United States Army during the Spanish–American War and World War I.

<span class="mw-page-title-main">Philippine Organic Act (1902)</span> 1902 U.S. federal law creating an elected lower house in the legislature of the Philippines

The Philippine Organic Act that was enacted by the United States Congress on July 1, 1902 was the basic law for the Insular Government. It is also known as the Philippine Bill of 1902 and the Cooper Act, after its author Henry A. Cooper.

<span class="mw-page-title-main">Seventh cholera pandemic</span> Seventh major cholera pandemic

The seventh cholera pandemic is the seventh major outbreak of cholera beginning in 1961 and continuing to the present. Cholera has become endemic in many countries. In 2017, WHO announced a global strategy aiming to end the pandemic by 2030.

The Philippines has one of the lowest rates of infection of HIV/AIDS, yet has one of the fastest growing number of cases worldwide. The Philippines is one of seven countries with growth in number of cases of over 25%, from 2001 to 2009.

<span class="mw-page-title-main">2009 swine flu pandemic in the Philippines</span> Disease outbreak in the Philippines

The 2009 swine flu pandemic was confirmed to have spread to the Philippines on May 21, 2009. In the following days, several local cases were reported to be caused by contact with two infected Taiwanese women who attended a wedding ceremony in Zambales.

<span class="mw-page-title-main">History of cholera</span>

Seven cholera pandemics have occurred in the past 200 years, with the first pandemic originating in India in 1817. The seventh cholera pandemic is officially a current pandemic and has been ongoing since 1961, according to a World Health Organization factsheet in March 2022. Additionally, there have been many documented major local cholera outbreaks, such as a 1991–1994 outbreak in South America and, more recently, the 2016–2021 Yemen cholera outbreak.

<span class="mw-page-title-main">Insular Government of the Philippine Islands</span> 1902–1935 US territory of the Philippines

The Insular Government of the Philippine Islands was an unincorporated territory of the United States that was established in 1902 and was reorganized in 1935 in preparation for later independence. The Insular Government was preceded by the Military Government of the Philippine Islands and was followed by the Commonwealth of the Philippines.

<span class="mw-page-title-main">Joseph J. Kinyoun</span> American physician

Joseph James Kinyoun was an American physician and the founder of the United States' Hygienic Laboratory, the predecessor of the National Institutes of Health.

<span class="mw-page-title-main">1900–1904 San Francisco plague</span> Early 20th-century epidemic in the US

The San Francisco plague of 1900–1904 was an epidemic of bubonic plague centered on San Francisco's Chinatown. It was the first plague epidemic in the continental United States. The epidemic was recognized by medical authorities in March 1900, but its existence was denied for more than two years by California's Governor Henry Gage. His denial was based on business reasons, to protect the reputations of San Francisco and California and to prevent the loss of revenue due to quarantine. The failure to act quickly may have allowed the disease to establish itself among local animal populations. Federal authorities worked to prove that there was a major health problem, and they isolated the affected area; this undermined Gage's credibility, and he lost the governorship in the 1902 elections. The new governor, George Pardee, implemented public-health measures and the epidemic was stopped in 1904. There were 121 cases identified, resulting in 119 deaths.

The Culion leper colony is a former leprosarium located on Culion, an island in the Palawan province of the Philippines. It was established by the U.S. government in order to rid leprosy from the Philippine Islands through the only method known at the time: isolating all existing cases and gradually phasing out the disease from the population. In addition to segregating the disease from the rest of the population, the island was later established in order to offer a better opportunity for people afflicted with leprosy to receive adequate care and modern treatments.

James Wesley Jobling (1876–1961) was an American physician who was a longtime professor at Columbia University College of Physicians and Surgeons and second president of the American Association of Immunologists.

USAT <i>Warren</i>

USAT Warren was the former Hamburg America Line liner Scandia, laid down as the Scandiinavia at AG Vulcan Stettin, launched on 24th Aug 1889. The liner was purchased by the U.S. Army Quartermaster Department 5 July 1898. In March 1899 Scandia was renamed Warren for Maj. Gen. Gouverneur K. Warren. Serving the Army Transport Service as United States Army Transport (USAT) Warren the ship was assigned to the Philippine Inter-Island Service based in Manila as one of the interisland transports. Along with routine voyages transporting troops and supplies among the islands the ship made routine trips to China with the Chinese port of Chingwangtao a routine part of service. Warren underwent major overhaul and was "practically reconstructed" during fiscal year 1916 including boiler replacement.

<span class="mw-page-title-main">2019–2021 polio outbreak in the Philippines</span> Disease outbreak in the Philippines

The 2019–2021 polio outbreak in the Philippines was an epidemic. For the previous 19 years, the Philippines was free of any polio-related diseases. On September 14, 2019, the disease began to resurface through a positive test result done to a 3-year-old girl from Mindanao. After the confirmation of a second case from tests done on a 5-year-old boy, the government of the Philippines publicly declared a polio outbreak on September 19, 2019. On June 11, 2021, the WHO announced that the outbreak has ended.

The Sleeping Sickness Commission was a medical project established by the British Royal Society to investigate the outbreak of African sleeping sickness or African trypanosomiasis in Africa at the turn of the 20th century. The outbreak of the disease started in 1900 in Uganda, which was at the time a protectorate of the British Empire. The initial team in 1902 consisted of Aldo Castellani and George Carmichael Low, both from the London School of Hygiene and Tropical Medicine, and Cuthbert Christy, a medical officer on duty in Bombay, India. From 1903, David Bruce of the Royal Army Medical Corps and David Nunes Nabarro of the University College Hospital took over the leadership. The commission established that species of blood protozoan called Trypanosoma brucei, named after Bruce, was the causative parasite of sleeping sickness.

References

  1. 1 2 Smallman-Raynor, Matthew; Cliff, Andrew D (1998-01-01). "The Philippines insurrection and the 1902–4 cholera epidemic: Part I—Epidemiological diffusion processes in war". Journal of Historical Geography. 24 (1): 69–89. doi:10.1006/jhge.1997.0077. ISSN   0305-7488.
  2. 1 2 Smallman-Raynor, M.; Cliff, A. D. (1998-04-01). "The Philippines insurrection and the 1902–4 cholera epidemic: Part II—Diffusion patterns in war and peace". Journal of Historical Geography. 24 (2): 188–210. doi:10.1006/jhge.1998.0085. ISSN   0305-7488.
  3. 1 2 3 4 5 6 7 8 9 Gillet, Mary C. (1995). "The Army Medical Department: 1865-1917". Center Of Military History.
  4. United States Philippine Commission (1900–1916) 1903, p. 267.
  5. United States Philippine Commission (1900–1916) 1903, p. 267–268.
  6. 1 2 3 4 5 6 7 8 9 10 Jandayran, Jan (2023). "A War on Two Fronts". Stony Brook Undergraduate History Journal.
  7. 1 2 3 Interior, Philippines Department of the (1902). Annual Report of the Secretary of the Interior to the Philippine Commission for the Fiscal Year Ended 1902. Bureau of Printing.
  8. United States Philippine Commission (1900–1916) 1903, p. 269.
  9. 1 2 Perry, J.C. (1902). "PHILIPPINE ISLANDS. Reports from Manila-Cholera in the islands". Public Health Reports (1896-1970). 17 (39). ISSN   2240-2241.
  10. Perry, J. C. (1902). "PHILIPPINE ISLANDS. Report on cholera in the Philippines for the three weeks ended July 12, 1902". Public Health Reports (1896-1970). 17 (37): 2130–2135. ISSN   0094-6214.
  11. United States Philippine Commission (1900–1916) 1903, p. 271.
  12. United States Philippine Commission (1900–1916) 1903, p. 273–274.
  13. Acevedo, Christian George F. (2021). Propaganda, Folk Beliefs, and Health Information: Insights from the Cholera Outbreaks in the Philippines. Capiz State University Roxas City Main Campus.
  14. 1 2 HEISER, VICTOR G. (1907-03-09). "THE OUTBREAK OF CHOLERA IN THE PHILIPPINES IN 1905.THE METHODS USED IN COMBATING IT, WITH STATISTICS TO JAN. 1, 1906". Journal of the American Medical Association. XLVIII (10): 856–861. doi:10.1001/jama.1907.25220360014001d. ISSN   0002-9955.

Sources