1971 New Jersey Senate election

Last updated

1971 New Jersey Senate elections
Flag of New Jersey.svg
  1967 November 2, 1971 1973  

All 40 seats in the New Jersey State Senate
21 seats needed for a majority
 Majority partyMinority party
 
Leader Raymond Bateman J. Edward Crabiel
Party Republican Democratic
Leader's seat 8th: Somerset 7th: Middlesex
Last election319
Seats before299
Seats won2416
Seat changeDecrease2.svg 5Increase2.svg 7
Popular vote919,262902,180

Senate President before election

Raymond Bateman [1]
Republican

Elected Senate President

Raymond Bateman
Republican

The 1971 New Jersey State Senate election was the mid-term election of Republican William Cahill's term as Governor of New Jersey. Democrats picked up seven Senate seats. Democrats flipped Districts 2, 3B, 11B, 11D, 11E, 14A, 14B, and 14C. Republicans flipped District 6A.

Contents

Background

Reapportioning

Legislative districts were redrawn by a 10-member bipartisan New Jersey Apportionment Commission to reflect population changes following the 1970 U.S. Census. Senators generally (with some exceptions) ran At-Large countywide.

Until 1965, the New Jersey State Senate was composed of 21 senators with each county electing one senator. After the U.S. Supreme Court decision Reynolds v. Sims required legislative districts to be approximately equal in population (a principle known as "one man, one vote"). [2] In 1965, the New Jersey Senate was increased to 29 members, with larger counties given multiple seats and some smaller counties sharing one or two senators.

The map was changed again in 1967, and again in 1971, as the state adjusted to the one man, one vote ruling. For the 1971 election, two seats were eliminated in District 11 and District 12 (Essex and Hudson counties, respectively). They were replaced by two new seats in the single-member District 4C and District 5 (Burlington and Monmouth counties, respectively). District 6 (now comprising Mercer and Hunterdon County) also switched from electing its senators at-large to electing them from two single-member districts because it became composed of more than one county.

The new districts were divided as follows:

DistrictCounties#
1Cape May and Cumberland1
2Atlantic1
3ASalem and Gloucester (part)1
3BGloucester (part) and Camden (part)1
3CCamden (part)1
4AOcean (part)1
4BBurlington (part) and Ocean (part)1
4CBurlington (part)1
5Monmouth3
6AHunterdon and Mercer (part)1
6BMercer (part)1
7Middlesex3
8Somerset1
9Union3
10Morris2
11Essex5
12Hudson3
13Bergen5
14Passaic3
15Warren and Sussex1

Incumbents not running for re-election

Democratic

Republican

Incumbents defeated

Two incumbent Republican senators were defeated for re-election: [3]

One incumbent Republican Senator who was denied party support for another term ran in the general election as an Independent candidate and was defeated; Republicans held this seat: [4]

Open Seats

Sixteen incumbents did not seek re-election. Thirteen incumbent Republican senators did not seek re-election in 1971, and Democrats won six of those seats: [5]

One incumbent Republican Senator was elected to Congress in 1970 and resigned his State Senate seat in January 1971 to take his seats in the U.S. House of Representatives: [6]

One incumbent Republican Senator resigned in 1970 to become a Judge. His seat was won in a November 1971 Special Election by a Democrat, but Republicans held the seat in the November 1971 General Election for a full term:

One incumbent Democratic Senator was defeated for renomination in the June primary and Democrats held that seat:

Two incumbent Democratic senators did not seek re-election in 1971. Democrats won one seat and Republicans won one seat: [8]

Summary of results by State Senate District

District Incumbent PartyElected SenatorParty
District 1 Robert E. Kay Rep James Cafiero Rep
District 2 Frank S. Farley Rep Joseph McGahn Dem
District 3A John L. White Rep James M. Turner Rep
District 3BHugh A. KellyRepJoseph MaressaDem
District 3C John L. Miller RepJohn L. MillerRep
District 3DFrank C. ItalianoRepFrank C. ItalianoRep
District 4AWilliam HieringRepJohn F. BrownRep
District 4BVacant [a] Barry T. ParkerRep
District 4CNew seat Edward J. Hughes Dem
District 5 Richard Stout RepRichard StoutRep
Alfred Beadleston RepAlfred BeadlestonRep
New seat Joseph Azzolina Rep
District 6 [b] Richard J. Coffee Dem William Schluter Rep
Sido L. Ridolfi Dem Joseph P. Merlino Dem
District 7 John A. Lynch Sr. DemJohn A. Lynch Sr.Dem
J. Edward Crabiel DemJ. Edward CrabielDem
Norman Tanzman DemNorman TanzmanDem
District 8 Raymond Bateman RepRaymond BatemanRep
District 9 Frank X. McDermott RepFrank X. McDermottRep
Matt Rinaldo RepMatt RinaldoRep
Vacant [c] Jerome Epstein Rep
District 10 Joseph Maraziti RepJoseph MarazitiRep
Harry L. Sears RepPeter W. ThomasRep
District 11 James Wallwork RepJames WallworkRep
David W. Dowd Rep Frank J. Dodd Dem
Michael Giuliano RepMichael GiulianoRep
Milton Waldor Rep Ralph DeRose Dem
Geraldo Del Tufo Rep Wynona Lipman Dem
Alexander Matturri RepSeat eliminated
District 12Frederick HauserDem James P. Dugan Dem
William F. Kelly Jr.DemWilliam F. Kelly Jr.Dem
William Musto DemWilliam MustoDem
Frank J. Guarini DemSeat eliminated
District 13Willard KnowltonRep Harold Hollenbeck Rep
Joseph Woodcock RepJoseph WoodcockRep
Fairleigh Dickinson Jr. Rep Frederick Wendel Rep
Alfred Schiaffo RepAlfred SchiaffoRep
Garrett Hagedorn RepGarrett HagedornRep
District 14Edward SiscoRep Joseph Hirkala Dem
Ira SchoemRep William J. Bate Dem
Frank SciroRepJoseph LazzaraDem
District 15 Wayne Dumont Jr. RepWayne Dumont Jr.Rep
  1. The seat was left vacant by the resignation of Edwin B. Forsythe, who was sworn into the U.S. House of Representatives in January 1971.
  2. Split into Districts 6A and 6B.
  3. The third Union seat was vacant after Nicholas LaCorte resigned in 1970. A special election was held simultaneously to complete the remainder of LaCorte's term (November 1971–January 1972) and was won by Democrat Jerry Fitzgerald English.

Close races

Seats where the margin of victory was under 10%:

  1. District 1, 1.6%
  2. District 3D, 1.6%
  3. District 3A, 0.02%
  4. District 4C, 3.1% gain
  5. District 5A, 4.2%
  6. District 5B, 4.2%
  7. District 5C, 2.8% gain
  8. District 7A, 7.2%
  9. District 7B, 6.8%
  10. District 7C, 7.0%
  11. District 9A, 5.6%
  12. District 9B, 2.9%
  13. District 9C, 1.1% gain
  14. District 13A, 2.2%
  15. District 13B, 2.3%
  16. District 13C, 2.1%
  17. District 13D, 2.0%
  18. District 13E, 2.3%
  19. District 14A, 6.0% gain
  20. District 14B, 4.9% gain
  21. District 14C, 4.8% gain

District 1

1971 New Jersey general election [9]
PartyCandidateVotes%
Republican James S. Cafiero 28,014 50.0
Democratic Paul R. Porreca27,09848.4
People's John W. Gotsch8671.5
Total votes55,979 100.0

District 2

1971 New Jersey general election [9]
PartyCandidateVotes%
Democratic Joseph L. McGahn 39,257 58.1
Republican Frank S. Farley 27,50940.7
Independent Charles Ross8401.2
Total votes67,606 100.0

District 3

District 3A

1971 New Jersey general election [9]
PartyCandidateVotes%
Republican James M. Turner 26,424 50.010
Democratic Louis J. Damminger, Jr.26,41349.990
Total votes52,837 100.0

District 3B

1971 New Jersey general election [9]
PartyCandidateVotes%
Democratic Joseph A. Maressa 27,347 56.3
Republican George E. Lord21,26643.7
Total votes48,613 100.0

District 3C

1971 New Jersey general election [9]
PartyCandidateVotes%
Republican John L. Miller 28,345 57.2
Democratic Morton H. Rappaport21,16842.8
Total votes49,513 100.0

District 3D

1971 New Jersey general election [9]
PartyCandidateVotes%
Republican Frank C. Italiano 22,312 50.8
Democratic Thomas R. Bristow21,61549.2
Total votes43,927 100.0

District 4

District 4A

1971 New Jersey general election [9]
PartyCandidateVotes%
Republican John F. Brown 30,272 53.4
Democratic John F. Russo 26,37846.6
Total votes56,650 100.0

District 4B

Special election, March 2, 1971 [10]
PartyCandidateVotes%
Republican Walter L. Smith 10,389 60.4
Democratic Charles B. Yates 6,79839.6
Total votes17,187 100.0
1971 New Jersey general election [9]
PartyCandidateVotes%
Republican Barry T. Parker 22,929 62.5
Democratic Fred M. Detrick, Jr.13,73737.5
Total votes36,666 100.0

District 4C

1971 New Jersey general election [9]
PartyCandidateVotes%
Democratic Edward J. Hughes, Jr. 24,043 51.1
Republican Walter L. Smith, Jr. 22,58048.0
Socialist Labor Bernardo S. Doganiero4350.9
Total votes47,058 100.0

District 5

1971 New Jersey general election [9]
PartyCandidateVotes%
Republican Richard R. Stout 69,067 19.4
Republican Alfred N. Beadleston 68,555 19.3
Republican Joseph Azzolina 60,199 16.9
Democratic Vincent Miller53,90215.2
Democratic William Himelman53,86115.1
Democratic Walter Gehricke50,20114.1
Total votes355,785 100.0

District 6

District 6A

1971 New Jersey general election [9]
PartyCandidateVotes%
Republican William E. Schluter 31,072 55.3
Democratic Robert R. Klein25,09144.7
Total votes56,163 100.0

District 6B

1971 New Jersey general election [9]
PartyCandidateVotes%
Democratic Joseph P. Merlino 29,758 70.0
Republican Charles A. Delehey12,74030.0
Total votes42,498 100.0

District 7

Districts 7A, B, and C

1971 New Jersey general election [9]
PartyCandidateVotes%
Democratic John A. Lynch 94,832 20.4
Democratic J. Edward Crabiel 92,637 19.9
Democratic Norman Tanzman 92,450 19.8
Republican Leonard A. Tobias61,67213.2
Republican Francis J. Coury61,04313.1
Republican Charles C. Griffith59,78812.8
Americans For ERGEdward R. Gavarny3,5470.8
Total votes465,969 100.0

District 8

1971 New Jersey general election [9]
PartyCandidateVotes%
Republican Raymond H. Bateman 37,017 70.9
Democratic Benjamin Levine15,16729.1
Total votes52,184 100.0

District 9

Districts 9, A, B, and C

Special election, November 2, 1971 [9]
PartyCandidateVotes%
Democratic Jerry F. English 73,314 50.8
Republican Van Dyke J. Pollitt64,79844.9
Independent CoalitionElmer L. Sullivan6,3054.4
Total votes144,417 100.0
1971 New Jersey general election [9]
PartyCandidateVotes%
Republican Matthew J. Rinaldo 93,608 20.6
Republican Francis X. McDermott 77,536 17.1
Republican Jerome M. Epstein 68,531 15.09
Democratic Carmine J. Liotta68,13115.00
Democratic Christopher Dietz64,48714.2
Democratic John T. Connor, Jr.63,88414.1
Independent CoalitionElmer L. Sullivan6,4511.4
Independent CoalitionArnold Gold6,0471.3
Independent CoalitionRichard Avant5,4061.2
Total votes454,081 100.0

District 10

1971 New Jersey general election [9]
PartyCandidateVotes%
Republican Joseph J. Maraziti 63,773 33.3
Republican Peter W. Thomas 58,532 30.5
Democratic Garret A. Hobart IV35,08718.3
Democratic Frank J. Schweighardt34,39617.9
Total votes191,788 100.0

District 11

Districts 11A-E

Special election, November 2, 1971 [9]
PartyCandidateVotes%
Democratic Charles DeMarco 83,525 46.9
Republican Nicholas LaSpina76,35242.9
Essex Bi-PartisanFrank J. Messina18,09510.2
Total votes177,972 100.0
1971 New Jersey general election [9]
PartyCandidateVotes%
Republican Michael A. Giuliano 92,166 9.8
Democratic Ralph C. DeRose 91,380 9.7
Republican James H. Wallwork 88,632 9.5
Democratic Frank J. Dodd 86,041 9.18
Democratic Wynona M. Lipman 85,644 9.14
Republican Milton A. Waldor 84,7369.04
Democratic Martin L. Greenberg 82,2918.8
Republican Matthew G. Carter 77,4188.3
Democratic Henry W. Smolen76,1908.1
Republican Frederic Remington 73,6637.9
Essex Bi-Partisan John J. Giblin 21,6882.3
Essex Bi-PartisanJohn F. Monica21,0722.2
Essex Bi-PartisanSylvester L. Casta19,0152.0
Essex Bi-PartisanJoseph J. Bradley16,3481.7
Essex Bi-PartisanRichard P. Weitzman15,7331.7
Unity-Victory-ProgressJoseph A. Santiago5,4830.6
Total votes937,500 100.0

District 12

Districts 12A, B, and C

1971 New Jersey general election [9]
PartyCandidateVotes%
Democratic William V. Musto 81,522 17.0
Democratic James P. Dugan 78,293 16.3
Democratic William F. Kelly, Jr. 76,177 15.9
Save Hudson CountyPatrick D. Conaghan47,0829.8
Save Hudson CountyFrancis X. Hayes47,0369.8
Save Hudson CountyAnthony M. Defino44,7039.3
Republican Joseph J. Panepinto33,9857.1
Republican Cosmo Palmitessa33,1316.9
Republican Mario DeLuca32,1316.7
Honesty-Efficiency-DecencyRichard D. McAleer5,4961.1
Total votes479,556 100.0

District 13

Districts 13A-E

1971 New Jersey general election [9]
PartyCandidateVotes%
Republican Harold C. Hollenbeck 158,615 11.3
Republican Joseph C. Woodcock, Jr. 157,280 11.2
Republican Garrett W. Hagedorn 153,203 10.9
Republican Alfred D. Schiaffo 151,806 10.8
Republican Frederick E. Wendel 150,962 10.8
Democratic John J. McCarthy 128,1099.1
Democratic Raymond Garramone 125,1548.9
Democratic Alfred W. Kiefer124,0838.8
Democratic Sidney Aglow123,8578.8
Democratic Lee M. Carlton119,2628.5
Nobody’s Rubber StampWillard B. Knowlton11,6680.8
Total votes1,403,999 100.0

District 14

Districts 14A, B, and C

1971 New Jersey general election [9]
PartyCandidateVotes%
Democratic Joseph Hirkala 64,725 21.2
Democratic Joseph A. Lazzara 54,426 17.8
Democratic William J. Bate 54,149 17.7
Republican Alfred E. Fontanella 46,47815.2
Republican Thomas W. E. Bowdler39,54512.9
Republican Henry Fette39,40612.9
Socialist Labor Robert Clement3,6451.2
Socialist Labor Josephine Clement3,4851.1
Total votes305,859 100.0

District 15

1971 New Jersey general election [9]
PartyCandidateVotes%
Republican Wayne Dumont, Jr. 28,041 66.6
Democratic Richard V. Laddey14,07233.4
Total votes42,113 100.0

References

  1. Sullivan, Ronald (March 24, 1971). "Hudson and Essex Losing Seats in Jersey's Senate". New York Times.
  2. "JERSEY ORDERED TO REAPPORTION; Judge Finds Congressional Districts Unconstitutional". New York Times. May 21, 1965.
  3. "Results of the General Election" (PDF). New Jersey Division of Elections. State of New Jersey. Retrieved December 6, 2014.
  4. "Results of the General Election" (PDF). New Jersey Division of Elections. State of New Jersey. Retrieved December 6, 2014.
  5. "Results of the General Election" (PDF). New Jersey Division of Elections. State of New Jersey. Retrieved December 6, 2014.
  6. "Results of the General Election" (PDF). New Jersey Division of Elections. State of New Jersey. Retrieved December 6, 2014.
  7. "Our Campaigns" (PDF).
  8. "Results of the General Election" (PDF). New Jersey Division of Elections. State of New Jersey. Retrieved December 6, 2014.
  9. 1 2 3 4 5 6 7 8 9 10 11 12 13 14 15 16 17 18 19 20 21 22 23 "Results of the General Election Held on November 2, 1971" (PDF). Secretary of State of New Jersey. Archived from the original (PDF) on July 6, 2015. Retrieved July 18, 2015.
  10. "GOP Wins N.J. Senate Race". The Record . March 3, 1971. p. 6. Retrieved March 29, 2020.