| Round | Nominees | Team | % of Votes | Opposition | Ground | Description |
|---|
| 1 | Jude Bolton | Sydney | 44% | Melbourne | MCG | One-handed miracle mark |
| Matt Thomas | Port Adelaide | 7% | Collingwood | Etihad Stadium | Thomas plucks it from the air |
| David Hille | Essendon | 48% | Western Bulldogs | Etihad Stadium | Magnificent fly over the top |
| 2 | Scott McMahon | North Melbourne | 13% | Collingwood | Etihad Stadium | Soaring effort by McMahon |
| Jackson Trengove | Port Adelaide | 18% | West Coast | AAMI Stadium | Big fly by Trengove |
| Mitch Morton | Richmond | 69% | St Kilda | MCG | Fantastic, well-timed leap |
| 3 | Jimmy Bartel | Geelong | 35% | Port Adelaide | Skilled Stadium | Terrific effort by Bartel |
| Mark Jamar | Melbourne | 40% | Brisbane Lions | MCG | Great flying grab |
| David Armitage | St Kilda | 25% | Essendon | Etihad Stadium | From in front of the pack |
| 4 | Jack Riewoldt | Richmond | 43% | Collingwood | MCG | Great use of the body by the Tiger superstar |
| Steve Johnson | Geelong | 37% | Sydney | SCG | Amidst the rain at the SCG, the super Cat leaps |
| Brett Ebert | Port Adelaide | 20% | Adelaide | AAMI Stadium | A great hanger by the small forward in Adelaide |
| 5 | Scott Thompson | Adelaide | 11% | Carlton | Etihad Stadium | The veteran Crow hangs in the air for a fine mark |
| Andrew Walker | Carlton | 80% | Adelaide | Etihad Stadium | Great leap to earn a goal right on half time |
| Chris Dawes | Collingwood | 10% | Essendon | MCG | The big Magpie takes a one-hander on Anzac Day |
| 6 | Jarred Moore | Sydney | 53% | Carlton | SCG | Wet weather can't stop this fine grab. |
| Kurt Tippett | Adelaide | 27% | St Kilda | AAMI Stadium | The big Crow leaps between two Saints |
| Lachlan Hansen | North Melbourne | 20% | Port Adelaide | Etihad Stadium | Super pack mark from young Kangaroo |
| 7 | Drew Petrie | North Melbourne | 28% | Geelong | Skilled Stadium | Petrie delivers with a great contested mark |
| Liam Patrick | Gold Coast | 32% | Brisbane Lions | The Gabba | Liam leaps high to pull in a special mark |
| Nathan Krakouer | Gold Coast | 40% | Brisbane Lions | The Gabba | Great leap over the pack |
| 8 | Todd Goldstein | North Melbourne | 28% | Melbourne | Etihad Stadium | Spectacular leap from Goldstein |
| James Podsiadly | Geelong | 38% | Collingwood | MCG | Pods takes a great mark |
| Rohan Bewick | Brisbane Lions | 34% | Essendon | The Gabba | Confident grab from up and over the top |
| 9 | Drew Petrie | North Melbourne | 17% | Brisbane Lions | The Gabba | Big jump over Maguire's head |
| Leon Davis | Collingwood | 6% | Adelaide | Etihad Stadium | Flies over the top to take the grab |
| Andrew Krakouer | Collingwood | 77% | Adelaide | Etihad Stadium | Magnificent leap from behind |
| 10 | Nathan Fyfe | Fremantle | 35% | St Kilda | Patersons Stadium | Fyfe in front of the pack |
| Dale Thomas | Collingwood | 40% | West Coast | MCG | Flying grab in front of goal |
| Harry O'Brien | Collingwood | 25% | West Coast | MCG | One-handed magic from O'Brien |
| 11 | Nathan Vardy | Geelong | 29% | Western Bulldogs | Skilled Stadium | Whirling speccy by Vardy |
| Nic Naitanui | West Coast | 28% | Gold Coast | Patersons Stadium | Huge hanger over Cox |
| Brendon Goddard | St Kilda | 43% | Collingwood | MCG | Goddard soars against the Pies |
| 12 | Paddy Ryder | Essendon | 10% | Fremantle | Patersons Stadium | Spectacular fly over two Freo opponents |
| Jack Riewoldt | Richmond | 32% | Sydney | SCG | Riewoldt's twisting aerial grab |
| Shaun Hampson | Carlton | 58% | Brisbane Lions | Etihad Stadium | Aggressive, leaping lead-up mark |
| 13 | Drew Petrie | North Melbourne | 30% | Essendon | Etihad Stadium | Spectacular one-handed grasp |
| Brad Green | Melbourne | 28% | Fremantle | MCG | The captain's bold grab |
| Jay Schulz | Port Adelaide | 42% | West Coast | Patersons Stadium | Monster mark over the top |
| 14 | Luke McPharlin | Fremantle | 33% | Brisbane Lions | Patersons Stadium | Big leap from McPharlin |
| Nic Naitanui | West Coast | 65% | Carlton | Etihad Stadium | Massive specky from the Eagles star |
| Jared Brennan | Gold Coast | 3% | Western Bulldogs | Gold Coast Stadium | Brennan's flying grab |
| 15 | Jack Riewoldt | Richmond | 23% | Carlton | MCG | Ripper one-hander |
| Ricky Petterd | Melbourne | 61% | Western Bulldogs | Etihad Stadium | Monster hanger on top of opponent Tom Williams |
| Jarrad Grant | Western Bulldogs | 15% | Melbourne | Etihad Stadium | Grant's big fly |
| 16 | Dale Thomas | Collingwood | 24% | North Melbourne | MCG | Thomas flies from behind |
| Heath Hocking | Essendon | 56% | Richmond | MCG | Spectacular hanger from the Bombers star |
| Sam Reid | Sydney | 20% | Gold Coast | Metricon Stadium | Big leap from Reid |
| 17 | James Podsiadly | Geelong | 20% | Brisbane Lions | The Gabba | Courageous mark by the J-Pod |
| Dale Thomas | Collingwood | 63% | Carlton | MCG | Thomas take a screamer |
| Liam Jurrah | Melbourne | 17% | Port Adelaide | TIO Stadium | Jurrah makes it look easy |
| 18 | Andrew Walker | Carlton | 80% | Essendon | MCG | Walker's huge hanger from atop Carlisle's shoulder |
| Brett Deledio | Richmond | 11% | Geelong | Etihad Stadium | Four-touch juggling act |
| Sam Reid | Sydney | 8% | Western Bulldogs | SCG | Classic skill from the youngster |
| 19 | Jay Schulz | Port Adelaide | 20% | Adelaide | AAMI Stadium | Sensational aerial grab |
| Drew Petrie | North Melbourne | 25% | Carlton | Etihad Stadium | Petrie's huge hanger |
| Nick Duigan | Carlton | 55% | North Melbourne | Etihad Stadium | Duigan's courageous mark |
| 20 | Paddy Ryder | Essendon | 38% | Sydney | Etihad Stadium | Big leap, spectacular mark |
| Zac Clarke | Fremantle | 44% | Carlton | Etihad Stadium | Huge hanger from the tall forward |
| Ricky Petterd | Melbourne | 18% | Carlton | MCG | Fantastic flying grab |
| 21 | Andrew Walker | Carlton | 39% | Fremantle | Patersons Stadium | Another huge hanger from Walker |
| Jeremy Howe | Melbourne | 26% | West Coast | Etihad Stadium | Magnificent jump over the top |
| Adam Goodes | Sydney | 34% | Richmond | MCG | Classic flying mark |
| 22 | Colin Sylvia | Melbourne | 38% | Richmond | MCG | Magnificent jump and grab |
| Ben Sinclair | Collingwood | 49% | Brisbane Lions | MCG | Sinclair takes one laying down |
| John Butcher | Port Adelaide | 13% | Western Bulldogs | AAMI Stadium | Butcher keeps his eye on the ball |
| 23 | Shannon Byrnes | Geelong | 23% | Sydney | Skilled Stadium | Byrnes' effortless hanger |
| Tendai Mzungu | Fremantle | 51% | Collingwood | Patersons Stadium | Remarkable one-handed grab |
| Drew Petrie | North Melbourne | 26% | St Kilda | Etihad Stadium | Petrie leaps a mile in the air |
| 24 | David Wojcinski | Geelong | 39% | Collingwood | MCG | Amazing leap |
| Drew Petrie | North Melbourne | 18% | Richmond | Etihad Stadium | Huge grab in front of goal |
| Alex Silvagni | Fremantle | 43% | Western Bulldogs | Etihad Stadium | Flying hanger over Barry Hall |
