Anne-Eva Brauneck

Last updated

Anne-Eva Brauneck (born 9 December 1910 in Hamburg; died 6 March 2007 in Lich) became the first or second female (West) German professor of law in 1965. [1] Brauneck studied law at the end of the Weimar Republic at the University of Heidelberg. [2] She turned to studies on the family backgrounds of juvenile offenders. Her work was suspect to the National Socialists because it did not conform to the government mantras involving the "hereditary nature" of criminal proclivity. [3]

Contents

Life

Provenance and early years

Anne-Eva Brauneck was born in Hamburg, the second of her parents' two daughters. The girls' father, who was very much older than their mother, was a secondary school head. [2]

She studied Jurisprudence at Heidelberg during the Great Depression in a period of socio-economic nemesis, political polarisation and parliamentary deadlock which led to the ending of democracy in Germany during 1933. At Heidelberg she was one of the last pupils of the criminal lawyer, legal philosopher and former Minister of Justice, Gustav Radbruch, before his government mandated dismissal from his post. A student contemporary who was also taught by Radbruch, and who subsequently became a life-long friend (and professional ally in the overwhelmingly male world of the West German criminal law) was Helga Einsele. [2]

Hitler years

It was in 1933 that Brauneck passed her Level-1 national law exams: she passed the Level-2 (final) exams in 1937. During this period she was simultaneously working on her doctorate which would normally have been seen as a milestone on the path to a career in the universities sector. [2] In 1936 she received her doctorate under the supervision of Rudolf Sieverts at Heidelberg. Her dissertation concerned "Pestalozzi's position on the problems of criminal law". [4] [5] Although she became, on paper, a fully qualified lawyer in 1937, women were still denied admission to the legal profession and higher judiciary during the period: there are indications that women's career options in the sector had actually been reduced under the Hitler government. Brauneck took, instead, a mid-level post with the police service, passing a further exam qualifying her as a "Kriminalassistent" in 1939, and allowing her a modest promotion to a higher-level grade. [2]

In the women's criminal police department she was able to enjoy a certain Narrenfreiheit [lower-alpha 1] During the twelve Hitler years the authorities became progressively less tolerant of divergent opinions among public officials, and Brauneck turned down at least one promotion opportunity in order to retain the "special protection [she was able to enjoy] in the female service". [2] She also found time to pursue her research interests, with a focus on young offenders and their family backgrounds. Her research findings did not necessary align with National Socialist theories on race and inheritance, however, and seem to have received little attention till after 1945. [3]

While working in the Berlin criminal section of the police service, having been assigned to the Berlin department in 1939, Brauneck drafted a decree on "police treatment of children and young people". [6] This amounted to a set of rules, which to her astonishment Reichsführer Himmler, whose wide accumulation of responsibilities included the police service, signed off without requiring any amendments. The decree, published by the Interior Ministry in July 1944, was later commended by no less a figure than her old doctoral supervisor, Gustav Radbruch, who thought it "humane". In 1942 she had been transferred to an all-women department that was mandated to focus on youth crime. Many of her colleagues had backgrounds in social work. Brauneck herself attributed the respect and relative professional freedom that she felt she enjoyed in the police service by this time to nothing more remarkable than her gender: "All the male criminal officials belonged to the SS: we could not do that, because as women we lacked certain essential characteristics, and so we did indeed have to greet every uniformed colleague we came across appropriately, but we were then left to follow old-fashioned human behavioural principles undisturbed [unlike our male colleagues]. Our superiors ... who secretly were no longer true believers in National Socialism, seemed often to find it entirely correct that, as women, we had certain 'innate weaknesses'". [2] [7]

Post-war years

After the Soviets captured Berlin in the early summer of 1945 members of the police department all found themselves dismissed without notice. She subsequently discovered that any accrued employment rights from her eight year of police service that she might have anticipated would in any case have been without effect, since under the Hitler government women police staff - unlike their male counterparts - only received "lifetime" contracts and the accompanying entitlements after reaching the age of 35. She was 34 when the war ended. She did not, in any event, re-apply for a job with the police service, since the only criminal investigation jobs open to women, even at this stage, were relatively low down in the organisational hierarchy, and poorly paid. Instead she worked "as a freelancer", at the same time devoting herself to studying aspects of Psychology. [2] She supported herself initially with "gardening and cleaning work". Later she found tutoring jobs, also earning money with journalistic contributions. [7]

With the western two thirds of Germany administratively divided and under military occupation, the future looked anything but certain. As the universities emerged from the rubble of military defeat, she evidently decided that for the next stage of her career she should try and return to the universities sector, and began to attend lectures in Psychology and Philosophy (broadly defined) at Berlin University and later also at Hamburg University in the British zone. She also participated in seminars and produced a substantial piece of academic work which she later described as "at the frontier" between her two chosen areas of study. [7]

UNESCO report

Between 1950 and 1952/53 Brauneck was one in a three member team conducting an in-depth study on the relationship of young people in Germany with authority. The other team members were the youth psychologist Rudolf Abshagen and a Finnish sociologist called Knut Pipping. [8] The report was commissioned by the UNESCO and the 3-person team operated under the theoretical supervision of an international board of trustees. [2] [7] On its completion it was published in 1954 (in German) Denmark by the Finnish Academy of Science and Letters. It earned one of the team members a "Habilitation" - a higher-level academic qualification normally awarded by a university), and it also appears usefully to have raised Brauneck's own profile in the German academic world. Looking back on her involvement Brauneck would recall the experience as "very interesting and instructive". She would recall later that she had written most of the report herself, and that the "Habilitation" had gone instead to Pipping, not because he was a man, but simply because he was the designated leader of the three person team. [7]

Research assistant+ in Hamburg

Brauneck would look back on her five years working at Hamburg for Rudolf Sieverts with mixed emotions: [7]

  • "I fully accept that in this position [as both Youth Justice research assistant and DVJJ 'honorary head of business'] I experienced and saw a lot of professionally interesting things, but I did not like always having to be the one who made the coffee for departmental meetings, always having to take the minutes, look after travel money, and undertake all sorts of other [basic administrative] functions".
  • "Ich leugne nicht, in dieser Rolle viel sachlich Interessantes erfahren und gesehen zu haben, mochte aber nicht, daß auf Arbeitstagungen neben Protokollführung, Reisegeldauszahlen und allerlei sonstigen Diensten auch das Kaffeekochen von mir erwartet wurde." [7]
Anne-Eva Brauneck in conversion with Margarete Fahricius-Brand and others, 1982

The British military authorities released Brauneck's old tutor Rudolf Sieverts from the Neuengamme Internment Camp only in 1946. He was one of a number of people detained in the camp on account of suspicions that he could have been involved in Nazi crimes in the Hamburg area. As far as is known, nothing came of those suspicions, but it evidently took him some time to get his university career, but at some point during or before 1954 he accepted the teaching chair in Criminology at the University of Hamburg. Both Sieverts and Brauneck held firm views on the causes of youth crime, and in many respects those views - which at the time would still have been popularly characterised in North America and the Soviet Union as "progressive" - overlapped. In 1952 she accepted a position at Hamburg as research assistant at the Hamburg University seminar for Youth Justice. Sieverts led the department: colleagues included the jurists Herbert Jäger, Claus Roxin and Horst Schüler-Springorum. The research assistant role was an important step in Brauneck's career progression. She was less enthusiastic about the additional role she was obliged to accept as "ehrenamtliche Geschäftsführerin" (loosely in this context, "honorary head of business") for the German Association for Youth Courts and Youth Justice Support ("Deutsche Vereinigung für Jugendgerichte und Jugendgerichtshilfen" / DVJJ). Rudolf Sieverts had headed up the DVJJ from Hamburg since its 1953 reinstatement. [2] [7] [9]

Habilitation

The conventional path to a life-long career in university-level education in West Germany was through a "Habilitation" (post-doctoral) degree, and during her five years working as an assistant for Sieverts awareness of this gap in her qualifications became increasingly pressing. She faced resistance to the idea both (she became convinced) on account of her gender and because Criminology, her speciality, had not yet been rehabilitated as an independent subject in its own right among the Hamburg academic community. It had been effectively downgraded in Germany during the 1940s, atrophied both by the simplistic inflexibility of National Socialist pseudo-science and by the enforced emigration, during the 1930s, of many of Germany's leading criminologists, most of whom seem to have ended up in the United States of America. By the later 1950s - partly as a result of the efforts of Rudolf Sieverts and his team - Criminology had regained a measure of academic respectability. Anne-Eva Brauneck completed her Habilitation dissertation in 1959 and finally received her Habilitation degree in 1961. It dealt with "Criminal Law and Criminal Law Support" ("Strafrecht und strafrechtliche Hilfswissenschaften") and was based on a catamnesistic investigation of around 300 convicted young offenders, and she had secured from Sieverts - who was by this time a senior member of the university - an assurance that in return for this work she should expect to receive a "venia legendi" ("permission to teach at the university"). [2] [7] [10]

Professor in Gießen

After securing her habilitation there is a sense in which Anne-Eva Brauneck had outgrown her various roles at Hamburg, and though her gender may still have counted against her, in 1965 she was able to accept the newly created teaching chair in "Criminal Law and Criminology" ("Strafrecht und Kriminologie" - subsequently re-focused as the teaching chair in "Criminology and Criminal Policy" - "Kriminologie und Kriminalpolitik") at the University of Giessen. [2] This made her the first female to become a full professor in a German university law faculty according to at least one source, and it is perfectly correct to identify her as the first female to become a full law professor in a West German university law faculty. [2] That is indeed how Brauneck herself described the position. [7] However, the situation is complicated by the fact that the German Federal Republic (West Germany) and the German Democratic Republic (East Germany) were only launched as semi-autonomous states in 1949. Between 1945 and 1949 the western two thirds of what had previously been Germany were divided up into four occupation zones and administered by the military authorities of the Soviet Union, the United States, Britain and France. If those post-war occupation zones are thought of as "Germany", then first female to become a full professor in a German university law faculty was Gertrud Schubart-Fikentscher (1896-1985), appointed in September 1948 to a teaching chair in civil law and legal history at the University of Halle, then in the Soviet occupation zone (relaunched in October 1949 as the Soviet-sponsored German Democratic Republic). By applying this alternative assumption, or even simply by remembering that East Germany was a part of what became Germany in 1990 just as surely as West Germany was (since Gertrud Schubart-Fikentscher retired only in 1957), Anne-Eva Brauneck becomes not the first but the second female German professor of law to be appointed. [11]

Celebration

Anne-Eva Brauneck retired in 1975. Her successor at Gießen, Arthur Kreuzer, produced an affectionate tribute to her when she died aged 96 at her home in Lich (just outside Gießen), more than thirty years later. He was fulsome in his praise of her contribution to various professional (and other) associations, including the Deutscher Juristinnenbund (German Association of [female] jurists), the Deutsche Vereinigung für Jugendgerichte und Jugendgerichtshilfen (German Association for Youth Courts and Youth Justice Support), the 16-member "Alternative Professors" working group on comprehensive Criminal Law Reform and the Humanist Union. Kreuzer also commended, in particular, Brauneck's contributions over the years to the Monatsschrift für Kriminologie und Strafrechtsreform, a specialist journal devoted to criminology and criminal law reform. [2]

Published output (selection)

Notes

  1. ↑ "Narrenfreiheit" refers to the freedom of late-medieval court jesters to mock their powerful masters and mistresses without being executed for sharing their insights. Although the idea is present in much Elizabethan literature, in the twentieth and twenty-first centuries the concept seems to feature more regularly as a metaphor in German language literature than in Anglo-American sources.

Related Research Articles

<span class="mw-page-title-main">Lucille Eichengreen</span> American memoirist (1925–2020)

Lucille Eichengreen was a survivor of the Łódź (Litzmannstadt) Ghetto and the Nazi German concentration camps of Auschwitz, Neuengamme and Bergen-Belsen. She moved to the United States in 1946, married, had two sons and worked as an insurance agent. In 1994, she published From Ashes to Life: My Memories of the Holocaust. She frequently lectured on the Holocaust at libraries, schools and universities in the U.S. and Germany. She took part in a documentary from the University of Giessen on life in the Ghetto, for which she was awarded an honorary doctorate.

<span class="mw-page-title-main">Heidelberg University Faculty of Law</span> Faculty of the Heidelberg University

The Heidelberg University Faculty of Law, located in Heidelberg, Germany, is one of the original four constituent faculties of Heidelberg University. Founded in 1386 by Rupert I, Elector Palatine, it is the oldest law school in Germany.

<span class="mw-page-title-main">Franz Jacob (Resistance fighter)</span> German Resistance fighter against Nazism and Communist politician

Franz Jacob was a German Resistance fighter against Nazism and a Communist politician.

Ralf Koelbel is professor of criminology, criminal law and criminal proceedings law at Bielefeld University.

<span class="mw-page-title-main">Aydan Özoğuz</span> German politician (SPD), Vice-President of the Bundestag

Aydan Özoğuz is a German politician of the Social Democratic Party (SPD), who has been serving as a Vice-president of the German Bundestag since October 2021. She has been a member of the Bundestag since 2009 and served as deputy chairperson of the party from 2011 until 2017.

<span class="mw-page-title-main">Rudolf Jaffé</span> German physician and pathologist

Rudolf Jaffé was a German physician and pathologist.

Horst Schüler-Springorum was a German Professor of Jurisprudence. The focus of his work was on Criminal justice.

Rudolf Klug was a Hamburg school teacher. He became a member of the Communist Party in 1928 and suffered from growing levels of harassment at work. When the Nazi Party took power in Germany at the beginning of 1933 his problems greatly intensified: he had already been dismissed from one teaching post, and participated in resistance to the government.

Letizia Paoli is a criminologist, originally from Prato. Since 2006 she has been a professor of the Law Faculty at Leuven/Louvain University. She served, between 2009 and 2016, as chair of the sometimes troubled "Freiburg Sports Medicine Commission" at Freiburg University.

<span class="mw-page-title-main">Rudolf Sieverts</span>

Rudolf Sieverts was a German Law professor and Criminologist.

Hans Joachim Schneider was a German jurist, criminologist and psychologist. He taught as Professor of Criminology at the University of Münster.

<span class="mw-page-title-main">Karl Engisch</span> German jurist

Karl Engisch was a German jurist and a Philosopher of Law. He was described by Hans Joachim Hirsch as one of the "outstanding theorists of criminal justice of the [twentieth] century".

Sven Simon is a German law professor and politician who has been serving as a Member of the European Parliament since 2019. He previously taught international and European law at Philipps University of Marburg. In the 2019 European Parliament election he was the lead candidate for the Christian Democratic Union Hessen.

Reinhard Frank was a German lawyer-academic specialising in criminal law and international public law. He was a prolific author of legal text books and became an influential law reformer. In 1920 Frank was appointed Rector of Munich University.

Franz Exner was an Austrian-German criminologist and criminal lawyer. Alongside Edmund Mezger, Hans von Hentig and Gustav Aschaffenburg, he was a leading and in some respects a pioneering representative of the German school of criminology in the first half of the twentieth century. During the 1920s and 1930s Exner produced pioneering work on the interface between Criminology and Sociology. He became a controversial figure among subsequent generations because of the extent to which during the 1930s and 1940s his ideas evolved towards National Socialist ideology, notably with regard to so-called "criminal biology", which, by more recent criteria imputed excessive weight to the role of hereditary factors as causes of criminal actions.

Gertrud Schubart-Fikentscher became Germany's first female professor of Law in September 1948, and remained the country's only female university law professor - after 1957 an emeritus (retired) law professor - for seventeen years. She taught at the University of Halle. By the time she received and accepted her professorship she was a few months short of her fifty-second birthday, reflecting a somewhat indirect career trajectory, her having grown up in a country where the educational system was not set up to enable women either to study or teach at any university.

Helga Einsele was a German criminologist, prison director and high-profile prisons reformer.

<span class="mw-page-title-main">Karl von Lilienthal</span>

Karl von Lilienthal was a German scholar of Jurisprudence who became a university professor of criminal law. After working briefly as an Assessor at the Wuppertal District Court he taught successively at the universities of Halle, Zürich, Marburg and then, between 1896 and 1924, Heidelberg, where he also served several terms as Dean of the Law Faculty and, for some years between 1902 and 1919, engaged in a parallel part time career in town as an assistant district judge.

Eva-Maria Kieninger is a German legal scholar and professor at the University of Würzburg.

Charlotte Leubuscher was a German-British social scientist and economist.

References

  1. ↑ Ulrike Schultz; Anja Böning; Ilka Peppmeier; Silke Schröder (4 July 2018). Die Nachkriegszeit .... Die ersten habilitierten Frauen und professorinenin Westdeutschland. Nomos Verlag. pp. 97–105. ISBN   978-3-8452-8722-5.{{cite book}}: |work= ignored (help)
  2. 1 2 3 4 5 6 7 8 9 10 11 12 13 14 Prof. em. Dr. Arthur Kreuzer, Direktor des Instituts für Kriminologie an der Justus-Liebig-Universität Gießen (2007). "Zum Tod von Anne-Eva Brauneck" (PDF). Monatsschrift für Kriminologie und Strafrechtsreform 90. pp. 351–359. Retrieved 2 October 2020.
  3. 1 2 "Anne-Eva Brauneck (1910 – 2007) Jurist". Famous alumni of Justus Liebirg University of Giessen from 1607 to 2011. Justus Liebig University Giessen. p. 24.
  4. ↑ "Pestalozzis Stellung zu den Strafrechtsproblemen". Breslau : Kurtze. Retrieved 2 October 2020.
  5. ↑ "Prof. Dr. Anne-Eva Brauneck". Verlag C.H.Beck oHG, München. Retrieved 2 October 2020.
  6. ↑ Anne-Eva Brauneck; Otto Backes (1999). Veroeffentlichungen von Anne-Eva Brauneck. Forum-Verlag Godesberg. p. 587. ISBN   978-3-930982-48-6.{{cite book}}: |work= ignored (help)
  7. 1 2 3 4 5 6 7 8 9 10 Margarete Fahricius-Brand (author-compiler); Sahine Berghahn (co-author); Kristine Sudhöher (co-author) (1982). Frauen in der Rechtwissenschaft (PDF). Elefanten Press Verlag GMBH. pp. 165–169. ISBN   3-88520-088-0 . Retrieved 2 October 2020.{{cite book}}: |author1= has generic name (help); |work= ignored (help)
  8. ↑ Knut Pipping; Rudolf Abshagen [in German]; Anne-Eva Brauneck (1 January 1954). "ZA0254: German Youth and Authority / Gesprache Mit Der Deutschen Jugend : Ein Beitrag Zum Autoritatsproblem". Aktuelle Version: 1.0.0, 2010-04-13, 10.4232/1.0254. GESIS – Leibniz-Institut für Sozialwissenschaften in Köln. (The report was originally published in Denmark: GESIS made available this online version, however.). doi:10.4232/1.0254 . Retrieved 3 October 2020.
  9. ↑ "Einführende Worte von Prof. Sieverts zum Generalreferat" (PDF). Erstkriminalität und Frühkriminalität. Deutsche Vereinigung für Jugendgerichte und Jugendgerichtshilfen. 1966. pp. 11, 6–158. Retrieved 3 October 2020.
  10. ↑ "Rückblick auf über ein Jahrhundert Kriminologie und Kriminalpolitik in Gießen .... Die Zeit nach der Wiederbegründung einer Kriminologie in Gießen 1967". Gießener Kriminologie. Univ.-Prof. Dr. iur. Arthur Kreuzer, Fernwald. Retrieved 3 October 2020.
  11. ↑ "Gertrud Schubart-Fikentsche". Archiv der Martin-Luther-Universität Halle-Wittenberg. 21 August 2020. Retrieved 3 October 2020.
This page is based on this Wikipedia article
Text is available under the CC BY-SA 4.0 license; additional terms may apply.
Images, videos and audio are available under their respective licenses.