Anti-subordination principle

Last updated

The anti-subordination principle(ASP) is a legal doctrine aiming to reveal, critique, and dismantle all forms of subordination. It's based on the idea that equal citizenship is not possible in a society with widespread social stratification. [1] The principle originates from the critical theory tradition. [2] It is often contrasted with the anti-classification principle, which focuses on preventing laws or policies from making distinctions based on classifications such as race or gender, regardless of the outcome.

Contents

The ASP emerged as a critique of the anti-discrimination approach within U.S. constitutional law, particularly as it relates to the Equal Protection Clause of the Fourteenth Amendment. Traditional anti-discrimination law often focuses on whether individuals are treated differently based on race, aiming for formal equality—the equal treatment of all individuals under the law. [3]

Critical race theory

Critical race theorists including Neil Gotanda focus on racial subordination and the role of law in organizing society along racial lines. [4] CRT scholars argue that the formalistic approach to race does not account for the deeper, systemic inequities that maintain racial hierarchies. Instead, they advocate for ASP, which seeks to address the structural inequality and institutional racism that keep certain racial groups in subordinate positions. In CRT, the principle emphasizes the need to dismantle systems that reproduce racial subordination, even when laws appear neutral on their face. CRT involves intersectionality to examine how different forms of domination and subordination are interlocking and co-dependent. [5]

Feminist legal theorists use the ASP to oppose gender subordination and the ways in which patriarchy propagates it. [6] Gender minorities are relegated to an inferior status in a male-dominated society, including either or both materially and socially. Feminists concern themselves with not just gender subordination, but all forms as women experience intersectional identities giving them unique positions within a wider system.

Magical law

Magical law theorists such as Qútb Ettúf employ the ASP to examine and oppose the magical subordination of witches and infamavits or those falsely accused of witchcraft. [7] Magical law holds that anti-witchcraft persecution has historically operated as a form of domination and subordination, with many individuals charged in courts. [8] Magical law theorists also incorporate intersectionality to challenge the ways in which people with various marginalized identities including women, Jewish people, and enslaved Africans experienced magical subordination in unique ways.

Disability rights advocacy

Disability rights advocacy involves the ASP to focus on disability subordination, aiming to liberate disabled people from oppression. [9] These advocates argue that the situating disability in the context of gender or other identities is vital for developing more robust legal protections. [10]

See also

Related Research Articles

Triple oppression, also called double jeopardy, Jane Crow, or triple exploitation, is a theory developed by black socialists in the United States, such as Claudia Jones. The theory states that a connection exists between various types of oppression, specifically classism, racism, and sexism. It hypothesizes that all three types of oppression need to be overcome at once.

Identity politics is politics based on a particular identity, such as ethnicity, race, nationality, religion, denomination, gender, sexual orientation, social background, caste, and social class. The term could also encompass other social phenomena which are not commonly understood as exemplifying identity politics, such as governmental migration policy that regulates mobility based on identities, or far-right nationalist agendas of exclusion of national or ethnic others. For this reason, Kurzwelly, Pérez and Spiegel, who discuss several possible definitions of the term, argue that it is an analytically imprecise concept.

The term "minority group" has different usages, depending on the context. According to its common usage, the term minority group can simply be understood in terms of demographic sizes within a population: i.e. a group in society with the least number of individuals, or less than half, is a "minority". Usually a minority group is disempowered relative to the majority, and that characteristic lends itself to different applications of the term minority.

Oppression is malicious or unjust treatment of, or exercise of power over, a group of individuals, often in the form of governmental authority or cultural opprobrium. It is related to regimentation, class, society, and punishment. Oppression may be overt or covert, depending on how it is practiced. Oppression refers to discrimination when the injustice does not target and may not directly afflict everyone in society, but instead targets or disproportionately impacts specific groups of people.

Feminist legal theory, also known as feminist jurisprudence, is based on the belief that the law has been fundamental in women's historical subordination. Feminist jurisprudence the philosophy of law is based on the political, economic, and social inequality of the sexes and feminist legal theory is the encompassment of law and theory connected.The project of feminist legal theory is twofold. First, feminist jurisprudence seeks to explain ways in which the law played a role in women's former subordinate status. Feminist legal theory was directly created to recognize and combat the legal system built primarily by the and for male intentions, often forgetting important components and experiences women and marginalized communities face. The law perpetuates a male valued system at the expense of female values. Through making sure all people have access to participate in legal systems as professionals to combating cases in constitutional and discriminatory law, feminist legal theory is utilized for it all.

Marxist feminism is a philosophical variant of feminism that incorporates and extends Marxist theory. Marxist feminism analyzes the ways in which women are exploited through capitalism and the individual ownership of private property. According to Marxist feminists, women's liberation can only be achieved by dismantling the capitalist systems in which they contend much of women's labor is uncompensated. Marxist feminists extend traditional Marxist analysis by applying it to unpaid domestic labor and sex relations.

The matrix of domination or matrix of oppression is a sociological paradigm that explains issues of oppression that deal with race, class, and gender, which, though recognized as different social classifications, are all interconnected. Other forms of classification, such as sexual orientation, religion, or age, apply to this theory as well. Patricia Hill Collins is credited with introducing the theory in her work entitled Black Feminist Thought: Knowledge, Consciousness, and the Politics of Empowerment. As the term implies, there are many different ways one might experience domination, facing many different challenges in which one obstacle, such as race, may overlap with other sociological features. Characteristics such as race, age, and sex, may intersectionally affect an individual in extremely different ways, in such simple cases as varying geography, socioeconomic status, or simply throughout time. Other scholars such as Kimberlé Crenshaw's Mapping the Margins: Intersectionality, Identity Politics, and Violence against Women of Color are credited with expanding Collins' work. The matrix of domination is a way for people to acknowledge their privileges in society. How one is able to interact, what social groups one is in, and the networks one establishes are all based on different interconnected classifications.

Postmodern feminism is a mix of postmodernism and French feminism that rejects a universal female subject. The goal of postmodern feminism is to destabilize the patriarchal norms entrenched in society that have led to gender inequality. Postmodern feminists seek to accomplish this goal through opposing essentialism, philosophy, and universal truths in favor of embracing the differences that exist amongst women in order to demonstrate that not all women are the same. These ideologies are rejected by postmodern feminists because they believe if a universal truth is applied to all women of society, it minimizes individual experience, hence they warn women to be aware of ideas displayed as the norm in society since it may stem from masculine notions of how women should be portrayed.

<span class="mw-page-title-main">Intersectionality</span> Theory of discrimination

Intersectionality is a sociological analytical framework for understanding how groups' and individuals' social and political identities result in unique combinations of discrimination and privilege. Examples of these factors include gender, caste, sex, race, ethnicity, class, sexuality, religion, disability, height, age, and weight. These intersecting and overlapping social identities may be both empowering and oppressing. However, little good-quality quantitative research has been done to support or undermine the practical uses of intersectionality.

Critical race theory (CRT) is an academic field focused on the relationships between social conceptions of race and ethnicity, social and political laws, and media. CRT also considers racism to be systemic in various laws and rules, not based only on individuals' prejudices. The word critical in the name is an academic reference to critical theory rather than criticizing or blaming individuals.

Standpoint theory, also known as standpoint epistemology, is a foundational framework in feminist social theory that examines how individuals' unique perspectives, shaped by their social and political experiences, influence their understanding of the world. Standpoint theory proposes that authority is rooted in individuals' personal knowledge and perspectives and the power that such authority exerts.

<span class="mw-page-title-main">Kimberlé Crenshaw</span> American academic and lawyer (born 1959)

Kimberlé Williams Crenshaw is an American civil rights advocate and a scholar of critical race theory. She is a professor at the UCLA School of Law and Columbia Law School, where she specializes in race and gender issues.

Feminist political theory is an area of philosophy that focuses on understanding and critiquing the way political philosophy is usually construed and on articulating how political theory might be reconstructed in a way that advances feminist concerns. Feminist political theory combines aspects of both feminist theory and political theory in order to take a feminist approach to traditional questions within political philosophy.

Intersectionality is the interconnection of race, class, and gender. Violence and intersectionality connect during instances of discrimination and/or bias. Kimberlé Crenshaw, a feminist scholar, is widely known for developing the theory of intersectionality in her 1989 essay, "Demarginalizing the Intersection of Race and Sex: A Black Feminist Critique of Antidiscrimination Doctrine, Feminist Theory and Antiracist Politics". Crenshaw's analogy of intersectionality to the flow of traffic explains, "Discrimination, like traffic through an intersection, may flow in one direction, and it may flow in another. If an accident happens in an intersection, it can be caused by cars traveling from any number of directions and, sometimes, from all of them. Similarly, if a Black woman is harmed because she is in the intersection, her injury could result from sex discrimination or race discrimination."

Multiracial feminist theory refers to scholarship written by women of color (WOC) that became prominent during the second-wave feminist movement. This body of scholarship "does not offer a singular or unified feminism but a body of knowledge situating women and men in multiple systems of domination."

White feminism is a term which is used to describe expressions of feminism which are perceived as focusing on white women while failing to address the existence of distinct forms of oppression faced by ethnic minority women and women lacking other privileges. Whiteness is crucial in structuring the lived experiences of white women across a variety of contexts. The term has been used to label and criticize theories that are perceived as focusing solely on gender-based inequality. Primarily used as a derogatory label, "white feminism" is typically used to reproach a perceived failure to acknowledge and integrate the intersection of other identity attributes into a broader movement which struggles for equality on more than one front. In white feminism, the oppression of women is analyzed through a single-axis framework, consequently erasing the identity and experiences of ethnic minority women in the space. The term has also been used to refer to feminist theories perceived to focus more specifically on the experience of white, cisgender, heterosexual, able-bodied women, and in which the experiences of women without these characteristics are excluded or marginalized. This criticism has predominantly been leveled against the first waves of feminism which were seen as centered around the empowerment of white middle-class women in Western societies.

Disability justice is a social justice movement which focuses on examining disability and ableism as they relate to other forms of oppression and identity such as race, class and gender. It was developed in 2005 by the Disability Justice Collective, a group including Patty Berne, Mia Mingus, Stacey Milbern, Leroy F. Moore Jr., and Eli Clare. In disability justice, disability is not considered to be defined in "white terms, or male terms, or straight terms." The movement also believes that ableism makes other forms of prejudice possible and that systems of oppression are intertwined. The disability justice framework is being applied to a intersectional reexamination of a wide range of disability, human rights, and justice movements.

Feminism and racism are highly intertwined concepts in intersectional theory, focusing on the ways in which women of color in the Western World experience both sexism and racism.

Magical law is the area of law that governs the practice of magic or witchcraft. Magical law catechizes the involvement of legal systems in anti-magic persecution, and as a body of law, is the principles, concepts, and statutes governing the use of magic. Historically, magical law has been closely associated with the persecution of individuals accused of witchcraft, sorcery, or other supernatural activities. While these laws have often been based on religious, cultural, and societal beliefs rather than empirical evidence, they have played a significant role in shaping the legal and social histories of many societies. In magical law, there are witches, infamavits, and nullmancers (non-witches).

References

  1. Colker, Ruth (1987). "The Anti-Subordination Principle: Applications". Wisconsin Women's Law Journal. 3: 59.
  2. Gonzalez, Marc Tizoc; Matambanadzo, Saru; Martínez, Sheila I. Vélez (2021-06-07). "Latina and Latino Critical Legal Theory: LatCrit Theory, Praxis and Community". Revista Direito e Práxis. 12 (2): 1316–1341.
  3. Lyons, Daniel (1966). "The Weakness of Formal Equality". Ethics. 76 (2): 146–148. ISSN   0014-1704.
  4. Gotanda, Neil (2011). "The Racialization of Islam in American Law". The Annals of the American Academy of Political and Social Science. 637: 184–195. ISSN   0002-7162.
  5. Crenshaw, Kimberle (1991). "Mapping the Margins: Intersectionality, Identity Politics, and Violence against Women of Color". Stanford Law Review. 43 (6): 1241–1299. doi:10.2307/1229039. ISSN   0038-9765.
  6. Volpp, Leti (2001). "Feminism versus Multiculturalism". Columbia Law Review. 101 (5): 1181–1218. doi:10.2307/1123774. ISSN   0010-1958.
  7. Ettúf, Qútb (2024). "Magical Law". Academia.
  8. Rives, James B. (2003). "Magic in Roman Law: The Reconstruction of a Crime". Classical Antiquity. 22 (2): 313–339. doi:10.1525/ca.2003.22.2.313. ISSN   0278-6656.
  9. Bagenstos, Samuel R. (2000). "Subordination, Stigma, and "Disability"". Virginia Law Review. 86 (3): 397–534. doi:10.2307/1073960. ISSN   0042-6601.
  10. Travis, Michelle A. (2017). "Gendering Disability to Enable Disability Rights Law". California Law Review. 105 (3): 837–884. ISSN   0008-1221.