Autopsy images of Ngatikaura Ngati

Last updated

Ngatikaura Ngati was a New Zealand-Tongan toddler who died of child abuse in January 2006. The deliberate judicial release of official autopsy photographs after the trial of his killers, for the subsequent distribution of those images on the Internet, and for the following debate about the images among government figures, including three successive Children's Commissioners caused controversy. This was the result of the tension between the desire for privacy and respect for victims of family violence, and the need for publicity to motivate changes in public attitudes to family violence.

Contents

Life and death

Ngati had been fostered by a cousin of his biological mother and was being raised in a Tongan language environment, until shortly after his third birthday, when he was returned to his birth mother, at her request. Maine Annabella Ngati, her partner, Teusila Fa'asisila, and their other children only spoke English. Within three months, Ngati was dead. Photos taken during the autopsy showed bruises from repeated beatings and weeping sores, one of which was "the size of a man's hand on his bottom." [1] Ngati and Fa'asisila were found not guilty of murder, but guilty of manslaughter, failing to provide a child with the necessities of life (medical care), and willful ill treatment of a child. [2] In June 2007, both were sentenced to eight and a half years in prison, with a minimum non-parole period of four years and eight months. [3] Ngati gave birth to another child while in custody – which was placed with either foster or adoptive parents [4] – and she was declined parole in November 2011. [4] Fa'asisila was expected to be deported to Tonga on release in December 2011. [5]

Distribution of the images

[It is] questionable whether publication of autopsy photographs of a young child beaten to death could ever be in the public interest.

Cindy Kiro, Children's Commissioner, March 2008 [6]

After trial, in an unusual and controversial move, Auckland High Court Judge Graham Lang allowed the release of the autopsy photos into the public realm, and allowed New Zealand's TV One (New Zealand) (TVNZ) to film the autopsy photographs "so that they may give pause to those people who choose to ignore that their family members are being hurt". [6] Since then, the images have been distributed through television, email, and web, fueling controversy and debate along the way.

Broadcast television

TVNZ broadcast the images during a television news programme at 6pm on 6 August 2007. During that segment, Children's Commissioner Cindy Kiro is shown commenting that the public did not need to see these "graphic images to show them how badly damaged this child was." [6] [7] After the broadcast, she lodged a complaint with the Broadcasting Standards Authority (BSA), arguing that "[One News] had displayed a disregard for the rights of the young victim and exploitation of him by showing these photos". Calling the broadcast a "further abuse in death" of the child, Kiro said that it was "... questionable whether publication of autopsy photographs of a young child beaten to death could ever be in the public interest." Her complaint alleged violations of several of the BSA's standards, including "good taste and decency", "privacy", "fairness", "children's interests", and "violence". [6]

[The Authority] recognises that news programmes will often contain "violent, disturbing or alarming material", and that broadcasters "should not falsify by omission, a world in which much violence and brutality occurs".

Broadcasting Standards Authority, March 2008 [6]

The complaint was investigated, but was "not upheld" on all counts. [8] With respect to "good taste and decency" the BSA acknowledged that "the autopsy images would have been distressing to some viewers. However, they conveyed the grim reality of child abuse in the context of [a news] item...." [6] They ruled that their privacy and fairness standards did not apply to deceased individuals – they did point out, however, that TVNZ complied with the judge's stipulations against showing the boy's face and genitals, and, "in this respect, the Authority finds that TVNZ exercised care and discretion in order to preserve the child's dignity." [6] [8]

The more the public of New Zealand is aware of the problem, the more chance something will be done.

Roger McClay, Preceding Children's Commissioner, August 2007 [9]

Regarding violence, the Authority quoted from their guidelines, which "recognises that news programmes will often contain 'violent, disturbing, or alarming material', and that broadcasters 'should not falsify by omission, a world in which much violence and brutality occurs'". [6] TVNZ provided advance warning to viewers, and didn't display the images until two minutes into the story played a role in the BSA's decision-making, [8] especially with respect to children's interests. Although the complaints were not upheld, two of the Authority's members went on record to note that "it is unusual to see autopsy photographs in the 6pm news, particularly involving children", and that "the warning could have made a specific reference to autopsy photographs of a child, in order to leave viewers in no doubt as to the content of the report." [6]

Email petition

The images were also circulated in an email sent by a protest group calling for tougher jail terms for child abusers, [10] with Kiro calling their use "abhorrent". [11] [12] Ngati's name (but not images) were used by Family First to advocate tougher sentences for child abuse, [13] and to highlight female family violence perpetrators. [14] Family First's Bob McCroskie supported the shock value of the images. [7] The images have also been used on placards (protest signs). [15]

Preceding Commissioner Roger McClay said, that use of the photos would serve to raise awareness of the child abuse "epidemic", which was not well known amongst New Zealanders. He added, "The more the public of New Zealand is aware of the problem, the more chance something will be done." [9] Inspector Richard Middleton, who was involved in the original police case, said, "The case was very disturbing in view of the amount of violence used against a defenceless three-year-old. Anything that raises awareness and prevents it happening again is great." [11]

Shock web sites

Some time later, the photos appeared on Internet shock sites; some sites are characterized as pornographic. [16] In 2011, months after taking office as Children's Commissioner, Russell Wills said he was "appalled" at their use. [17]

Court documents

See also

Related Research Articles

Shortland Street is a New Zealand prime-time soap opera centring on the fictitious Shortland Street Hospital, first broadcast on TVNZ 2 on 25 May 1992. It is New Zealand's longest-running drama and soap opera, being broadcast continuously for over 7,700 episodes and 31 years, and is one of the most watched television programmes in New Zealand.

Three, stylized as +HR=E, is a New Zealand nationwide television channel. Launched on 26 November 1989 as TV3, it was New Zealand's first privately owned television channel. The channel currently broadcasts nationally in digital free-to-air form via the state-owned Kordia on terrestrial and satellite. Vodafone also carries the channel for their cable subscribers in Wellington and Christchurch. It previously broadcast nationally on analogue television until that was switched off on 1 December 2013.

<span class="mw-page-title-main">Ngāi Tūhoe</span> Māori iwi in New Zealand

Ngāi Tūhoe, often known simply as Tūhoe, is a Māori iwi of New Zealand. It takes its name from an ancestral figure, Tūhoe-pōtiki. Tūhoe is a Māori-language word meaning "steep" or "high noon". Tūhoe people also bear the sobriquet Nga Tamariki o te Kohu. Tūhoe traditional land is at Te Urewera in the eastern North Island, a steep, heavily forested area which includes Lake Waikaremoana. Tūhoe traditionally relied on the forest for their needs. The tribe had its main centres of population in the small mountain valleys of Ahikereru and Ruatāhuna, with Maungapohatu, the inner sanctum of the Urewera, as their sacred mountain. The Tūhoe country had a great reputation among the neighbouring tribes as a graveyard for invading forces.

<span class="mw-page-title-main">Hone Harawira</span> New Zealand Māori activist and politician

Hone Pani Tamati Waka Nene Harawira is a New Zealand Māori activist and former parliamentarian. He was elected to parliament as the member for the Māori electorate of Te Tai Tokerau in 2005 as the Māori Party candidate.

<span class="mw-page-title-main">Paul Henry (broadcaster)</span> New Zealand radio and television broadcaster

Paul Henry Hopes, known professionally as Paul Henry, is a New Zealand radio and television broadcaster who was the host of the late night show The Paul Henry Show on New Zealand's TV3 which ended December 2014 so that Henry could host a new cross platform three-hour breakfast show Monday to Friday on TV3, RadioLive and online. Paul Henry launched on 7 April 2015 and initially had an audience larger than the two shows it replaced on radio and TV. For nine months in 2012, he also co-hosted an Australian television show, Breakfast, which ceased production on 30 November 2012, due to low ratings.

<span class="mw-page-title-main">Broadcasting Standards Authority</span>

The Broadcasting Standards Authority |Te Mana Whanonga Kaipāho (BSA) is a New Zealand Crown entity created by the Broadcasting Act 1989 to develop and uphold standards of broadcasting for radio, free-to-air and pay television.

The Independent Police Conduct Authority is an independent civilian oversight body that considers complaints against the New Zealand Police and oversees their conduct. It derives its responsibilities and powers from the Independent Police Conduct Authority Act. Under section 12(1) of the Act, the Authority's functions are to receive complaints alleging misconduct or neglect of duty by police employees; or concerning any practice, policy, or procedure of New Zealand Police and to take action as contemplated by the Act. It may also investigate any police incident involving death or serious bodily harm and make recommendations to the Commissioner of Police based on those investigations.

<span class="mw-page-title-main">Crimes (Substituted Section 59) Amendment Act 2007</span> New Zealand law concerning corporal punishment

The Crimes Amendment Act 2007 is an amendment to New Zealand's Crimes Act 1961 which removed the legal defence of "reasonable force" for parents prosecuted for assault on their children.

<span class="mw-page-title-main">2007 New Zealand police raids</span> Series of armed NZ police raids in October 2007

The 2007 New Zealand police raids were a series of armed police raids conducted on 15 and 16 October 2007, in response to alleged paramilitary training camps in the Urewera mountain range near the town of Ruatoki. About 300 police, including members of the Armed Offenders Squad and Special Tactics Group, were involved in the raids, which involved the execution of search warrants at various addresses throughout New Zealand, and the establishment of roadblocks at Ruatoki and Tāneatua. The police seized four guns and 230 rounds of ammunition and arrested eighteen people. According to police, the raids were a culmination of more than a year of surveillance that uncovered and monitored the training camps.

Michael Noel James Hosking IV is a New Zealand television and radio broadcaster who has worked for Radio New Zealand and TVNZ and from 2008 has been the weekday breakfast host on Newstalk ZB with "The Mike Hosking Breakfast". He is a supporter of the centre-right National party and is often openly critical of the Labour-led government. He has lived and worked as a broadcaster in Wellington, Christchurch and currently resides in Auckland.

<span class="mw-page-title-main">Miriama Kamo</span> New Zealand television presenter

Miriama Jennet Kamo is a New Zealand journalist, children's author and television presenter. She currently presents TVNZ's flagship current affairs programme Sunday, and Māori current affairs programme Marae.

<span class="mw-page-title-main">Howard Broad</span>

Howard George Broad was the thirtieth New Zealand Commissioner of Police, serving from 2006 to 2011. He is a former career police officer, working in uniform and as a detective for eighteen years, before moving into senior roles at the Police National Headquarters in Wellington. As commissioner, he successfully completed rewriting the policing law, the introduction of tasers, and survived a number of controversies in the media.

Privacy advocates have objected to the Google Street View feature, pointing to photographs that show people leaving strip clubs, protesters at an abortion clinic, sunbathers in bikinis, cottagers at public parks, people picking up prostitutes, and people engaging in activities visible from public property which they do not wish to be photographed and have published online. Google maintains that the photos were taken from public property. However, this does not take into account that the Street View cameras take pictures from an elevated position, enabling them to look over hedges and walls designed to prevent some areas from being open to public view. Before launching the service, Google removed photos of domestic violence shelters, and additionally allows users to flag inappropriate or sensitive imagery for Google to review and remove. When the service was first launched, the process for requesting that an image be removed was not trivial. Google changed its policy to make removal more straightforward, but has since removed the option to request removal of an image, replacing it by an option to request blurring of an image. Images of potential break-ins, sunbathers, and individuals entering adult bookstores have, however, remained active and these images have been widely republished.

The Office of the Children's Commissioner was an independent New Zealand Crown entity that was established under the Children's Commissioner Act 2003. Its role has been superseded by Mana Mokopuna - Children and Young People's Commission. OCC's main responsibilities were to protect the rights, health, welfare, and wellbeing of minors under the age of 18 years.

New Zealand is committed to the Universal Declaration of Human Rights and has ratified the International Covenant on Civil and Political Rights, both of which contain a right to privacy. Privacy law in New Zealand is dealt with by statute and the common law. The Privacy Act 2020 addresses the collection, storage and handling of information. A general right to privacy has otherwise been created in the tort of privacy. Such a right was recognised in Hosking v Runting [2003] 3 NZLR 385, a case that dealt with publication of private facts. In the subsequent case C v Holland [2012] NZHC 2155 the Court recognised a right to privacy in the sense of seclusion or a right to be free from unwanted intrusion. For a useful summary see: court-recognises-intrusion-on-seclusion-privacy-tort-hugh-tomlinson-qc/

<span class="mw-page-title-main">Cindy Kiro</span> Governor-General of New Zealand since 2021

Dame Alcyion Cynthia Kiro is a New Zealand public-health academic, administrator, and advocate, who has served as the 22nd governor-general of New Zealand since 21 October 2021. Kiro is the first Māori woman, the third person of Māori descent, and the fourth woman to hold the office.

<span class="mw-page-title-main">Marama Davidson</span> New Zealand politician

Marama Mere-Ana Davidson is a New Zealand politician who entered the New Zealand Parliament in 2015 as a list-member representing the Green Party of Aotearoa New Zealand, of which she became the female co-leader in 2018.

<span class="mw-page-title-main">Apna (New Zealand)</span> Radio station

Apna is a New Zealand radio network targeted towards ethnic minorities. The radio network broadcasts on 990 AM in Whangārei, Auckland and Hamilton, and plays Bollywood music alongside cultural features and discussions.

<span class="mw-page-title-main">Parikino</span>

Parikino is a settlement 24 kilometres (15 mi) upriver from Whanganui, New Zealand; the original pā site was across the Whanganui River.

<span class="mw-page-title-main">The Royal Commission of Inquiry into Abuse in Care</span>

The Royal Commission of Inquiry into Abuse in Care is a royal commission established in 2018 by the New Zealand government pursuant to the Inquiries Act 2013 to inquire into and report upon responses by institutions to instances and allegations of historical abuse in state care and faith based institutions between 1950 and 2000.

References

  1. ↑ Binning, Elizabeth (May 12, 2007). "From happiness to hell". The New Zealand Herald . Archived from the original on 2012-01-02. Retrieved 5 October 2012.
  2. ↑ Vass, Beck (15 June 2007). "Ex-carer tells boy's killers to hang themselves". The New Zealand Herald . Archived from the original on 2015-09-24. Retrieved 8 October 2011.
  3. ↑ Vass, Beck (16 June 2007). "Toddler's killers get 8 1/2 years". The New Zealand Herald . Retrieved 8 October 2011.
  4. 1 2 Carroll, Joanne (11 December 2011). "Child killer gives birth in jail". The New Zealand Herald . Archived from the original on 2011-12-10. Retrieved 11 December 2011. 'She has a lot of children and we believe she has even given birth to another child while on this prison sentence. That child has been fostered or adopted into the community,' the report said.
  5. ↑ "Teusila Ki Vaiola Fa'asisila". Offender Database. Sensible Sentencing Trust. Archived from the original on 13 October 2012. Retrieved 6 October 2012.
  6. 1 2 3 4 5 6 7 8 9 "Kiro and Television New Zealand Ltd - 2007-111; Complaint under section 8(1)(a) of the Broadcasting Act 1989". bsa.govt.nz. Broadcasting Standards Authority. 26 March 2008. Archived from the original on 15 April 2012. Retrieved 5 October 2012.
  7. 1 2 "Call to stand up against abuse". TV One (New Zealand). 6 August 2007. Archived from the original on 2018-03-16. Retrieved 16 October 2012.
  8. 1 2 3 "Complaint about autopsy photos rejected". The Dominion Post . 1 April 2008. Retrieved 16 October 2012.
  9. 1 2 "E-mailer backs abuse photos". stuff.co.nz. Dominion Post. 6 August 2007. Retrieved 8 October 2011.
  10. ↑ "The real face of child abuse in NZ". biggie.co.nz. 31 July 2007. Archived from the original on 25 February 2012. Retrieved 9 October 2011.
  11. 1 2 "Photos sent in emails of dead boy slammed". stuff.co.nz . 5 August 2007. Retrieved 8 October 2011.
  12. ↑ "Grisly photos in email petition". stuff.co.nz. 6 August 2007. Retrieved 8 October 2011.
  13. ↑ "Sentence for Beating Partner to Death slammed". Press Release. Family First / Scoop (website). 28 February 2008. Archived from the original on 2016-03-04. Retrieved 8 October 2011. His entire body was covered in bruises and his blood was found in every inch of the house. Yet his mother and step-father will be up for parole in four years.
  14. ↑ "Child Abusers Are Also Women". Press Release. Family First / Scoop. 31 July 2007. Archived from the original on 2015-09-26. Retrieved 8 October 2011.
  15. ↑ "Ngatikaura Ngati". flickr.com. 2011. Retrieved 8 October 2011.
  16. ↑ "Dead child's pictures posted on pornographic website". Otago Daily Times. 7 October 2011. Archived from the original on 2011-10-09. Retrieved 10 October 2012.
  17. ↑ "Disgust over dead boy's pictures on porn site". New Zealand Herald. 8 October 2011. Archived from the original on 2011-11-04. Retrieved 8 October 2011. Ngatikaura Ngati died after horrific abuse by his parents. Children's advocates are appalled that pictures of a young Auckland boy killed by his parents were posted on a pornographic site featuring beheadings, impalement and necrophilia.
This page is based on this Wikipedia article
Text is available under the CC BY-SA 4.0 license; additional terms may apply.
Images, videos and audio are available under their respective licenses.