Battle of Afabet

Battle of Afabet
Part of the Eritrean War of Independence and the Ethiopian Civil War
Date 17–20 March 1988 Location Afabet, Eritrea 16°11′00″N38°41′00″E / 16.183333°N 38.683333°E / 16.183333; 38.683333 Result EPLF victory
Belligerents
EPLF	Ethiopia   Soviet Union (advisors) [1]
Commanders and leaders
Mesfin Hagos	Getaneh Haile
Strength
15,000–20,000	15,223 [2]
Casualties and losses
4,000–5,000 killed [3] 5,000 wounded	8,000–9,000 killed 5,000 captured [3] 1 killed 3 captured
class=notpageimage| Location within Eritrea

The Battle of Afabet was a three-day battle fought from 17 March through 20 March 1988 in and around the town of Afabet, as part of the Eritrean War of Independence. ^[4] The battle has been described as being the largest battle in Africa since the Second Battle of El Alamein. ^[5] It has been described as the most significant battle in terms of military and political consequences since the Ethio-Somali War, alongside the 1989 Battle of Shire of the Ethiopian Civil War. ^[6]

Background

The Nadew Command was one of four commands, or army corps, of the Ethiopian Second Revolutionary Army. Led by Colonel Getaneh Haile, it was composed of three infantry divisions and accompanying support units, and some sources state it had between 20,000 ^[7] and 22,000 ^[8] soldiers. Gebru Tareke, noted that the morale of the soldiers was at an all-time low, and none of the divisions "had even half of the numbers that would normally constitute an Ethiopian division – ten to twelve thousand men", quotes Ministry of Defense reports to state that there were 15,223 men in the three divisions. ^[9]

The Eritrean People's Liberation Front (EPLF) had attacked the Nadew Command a few months previously, with limited success. On 8 December 1987, the EPLF attacked one of the divisions of the Command, the 22nd Mountain Division, with a force that may have contained as many as five infantry brigades, one mechanized battalion, and three heavy-weapon battalions. On the second day of the assault, Eritrean infiltrators destroyed the divisional control center. It required the assistance of the Nineteenth Mountain Infantry Division and the 45th Infantry Brigade to halt further advances and repel the EPLF forces. Ethiopian losses in this preliminary engagement were 242 killed, 291 wounded, and 615 missings; Eritrean losses have been estimated at 125 killed and 269 wounded. ^[9] However, the Ethiopian side suffered even graver losses in the aftermath: on Mengistu Haile Mariam's order twenty senior officers were transferred and the commander of the Nadew Command, General Tariku Ayne, who had been absent from Afabet for medical treatment, was executed outside of Asmara on 15 February 1988. The death of one of Ethiopia's most prominent generals surprised even the EPLF, whose Radio of the Masses broadcast that the Derg had "cut off its right hand with its left hand". The 22nd Division was moved to Keren, and replaced with the Fourteenth Infantry Division. ^[10]

By this time, Nadew Command had three divisions over-stretching to cover the wide area of operation which had been covered by five divisions prior. The Command could not adequately provide force to strategically operate at a distance from its main body for the purpose of resistance against enemy attack. Thus, Command's ability to provide early and accurate warning on enemy movement and appropriate response was degraded. Subsequently, the main force lacked the benefit of enough reaction time and maneuver space to effectively respond to enemy attack.

By mid-March 1988 the Nadew Command had planned to launch an offensive campaign against the Eritrean People's Liberation Front (EPLF); however, they were pre-empted by the EPLF.^{[ citation needed ]}

Battle

On the morning of 17 March 1988, the EPLF deployed troops on three sides around Hedai Valley to encircle the Ethiopian garrison. The first unit attacked was the newly arrived Fourteenth Division. ^[10] Upon their attack, the Ethiopian forces began to withdraw but were cut off. The battle continued while the Ethiopian garrison from Keren tried to reinforce their position, which was thwarted by the EPLF. ^[11]

A stumbling block for the EPLF was on the left flank, where their Eighty-fifth Division was held up by the dogged resistance of the Ethiopian Twenty-ninth Mechanized Brigade. It fought without reinforcement for most of a day until its commander gambled on a retreat to Afabet. Lacking time for careful reconnaissance before its withdrawal, the brigade was halted when a tank and truck were disabled by Eritrean 100mm guns, the burning vehicles blocking the road. The Ethiopians were forced to destroy their weaponry to prevent them from falling into EPLF hands. ^[12] Ethiopian aircraft even bombed their own troops. ^[13] The commander of the Second Revolutionary Army came to the battlefield himself to supervise opening the road to Afabet "until he allegedly 'escaped on a camel' just before the fall of the garrison." ^[14] Once the Ethiopian troops were routed in Hedai Valley, the EPLF stormed and captured Afabet. As the town was a major garrison the EPLF also captured a large cache of weapons in addition to those captured in the valley.

Killion estimates that by the end of the three-day battle, the EPLF had killed over 8,000 Ethiopian soldiers. ^[8] After losing Afabet, on the following days the Ethiopian troops abandoned the towns of Tesseneiei, Barentu and Agordat, since they thought they could not defend them any longer, and concentrated most of their forces on Keren.

Aftermath

Not long after this defeat, Berhane Woldemichael wrote in the periodical Review of African Political Economy,

The significance to the Ethiopian regime of the loss of Afabet cannot be overstated. In this single battle, Ethiopia lost whole divisions of its best-trained and armed troops. Worse still, it left behind a weapons stockpile that it had amassed to carry out what it believed was to have been 'a decisive offensive' against the EPLF. That 'decisive offensive' was being planned by Soviet military advisors. As it was, the EPLF, clearly outsmarting the Soviets, turned around the 'planned offensive' to their advantage. The Soviet Union had always denied direct involvement in Eritrea but was caught red-handed by the EPLF at Afabet by the capture of three Soviet military personnel, another one was killed in the combat. ^{[15] : 61}

The victory over the Nadew Command is considered by the historian Basil Davidson to be the most significant victory for any liberation movement since the Vietnamese victory at Dien Bien Phu. ^[16] It has also been described as the largest battle in Africa since El Alamein. ^[5] However, the Ethiopian historian Gebru Tareke disagrees with this comparison to Dien Bien Phu, pointing out that Davidson made his observation from the field as a guest of the EPLF, and that "the Ethiopian armed forces continued to fight, at times quite vigorously, for another three years." ^[17] He concludes, "From a global perspective, Afabet was an event whereas Dien Bien Phu was eventful." ^[18]

References

1. "Attempts to distort history". Archived from the original on 17 November 2008. Retrieved 22 January 2008.
2. Perlez, Jane (19 February 1990). "Prisoner No. 14279: Forlorn Pawn in Ethiopia's Long and Ruinous Civil War". The New York Times.
3. "Afabet, March 1988: The Decisive Battle for Eritrean Independence" (PDF).
4. Battiata, Mary (24 March 1988). "Ethiopian Rebels Claim Huge Victory". Washington Post. ISSN   0190-8286 . Retrieved 13 March 2024.
5. Worthington, Peter (27 December 1998). "Needless war engulfs a unique African oasis". QSL.net. Retrieved 25 June 2008.
6. Tareke, Gebru (2004). "From Af Abet to Shire: The Defeat and Demise of Ethiopia's 'Red' Army 1988–89". The Journal of Modern African Studies. 42 (2): 239–281. ISSN   0022-278X.
7. "Deceit is its own damnation (part I)". 19 November 1999. Retrieved 31 October 2006.
8. Killion, Tom (1998). Historical Dictionary of Eritrea. The Scarecrow Press. ISBN   978-0-8108-3437-8.
9. Tareke 2016, p. 251.
10. Tareke 2016, p. 252.
11. "Ethiopia and Eritrea, 1950–1991". Archived from the original on 23 August 2006. Retrieved 31 October 2006.
12. Tareke 2016, p. 254.
13. Worthington, Peter. "Remarkable to witness the birth of Eritrea". Toronto Sun. Retrieved 14 September 2013.
14. Tareke 2016, p. 256.
15. Woldemichael, Berhane (1989). "Ethiopian Military in Disarray". Review of African Political Economy. 16 (44): 60–63. doi:10.1080/03056248908703812. ISSN   0305-6244. JSTOR   4005837.
16. Cliffe, Lionel; Davidson, Basil (1988). The Long Struggle of Eritrea for Independence and Constructive Peace. Red Sea Press. ISBN   978-0-932415-37-0.
17. Tareke 2016, p. 248.
18. Tareke 2016, p. 260.

Sources

• Tareke, Gebru (2016). The Ethiopian Revolution: War in the Horn of Africa. ISBN   978-99944-951-2-2. OCLC   973809792.