Benedikt Carpzov Jr.

Last updated
Benedikt Carpzov Junior Benedikt-Carpzov-d-J-04.jpg
Benedikt Carpzov Junior

Benedikt Carpzov the Younger (27 May 1595, Wittenberg - 30 August 1666, Leipzig) was a German criminal lawyer and a witchcraft theoretician who wrote extensively on witch processes. His 1635 work Practica Rerum Criminalium dealt with the trial of those accused of witchcraft, supporting the use of torture to extract confessions from the accused. Carpzov is considered the founder of the German jurisprudence. He is also known under pen-name Ludovicus de Montesperato.

Contents

Life

Benedikt Carpzov the Younger was a descendant of the famous Carpzov family, the son of Benedikt Carpzov the Elder, a renowned lawyer of his time from the Carpzov family. He grew up in Colditz, where he was trained by his father and private tutors. He began his studies of philosophy and jurisprudence at the University of Wittenberg together with his brother Konrad Carpzov in 1610. He eventually focused on law, and continued his studies in 1615 at the University of Leipzig and 1616 at the University of Jena. Upon his return to Wittenberg in 1618, he participated in a dispute under guidance of Wolfgang Hirschbach on December 3 to obtain a licentiate degree, and then received his doctorate in law on February 16, 1619.

In April he left Wittenberg for an educational trip to Italy. There he arrived in Rome via Venice, where he learned Italian, then traveled on to Naples, France, England and the Netherlands. At the latter place he received a letter from his father, who told him that the Elector Johann Georg I of Saxony promised him a position at the Saxon Schöppenstuhl (judicial panel) in Leipzig. On April 25, 1620, he was sworn in as an extraordinary assessor and in 1623 as full assessor. In 1632 he rose to seniority of the institution, worked from 1636 at the Court of Appeals in Leipzig and on 25 June 1639 became Councilor at the Appeal Court.

In August 1644, the Elector appointed him as court and justice councilor in Dresden. But he did not take office because Sigismund Finckelthaus had died. Therefore, on 25 March 1645 he returned with his family to Leipzig and took over a professorship at the Law School of the Leipzig Academy. On February 24, 1648, he took the ordinariate at the Law School and was appointed head of the judicial panel (Schöppenstuhl). Having settled in Leipzig, he was unable to evade a vocation as a Privy Councilor to Dresden in 1653. When he was released in 1661 for reasons of age, he went back to Leipzig and resumed his judicial office at the judicial panel.

He was buried in the Paulinerkirche. His epitaph could be saved before the demolition of the church in 1968 and was restored in 2011.

Influence

He played an important role in establishing an independent German legal system. Based on his own experience, he wrote his works on particular case studies. His most famous work is the Practica nova Imperialis Saxonica rerum criminalium, in which he outlined backgrounds of the criminal law and criminal procedure law. The German criminal law has borrowed so much from this book that for a century it served as a source of law. His last great work, Processus juris in foro Saxonica, has long been a textbook valid in the development of procedural law.

As Carpzov was deeply rooted in the religiosity of his time, his views on criminal justice were under strong influence of the Catholic school of Salamanca, in particular Diego de Covarrubias y Leyva (even though he was a Protestant himself). Following the views of this school, he considered a crime as a rebellion, and ultimately as an insult to God himself. For Carpzov, the offender was not only a lawbreaker who violated a restriction imposed by the authorities, but also a sinner who had rebelled against God. In addition to retribution, the punishment was meant to deter the general public from committing similar offences. Although his views on criminal punishment were quite severe (in the midst of the Thirty Years' War), he paid special attention to the punishment being commensurate with the offence.

Among other things, his objective was to refine the concept of guilt, to lay down a limited order of extraordinary punishment, and to limit legal interpretation and analogy. In criminal cases, he sought to minimize the use of torture and to acquit a guilty party rather than convict an innocent person. [ citation needed ]

Witch trials

It is often claimed he was involved in sentencing 20,000 people accused of witchcraft to death. This is a myth based on a single note and no actual evidence. In 1635 he published Practica Rerum Criminalium, dealing with the trial of those accused of witchcraft. [1] Carpzov conceded that the use of torture could be abused in certain cases, but that its use was nonetheless necessary, even on those who might appear to be innocent. [1] Carpzov urged that even those who merely believed that they had attended a witches' sabbath should be executed, for the belief itself implied the will. [1] Under Carpzov's influence the use of torture to extract confessions from those accused of witchcraft was intensified. [1]

Carpzov was married twice and had multiple children in his first marriage.

Epitaph in the Paulinerkirche (2017) 20171108 Epitaph Carpzov.jpg
Epitaph in the Paulinerkirche (2017)

Memory

In 2001 a street in Leipzig was named Carpzovstrasse in his memory.

Works

Literature

Related Research Articles

<span class="mw-page-title-main">Rudolf von Jhering</span> German jurist (1818–1892)

Caspar Rudolph Ritter von Jhering was a German jurist. He is best known for his 1872 book Der Kampf ums Recht, as a legal scholar, and as the founder of a modern sociological and historical school of law. His ideas were important to the subsequent development of the "jurisprudence of interests" in Germany.

<span class="mw-page-title-main">Simon Dach</span> German lyrical poet and hymnwriter

Simon Dach was a German lyrical poet and hymnwriter, born in Memel, Duchy of Prussia.

<span class="mw-page-title-main">Georg Jellinek</span>

Georg Jellinek was a German public lawyer and was considered to be "the exponent of public law in Austria“.

Carpzov is the name of a family, many of whose members attained distinction in Saxony in the 17th and 18th centuries as jurists, theologians and statesmen.

<span class="mw-page-title-main">Johann Pistorius</span>

Johann Pistorius, also anglicized as John Pistorius or distinguished as Johann Pistorius the Younger, was a German controversialist and historian. He is sometimes called Niddanus from the name of his birthplace, Nidda in Hesse.

<span class="mw-page-title-main">Benedict Friedlaender</span> German academic and scientist (1866–1908)

Benedict Friedlaender was a German Jewish sexologist, sociologist, economist, volcanologist, and physicist.

<span class="mw-page-title-main">Werewolf witch trials</span> Historical witch trials combined with werewolf trials

Werewolf witch trials were witch trials combined with werewolf trials. Belief in werewolves developed parallel to the belief in European witches, in the course of the Late Middle Ages and the Early Modern period. Like the witchcraft trials as a whole, the trial of supposed werewolves emerged in what is now Switzerland during the Valais witch trials in the early 15th century and spread throughout Europe in the 16th, peaking in the 17th and subsiding by the 18th century. The persecution of werewolves and the associated folklore is an integral part of the "witch-hunt" phenomenon, albeit a marginal one, accusations of lycanthropy involved in only a small fraction of witchcraft trials.

<span class="mw-page-title-main">Joos de Damhouder</span>

Joos de Damhouder, also referred to as Joost, Jost, Josse or Jodocus (de) Damhouder, was a jurist from Bruges, in the County of Flanders. His writings had a lasting influence on European criminal law.

<span class="mw-page-title-main">Johann Daniel Major</span>

Johann Daniel Major was a German professor of theoretical medicine, naturalist, collector and the founder of museology.

<span class="mw-page-title-main">Christoph von Scheurl</span>

Christoph Scheurl or von Scheurl was a German jurist, diplomat and humanist who became famous for arranging a humanistic friendship between Johann Eck and Martin Luther.

<span class="mw-page-title-main">Johann Friedrich Gleditsch</span>

Johann Friedrich Gleditsch was a major book publisher in the late 17th and early 18th centuries.

Wolfgang Hirschbach was a German legal scholar.

<span class="mw-page-title-main">Carl Joseph Anton Mittermaier</span>

Carl Joseph Anton Mittermaier was a German jurist. Historian Richard J. Evans has described him as the 'nineteenth century's most influential critic of the death penalty'.

<span class="mw-page-title-main">Caspar Ziegler</span> German jurist, poet and composer (1621–1690)

Caspar Ziegler, also Kaspar Ziegler, was a German jurist, poet, hymnwriter and composer. He was the Rektor of the University of Wittenberg.

<span class="mw-page-title-main">August Buchner</span>

August Buchner was a German philologist, poet and literary scholar, an influential professor of poetry and rhetoric at the University of Wittenberg.

Ludwig Weimer ( is a German theologian and priest of the Catholic Integrated Community.

<span class="mw-page-title-main">Gottlob Benedict Bierey</span> German composer

Gottlob Benedict Bierey was a German composer, Kapellmeister and Theatre tenant.

<span class="mw-page-title-main">Johann Heinrich von Heucher</span> German botanist and physicist (1677-1746)

Johann Heinrich von Heucher was a German physician and botanist.

<span class="mw-page-title-main">Carl Georg von Wächter</span> German jurist (1797–1880)

Carl Joseph Georg Sigismund Wächter, from 1835 von Wächter, was a leading German jurist in the 19th century. For a brief period he served as president of the Oberappellationsgericht der vier Freien Städte.

<span class="mw-page-title-main">Eckart Brödermann</span> German legal scholar

Eckart Brödermann is an internationally active German legal scholar, specialist in international business law, arbitrator and author. He is a professor at the University of Hamburg.

References

  1. 1 2 3 4 Trevor-Roper, p.159