Benjamin Mills | |
---|---|
Associate Justice of the Kentucky Court of Appeals | |
In office 1820–1828 | |
Nominated by | Gabriel Slaughter |
Preceded by | John Rowan |
Personal details | |
Born | January 12,1779 Worcester County,Maryland |
Died | December 6,1831 52) Frankfort,Kentucky | (aged
Spouse | Mary Read Thornton |
Profession | Lawyer |
Benjamin Mills was a lawyer and judge who served in the Kentucky Circuit Courts and the Kentucky Court of Appeals. He also represented Bourbon County,Kentucky,in the Kentucky House of Representatives. Mills issued a significant ruling in the 1820 case of Rankin v. Lydia which dealt with the rights of slaves brought to the Northwest Territory,where slavery was illegal. Mills' opinion in Rankin established a precedent that was cited in U.S. courts until the abolition of slavery following the Civil War.
Later,Mills was ensnared in the state's Old Court –New Court controversy wherein the state legislature attempted to abolish the Court of Appeals in retaliation for its opinion overturning a piece of debt relief legislation. The legislature established a new Court of Appeals,and for a time,both courts claimed authority as the court of last resort in Kentucky. The controversial measure abolishing the old court was repealed in 1826,and Mills resigned from the court in 1828. He died suddenly of an apoplectic stroke on December 6,1831.
Benjamin Mills was born January 12,1779,in Worcester County,Maryland. [1] When he was young,the family moved to Washington,Pennsylvania,where Mills was educated and studied medicine. [2]
Mills married Mary Read Thornton. [3] One son,Thornton Anthony Mills,was born in September 1810. [3] Another son,Benjamin Mills,was born June 23,1820. [3] The family attended Paris Presbyterian Church,and both Benjamin and Thornton became Presbyterian ministers. [3] Benjamin also served as a brigadier general in the Union Army during the Civil War. [3]
His nephew Joseph Trotter Mills,Wisconsin State Assemblyman and jurist,lived and studied with his uncle. [4]
Mills served for a time as president of Washington Academy (now Washington and Lee University). [5] Later,he moved to Bourbon County,Kentucky,with his father. [5] He abandoned the practice of medicine and studied law,commencing practice in Paris,Kentucky,around 1806. [5] He served six one-year terms in the Kentucky House of Representatives —in 1806,1809,and 1813 through 1816. [5] In 1816,he failed to secure a seat in the United States Senate,losing to Isham Talbot by three votes. [5]
In 1817,Governor Gabriel Slaughter appointed Mills to the circuit court of Montgomery County. [2] [5] In 1818,at the request of the bar in Fayette County,he was transferred to the circuit court there. [2] In February 1820,Slaughter elevated him to the Kentucky Court of Appeals to replace John Rowan. [5]
In 1820,Mills authored the court's opinion in the case of Rankin v. Lydia [6] concerning the status of slaves born in the Northwest Territory where the Ordinance of 1787 outlawed slavery. [7] In his opinion,Mills was careful to avoid judgments regarding the institution of slavery itself,but upheld the decision of the Shelby County circuit court that the slave (Lydia) ought to be freed under terms of an indenture she had agreed to in Indiana before being sold to a master in Kentucky. [7] Mills' opinion set a precedent that was adhered to in Kentucky for the next forty-five years and was frequently cited in both northern and southern courts. [7]
In 1823,Mills and his fellow Court of Appeals justices were ensnared in Kentucky's Old Court –New Court controversy. In response to the Panic of 1819,the Kentucky General Assembly had passed a law of replevin that was extremely favorable to debtors. The law was challenged in two separate cases—Lapsley v. Brashear [8] and Blair v. Williams. [9] In both cases,the circuit courts had ruled the replevin law impaired the obligation of contracts in violation of the Contract Clause of the United States Constitution and similar language in the Kentucky Constitution. In October 1823,Mills and fellow justices John Boyle and William Owsley upheld the lower courts' rulings. An outraged General Assembly passed a measure abolishing the Court of Appeals and setting up a new Court of Appeals in its place,which pro-relief governor John Adair stocked with judges favorable to the debt relief cause. The Old Court considered the action illegal,and for a time,both the Old and New Courts claimed authority as the court of last resort in Kentucky. [10]
As the state's economy began to recover,Old Court supporters made steady gains in the legislature. By late 1826,they commanded a veto-proof majority in the General Assembly and passed legislation abolishing the New Court and reinstating the Old Court. In 1828,Boyle resigned his seat on the Court of Appeals to accept a federal judgeship. In an attempt to placate the remaining New Court supporters that insisted the Old Court judges did not represent the will of the people,Owsley and Mills also resigned,hoping to be reappointed and reconfirmed to their posts. Governor Thomas Metcalfe reappointed both,but the Kentucky Senate would not confirm them. Thus ended Mills' tenure on the Court of Appeals. [11]
Following his time on the bench,Mills moved to Frankfort,where he resumed his legal practice. [2] He died suddenly of an apoplectic stroke on December 6,1831. [2] [12]
Dred Scott was an enslaved African American man who,along with his wife,Harriet,unsuccessfully sued for the freedom of themselves and their two daughters,Eliza and Lizzie,in the Dred Scott v. Sandford case of 1857,popularly known as the "Dred Scott decision". The Scotts claimed that they should be granted freedom because Dred had lived in Illinois and the Wisconsin Territory for four years,where slavery was illegal,and laws in those jurisdictions said that slave holders gave up their rights to slaves if they stayed for an extended period.
James Gillespie Birney was an American abolitionist,politician,and attorney born in Danville,Kentucky. He changed from being a planter and slave owner to abolitionism,publishing the abolitionist weekly The Philanthropist. He twice served as the presidential nominee for the anti-slavery Liberty Party.
John Marshall Harlan was an American lawyer and politician who served as an associate justice of the Supreme Court of the United States from 1877 until his death in 1911. He is often called "The Great Dissenter" due to his many dissents in cases that restricted civil liberties,including the Civil Rights Cases,Plessy v. Ferguson,and Giles v. Harris. Many of Harlan's views expressed in his notable dissents would become the official view of the Supreme Court starting from the 1950s Warren Court and onward.
William Owsley was an associate justice of the Kentucky Court of Appeals and the 16th Governor of Kentucky. He also served in both houses of the Kentucky General Assembly and was Kentucky Secretary of State under Governor James Turner Morehead.
John Rankin was an American Presbyterian minister,educator and abolitionist. Upon moving to Ripley,Ohio,in 1822,he became known as one of Ohio's first and most active "conductors" on the Underground Railroad. Prominent pre-Civil War abolitionists William Lloyd Garrison,Theodore Weld,Henry Ward Beecher,and Harriet Beecher Stowe were influenced by Rankin's writings and work in the anti-slavery movement.
James Garrard was an American farmer,Baptist minister and politician who served as the second governor of Kentucky from 1796 to 1804. Because of term limits imposed by the state constitution adopted in 1799,he was the last Kentucky governor elected to two consecutive terms until the restriction was eased by a 1992 amendment,allowing Paul E. Patton's re-election in 1999.
Humphrey Marshall was a politician from the U.S. states of Virginia and Kentucky. He served in the state legislatures of both states and represented Kentucky in the United States Senate from 1795 to 1801. He was a member of the Marshall political family which included his cousins Chief Justice of the United States John Marshall,federal judge James Markham Marshall,and noted educator Louis Marshall. All the prominent members of this family were Federalists. Marshall was also the father of Congressman Thomas Alexander Marshall and the grandfather of Congressman and Confederate General Humphrey Marshall.
James Clark was a 19th-century American politician who served in all three branches of Kentucky's government and in the U.S. House of Representatives. His political career began in the Kentucky House of Representatives in 1807. In 1810,he was appointed to the Kentucky Court of Appeals,where he served for two years before resigning to pursue a seat in the U.S. House of Representatives. He served two terms in that body,resigning in 1816.
The United States District Court for the Eastern District of Kentucky is the Federal district court whose jurisdiction comprises approximately the Eastern half of the Commonwealth of Kentucky. The United States Court of Appeals for the Sixth Circuit in Cincinnati,Ohio maintains appellate jurisdiction for the district.
Robert Jefferson Breckinridge was a politician and Presbyterian minister. He was a member of the Breckinridge family of Kentucky,the son of Senator John Breckinridge.
The Old Court –New Court controversy was a 19th-century political controversy in the U.S. state of Kentucky in which the Kentucky General Assembly abolished the Kentucky Court of Appeals and replaced it with a new court. The justices of the old court refused to recognize the action as valid,and for a time,two separate courts operated as the court of last resort for the state.
Thomas Todd was an Associate Justice of the Supreme Court of the United States from 1807 to 1826. Raised in the Colony of Virginia,he studied law and later participated in the founding of Kentucky,where he served as a clerk,judge,and justice. He was married twice and had a total of eight children. Todd joined the U.S. Supreme Court in 1807 and his handful of legal opinions there mostly concerned land claims. He was labeled the most insignificant U.S. Supreme Court justice by Frank H. Easterbrook in The Most Insignificant Justice:Further Evidence,50 U. Chi. L. Rev. 481 (1983).
Robert Trimble was a lawyer and jurist who served as Justice of the Kentucky Court of Appeals,as United States district judge of the United States District Court for the District of Kentucky and as Associate Justice of the Supreme Court of the United States from 1826 to his death in 1828. During his brief Supreme Court tenure he authored several majority opinions,including the decision in Ogden v. Saunders,which was the only majority opinion that Chief Justice John Marshall ever dissented from during his 34 years on the Court.
The Kentucky Circuit Courts are the state courts of general jurisdiction in the U.S. state of Kentucky.
Williamson Dunn was an American judge and politician in the early history of Indiana. He served as the third Speaker of the Indiana House of Representatives. Dunn is credited with having founded the town of Hanover,Indiana,as well as having contributed funds towards the founding of Hanover College.
Samuel Crothers was a Presbyterian minister,writer,and outspoken antislavery advocate.
Joseph Trotter Mills was an American attorney,jurist,Republican politician,and Wisconsin pioneer. He served four one-year terms in the Wisconsin State Assembly,and was Wisconsin circuit court judge for the 5th circuit from 1865 through 1877.
Mary Bateman Clark (1795–1840) was an American woman,born into slavery,who was taken to Indiana Territory. She was forced to become an indentured servant,even though the Northwest Ordinance prohibited slavery. She was sold in 1816,the same year that the Constitution of Indiana prohibited slavery and indentured servitude. In 1821,attorney Amory Kinney represented her as she fought for her freedom in the courts. After losing the case in the Circuit Court,she appealed to the Indiana Supreme Court in the case of Mary Clark v. G.W. Johnston. She won her freedom with the precedent-setting decision against indentured servitude in Indiana. The documentary,Mary Bateman Clark:A Woman of Colour and Courage,tells the story of her life and fight for freedom.
Kentucky raid in Cass County (1847) was conducted by slaveholders and slave catchers who raided Underground Railroad stations in Cass County,Michigan to capture black people and return them to slavery. After unsuccessful attempts,and a lost court case,the Fugitive Slave Act of 1850 was enacted. Michigan's Personal Liberty Act of 1855 was passed in the state legislature to prevent the capture of formerly enslaved people that would return them to slavery.
The Paris,Kentucky slave coffle of summer 1822 is notable among thousands of such coffles of chained slaves forced to travel overland as part of the interstate slave trade in the United States because it was observed and carefully described by Ohio Presbyterian minister Rev. James H. Dickey,who reported that the slaves were marching under the flag of the United States. According to The Liberator by way of John Rankin this group of slaves was the legal property of Kentucky slave traders named Stone and Kinningham. This is presumably Edward Stone and Benjamin Keiningham of Bourbon County,Kentucky.
In the summer of 1822,as I returned with my family from a visit to the Barrens of Kentucky,I witnessed a scene such as I never witnessed before,and such as I hope never to witness again. Having passed through Paris,in Bourbon County,Kentucky,the sound of music attracted my attention. I looked forward,and saw the flag of my country waving. Supposing that I was about to meet a military parade,I drove hastily to the side of the road;and,having gained the ascent,I discovered about 40 black men all chained together after the following manner:each of them was handcuffed,and they were arranged in rank and file. A chain perhaps 40 feet long,the size of a fifth-horse-chain,was stretched between the two ranks,to which short chains were joined,which connected with the handcuffs. Behind them were,I suppose,about 30 women,in double rank,the couples tied hand to hand. A solemn sadness sat on every countenance,and the dismal silence of this march of despair was interrupted only by the sound of two violins;yes,as if to add insult to injury,the foremost couple were furnished with a violin a-piece;the second couple were ornamented with cockades,while near the centre waved the republican flag,carried by a hand literally in chains.