Bernard the Dane

Last updated

Bernard the Dane is described by the tenth century ecclesiastical writer Dudo of Saint-Quentin as a 'warrior' of Rouen from 'Dacia', [note 1] an ally and confidant of the first leaders of Normandy, political counsellor to Rollo's son William Longsword, and co-regent of the territory during the minority of his son and heir, Richard I of Normandy. In particular, Bernard is seen as being at the centre of events in the aftermath of the assassination of William Longsword.

Contents

Life

We know extremely little about Bernard the Dane and all that we do know comes from Dudo of Saint-Quentin in his work commonly referred to as 'De moribus', the story of the lives of the earliest leaders of Normandy. [1] He would have been alive in the middle of the tenth century but we have no birth or death dates for him. Dudo ascribes to him great wealth and a 'beautiful wife' [2] but doesn't name her or mention any children. In fact, the section of Dudo's story that includes mentions of Bernard the Dane only spans four years from 942 to 946 CE.

In 942 CE [note 2] , William Longsword is assassinated, [3] sparking a series of dramatic events during which Dudo depicts Bernard the Dane as having a significant role, not only as a military leader in Rouen, but also as co-regent of the territory whilst William's son and heir, Richard, is still in his minority. [4] [note 3]

Dudo recounts that, after the murder of his father, the young heir, Richard, is abducted by allies of the king (Louis IV) and taken to the royal stronghold of Laon under the guise of protecting and educating him. Then we hear of his rescue and return to Rouen where, Dudo says, he is put under the protection of Bernard the Dane. [6]

As a result of the perceived weakness of Normandy at this point, the king and Hugh the Great both attack the province. The Normans - in the person of Bernard the Dane in Dudo's account - respond by calling on the Danish king (Harald Bluetooth) to raise an army which duly lands in Normandy and captures the king. He is then held hostage in Rouen. Negotiations follow, with Bernard playing a central role, which culminate in the release of the king in return for a renewed treaty re-asserting the Normans' right to their territory and Richard's right to its leadership. [7]

These events had concluded by early 946 CE, after which Dudo makes no further mention of Bernard the Dane.

Historicity

There is no extant contemporary source for Bernard the Dane, [note 4] despite there being two writers who were both maintaining chronicles at the time: Flodoard and Richer, both of Reims.

Absence from contemporary sources

Flodoard of Reims, maintained his 'Annals' over the period 920 to 960 CE. [8] He would have been a young man when the treaty establishing Normandy was signed and in the midst of writing his chronicles when William was killed in 942 CE. He describes this shocking event, and those that followed it, but fails to mention Bernard the Dane either in this context or at any point in his forty year chronicle. This is surprising if the prominence ascribed by Dudo to Bernard is to be believed, especially since Flodoard is regarded as a light in the darkness of the history of this period. (In his notes to his edition of Flodoard's 'Annals', Philippe Lauer says that, but for Flodoard, "a good part of the tenth century history of France would consist only in a few scattered and discordant mentions, and in a web of legends"). [9] [note 5]

The 'Historia' by the monk Richer [11] covers the period from 885 to 996 CE. For the earlier part of that period, that of interest in regard to Bernard, Richer relied upon and closely followed Flodoard. He doesn't mention Bernard the Dane.

Dudo of Saint-Quentin

Dudo started writing his version of events in 996 CE, over fifty years after the assassination of William Longsword. His 'De moribus' is a panegyric, part prose and part verse, written in florid and arcane language, which has been widely questioned by modern historians. Sir Frank Stenton said of it: "The panegyrical history of the early dukes written by Dudo of St. Quentin for Duke Richard II has suffered irretrievably from modern criticism." [10] Graham Loud has described it as "a piece of extremely learned, not to say remarkably pretentious, literary fiction" and adds that most of what Dudo wrote was "either his own invention or the product of skilful plagiarisation or reworking of other events." [12] The historian Leah Shopkow regards Bernard the Dane, specifically, as an invention of Dudo. [13]

Later histories

In the eleventh century both William of Jumièges [14] and Hugh of Fleury [15] write histories of the period, mirroring Dudo for the tenth century, adding nothing of substance about Bernard the Dane or indicating other primary sources. Dudo's 'De moribus' continues to form the basis of further histories of Normandy for the period.

Bernard in genealogy

Despite Dudo suggesting nothing more than Bernard the Dane having an unnamed "beautiful wife", this hasn't stopped genealogists from creating a family for him. Notably, Gilles-André de La Roque [16] in his 1633 work on the genealogy of the Harcourt family, [17] ascribes a family to Bernard that is not found elsewhere. He asserts that Torf the Rich was Bernard's son, thus implying that Bernard was the earliest known forebear of the houses of Beaumont and Harcourt. This has since been replicated very widely and is evident in countless online genealogies and family histories today. La Roque's 'sources' for Bernard the Dane are limited to discussions with fellow genealogists and recent manuscripts, which do not provide a source for the family he attaches to Bernard the Dane. [note 6]

Notes

  1. ↑ Bernard the Dane is a convenient widely-used standardisation of the name. Dudo calls him either 'Bernard of Rouen' (L. Bernardum Rothomagensis) or 'Bernard the Dacian' (L. Bernardum Dacigenam) where 'Dacia' refers to a diocese of eastern Scandinavia, not the province bordering the Black Sea. Dudo sometimes follows the name with militem ('knight' or 'warrior').
  2. ↑ Dudo does not provide dates but these events appear in other sources (see references) and can be dated by contextual cross-referencing.
  3. ↑ In this work there is more than one character named Bernard and Dudo sometimes fails to be clear about which Bernard he is referring to. For example, after Rollo hands over power to his son William Longsword (in 928 CE), Dudo mentions that "a certain Bernard, privy to duke William's secrets", recalls the brave deeds of his father Rollo. [5] This may refer to either Bernard the Dane or Bernard of Senlis, a relative of William. If it is indeed Bernard the Dane then there follows a period of some fifteen years when he is absent from Dudo's story.
  4. ↑ The 'cartularies', ecclesiastical records kept by the monasteries and churches, do not generally stretch back to this period.
  5. ↑ The noted historian, Sir Frank Stenton also refers to the paucity of sources: "In dealing with any aspect of early Norman history it is impossible to get very far down beneath speculation to concrete fact" and "For the study of early Norman society materials are few, and many of them are untrustworthy." [10]
  6. ↑ La Roque includes some side notes and an extensive section which he calls his "Preuves" or proofs. The side note for Bernard the Dane [18] refers only to discussions with his colleagues in 1613 and a work entitled "Chroniques de Normandie" which is described in the 'Encyclopedia of the Medieval Chronicle', [19] as being "drawn up from the Latin chronicles of Dudo of St. Quentin, William of Jumièges, and Orderic Vitalis". The Foundation for Medieval Genealogy describes La Roque's "Preuves" as copies or summaries of other documents, which lack source references and mainly lack dates, and are unverifiable. [20]

Related Research Articles

<span class="mw-page-title-main">Rollo</span> 10th-century Viking and Count of Rouen

Rollo was a Viking who, as Count of Rouen, became the first ruler of Normandy, today a region in northern France. He emerged as the outstanding warrior among the Norsemen who had secured a permanent foothold on Frankish soil in the valley of the lower Seine. After the Siege of Chartres in 911, Charles the Simple, the king of West Francia, granted them lands between the mouth of the Seine and what is now Rouen in exchange for Rollo agreeing to end his brigandage, swearing allegiance to him, religious conversion and a pledge to defend the Seine's estuary from Viking raiders.

<span class="mw-page-title-main">Duchy of Normandy</span> Medieval duchy in northern France

The Duchy of Normandy grew out of the 911 Treaty of Saint-Clair-sur-Epte between King Charles III of West Francia and the Viking leader Rollo. The duchy was named for its inhabitants, the Normans.

<span class="mw-page-title-main">Richard II, Duke of Normandy</span> Duke of Normandy from 996 until 1026

Richard II, called the Good, was the duke of Normandy from 996 until 1026.

William III, called Towhead from the colour of his hair, was the "Count of the Duchy of Aquitaine" from 959 and Duke of Aquitaine from 962 to his death. He was also the Count of Poitou from 935 and Count of Auvergne from 950. The primary sources for his reign are Ademar of Chabannes, Dudo of Saint-Quentin, and William of Jumièges.

<span class="mw-page-title-main">Richard I of Normandy</span> 10th-century Duke of Normandy

Richard I, also known as Richard the Fearless, was the count of Rouen from 942 to 996. Dudo of Saint-Quentin, whom Richard commissioned to write the "De moribus et actis primorum Normanniae ducum", called him a dux. However, this use of the word may have been in the context of Richard's renowned leadership in war, and not as a reference to a title of nobility. Richard either introduced feudalism into Normandy or he greatly expanded it. By the end of his reign, the most important Norman landholders held their lands in feudal tenure.

Dudo, or Dudon, was a Picard historian, and dean of Saint-Quentin, where he was born about 965. Sent in 986 by Albert I, Count of Vermandois, on an errand to Richard I, Duke of Normandy, he succeeded in his mission, and, having made a very favorable impression at the Norman court, spent some years in that country. During a second stay in Normandy, Dudo wrote his history of the Normans, a task which Duke Richard had urged him to undertake. Very little else is known about his life, except that he died before 1043.

<i>Gesta Normannorum Ducum</i>

Gesta Normannorum Ducum is a chronicle originally created by the monk William of Jumièges just before 1060. In 1070 William I had William of Jumièges extend the work to detail his rights to the throne of England. In later times, Orderic Vitalis and Robert of Torigni, extended the volumes to include history up until Henry I.

<i>Roman de Rou</i>

Roman de Rou is a verse chronicle by Wace in Norman covering the history of the Dukes of Normandy from the time of Rollo of Normandy to the battle of Tinchebray in 1106. It is a national epic of Normandy.

<span class="mw-page-title-main">William of Jumièges</span> 11th century monk and historian

William of Jumièges was a contemporary of the events of 1066, and one of the earliest writers on the subject of the Norman conquest of England. He is himself a shadowy figure, only known by his dedicatory letter to William the Conqueror as a monk of Jumièges. Since he also mentions that he was an eyewitness of some events from the reign of Duke Richard III (1026-7), it seems reasonable to assume that he was born some time about the year 1000. He probably entered the monastery during the first quarter of the eleventh century and received his education from Thierry de Mathonville. According to Orderic Vitalis, William's nickname was "Calculus". The meaning behind this nickname is unknown. His death, after 1070, is unrecorded. He was a Norman writing from a Norman point of view. Although only a monk with evidently no military training, he wrote with pride in the accomplishments of his people.

<span class="mw-page-title-main">William Longsword</span> Count of Normandy from 927 to 942

William Longsword was the second ruler of Normandy, from 927 until his assassination in 942.

<span class="mw-page-title-main">History of Normandy</span>

Normandy was a province in the North-West of France under the Ancien Régime which lasted until the later part of the 18th century. Initially populated by Celtic tribes in the West and Belgic tribes in the North East, it was conquered in AD 98 by the Romans and integrated into the province of Gallia Lugdunensis by Augustus. In the 4th century, Gratian divided the province into the civitates that constitute the historical borders. After the fall of Rome in the 5th century, the Franks became the dominant ethnic group in the area and built several monasteries. Towards the end of the 8th century, Viking raids devastated the region, prompting the establishment of the Duchy of Normandy in 911. After 150 years of expansion, the borders of Normandy reached relative stability. These old borders roughly correspond to the present borders of Lower Normandy, Upper Normandy and the Channel Islands. Mainland Normandy was integrated into the Kingdom of France in 1204. The region was badly damaged during the Hundred Years War and the Wars of Religion, the Normans having more converts to Protestantism than other peoples of France. In the 20th century, D-Day, the 1944 Allied invasion of Western Europe, started in Normandy. In 1956, mainland Normandy was separated into two regions, Lower Normandy and Upper Normandy, which were reunified in 2016.

Étienne de Rouen, also Stephen of Rouen and Latin: Stephanus de Rouen, was a Norman Benedictine monk of Bec Abbey of the twelfth century, and a chronicler and poet.

Anslech or Anslec de Bricquebec played a major political role in the first days of the duchy of Normandy, though the sources on him are rather opaque.

The phrase more danico is a Medieval Latin legal expression which may be translated as "according to Danish custom", i.e. under Medieval Scandinavian customary law.

<span class="mw-page-title-main">Poppa of Bayeux</span> French mistress or wife of Viking conqueror Rollo

Poppa of Bayeux, was the wife more danico' of the Viking conqueror Rollo. She was the mother of William I Longsword, Gerloc and grandmother of Richard the Fearless, who forged the Duchy of Normandy into a great fief of medieval France. Dudo of Saint-Quentin, in his panegyric of the Norman dukes, describes her as the daughter of a "Count Berengar", the dominant prince of that region, who was captured at Bayeux by Rollo in 885 or 889, shortly after the siege of Paris. This has led to speculation that she was the daughter of Berengar II of Neustria.

<span class="mw-page-title-main">Gisela of France</span> Legendary 10th-century French princess

Gisela was a French princess who was married to Rollo, Duke of Normandy.

Sprota was an early 10th century woman of obscure origin who became wife 'in the Viking fashion' of William I, Duke of Normandy, by her becoming mother of his successor, Duke Richard I. After the death of William, she married a wealthy landowner, Esperleng, by him having another son, Norman nobleman Rodulf of Ivry.

Hagrold, also known as Hagroldus, Harold, and Harald, was a powerful tenth-century Viking chieftain who ruled Bayeux. He was apparently a pagan from Scandinavia, and seems to have seized power in Normandy at about the time of the death of William, Count of Rouen. His career can be interpreted in the context of aiding the Normans against the intrusion of Frankish authority, or conversely in the context of taking advantage of the Normans.

<span class="mw-page-title-main">Louis IV of France</span> King of West Francia from 936 to 954

Louis IV, called d'Outremer or Transmarinus, reigned as King of West Francia from 936 to 954. A member of the Carolingian dynasty, he was the only son of king Charles the Simple and his second wife Eadgifu of Wessex, daughter of King Edward the Elder of Wessex. His reign is mostly known thanks to the Annals of Flodoard and the later Historiae of Richerus.

Taisson le Ancien, or Old Badger, was a close companion of William Longsword and played a major political role in the early days of the Duchy of Normandy.

References

  1. ↑ Dudo of Saint-Quentin - De moribus et actis primorum Normanniae ducum, English edition and translation by Felice Lifshitz, 1998, ORB. Based upon the Fécamp (Berlin) manuscript, the chapter and folio numbering of which are used for the citations of this work on this page.
  2. ↑ De moribus ch. 40, f. 61v
  3. ↑ The Anglo-Saxon Chronicles, Swanton, p.111
  4. ↑ De moribus chs. 27-42, ff. 46r-64r
  5. ↑ De moribus ch. 20, ff. 38r-39r
  6. ↑ De moribus chs. 34-36, ff. 52v-55v
  7. ↑ De moribus chs. 38-42, ff. 56v-64r
  8. ↑ Philippe Lauer (editor), Les annales de Flodoard, Picard, 1905. In Latin with a French introduction and notes, archive.org
  9. ↑ Lauer, Les annales de Flodoard, Introduction by Lauer, p. xviii
  10. 1 2 Sir Frank Stenton - speech made on becoming President of the Royal Historical Society in 1944, reproduced in 'The transactions of the Royal Historical Society', 4th Series, Volume 27, 1945. MGH
  11. ↑ Richer - Historia congressus Gallorum, Latin with French facing page translation, edition by A.M. Poinsignon, 1855; BNF
  12. ↑ Graham A Loud - review of Eric Christiansen's 'Dudo of St Quentin: History of the Normans', JSTOR.
  13. ↑ Leah Shopkow - History and Community: Norman Historical Writing in the Eleventh and Twelfth Centuries, Catholic University of America Press, 1997, ch.2.
  14. ↑ William of Jumièges - Gesta Normannorum Ducum, edition by Francois Guizot, Project Gutenberg
  15. ↑ Hugh of Fleury, appendix to Lauer, p.216
  16. ↑ Gilles-André de La Roque (French)
  17. ↑ Gilles-André de La Roque - Histoire généalogique de la maison de Harcourt BNF
  18. ↑ La Roque, preface p.7
  19. ↑ eds. Graeme Dunphy, Cristian Bratu Brill
  20. ↑ FMG Medieval Lands
This page is based on this Wikipedia article
Text is available under the CC BY-SA 4.0 license; additional terms may apply.
Images, videos and audio are available under their respective licenses.