Better Angel

Last updated

Better Angel is a novel by Forman Brown first published in 1933 under the pseudonym Richard Meeker. It was republished as Torment in 1951. It is an early novel which describes a gay lifestyle without condemning it. [1] Christopher Carey called it "the first homosexual novel with a truly happy ending". [2]

Contents

The novel's title references Shakespeare's Sonnet 144: "the better angel is a man right fair", [3] a poem which has been read as having a homosexual subtext.

Publication history

Brown's novel was published pseudonymously in 1933 and attracted little critical attention. [4] Universal paperbacks re-published it 1951 under the title Torment. The blurb on the cover read: "Is it evil for one man to lavish affection on another? Torn between the boy who cherished him and the girl who struggled for his love, Kurt Gray could not be sure." [5] The Mattachine Review described Kurt as "perhaps the healthiest homosexual in print". [4] Alyson Publications published the novel again in 1987 under its original title with an introduction by Hubert Kennedy. [4] Brown was unaware of the 1987 edition; his copyright had expired, and the novel could be printed and sold without his permission. He learned of its appearance from a friend who reported seeing it in a bookstore. [6] He provided an epilogue for the 1990 reprint of the 1987 edition in which he explained that he used a pseudonym decades earlier to protect his writing career at CBS and to shield his parents. [4]

Plot

The novel is a Bildungsroman recounting the passage of Kurt Gray—his surname plays on the author's Brown—from his adolescent years in central Michigan to mature adult and his development as a musician and composer. [7] Kurt's teenage years are marked by "solitude, bookish seriousness, gender dislocation, and religion", a dislike of sports, and an interest in amateur theatricals. He memorizes Bible stories and experiences a Christian awakening that transforms into a spiritual devotion to poetry and music. At the University of Michigan, he has his first same-sex experiences and discovers the poetry of Swinburne, "a revelation". After graduating he explores the psychological literature of Jung, Freud, and Ellis, then Edward Carpenter, Plato's Phaedrus and Symposium , and Oscar Wilde. Kurt identifies a contrast between American religiosity and an alternative offered by the Europeans he reads, which he identifies as spiritual, even preferring the French spirituel: "The English never had created so exact a word for it." [8]

The novel describes the love affair between Kurt and another man Derry, and their relationship with a third man, David. Brown later said that it was in the main autobiographical, that he based Kurt on himself, Derry on Harry Burnett, David on his long-time partner Richard "Roddy" Brandon, and fourth major character, Tony, on actor Alexander Kirkland. [4] Brown and Burnett were lovers for 60 years, beginning in 1926. [9] All three of them worked together in the Yale Puppeteers on tour and then in their base at the Turnabout Theatre in Los Angeles.

Treatment of homosexuality

Homosexual themes in literature were becoming more common in the 1930s, following the example of writers such as Clarkson Crane and Carl van Vechten in the 1920s. Nevertheless, many works from the 1930s with a homosexual theme remained unpublished until much later. [7] This novel stands out from its contemporaries in allowing its gay protagonist a happy ending.

The novel does not portray any sexual activity. It includes the word homosexual only once and uses the word queer a few times in a way that suggests homosexual. [1] Kurt's early discovery of masturbation is described in euphemisms, and he reads Bible passages—the stories of Onan, David, Sodom, Lot—"that suggested hidden knowledge". Brown describes his reaction: "He felt, though he had never been told, that what he did was wrong." The subject is developed as the prime motivation of his religious conversion. [8]

Critical response

The Continuum Encyclopedia of American Literature (2005) called it "rather artless", but still a cut above the usual sensationalist and exploitative treatment of homosexuality in other works of the same period. [7]

Donovan R. Walling listed the novel in 2003 as a homosexual coming-of-age novel that might be of interest for classroom reading. [10]

See also

Related Research Articles

<span class="mw-page-title-main">E. M. Forster</span> English novelist and writer (1879–1970)

Edward Morgan Forster was an English author, best known for his novels, particularly A Room with a View (1908), Howards End (1910) and A Passage to India (1924).

<span class="mw-page-title-main">Mary Renault</span> British novelist (1905–1983)

Eileen Mary Challans, known by her pen name Mary Renault, was a British writer best known for her historical novels set in ancient Greece.

<i>Maurice</i> (novel) 1971 novel by E. M. Forster

Maurice is a novel by E. M. Forster. A tale of homosexual love in early 20th-century England, it follows Maurice Hall from his schooldays through university and beyond. It was written in 1913–1914 and revised in 1932 as well as 1952–1960. Forster was an admirer of the poet, philosopher, socialist, and early gay rights activist Edward Carpenter and, following a visit to Carpenter's home at Millthorpe, Derbyshire in 1913, was inspired to write Maurice. The cross-class relationship between Carpenter and his working-class partner, George Merrill, presented a real-life model for that of Maurice and Alec Scudder.

<span class="mw-page-title-main">Adolf Brand</span> German writer (1874–1945)

Gustav Adolf Franz Brand was a German writer, egoist anarchist, and pioneering campaigner for the acceptance of male bisexuality and homosexuality.

<span class="mw-page-title-main">Ronald Firbank</span> English novelist (1886–1926)

Arthur Annesley Ronald Firbank was an innovative English novelist. His eight short novels, partly inspired by the London aesthetes of the 1890s, especially Oscar Wilde, consist largely of dialogue, with references to religion, social-climbing, and sexuality.

<span class="mw-page-title-main">Gay literature</span> Literary genre

Gay literature is a collective term for literature produced by or for the gay community which involves characters, plot lines, and/or themes portraying male homosexual behavior.

Greek love is a term originally used by classicists to describe the primarily homoerotic customs, practices, and attitudes of the ancient Greeks. It was frequently used as a euphemism for both homosexuality and pederasty. The phrase is a product of the enormous impact of the reception of classical Greek culture on historical attitudes toward sexuality, and its influence on art and various intellectual movements.

'Greece' as the historical memory of a treasured past was romanticised and idealised as a time and a culture when love between males was not only tolerated but actually encouraged, and expressed as the high ideal of same-sex camaraderie. ... If tolerance and approval of male homosexuality had happened once—and in a culture so much admired and imitated by the eighteenth and nineteenth centuries—might it not be possible to replicate in modernity the antique homeland of the non-heteronormative?

<span class="mw-page-title-main">LGBT themes in comics</span>

In comics, LGBT themes are a relatively new concept, as lesbian, gay, bisexual, and transgender (LGBT) themes and characters were historically omitted from the content of comic books and their comic strip predecessors due to anti-gay censorship. LGBT existence was included only via innuendo, subtext and inference. However the practice of hiding LGBT characters in the early part of the twentieth century evolved into open inclusion in the late twentieth and early twenty-first centuries, and comics explored the challenges of coming-out, societal discrimination, and personal and romantic relationships between gay characters.

<i>The Lost Weekend</i> (novel) 1944 novel by Charles R. Jackson

The Lost Weekend is Charles R. Jackson's first novel, published by Farrar & Rinehart in 1944. The story of a talented but alcoholic writer was praised for its powerful realism, closely reflecting the author’s own experience of alcoholism, from which he was temporarily cured. It served as the basis for the classic 1945 Oscar winning film adaptation.

<span class="mw-page-title-main">Forman Brown</span> American puppeteer

Forman Brown was one of the world's leaders in puppet theatre in his day, as well as an important early gay novelist. He was a member of the Yale Puppeteers and the driving force behind Turnabout Theatre. He was born in Otsego, Michigan, in 1901 and died in 1996, two days after his 95th birthday. Brown briefly taught at North Carolina State College, followed by an extensive tour of Europe.

<span class="mw-page-title-main">Gay pulp fiction</span> Genre of pulp fiction literature

Gay pulp fiction, or gay pulps, refers to printed works, primarily fiction, that include references to male homosexuality, specifically male gay sex, and that are cheaply produced, typically in paperback books made of wood pulp paper; lesbian pulp fiction is similar work about women. Michael Bronski, the editor of an anthology of gay pulp writing, notes in his introduction, "Gay pulp is not an exact term, and it is used somewhat loosely to refer to a variety of books that had very different origins and markets". People often use the term to refer to the "classic" gay pulps that were produced before about 1970, but it may also be used to refer to the gay erotica or pornography in paperback book or digest magazine form produced since that date.

<span class="mw-page-title-main">Lesbian literature</span> Subgenre of literature with lesbian themes

Lesbian literature is a subgenre of literature addressing lesbian themes. It includes poetry, plays, fiction addressing lesbian characters, and non-fiction about lesbian-interest topics.

<i>Just Above My Head</i> 1979 novel by James Baldwin

Just Above My Head is James Baldwin's sixth and last novel, first published in 1979. He wrote it in his house in Saint-Paul-de-Vence, France.

<i>Joseph and His Friend: A Story of Pennsylvania</i> 1870 American novel

Joseph and His Friend: A Story of Pennsylvania is an 1870 novel by American author Bayard Taylor, a prolific writer in many genres. It presented a special attachment between two men and discussed the nature and significance of such a relationship, romantic but not sexual. Critics are divided in interpreting Taylor's novel as a political argument for homosexual relationships or an idealization of male spirituality.

In Mexican culture, it is now relatively common to see gay characters represented on Mexican sitcoms and soap operas (telenovelas) and being discussed on talk shows. However, representations of male homosexuals vary widely. They often include stereotypical versions of male effeminacy meant to provide comic relief as well as representations meant to increase social awareness and generate greater acceptance of homosexuality. However, efforts to represent lesbians have remained nearly non-existent, which might be related to the more general invisibility of lesbian subcultures in Mexico.

John Stewart Wynne is an American author of novels, short stories and poetry, as well as a Grammy-nominated producer of spoken word recordings.

<span class="mw-page-title-main">Harry Burnett</span>

Harry Burnett was the designer of the Yale Puppeteers. He was also a mask creator. In Better Angel, Forman Brown's early gay novel, he is Derry.

<i>Lost Gay Novels</i> 2003 non-fiction book about gay literature

Lost Gay Novels is a 2003 reference guide written by Anthony Slide that provides commentary on 50 works of gay literature published between 1900 and 1950 that Slide found to be not well known by late 20th and early 21st-century audiences.

<i>The Western Shore</i> 1925 novel

The Western Shore is a 1925 novel written by Clarkson Crane. It depicts life at the University of California, Berkeley in a series of 20 "episodes" featuring a variety of characters. Lawrence Clark Powell described it as one of the first and best novels about university life at Berkeley.

References

  1. 1 2 Slide, Anthony (2003). Lost Gay Novels: A Reference Guide to Fifty Works from the First Half of the Twentieth Century. Routledge. p. 127. ISBN   9781560234142.
  2. Carey, Christopher (2012). Trials from Classical Athens. Routledge. p. 484.
  3. Hallock, John W.M. (2000). American Byron: Homosexuality & The Fall Of Fitz-Greene Halleck. University of Wisconsin Press. p. 163.
  4. 1 2 3 4 5 Slide, Anthony (2003). Lost Gay Novels: A Reference Guide to Fifty Works from the First Half of the Twentieth Century. Routledge. p. 128. ISBN   9781560234142.
  5. Jordan, Mark D. (2011). Recruiting Young Love: How Christians Talk about Homosexuality. University of Chicago Press. p. 48.
  6. Bessie, Dan (2012). Rare Birds: An American Family. Untreed Reads. p. ?. ISBN   9781611872606.
  7. 1 2 3 Serafin, Alfred Bendixen (2005). The Continuum Encyclopedia of American Literature. Continuum.
  8. 1 2 Jordan, Mark D. (2011). Recruiting Young Love: How Christians Talk about Homosexuality. University of Chicago Press. pp. 22–5.
  9. Bessie, Dan (2012). Rare Birds: An American Family. Untreed Reads. p. ?. ISBN   9781611872606.
  10. Walling, Donovan R (2003). "Gay- and Lesbian-Themed Novels for Classroom Reading". Journal of Gay & Lesbian Issues in Education. 1 (2): 97–108 [103]. doi:10.1300/J367v01n02_12. S2CID   158993807.

Further reading