Billy Green (scout)

Last updated

William Green, otherwise known as Billy Green the Scout, was key to the British-Upper Canadian victory at the Battle of Stoney Creek. Billy Green was born February 4, 1794, in the Saltfleet Township in Upper Canada, and died March 15, 1877. His father was a New Jersey Loyalist named Ensign Adam Green. His mother, Martha Green, died a year or so after Billy was born, so he was raised by his oldest sister. He was the last born of the eleven children in his family. According to local tradition, he is believed the first white child born in the vicinity of Stoney Creek, Ontario. [1] [2]

Contents

Billy Green's contribution to the battle

Photograph taken of a painting in the house William Green built, and occupied by his great, great granddaughter Barbara Green. Artist unknown. Billy Green the Scout.jpg
Photograph taken of a painting in the house William Green built, and occupied by his great, great granddaughter Barbara Green. Artist unknown.

On June 5, 1813, Billy's sister reported to him that her husband, Isaac Corman, had been captured by the Americans, who held him near the beach on Lake Ontario. Corman convinced some American officers that he was a cousin of William Henry Harrison, an American politician (and later president) who was major-general of US troops in the north-west. The officers released Isaac, who then requested the counter-sign so that he could get past the American sentries and go home. They gave it to him—it was Wil-Hen-Har, after the major general, and released him. Billy caught up to Corman and got the password. The Americans, realizing their mistake, promptly caught up to Corman and recaptured him.

Billy took his brother Levi's horse "Tip" and rode to Burlington Heights to warn the British. The British, who had recently themselves spied on the Americans, assumed Billy was a spy. After questioning him, Lieutenant-Colonel John Harvey decided he was not a spy. He realized that the password and Billy's intimate knowledge of the countryside would help Harvey's planned surprise attack on the American camp at night. He gave Billy a sword [3] and asked him to guide the troops. They left just before midnight, with Harvey in charge.

They first encountered American sentries at Davis' tavern at Big Creek (now Red Hill Creek), who fired their muskets and dispersed. They encountered more sentries along the way, in the woods and near a church. Billy dispatched one of the sentries with his sword, while giving him the countersign. As they snuck up to the American camp they saw fires set by the American troops, on the other side of a lane. Billy was present at the battle but was not injured.

The monument, erected on the battlefield in 1913, at the centenary of the Battle, is inscribed Scout Green. [4]

Controversy and proof

Various accounts have greatly embellished this version of events. For example, one account called Green the "Paul Revere of Canada," and claimed that he "sighted the American army massing below the mountain at Stoney Creek" and "felt it his duty to inform the English troops of their nearness". [5] This is a fabrication, as the British knew exactly where the Americans were, and knew they were being pursued by them. Such easily demonstrable inventions have fueled commentary that the whole story is a legend, raising substantial questions as to the authenticity of the accepted historical record regarding Billy Green's purported actions and presence at the Battle of Stoney Creek, most notably by journalist James E. Elliott. [6] A shorter version of Elliott's analysis of the historical record was published in The Hamilton Spectator in December 2009. [7]

The sword Lieutenant-Colonel John Harvey gave to Billy Green the Scout before the Battle of Stoney Creek, June 5, 1813 Billy Green the Scout's sword..JPG
The sword Lieutenant-Colonel John Harvey gave to Billy Green the Scout before the Battle of Stoney Creek, June 5, 1813

Articles published in 2011 and 2013 rebut questions raised about Green's actions at Stoney Creek. The first is an article [8] in the War of 1812 Magazine, in which author Philip Green reviews primary and secondary source evidence and material cultural evidence from the time of the battle. The primary source evidence consists mostly of written correspondence from British officers and American officers in the periods leading up to and immediately after the battle. The article compared the correspondence with accounts by Billy Green, and found a close correspondence. The conclusion from the article is that, by the standard of evidence used to accept Laura Secord as historical fact, the story of Billy Green must be accepted as historical fact.

A second article [9] that rebuts Elliot's claim was published in 2011. The authors followed shortly after with another. [10]

Tribute

Billy Green Falls, a complex ribbon waterfall found in Battlefield Creek, Stoney Creek, Hamilton, Ontario, Canada was named after him. [11] Billy Green Elementary School, is also named after him and is nearby. [12]

The book of poetry "Never Counting the Cost" (2012), by Raymond Souster and Les Green, recounts the War of 1812 and Billy Green the Scout. Souster won the Governor General's Award and the Order of Canada. Published by The Battered Silicon Dispatch Box, Eugenia, Ontario.

Media

Stan Rogers popularized Billy Green's exploits in the song "Billy Green the Scout" on the album 'From Coffee House to Concert Hall'. Billy's story was also celebrated by singer George Fox. [13]

Related Research Articles

<span class="mw-page-title-main">Battle of Horseshoe Bend</span> Penultimate battle of the Creek War (1814)

The Battle of Horseshoe Bend, was fought during the War of 1812 in the Mississippi Territory, now central Alabama. On March 27, 1814, United States forces and Indian allies under Major General Andrew Jackson defeated the Red Sticks, a part of the Creek Indian tribe who opposed American expansion, effectively ending the Creek War.

<span class="mw-page-title-main">Battle of Crysler's Farm</span> War of 1812 battle

The Battle of Crysler's Farm, also known as the Battle of Crysler's Field, was fought on 11 November 1813, during the War of 1812. A British and Canadian force won a victory over a US force which greatly outnumbered them. The US defeat prompted them to abandon the St. Lawrence Campaign, their major strategic effort in the autumn of 1813.

<span class="mw-page-title-main">Battle of Stoney Creek</span> 1813 battle during the War of 1812

The Battle of Stoney Creek was a British victory over an American force fought on 6 June 1813, during the War of 1812 near present-day Stoney Creek, Ontario. British units made a night attack on the American encampment, and due in large part to the capture of the two senior officers of the American force, and an overestimation of British strength by the Americans, the battle resulted in a total victory for the British, and a turning point in the defence of Upper Canada.

<span class="mw-page-title-main">Battle of Beaver Dams</span> War of 1812 battle

The Battle of Beaver Dams took place on 24 June 1813, during the War of 1812. A column of troops from the United States Army marched from Fort George and attempted to surprise a British outpost at Beaver Dams, billeting themselves overnight in the village of Queenston, Ontario. Laura Secord, a resident of Queenston, had earlier learned of the American plans from several Americans billeted at her house and had struck out on a long and difficult trek to warn the British at Decou's stone house near present-day Brock University. When the Americans resumed their march, they were ambushed by Kahnawake and other native warriors and eventually surrendered to a small British detachment led by Lieutenant James FitzGibbon. About 500 U.S. troops, including their wounded commander, were taken prisoner.

<span class="mw-page-title-main">Stoney Creek, Ontario</span> Dissolved city in Ontario, Canada

Stoney Creek is a community in the city of Hamilton in the Canadian province of Ontario. It was officially a city from 1984 to 2001, when it was amalgamated with the rest of the cities of the Regional Municipality of Hamilton–Wentworth.

<span class="mw-page-title-main">Second Battle of Sacket's Harbor</span>

The Second Battle of Sacket's Harbor, or simply the Battle of Sacket's Harbor, took place on 29 May 1813, during the War of 1812. A British force was transported across Lake Ontario and attempted to capture the town, which was the principal dockyard and base for the American naval squadron on the lake. Twelve warships were built here. The British were repulsed by American regulars, militia, marines and sailors.

<span class="mw-page-title-main">Battle of Fort George</span> 1813 battle of the War of 1812

The Battle of Fort George was fought during the War of 1812, in which the Americans defeated a British force and captured Fort George in Upper Canada. The troops of the United States Army and vessels of the United States Navy cooperated in a very successful amphibious assault, although most of the opposing British force escaped encirclement.

<span class="mw-page-title-main">Battle of Frenchtown</span> Battle in the War of 1812

The Battles of Frenchtown, also known as the Battle of the River Raisin and the River Raisin Massacre, were a series of conflicts in Michigan Territory that took place from January 18–23, 1813, during the War of 1812. It was fought between the United States of America and a joint force of British and Native Americans near the River Raisin in Frenchtown.

<span class="mw-page-title-main">History of Hamilton, Ontario</span>

Hamilton, from the point at which it was first colonized by settlers, has benefited from its geographical proximity to major land and water transportation routes along the Niagara Peninsula and Lake Ontario. Its strategic importance has created, by Canadian standards, a rich military history which the city preserves.

The Battle of Longwoods took place during the Anglo-American War of 1812. On 4 March 1814, a mounted American raiding party defeated an attempt by British regulars, volunteers from the Canadian militia and Native Americans to intercept them near Wardsville, in present-day Southwest Middlesex, Ontario.

<span class="mw-page-title-main">John Harvey (British Army officer)</span>

Lieutenant-General Sir John Harvey, was a British Army officer and a lieutenant governor.

General John Vincent (1764–1848) was the British commanding officer of the Niagara Peninsula in Upper Canada when the United States attacked in the spring of 1813. He was defeated at the Battle of Fort George but was able to rebound and establish the new lines at Burlington Heights. He directed the campaign during the summer and fall that eventually forced the Americans to abandon the Niagara area in December 1813, thanks in large part due to his victory over the Americans at the Battle of Stoney Creek. Due to illness he was replaced by General Phineas Riall, though of the several officers of the 49th Regiment who reached high command during the War of 1812, Vincent was the longest-serving of them. British and Canadian accounts of the War give the impression of a modest, well-liked and generous officer, who gave whatever help he could to other commanders. From 1814, he had held the sinecure post of Lieutenant-Governor of Dumbarton Castle.

<span class="mw-page-title-main">James Gage</span>

James Gage was born in Greenbush, New York. His father, also James Gage, served as a private in the New York militia during the Revolutionary War, and was killed fighting the British in 1777. His mother, Mary, moved with the family to Stoney Creek in 1790 and began farming.

<span class="mw-page-title-main">Centennial Parkway</span> Road in Hamilton, Ontario, Canada

Centennial Parkway is an arterial road in southeastern Hamilton, Ontario, Canada. It is best known as the western terminus of the former King's Highway 20, now maintained by the City of Hamilton. It starts off as Upper Centennial Parkway, a mountain-access road in the City right before the Canadian Pacific Railway line at the backend of Battlefield Park, and is a two-way street throughout that extends north over the Queen Elizabeth Way and ends at Beach Boulevard/Van Wagners Beach Road in front of Confederation Park.

<span class="mw-page-title-main">Burlington Heights (Ontario)</span> Promontory and peninsula between Hamilton and Burlington, Ontario, Canada

Burlington Heights refers to a promontory or area of flat land sitting elevated above the west end of Hamilton Harbour in the city of Hamilton, Ontario which continues as a peninsula to the north toward the city of Burlington, Ontario. It separates Cootes Paradise Marsh on the west from the harbor on the east. Geologically the Burlington Heights is a sand and gravel bar formed across the eastern end of the Dundas Valley by Glacial Lake Iroquois. It is the northern continuation of the longer Iroquois Bar which extends south into Hamilton.

<span class="mw-page-title-main">Battlefield House (Stoney Creek, Ontario)</span>

Battlefield House near King Street East and Centennial Parkway in Stoney Creek, Hamilton, Ontario, Canada is a living history museum and site of the historic Battle of Stoney Creek on June 6, 1813, which was fought during the War of 1812. It was built in 1796. The house and 15.5 acres (6.3 ha) of parkland, were the property of the Women's Wentworth Historical Society, (1899-1962), and given by this society to the Niagara Parks Commission on January 19, 1962. The park was designated a National Historic Site in 1960.

Captain Runchey's Company of Coloured Men was a Canadian militia company of free blacks and indentured black servants, raised in Upper Canada as a small Black corps under a White officer, Robert Reuben Runchey (1759–1819), a tavern keeper from Jordan, Upper Canada. The unit fought in several actions during the early part of the Anglo-American War of 1812. In 1813, Runchey's Company was converted into a unit of the Canadian Corps of Provincial Artificers, attached to the Royal Sappers and Miners, in which sappers and miners performed specialized military operations. They served on the Niagara River front during the war, and were disbanded a few months after the war ended. The Company of Coloured Men's military heritage is perpetuated in the modern Canadian Army by the Lincoln and Welland Regiment.

Benjamin Franklin Graves (1771–1813) was a politician and military leader in early 19th-century Kentucky. During the War of 1812, Graves served as a major in the 2nd Battalion, 5th Kentucky Volunteer regiment. Together with other officers, he commanded Kentucky troops in the Battle of Frenchtown on January 22, 1813, in Michigan Territory. This was part of an effort by Americans to take the British-controlled fort at Detroit, Fort Shelby. This battle had the highest number of American fatalities in the war: of 1,000 American troops, nearly 400 were killed in the conflict, and 547 were taken prisoner. The next day an estimated 30-100 Americans were killed by Native Americans after having surrendered.

References

  1. 1813 Billy Green on Battle of Stoney Creek Archived October 4, 2007, at the Wayback Machine
  2. The War of 1812 Archived July 20, 2008, at the Wayback Machine
  3. The sword is held by the Stoney Creek Historical Society, Accession number 012-017-003.
  4. Battlefield House Museum - Billy Green and the Battle of Stoney Creek - June 6, 1813 - Stoney Creek, Ontario, Canada
  5. Anon. "Descendants of Billy the Scout Recall his Deeds", Hamilton Spectator, March 12, 1938.
  6. Strange Fatality: The Battle of Stoney Creek, 1813
  7. Is the Billy Green Story Balderdash?
  8. Green, Philip E. J. 2013. "Billy Green the Scout and the Battle of Stoney Creek (June 5-6, 1813)", War of 1812 Magazine, Issue 20, May 2013.
  9. Clark, David B. U.E., Green, Douglas A. , U.E, Lubell, M. 2011. "BILLY GREEN AND BALDERDASH A Presentation of the Facts" Published by the Stoney Creek Historical Society
  10. Lubell, M., Clark, David B. U.E., Green, Douglas A. , U.E. 2012. "Billy Green and More Balderdash" Published by the Stoney Creek Historical Society
  11. "Hamilton- Waterfall Capital of the World". (www.cityofwaterfalls.ca). Retrieved 2008-07-31.
  12. Billy Green Elementary School, Hamilton Wentworth District School Board.
  13. "Fox, George. "Billy Green" in the Album "George Fox-Canadian"". Archived from the original on 2013-09-28. Retrieved 2013-06-04.