Carnot method

Last updated

The Carnot method is an allocation procedure for dividing up fuel input (primary energy, end energy) in joint production processes that generate two or more energy products in one process (e.g. cogeneration or trigeneration). It is also suited to allocate other streams such as CO2-emissions or variable costs. The potential to provide physical work (exergy) is used as the distribution key. For heat this potential can be assessed the Carnot efficiency. Thus, the Carnot method is a form of an exergetic allocation method. It uses mean heat grid temperatures at the output of the process as a calculation basis. The Carnot method's advantage is that no external reference values are required to allocate the input to the different output streams; only endogenous process parameters are needed. Thus, the allocation results remain unbiased of assumptions or external reference values that are open for discussion.

Contents

Fuel allocation factor

The fuel share ael which is needed to generate the combined product electrical energy W (work) and ath for the thermal energy H (useful heat) respectively, can be calculated accordingly to the first and second laws of thermodynamics as follows:

ael= (1 · ηel) / (ηel + ηc · ηth)

ath= (ηc · ηth) / (ηel + ηc · ηth)

Note: ael + ath = 1

with
ael: allocation factor for electrical energy, i.e. the share of the fuel input which is allocated to electricity production
ath: allocation factor for thermal energy, i.e. the share of the fuel input which is allocated to heat production

ηel = W/QF
ηth = H/QF
W: electrical work
H: useful heat
QF: Total heat, fuel or primary energy input

and
ηc: Carnot factor 1-Ti/Ts (Carnot factor for electrical energy is 1)
Ti: lower temperature, inferior (ambient)
Ts: upper temperature, superior (useful heat)

In heating systems, a good approximation for the upper temperature is the average between forward and return flow on the distribution side of the heat exchanger.
Ts = (TFF+TRF) / 2
or - if more thermodynamic precision is needed - the logarithmic mean temperature [1] is used
Ts = (TFF-TRF) / ln(TFF/TRF)
If process steam is delivered which condenses and evaporates at the same temperature, Ts is the temperature of the saturated steam of a given pressure.

Fuel factor

The fuel intensity or the fuel factor for electrical energy fF,el resp. thermal energy fF,th is the relation of specific input to output.

fF,el= ael / ηel = 1 / (ηel + ηc · ηth)

fF,th= ath / ηth = ηc / (ηel + ηc · ηth)

Primary energy factor

To obtain the primary energy factors of cogenerated heat and electricity, the energy prechain needs to be considered.

fPE,el = fF,el · fPE,F
fPE,th = fF,th · fPE,F

with
fPE,F: primary energy factor of the used fuel

Effective efficiency

The reciprocal value of the fuel factor (f-intensity) describes the effective efficiency of the assumed sub-process, which in case of CHP is only responsible for electrical or thermal energy generation. This equivalent efficiency corresponds to the effective efficiency of a "virtual boiler" or a "virtual generator" within the CHP plant.

ηel, eff = ηel / ael = 1 / fF,el
ηth, eff = ηth / ath = 1 / fF,th

with
ηel, eff: effective efficiency of electricity generation within the CHP process
ηth, eff: effective efficiency of heat generation within the CHP process

Performance factor of energy conversion

Next to the efficiency factor which describes the quantity of usable end energies, the quality of energy transformation according to the entropy law is also important. With rising entropy, exergy declines. Exergy does not only consider energy but also energy quality. It can be considered a product of both. Therefore any energy transformation should also be assessed according to its exergetic efficiency or loss ratios. The quality of the product "thermal energy" is fundamentally determined by the mean temperature level at which this heat is delivered. Hence, the exergetic efficiency ηx describes how much of the fuel's potential to generate physical work remains in the joint energy products. With cogeneration the result is the following relation:

ηx,total = ηel + ηc · ηth

The allocation with the Carnot method always results in:
ηx,total = ηx,el = ηx,th

with
ηx,total = exergetic efficiency of the combined process
ηx,el = exergetic efficiency of the virtual electricity-only process
ηx,th = exergetic efficiency of the virtual heat-only process

The main application area of this method is cogeneration, but it can also be applied to other processes generating a joint products, such as a chiller generating cold and producing waste heat which could be used for low temperature heat demand, or a refinery with different liquid fuels plus heat as an output.

Mathematical derivation

Let's assume a joint production with Input I and a first output O1 and a second output O2. f is a factor for rating the relevant product in the domain of primary energy, or fuel costs, or emissions, etc.

evaluation of the input = evaluation of the output

fi · I = f1 · O1 + f2 · O2

The factor for the input fi and the quantities of I, O1, and O2 are known. An equation with two unknowns f1 and f2 has to be solved, which is possible with a lot of adequate tuples. As second equation, the physical transformation of product O1 in O2 and vice versa is used.

O1 = η21 · O2

η21 is the transformation factor from O2 into O1, the inverse 1/η21=η12 describes the backward transformation. A reversible transformation is assumed, in order not to favour any of the two directions. Because of the exchangeability of O1 and O2, the assessment of the two sides of the equation above with the two factors f1 and f2 should therefore result in an equivalent outcome. Output O2 evaluated with f2 shall be the same as the amount of O1 generated from O2 and evaluated with f1.

f1 · (η21 · O2) = f2 · O2

If we put this into the first equation, we see the following steps:

fi · I = f1 · O1 + f1 · (η21 × O2)

fi · I = f1 · (O1 + η21 · O2)

fi = f1 · (O1/I + η21 · O2/I)

fi = f1 · (η1 + η21 · η2)

f1 = fi / (η1 + η21 · η2) or respectively f2 = η21 · fi / (η1 + η21 · η2)

with η1 = O1/I and η2 = O2/I

See also

Related Research Articles

<span class="mw-page-title-main">Carnot heat engine</span> Theoretical engine

A Carnot heat engine is a theoretical heat engine that operates on the Carnot cycle. The basic model for this engine was developed by Nicolas Léonard Sadi Carnot in 1824. The Carnot engine model was graphically expanded by Benoît Paul Émile Clapeyron in 1834 and mathematically explored by Rudolf Clausius in 1857, work that led to the fundamental thermodynamic concept of entropy. The Carnot engine is the most efficient heat engine which is theoretically possible. The efficiency depends only upon the absolute temperatures of the hot and cold heat reservoirs between which it operates.

<span class="mw-page-title-main">Heat engine</span> System that converts heat or thermal energy to mechanical work

A heat engine is a system that converts heat to usable energy, particularly mechanical energy, which can then be used to do mechanical work. While originally conceived in the context of mechanical energy, the concept of the heat engine has been applied to various other kinds of energy, particularly electrical, since at least the late 19th century. The heat engine does this by bringing a working substance from a higher state temperature to a lower state temperature. A heat source generates thermal energy that brings the working substance to the higher temperature state. The working substance generates work in the working body of the engine while transferring heat to the colder sink until it reaches a lower temperature state. During this process some of the thermal energy is converted into work by exploiting the properties of the working substance. The working substance can be any system with a non-zero heat capacity, but it usually is a gas or liquid. During this process, some heat is normally lost to the surroundings and is not converted to work. Also, some energy is unusable because of friction and drag.

<span class="mw-page-title-main">Second law of thermodynamics</span> Physical law for entropy and heat

The second law of thermodynamics is a physical law based on universal empirical observation concerning heat and energy interconversions. A simple statement of the law is that heat always flows spontaneously from hotter to colder regions of matter. Another statement is: "Not all heat can be converted into work in a cyclic process."

<span class="mw-page-title-main">Carnot's theorem (thermodynamics)</span> Maximum attainable efficiency of any heat engine

Carnot's theorem, also called Carnot's rule, is a principle of thermodynamics developed by Nicolas Léonard Sadi Carnot in 1824 that specifies limits on the maximum efficiency that any heat engine can obtain.

<span class="mw-page-title-main">Combined cycle power plant</span> Assembly of heat engines that work in tandem from the same source of heat

A combined cycle power plant is an assembly of heat engines that work in tandem from the same source of heat, converting it into mechanical energy. On land, when used to make electricity the most common type is called a combined cycle gas turbine (CCGT) plant, which is a kind of gas-fired power plant. The same principle is also used for marine propulsion, where it is called a combined gas and steam (COGAS) plant. Combining two or more thermodynamic cycles improves overall efficiency, which reduces fuel costs.

<span class="mw-page-title-main">Rankine cycle</span> Model that is used to predict the performance of steam turbine systems

The Rankine cycle is an idealized thermodynamic cycle describing the process by which certain heat engines, such as steam turbines or reciprocating steam engines, allow mechanical work to be extracted from a fluid as it moves between a heat source and heat sink. The Rankine cycle is named after William John Macquorn Rankine, a Scottish polymath professor at Glasgow University.

<span class="mw-page-title-main">Cogeneration</span> Simultaneous generation of electricity and useful heat

Cogeneration or combined heat and power (CHP) is the use of a heat engine or power station to generate electricity and useful heat at the same time.

Exergy, often referred to as "available energy" or "useful work potential", is a fundamental concept in the field of thermodynamics and engineering. It plays a crucial role in understanding and quantifying the quality of energy within a system and its potential to perform useful work. Exergy analysis has widespread applications in various fields, including energy engineering, environmental science, and industrial processes.

<span class="mw-page-title-main">Sulfur–iodine cycle</span> Thermochemical process used to produce hydrogen

The sulfur–iodine cycle is a three-step thermochemical cycle used to produce hydrogen.

<span class="mw-page-title-main">Energy quality</span>

Energy quality is a measure of the ease with which a form of energy can be converted to useful work or to another form of energy: i.e. its content of thermodynamic free energy. A high quality form of energy has a high content of thermodynamic free energy, and therefore a high proportion of it can be converted to work; whereas with low quality forms of energy, only a small proportion can be converted to work, and the remainder is dissipated as heat. The concept of energy quality is also used in ecology, where it is used to track the flow of energy between different trophic levels in a food chain and in thermoeconomics, where it is used as a measure of economic output per unit of energy. Methods of evaluating energy quality often involve developing a ranking of energy qualities in hierarchical order.

<span class="mw-page-title-main">Steam-electric power station</span>

The steam-electric power station is a power station in which the electric generator is steam driven. Water is heated, turns into steam and spins a steam turbine which drives an electrical generator. After it passes through the turbine, the steam is condensed in a condenser. The greatest variation in the design of steam-electric power plants is due to the different fuel sources.

<span class="mw-page-title-main">Thermal efficiency</span> Performance measure of a device that uses thermal energy

In thermodynamics, the thermal efficiency is a dimensionless performance measure of a device that uses thermal energy, such as an internal combustion engine, steam turbine, steam engine, boiler, furnace, refrigerator, ACs etc.

<span class="mw-page-title-main">Energy conversion efficiency</span> Ratio between the useful output and the input of a machine

Energy conversion efficiency (η) is the ratio between the useful output of an energy conversion machine and the input, in energy terms. The input, as well as the useful output may be chemical, electric power, mechanical work, light (radiation), or heat. The resulting value, η (eta), ranges between 0 and 1.

<span class="mw-page-title-main">Heat pump and refrigeration cycle</span> Mathematical models of heat pumps and refrigeration

Thermodynamic heat pump cycles or refrigeration cycles are the conceptual and mathematical models for heat pump, air conditioning and refrigeration systems. A heat pump is a mechanical system that allows for the transmission of heat from one location at a lower temperature to another location at a higher temperature. Thus a heat pump may be thought of as a "heater" if the objective is to warm the heat sink, or a "refrigerator" or “cooler” if the objective is to cool the heat source. In either case, the operating principles are similar. Heat is moved from a cold place to a warm place.

The Glossary of fuel cell terms lists the definitions of many terms used within the fuel cell industry. The terms in this fuel cell glossary may be used by fuel cell industry associations, in education material and fuel cell codes and standards to name but a few.

<span class="mw-page-title-main">Waste heat recovery unit</span> Energy recovery heat exchanger

A waste heat recovery unit (WHRU) is an energy recovery heat exchanger that transfers heat from process outputs at high temperature to another part of the process for some purpose, usually increased efficiency. The WHRU is a tool involved in cogeneration. Waste heat may be extracted from sources such as hot flue gases from a diesel generator, steam from cooling towers, or even waste water from cooling processes such as in steel cooling.

<span class="mw-page-title-main">Endoreversible thermodynamics</span>

Endoreversible thermodynamics is a subset of irreversible thermodynamics aimed at making more realistic assumptions about heat transfer than are typically made in reversible thermodynamics. It gives an upper bound on the power that can be derived from a real process that is lower than that predicted by Carnot for a Carnot cycle, and accommodates the exergy destruction occurring as heat is transferred irreversibly.

Thermochemical cycles combine solely heat sources (thermo) with chemical reactions to split water into its hydrogen and oxygen components. The term cycle is used because aside of water, hydrogen and oxygen, the chemical compounds used in these processes are continuously recycled.

The so-called COGIX is an indicator for the operating efficiency of CHP-plants, that receive revenues at the wholesale electricity market. It is similar to the spark spread resp. green spark spread including emission costs for greenhouse gases, which is a contribution margin calculated from fuel costs, emission costs and revenues from electricity sales. In the COGIX framework, also the revenues from heat sales of the CHP-plant are considered.

The equivalence number method is a cost calculation method for co-production in cost and activity accounting. The resulting costs of the input factors are allocated to the individual products according to a weighting key, the so-called equivalence numbers.

References

  1. Tereshchenko, Tymofii; Nord, Natasa (2015-02-05), "Uncertainty of the allocation factors of heat and electricity production of combined cycle power plant", Applied Thermal Engineering, Amsterdam: Elsevier, 76: 410–422, doi:10.1016/j.applthermaleng.2014.11.019, hdl: 11250/2581526

Further reading