Collingwood Manor Massacre

Last updated

Collingwood Manor Massacre
LocationCollingwood Manor Apartments 1740 Collingwood Avenue
Detroit, Michigan
DateSeptember 16, 1931
TargetJoseph "Nigger [lower-alpha 1] Joe" Lebowitz
Attack type
Massacre
DeathsJoseph Lebowitz
Herman "Hymie" Paul
Isadore "Izzy the Rat" Sutker
Perpetrators The Purple Gang

The Collingwood Manor Massacre is the name of an infamous hit on three Chicago gunmen by the notorious Purple Gang on September 16, 1931 after the men had betrayed the trust of the others in the gang.

Contents

Background

Gambling, local wire service, drug distribution, bootlegging, certain trade unions, as well as extortion rackets, were all operated by the Purple Gang. In 1927, the Purple Gang was on top of their game running Detroit's underworld. When three Chicago gunmen, Joseph "Nigger Joe" Lebowitz, Herman "Hymie" Paul, and Isadore "Izzy the Rat" Sutker, fled to Detroit, the Purple Gang's status was put to the test. The men shook down Chicago speakeasy operators for protection money. Unknown to them, the victims were under Al Capone's syndicate for purchasing liquor from his suppliers. After finding that out, Capone gave the men an ultimatum: they could leave Chicago willingly or in a box. Willingly, the men fled to Detroit.

After arriving in the city the men soon became affiliated with a smaller faction of the Purple Gang, the "Little Jewish Navy." They would use member-owned speedboats to run liquor from Canada to Detroit. Trust would soon be lost between the men and the Purple Gang. Lebowitz, Paul, and Sutker hijacked members of the gang and preyed on other local gang members, disregarding their territories. Trying to establish themselves as an independent power, they became known as the "Third Avenue Terrors." Trying to take over Detroit's underworld, which was controlled mainly by the Purple Gang, was going to be a hard task, and the Gang was not going to let happen easily.

Massacre

After failing to pay back past debts to the Purple Gang, Ray Bernstein, one of the founders of the gang, developed a plan to kill the "Third Avenue Terrors." Bernstein would use Sol Levine as an unknown accomplice to the crime. Levine was a good friend of both groups. The plan started by buying an apartment at the Collingwood Manor Apartments. Bernstein then convinced Levine that the Purples had decided to let Lebowitz, Paul, and Sutker be their agents in the liquor business. A meeting was apparently set up to meet with Levine and the other men later.

The meeting was called on September 16, 1931. Levine and the men met up at 1740 Collingwood Avenue. After engaging in a quick conversation, Bernstein left to go start the getaway car. He waited for the sound of backfiring and honking the horn to cue the men left in the apartment to carry out the plan. Fleisher stood to his feet, pulled out a .38 caliber revolver, and shot Lebowitz at point-blank range. Irving Milberg and Harry Keywell jumped up and began to shoot. That was not the first major massacre carried out by Keywell, who also took part in the St. Valentine's Day Massacre, along with other Purple Gang members. Keywell emptied his revolver into Sutker and Milberg emptied his into Paul. While all of that was happening, Sol Levine watched helplessly as the men scrambled to save their lives.

Aftermath

After the crime, Bernstein, Keywell, Milberg, and Fleisher fled the scene, leaving Sol Levine as the sole eyewitness. The police took him into their headquarters and, after long interrogation, Levine finally confessed to seeing the murders take place and to who did it. The guns used in the crime had their serial numbers scratched off and were thrown into paint to try to get rid of any evidence linking back to the members of the Purple Gang.

A ballistics test, taken shortly afterward, proved that the guns had been used in the murders of Lebowitz, Paul, and Sutker. After the confession, an anonymous call was received by the detectives' office. The message stated: "Two of the men you want for the Collingwood Murder are at 2649 Calvert. They will be out of town within the hour." Heavily armed, the police went to the location, which was owned by Charles Aurbach, an underworld consultant and Purple Gang member. Ray Bernstein and Harry Keywell were arrested in their pajamas. The following night, Irving Milberg was arrested while preparing to skip town, but Fleisher disappeared. [1]

Trial

The examination for the Collingwood Manor Massacre began on September 30, 1931. Sol Levine appeared at the pre-trial but was frightened to testify against the men. Levine pointed to Bernstein, Keywell, and Milberg as the men who killed Lebowitz, Paul, and Sutker. He said that Harry Fleisher also took part in the shooting, but Fleisher was not present at the time. During his testimony, Levine focused solely on the prosecutor and did not once look at the accused men. In contrast, Bernstein, Keywell, and Milberg focused mainly on Levine, glaring at him during the trial. On October 2, 1931, the men were arraigned before Judge Donald Van Zile after a motion for dismissal of Levine's claim was denied. An order was issued for the men to be held without bond.

Testimony for the case began on November 2, 1931. Levine began his account of what happened on the day of the massacre. Eight detectives constantly guarded him and ten stood guard during the trial, with four on point as he testified, as he feared he would be killed during the case. Witness after witness went to the stand and testified against the gang members, claiming to have seen them run from the building after hearing gunshots. After an hour and 37 minutes, the jury returned with the verdict, finding the men guilty of the charge of first-degree murder. The members of the Purple Gang were convicted and sentenced to life in prison without parole and were sent to Marquette Prison. Chief of Detectives James E. McCarty made a statement to the press: "This conviction is the greatest accomplishment in years. Not only does it break the back of the Purple Gang but it serves notice on other mobs that murder doesn't go anymore in Detroit." It was the beginning of the end for the notorious Purple Gang.

On June 9, 1932, Harry Fleisher surprised the prosecutor by strolling into the prosecutor's office with attorneys to turn himself in on the warrant for the Collingwood Manor Massacre. During the nine months that he was missing he had been a suspect in many major crimes, including the kidnapping of Lindbergh's baby. [2] By July 25, 1932, the prosecutor, Harry Toy, was forced to admit that eyewitness Solly Levine could not be found. The case against Harry Fleisher was eventually dismissed and the judgment against Bernstein, Keywell & Milberg was held. There was the option to reopen the case if new evidence was ever discovered. [1]

See also

Notes

  1. At the time, this racial epithet was often applied to people with relatively dark hair or skin complexion, even if they were not of African ancestry.

Related Research Articles

<span class="mw-page-title-main">Saint Valentine's Day Massacre</span> 1929 gang shooting in Chicago

The Saint Valentine's Day Massacre was the murder of seven members and associates of Chicago's North Side Gang that occurred on Saint Valentine's Day 1929. The men were gathered at a Lincoln Park, Chicago garage on the morning of February 14, 1929. They were lined up against a wall and shot by four unknown assailants, two dressed as police officers.

Murder, Inc. was an organized crime group active from 1929 to 1941 that acted as the enforcement arm of the National Crime Syndicate – a closely connected criminal organization that included the Italian-American Mafia, the Jewish Mob, and other criminal organizations in New York City and elsewhere. Murder, Inc. was composed of Jewish and Italian-American gangsters, and members were mainly recruited from poor and working-class Jewish and Italian neighborhoods in Manhattan and Brooklyn. It was initially headed by Louis "Lepke" Buchalter and later by Albert "Mad Hatter" Anastasia.

<span class="mw-page-title-main">Chicago Outfit</span> Italian-American organized crime syndicate based in Chicago, Illinois

The Chicago Outfit is an Italian-American organized crime syndicate or crime family based in Chicago, Illinois, that originated in the city's South Side in 1910. It is part of the larger Italian-American Mafia.

The Irish Mob is a usually crime family-based ethnic collective of organized crime syndicates composed of primarily ethnic Irish members which operate primarily in Ireland, the United States, the United Kingdom, Canada and Australia, and have been in existence since the early 19th century. Originating in Irish-American street gangs – famously first depicted in Herbert Asbury's 1927 book, The Gangs of New York – the Irish Mob has appeared in most major U.S. and Canadian cities, especially in the Northeast and the urban industrial, including Boston, New York City, Philadelphia, Pittsburgh, Baltimore, Cleveland, and Chicago.

<span class="mw-page-title-main">Jewish-American organized crime</span> Jewish Mob or the Jewish Mafia

Jewish-American organized crime initially emerged within the American Jewish community during the late 19th and early 20th centuries. It has been referred to variously in media and popular culture as the Jewish Mob, Jewish Mafia, Kosher Mob, Kosher Mafia, and Kosher Nostra or Undzer Shtik. The last two of these terms are direct references to the Italian cosa nostra; the former is a play on the word for kosher, referring to Jewish dietary laws, while the latter is a calque of the Italian phrase 'cosa nostra' into Yiddish, which was at the time the predominant language of the Jewish diaspora in the United States.

<span class="mw-page-title-main">Atlantic City Conference</span> 1929 summit of organized crime leaders

The Atlantic City Conference held between 13–16 May 1929 was a historic summit of leaders of organized crime in the United States. It is considered by most crime historians to be the earliest organized crime summit held in the US. The conference had a major impact on the future direction of the criminal underworld and it held more importance and significance than the Havana Conference of 1946 and the Apalachin meeting of 1957. It also represented the first concrete move toward a National Crime Syndicate.

Thomas "Yonnie" Licavoli was an American gangster and bootlegger during Prohibition. Born in St. Louis, Missouri, Licavoli, along with brother Peter Joseph Licavoli and cousin James Licavoli, worked with Jewish gangsters to take over illegal gambling in St. Louis. The Licavolis soon moved on to Detroit, Michigan and would control criminal operations in Detroit and Toledo, Ohio, throughout the Prohibition era.

Abe Bernstein was a Detroit-based Jewish-American organized crime figure and leader of the infamous Prohibition-era Purple Gang.

<span class="mw-page-title-main">Joseph Zerilli</span>

Joseph Zerilli was an Italian-born American gangster who rose to power in the crime family known as the Detroit Partnership, leading from the 1930s through much of the 1970s. He immigrated to the United States from Sicily in 1914 at the age of 17.

<span class="mw-page-title-main">Gus Winkler</span> American mobster (1901–1933)

Gus Winkler was an American gangster who headed a Prohibition-era criminal gang specializing in armed robbery and murder for hire with Fred "Killer" Burke. Winkler was a senior associate of Chicago Outfit boss Al Capone and is considered a suspect in the St. Valentine's Day Massacre. Winkler is believed to be the first member of the National Crime Syndicate to be murdered for talking to the FBI.

Egan's Rats was an American organized crime gang that exercised considerable power in St. Louis, Missouri, from 1890 to 1924. Its 35 years of criminal activity included bootlegging, labor slugging, voter intimidation, armed robbery, and murder. Although predominantly Irish-American, Egan's Rats did include a few Italian-Americans and some Jewish immigrants, most notably Max "Big Maxie" Greenberg.

The Flathead Gang, also known as The Flatheads, was a group of bank robbers. The gang was operating in the Detroit, Michigan area. When the police became a major problem for the gang they decided to move their robberies and other crimes to the State of Pennsylvania. Paul Jaworski, the leader of the gang was executed in Pennsylvania in 1929 for murder.

The East Harlem Purple Gang was a gang or organized crime group consisting of Italian-American hit-men and heroin dealers who were semi-independent from the Italian-American Mafia and, according to federal prosecutors, dominated heroin distribution in East Harlem, Italian Harlem, and the Bronx during the 1970s and early 1980s in New York City. Though mostly independent of the Italian-American Mafia and not an official Mafia crew, the gang was originally affiliated with and worked with the Lucchese crime family and later with the Bonanno crime family and Genovese crime family. It developed its "closest ties" with the Genovese family, and its remnants or former members are now part of the Genovese family's 116th Street Crew.

The Detroit Partnership is an Italian-American organized crime syndicate based in Detroit, Michigan, and mainly operates in the Greater Detroit area as part of the larger Italian-American Mafia. They hold interests in Windsor, Ontario, Toledo, Ohio; as well as other cities in Michigan, Ohio, West Virginia, Nevada, and Sicily.

Salvatore "Sam Sings in the Night" Catalanotte was an Italian-American mobster. "Sings in the night" is a translation of a close misspelling of his last name. Catalanotte immigrated from Sicily to Detroit in 1912 and participated and survived the Giannola and Vitale gang war. After surviving this war, Catalanotte later assumed the highest leadership position within the Detroit mafia. In addition to his mafia dealings, Catalanotte was also recorded to be a baker and a director of the Detroit Italian bakeries. Catalanotte died on February 14, 1930, from pneumonia and his funeral took place in Detroit.

<span class="mw-page-title-main">Angelo Meli</span> Italian-American mobster

Angelo Meli was an Italian-American mobster who became a consigliere and then leading Chairman of the Detroit Partnership criminal organization of La Cosa Nostra.

The Milaflores Massacre is the name given to the shooting of three gangsters in retaliation for two murders and a kidnapping in the winter of 1927 in Detroit, Michigan. The crime was suspected to have been perpetrated by the Purple Gang.

Harry Keywell was a convicted member of the infamous Purple Gang, that terrorized Detroit, US during Prohibition. Chicago Police questioned him about the infamous St. Valentine's Day Massacre in February 1929, on the suspicion that Keywell acted as a lookout for the killers, however Harry had a cast-iron alibi for the day.

<span class="mw-page-title-main">The Purple Gang</span> Criminal mob group of the 1920s

The Purple Gang, also known as the Sugar House Gang, was a criminal mob of bootleggers and hijackers composed predominantly of Jewish gangsters. They operated in Detroit, Michigan, during the 1920s of the Prohibition era and came to be Detroit's dominant criminal gang. Excessive violence and infighting caused the gang to destroy itself in the 1930s.

<span class="mw-page-title-main">Joe Massei</span> US gangster involved in bootleg liquor, illegal gambling and money laundering

Joseph D. Massei, or Joe Massey, was an American gangster of Italian-Irish origins. He was involved in the Detroit bootleg liquor trade in the Prohibition era and was arrested many times, but was only imprisoned once. In 1936 he moved to Miami Beach, Florida, and became a central figure in illegal gambling. He was a consiglieri of the mob, and helped resolve disputes between the gangsters. He acted as the Detroit mob's money man, funneling illegal earnings into legitimate businesses in Miami. He died at home in Miami Beach at the age of 71.

References

  1. 1 2 The Purple Gang: Organized Crime in Detroit
  2. "Lindbergh Baby Kidnapping FBI Files".