| Year | Champion | Score | Runner-up | Location | Tournament MVP |
|---|
| 1996 | Memphis | 93–87 (OT) | DePaul | Bartow Arena, Birmingham, Alabama | Keeta Matthews, Memphis |
| 1997 | Tulane | 76–53 | Marquette | Alumni Hall, Chicago, Illinois | Mary Lowry, Tulane |
| 1998 | Memphis | 79–75 | Louisville | Louisville Gardens, Louisville, Kentucky | LaTonya Johnson, Memphis |
| 1999 | Tulane | 58–44 | Cincinnati | Fogelman Arena, New Orleans, Louisiana | Grace Daley, Tulane |
| 2000 | Tulane | 73–70 | UAB | Freedom Hall, Louisville, Kentucky | Janell Burse, Tulane |
| 2001 | Tulane | 63–50 | Cincinnati | U.S. Cellular Arena, Milwaukee, Wisconsin | Valerie King, Cincinnati |
| 2002 | Cincinnati | 68–56 | Tulane | DePaul Athletic Center, Chicago, Illinois | Valerie King, Cincinnati |
| 2003 | TCU | 85–76 (OT) | Cincinnati | The Pyramid, Memphis, Tennessee | Sandora Irvin, TCU |
| 2004 | Houston | 86–75 | TCU | Daniel-Meyer Coliseum, Fort Worth, Texas | Chandi Jones, Houston |
| 2005 | TCU | 60–41 | Louisville | Dale F. Halton Arena, Charlotte, North Carolina | Sandora Irvin, TCU |
| 2006 | Tulsa | 55–52 | Rice | Moody Coliseum, Dallas, Texas | Jillian Robbins, Tulsa |
| 2007 | East Carolina | 79–70 | Rice | Reynolds Center, Tulsa, Oklahoma | LaCoya Terry, East Carolina |
| 2008 | SMU | 73–57 | UTEP | UCF Arena, Orlando, Florida | Janielle Dodds, SMU |
| 2009 | UCF | 65–54 (OT) | Southern Miss | Fogelman Arena, New Orleans, Louisiana | Emma Cannon, UCF |
| 2010 | Tulane | 62–54 | UAB | Reynolds Center, Tulsa, Oklahoma | Danielle Nunn, Tulane |
| 2011 | UCF | 85–73 | Tulane | Don Haskins Center
Memorial Gym, El Paso, Texas | Jelisa Caldwell, UCF |
| 2012 | UTEP | 69–65 | Tulane | FedExForum
Elma Roane Fieldhouse, Memphis, Tennessee | Gloria Brown, UTEP |
| 2013 | Tulsa | 75–66 | UCF | BOK Center, Tulsa, Oklahoma | Taleya Mayberry, Tulsa |
| 2014 | Middle Tennessee | 84–55 | Tulsa | Don Haskins Center
Memorial Gym, El Paso, Texas | Ebony Rowe, Middle Tennessee |
| 2015 | Western Kentucky | 60–57 | Southern Miss | Legacy Arena, Birmingham, Alabama | Alexis Govan, Western Kentucky |
| 2016 | Middle Tennessee | 70–54 | Old Dominion | Legacy Arena, Birmingham, Alabama | Ty Petty, Middle Tennessee |
| 2017 | Western Kentucky | 67–56 | Southern Miss | Legacy Arena, Birmingham, Alabama | Kendall Noble, Western Kentucky |
| 2018 | Western Kentucky | 72–57 | UAB | The Ford Center at The Star, Frisco, Texas | Tashia Brown, Western Kentucky |
| 2019 | Rice | 69–54 | Middle Tennessee | The Ford Center at The Star, Frisco, Texas | Nancy Mulkey, Rice |
| 2020 | Canceled due to the COVID-19 pandemic |
| 2021 | Middle Tennessee | 68–65 | Rice | The Ford Center at The Star, Frisco, Texas | Anastasia Hayes, Middle Tennessee |
| 2022 | Charlotte | 68–63 | Louisiana Tech | The Ford Center at The Star, Frisco, Texas | Octavia Jett-Wilson, Charlotte |
| 2023 | Middle Tennessee | 82-70 | Western Kentucky | The Ford Center at The Star, Frisco, Texas | Jalynn Gregory, Middle Tennessee |
| 2024 | Middle Tennessee | 67–51 | Liberty | Propst Arena, Huntsville, Alabama | Savannah Wheeler, Middle Tennessee |
| 2025 | Liberty | 53-48 | Middle Tennessee | Propst Arena, Huntsville, Alabama | |
