| Year | Champion | Score | Runner-up | Site | Offensive MVP | Defensive MVP | Reference |
|---|
| 1995 | Charlotte (1) | 1–0*(OT) | Evansville | Meyers Field • Cincinnati, Ohio | Blair Angell (Charlotte) (Forward)
Terra May (Evansville) (Midfielder) | Benji Lewis (Charlotte) (Defender)
Heather Bridgewater (Charlotte) (Goalkeeper) | |
| 1996 | Cincinnati (1) | 4–2*(OT) | Marquette | Transamerica Field • Charlotte, North Carolina | Regina Sekyra (Marquette) (Forward)
Paulette Angilecchia (Cincinnati) (Midfielder) | Nicole Thorne (Cincinnati) (Defender)
Stacy Sipotz (Marquette) (Goalkeeper) | |
| 1997 | Cincinnati(2) | 1–0 | Marquette | Anheuser-Busch Conference & Sports Centre • Fenton, Missouri | Tina Matlock (Cincinnati) (Forward)
Kelly Roethe (Marquette) (Midfielder) | Rhegan Hyypio (Marquette) (Defender)
Christy Hoffman (Cincinnati) (Goalkeeper) | |
| 1998 | Charlotte (2) | 0–0†
(5–4 pen.) | Marquette | Cox Soccer Complex • Farmers Branch, Texas | Christian Papp (Charlotte) (Forward)
Lynette Rossini (Marquette) (Midfielder) | Rhegan Hyypio (Marquette) (Defender)
Mo Bothwell (Marquette) (Goalkeeper) | |
| 1999 | Marquette (1) | 2–1*(OT) | Charlotte | Erin Morgan (Marquette) (Forward)
Kelly Roethe (Marquette) (Midfielder) | Jen Bransford (Charlotte) (Defender)
Jennifer Howell (Charlotte) (Goalkeeper) | |
| 2000 | Marquette(2) | 1–0*(OT) | Charlotte | Hermann Stadium • St. Louis, Missouri | Kate Gordon (Marquette) (Forward)
Kristen Jensen (Marquette) (Midfielder) | Heather O'Neil (Marquette) (Defender)
Christy Hoffman (Cincinnati) (Goalkeeper) | |
| 2001 | Cincinnati(3) | 1–0 | Marquette | Valley Fields • Milwaukee, Wisconsin | Ann Thomas (Cincinnati) (Forward)
Nicole Luse (Cincinnati) (Midfielder) | Anne Dalecky (Marquette) (Defender)
Christy Hoffman (Cincinnati) (Goalkeeper) | |
| 2002 | Cincinnati (4) | 2–1 | Marquette | Transamerica Field • Charlotte, North Carolina | Tasha Wagner (Cincinnati) | Stacey Kyser (Cincinnati) | |
| 2003 | DePaul (1) | 1–1†
(4–3 pen.) | Saint Louis | Julianne Sitch (DePaul) | Lindsay Deason (DePaul) | |
| 2004 | UAB (1) | 2–1 | Saint Louis | Hermann Stadium • St. Louis, Missouri | Jenny Rynders (UAB) | Brianna McCarty (UAB) | |
| 2005 | Rice (1) | 3–0 | UTEP | Rice Soccer & Track Stadium • Houston, Texas | Anne Candee (Rice) | Adriene Giese (Rice) | |
| 2006 | UAB (2) | 3–2 | Colorado College | Westcott Field • Dallas, Texas | Jill Porto (UAB) | Laura Richards (UAB) | |
| 2007 | Memphis (1) | 2–0 | UCF | University Field • El Paso, Texas | Ashley Berra (Memphis) | Kelsey Bakker (Memphis) | |
| 2008 | Memphis (2) | 4–1 | East Carolina | Rice Soccer & Track Stadium • Houston, Texas | Laura Laufenberg (Memphis) | |
| 2009 | Memphis (3) | 3–0 | UCF | Westcott Field • Dallas, Texas | Taylor Isenhower (Memphis) | Elise Kuhar-Pitters (Memphis) | |
| 2010 | Memphis (4) | 1–0 | UCF | UCF Soccer Complex • Orlando, Florida | Vendula Strnadova (Memphis) | |
| 2011 | Memphis(5) | 2–1*(OT) | UTEP | Mike Rose Soccer Complex • Memphis, Tennessee | Christabel Oduro (Memphis) | Lizzy Simonin (Memphis) | |
| 2012 | UCF (1) | 2–0 | Tulsa | University Field • El Paso, Texas | Nicolette Radovcic (UCF) | Marissa Diggs (UCF) | |
| 2013 | Colorado College(1) | 3–0 | North Texas | Holloway Field • Houston, Texas | Jessie Ayers (Colorado College) | Kate Scheele (Colorado College) | |
| 2014 | Rice (2) | 1–0 | North Texas | Transamerica Field • Charlotte, North Carolina | Gabriela Iribarne (Rice) | Ashton Geisendorff (Rice) | |
| 2015 | North Texas(1) | 1–0 | Marshall | FIU Soccer Stadium • Miami, Florida | Rachel Holden (North Texas) | Jackie Kerestine (North Texas) | |
| 2016 | Charlotte (3) | 4–0 | Florida Atlantic | Transamerica Field • Charlotte, North Carolina | Katie O'Neill (Charlotte) | Shelby Hicks (Charlotte) | [2] |
| 2017 | North Texas (2) | 0–0†
(3–1 pen.) | Charlotte | FAU Soccer Stadium • Boca Raton, Florida | Taylor Torres (North Texas) | Dominique James (North Texas) | [3] |
| 2018 | North Texas(3) | 2–1*(2OT) | Southern Miss | Old Dominion Soccer Complex • Norfolk, Virginia | Lauryn Bruffett (North Texas) | Carissa Sanders (North Texas) | [4] |
| 2019 | North Texas (4) | 5–2 | Florida Atlantic | North Texas Soccer Stadium • Denton, Texas | Allie Byrd (North Texas) | Dominique James (North Texas) | [5] |
| 2020 | Rice(3) | 2–0 | Charlotte | Holloway Field • Houston, Texas | Delaney Schultz (Rice) | Mijke Roelfsema (Rice) | [6] |
| 2021 | Old Dominion (1) | 1–0 | Southern Miss | FAU Soccer Stadium • Boca Raton, Florida | Carla Morich (Old Dominion) | Emily Roberts (Old Dominion) | [7] |
| 2022 | UTSA (1) | 3–2*(2OT) | Florida Atlantic | Transamerica Field • Charlotte, North Carolina | Anna Sutter (UTSA) | Kendall Kloza (UTSA) | [8] |
| 2023 | Liberty (1) | 2–1 | New Mexico State | Robert Mack Caruthers Field • Ruston, Louisiana | Rachel DeRuby (Liberty) | Ainsley Leja (Liberty) | [9] |
| 2024 | FIU (1) | 1–0 | Liberty | FIU Soccer Stadium • Miami, Florida | Noémi Paquin (FIU) | Delinda Sehlin (FIU) | [10] |
