Denise Schmandt-Besserat

Last updated
Schmandt-Besserat Denise Schmandt-Besserat.jpg
Schmandt-Besserat

Denise Schmandt-Besserat (born August 10, 1933 in Ay, Marne, France) is a French-American archaeologist and retired professor of art and archaeology of the ancient Near East. She spent much of her professional career as a professor at the University of Texas. [1] She is best known for her work on the history and invention of writing. While her research is highly cited, it has been controversial among scholars. [2] [3] The controversies, as detailed below, concern the interpretation of early tokens, particularly the complex ones; however, the idea that writing emerged out of the counting, cataloging, management, and transactions of agricultural produce has been largely accepted.

Contents

Early life and education

Denise Besserat was born into a family of lawyers and winemakers. Her early education was at the hands of tutors. Her family evacuated to southern France during World War II, after which she attended a Catholic boarding school at Reims. The school's nuns directed her to a prospective career as a language interpreter, for which she spent periods in Ireland and Germany in language studies. [1] She met her future husband, Jurgen Schmandt (a philosopher and expert in science policy), in Bonn in 1954; they were married in 1956. They lived in Paris, where three sons (Alexander, Christophe, Phillip) were added to the family.

Deciding to resume her studies, she entered the École du Louvre. She graduated in 1965, after which the family moved to Cambridge, Massachusetts, where her husband had been offered employment. She applied for a fellowship at Harvard University's Peabody Museum of Archaeology and Ethnology, to study the origins of the use of clay as a writing material in the Middle East.

She and her family moved to Austin, Texas in 1971, where she began teaching Art History.

Career

Schmandt-Besserat has worked on the origin of writing and counting, [4] and the nature of information management systems in oral societies.

Her first published works on clay tokens were the monograph, "Archaic Recoding System and the Origin of Writing," published by Syro-Mesopotamian Studies in 1977 [5] and The Earliest Precursor of Writing in a 1978 issue of Scientific American magazine. [1]

In those articles Schmandt-Besserat explained her methodology and reviewed the history of archeological discoveries of clay counting tokens found at the main sites in the Asia. She credited the work done by A. Leo Oppenheim of University of Chicago and Pierre Amiet of the Louvre Museum for their original insights. Oppenheim, she says, "visualized a kind of dual bookkeeping system." Amiet demonstrated that the tokens were in existence far earlier than previously thought, a finding, she says, "of great significance." [6]

Her publications on these subjects include:

Her work has been widely reported in the public media (Scientific American, Science News, Time, Life, New York Times, The Washington Post, Los Angeles Times, Christian Science Monitor.) She was featured in several television programs such as Out of the Past (Discovery Channel), Discover (Disney Channel); The Nature of Things (CBC), Search for Solutions (PBS), and Tell the Truth (NBC).

She retired in 2004 as Professor of Art and Middle Eastern Studies at the University of Texas at Austin.

In her most recent book, When Writing Met Art (2007), Schmandt-Besserat investigated the impact of literacy on visual art. She showed that, before writing, art of the ancient Near East mostly consisted of repetitive motifs. But, after writing, conventions of the Mesopotamian script, such as the semantic use of form, size, order and placement of signs on a tablet was applied to images resulting in complex visual narratives. She also shows how, reciprocally, art played a crucial role in the evolution of writing from a mere accounting system to literature when funerary and votive inscriptions started to be featured on art monuments.

Schmandt-Besserat's present interest is the cognitive aspects of the token system that functioned as an extension of the human brain to collect, manipulate, store and retrieve data. She studies how processing an increasing volume of data over thousands of years brought people to think in greater abstraction. However, some of her conclusions have been questioned by later researchers. [7] [8] [9] [10] She also continues her research on Neolithic symbolism at the site of 'Ain Ghazal, near Amman, Jordan. [11]

Awards and honors

Schmandt-Besserat has received the Walter J. Ong Award for Career Achievement; the Holloway teaching award; the Eugene Kayden Press Book Award and the Hamilton book Award. She been cited Outstanding Woman in the Humanities by the American Association of University Women.

Her book, How Writing Came About, was listed by American Scientist as one of the 100 books that shaped science in the 20th century. [12]

She is listed in Who's Who in America .

At the 180th Commencement of Kenyon College she received an honorary degree.

Criticisms

Correspondences between (plain) tokens and numerical impressions suggest that tokens were used as numerical counters in the 4th millennium BC. The possible role of tokens was initially noticed and published by French archaeologists Pierre Amiet [13] [14] and Maurice Lambert [15] and other scholars. [16] [17] In the decades since these publications, the idea has become widely accepted. As noted by the Assyriologist Robert K. Englund in 1998, "a general consensus of opinion in the field tends to support" the argument that the plain tokens were "the precursors of the impressed proto-cuneiform signs used for numerical and metrological notations in the earliest texts to represent numbers and measures of products of a redistributive archaic economy" [18] :258Although Schmandt-Besserat gave credit to the work of her predecessors in the field, she has often been singled out as the discoverer of these correspondences. William Goetzmann's history of money, Money Changes Everything (Princeton U.P., 2012) is one example. [19]

Schmandt-Besserat's claims about the role of tokens in both numbers and writing, particularly the complex tokens, have been significantly criticized:

See also

Related Research Articles

<span class="mw-page-title-main">Writing</span> Persistent representation of language

Writing is the act of creating a persistent representation of human language. A writing system uses a set of symbols and rules to encode aspects of spoken language, such as its lexicon and syntax. However, written language may take on characteristics distinct from those of any spoken language.

<span class="mw-page-title-main">Cuneiform</span> Writing system of the ancient Near East

Cuneiform is a logo-syllabic writing system that was used to write several languages of the Ancient Near East. The script was in active use from the early Bronze Age until the beginning of the Common Era. Cuneiform scripts are marked by and named for the characteristic wedge-shaped impressions which form their signs. Cuneiform is the earliest known writing system and was originally developed to write the Sumerian language of southern Mesopotamia.

<span class="mw-page-title-main">Tărtăria tablets</span> Neolithic artefacts purported to contain writing

The Tărtăria tablets are three tablets, reportedly discovered in 1961 at a Neolithic site in the village of Tărtăria in Săliștea commune, from Transylvania.

<span class="mw-page-title-main">Uruk period</span> Archaeological culture

The Uruk period existed from the protohistoric Chalcolithic to Early Bronze Age period in the history of Mesopotamia, after the Ubaid period and before the Jemdet Nasr period. Named after the Sumerian city of Uruk, this period saw the emergence of urban life in Mesopotamia and the Sumerian civilization. The late Uruk period saw the gradual emergence of the cuneiform script and corresponds to the Early Bronze Age; it has also been described as the "Protoliterate period".

<span class="mw-page-title-main">Proto-Elamite (period)</span> Historical period of Iranian civilization (c. 3200–2700 BCE)

The Proto-Elamite period, also known as Susa III, is a chronological era in the ancient history of the area of Elam, dating from c. 3100 BC to 2700 BC. In archaeological terms this corresponds to the late Banesh period. Proto-Elamite sites are recognized as the oldest civilization in Iran. The Proto-Elamite script is an Early Bronze Age writing system briefly in use before the introduction of Elamite cuneiform.

<span class="mw-page-title-main">Proto-Elamite script</span> Early Bronze Age writing system in present-day Iran

The Proto-Elamite script is an early Bronze Age writing system briefly in use before the introduction of Elamite cuneiform.

<span class="mw-page-title-main">Ancient Mesopotamian units of measurement</span>

Ancient Mesopotamian units of measurement originated in the loosely organized city-states of Early Dynastic Sumer. Each city, kingdom and trade guild had its own standards until the formation of the Akkadian Empire when Sargon of Akkad issued a common standard. This standard was improved by Naram-Sin, but fell into disuse after the Akkadian Empire dissolved. The standard of Naram-Sin was readopted in the Ur III period by the Nanše Hymn which reduced a plethora of multiple standards to a few agreed upon common groupings. Successors to Sumerian civilization including the Babylonians, Assyrians, and Persians continued to use these groupings. Akkado-Sumerian metrology has been reconstructed by applying statistical methods to compare Sumerian architecture, architectural plans, and issued official standards such as Statue B of Gudea and the bronze cubit of Nippur.

<span class="mw-page-title-main">History of writing</span>

The history of writing traces the development of writing systems and how their use transformed and was transformed by different societies. The use of writing prefigures various social and psychological consequences associated with literacy and literary culture.

<span class="mw-page-title-main">Bulla (seal)</span> Device to seal or authenticate documents

A bulla is an inscribed clay, soft metal, bitumen, or wax token used in commercial and legal documentation as a form of authentication and for tamper-proofing whatever is attached to it.

A sign-value notation represents numbers using a sequence of numerals which each represent a distinct quantity, regardless of their position in the sequence. Sign-value notations are typically additive, subtractive, or multiplicative depending on their conventions for grouping signs together to collectively represent numbers.

Number systems have progressed from the use of fingers and tally marks, perhaps more than 40,000 years ago, to the use of sets of glyphs able to represent any conceivable number efficiently. The earliest known unambiguous notations for numbers emerged in Mesopotamia about 5000 or 6000 years ago.

Tell Billa is an archaeological site near Bashiqa in Nineveh Province (Iraq) 20 kilometers northeast of Mosul.

<span class="mw-page-title-main">Habuba Kabira</span> Archaeological site in Syria

Habuba Kabira at Tell Qanas is the site of an Uruk settlement along the Euphrates in Syria, founded during the later part of the Uruk period. It was about 800 mi (1,300 km) from the city of Uruk. The site is now mostly underwater due to the Tabqa Dam project. It consists of Habuba Kabira South, which is protoliterate, and Habuba Kabira North, which is protoliterate, Middle Bronze Age, Late Bronze Age, and Roman.

Choghā Mīsh (Persian language; چغامیش čoġā mīš) dating back to about 6800 BC, is the site of a Chalcolithic settlement located in the Khuzistan Province Iran on the eastern Susiana Plain. It was occupied at the beginning of 6800 BC and continuously from the Neolithic up to the Proto-Literate period, thus spanning the time periods from Archaic through Proto-Elamite period. After the decline of the site about 4400 BC, the nearby Susa, on the western Susiana Plain, became culturally dominant in this area. Chogha Mish is located just to the east of Dez River, and about 25 kilometers to the east from the ancient Susa. The similar, though much smaller site of Chogha Bonut lies six kilometers to the west.

<i>Investiture of Zimri-Lim</i>

The Investiture of Zimri-Lim is a large colorful mural discovered at the Royal Palace of the ancient city-state of Mari in eastern Syria. The fresco, which dates back to the 18th century BC, depicts Zimri-Lim, king of Mari, receiving the rod-and-ring symbol from the goddess Ishtar. The painting was discovered in situ on its original wall located opposite the grand doorway to the podium which leads to the throne room of the palace. It was discovered by French archaeologist André Parrot during excavations at Mari in 1935–1936. The painting is now displayed at the Musée du Louvre in Paris, France.

<span class="mw-page-title-main">Kushim (Uruk period)</span> Sumerian person, c. 3400–3000 BC

Kushim is supposedly the earliest known recorded name of a person in writing. The name "Kushim" is found on several Uruk period clay tablets used to record transactions of barley. It is uncertain if the name refers to an individual, a generic title of an officeholder, or an institution.

Robert K. Englund was an American Archaeologist and Assyriologist.

Karenleigh A. Overmann is a cognitive archaeologist known for her work on how ancient societies became numerate and literate. She currently directs the Center for Cognitive Archaeology at the University of Colorado, Colorado Springs. Before becoming an academic researcher, Overmann served 25 years of active duty in the U.S. Navy.

<span class="mw-page-title-main">Proto-cuneiform</span> Early proto-writing system

The proto-cuneiform script was a system of proto-writing that emerged in Mesopotamia, eventually developing into the early cuneiform script used in the region's Early Dynastic I period. It arose from the token-based system that had already been in use across the region in preceding millennia. While it is known definitively that later cuneiform was used to write the Sumerian language, it is still uncertain what the underlying language of proto-cuneiform texts were.

A data physicalization is a physical artefact whose geometry or material properties encode data. It has the main goals to engage people and to communicate data using computer-supported physical data representations.

References

  1. 1 2 3 Austin American-Statesman, Michael Barnes, The Austinite who discovered origin of writing, 3 July 2016, p. D1
  2. Michalowski, Piotr (1993). "Tokenism: Before Writing, Volume 1: From Counting to Cuneiform. Before Writing, Volume 2: A Catalog of Near Eastern Tokens". American Anthropologist. 95 (4): 996–999. doi:10.1525/aa.1993.95.4.02a00110. ISSN   0002-7294.
  3. Chrisomalis, Stephen, "The Origins and Co-Evolution of Literacy and Numeracy", The Cambridge Handbook of Literacy, Cambridge University Press, pp. 59–74, doi:10.1017/cbo9780511609664.005
  4. Rudgley, Richard (2000). The Lost Civilizations of the Stone Age. New York: Simon & Schuster. pp. 48–57.
  5. Schmandt-Besserat, Denise (July 1977). "AN ARCHAIC RECORDING SYSTEM AND THE ORIGIN OF WRITING" (PDF). Syro-Mesopotamian Studies. 1 (2): 1–32. Retrieved 19 August 2024.
  6. Schmandt-Besserat, Denise (June 1978). "The Earliest Precursor to Writing". Scientific American. 238 (6): 50–59.
  7. 1 2 Chrisomalis, Stephen (2009). "The Cognitive and Cultural Foundations of Numbers". In Robson, Eleanor; Stedall, Jacqueline A (eds.). The Oxford Handbook of the History of Mathematics. Oxford University Press. pp. 495–517. ISBN   9780199213122.
  8. 1 2 Chrisomalis, Stephen (2005). "Evaluating Ancient Numeracy: Social versus Developmental Perspectives on Ancient Mesopotamian Numeration. Paper Presented at the Annual Meeting of the Jean Piaget Society (Vancouver, British Columbia)". pp. 1–21. Retrieved June 3, 2021.
  9. Overmann, Karenleigh A (2018). "Updating the "abstract–concrete" distinction in Ancient Near Eastern numbers". Cuneiform Digital Library Journal. 1: 1–22. Retrieved June 3, 2021.
  10. Glassner, Jean-Jacques (2003). The Invention of Cuneiform: Writing in Sumer. Baltimore, MD: Johns Hopkins University Press. pp. 63–83. ISBN   9780801873898.
  11. 'Ain Ghazal Excavation Reports, Vol. 1 Symbols at 'Ain Ghazal
  12. Philip Morrison, Phylis Morrison (Nov–Dec 1999). "100 or so Books that shaped a Century of Science". American Scientist. Archived from the original on 2008-12-28. Retrieved 2008-08-03.
  13. Amiet, Pierre (1966). "Il y a 5000 ans les Élamites inventaient l'écriture". Archéologia. 12 (20): 16–23.
  14. Amiet, Pierre (1972). "Mémoires de la délégation archéologique en Iran, Tome XLIII, Mission de Susiane". Mémoires de la Délégation Archéologique en Iran. Paris: Paul Geuthner. ISSN   1148-6198.
  15. Lambert, Maurice (1966). "Pourquoi l'écriture est née en Mésopotamie". Archéologia. 12: 24–31.
  16. Broman, Vivian L (1958). Jarmo figurines. Cambridge, MA: Radcliffe College. OCLC   79711397.
  17. Oppenheim, A Leo (1959). "On an operational device in Mesopotamian bureaucracy". Journal of Near Eastern Studies. 18 (2): 121–128. doi:10.1086/371519. JSTOR   543273. S2CID   159942165.
  18. 1 2 3 Englund, Robert K. (1998). "Review of D. Schmandt-Besserat, How Writing Came About". Written Language and Literacy. 1: 257–261. doi:10.1075/wll.1.2.08eng.
  19. Goetzmann, William N. (2017). Money changes everything: how finance made civilization possible ; with a new afterword by the author (Third printing, and first paperback printing ed.). Princeton, New Jersey Oxford: Princeton University Press. p. 23. ISBN   978-0-691-17837-0. The little objects went largely unstudied until Professor Denise Schmandt-Besserat, a scholar at the University of Texas at Austin, began to analyze them in a systematic fashion.
  20. Schmandt-Besserat, Denise (1992). Before writing: From counting to cuneiform. Austin, TX: University of Texas at Austin. OCLC   438875637.
  21. Damerow, Peter; Englund, Robert K (1987). Die zahlzeichensysteme der archaischen texte aus Uruk. Berlin: Gebr. Mann. OCLC   255161013.
  22. Damerow, Peter; Englund, Robert K; Nissen, Hans J (1988). "Die ersten Zahldarstellungen und die Entwicklung des Zahlbegriffs". Spektrum der Wissenschaft. 3: 46–55.
  23. Nissen, Hans J; Damerow, Peter; Englund, Robert K (1993). Archaic bookkeeping: Early writing and techniques of economic administration in the ancient Near East. Chicago: University of Chicago Press. OCLC   469457678.
  24. Damerow, Peter; Meinzer, Hans-Peter (1995). "Computertomografische Untersuchung ungeöffneter archaischer Tonkugeln aus Uruk, W 20987, 9, W 20987, 11 und W 20987, 12". Baghdader Mitteilungen. 26: 7–33.
  25. Friberg, Jöran (1994). "Preliterate counting and accounting in the Middle East: A constructively critical review of Schmandt-Besserat's Before Writing". Orientalistische Literaturzeitung. 89 (5): 477–489. doi:10.1524/olzg.1994.89.56.477. S2CID   163900636.
  26. Zimansky, Paul (1993). "Review of Denise Schmandt-Besserat's Before Writing, Volumes I and II". Journal of Field Archaeology. 20 (4): 513–517. doi:10.2307/530080. JSTOR   530080.
  27. Overmann, Karenleigh A (2021). "A New Look at Old Numbers, and What It Reveals about Numeration". Journal of Near Eastern Studies. 80 (2): 291–321. doi:10.1086/715767. S2CID   239028709 . Retrieved October 23, 2021.