Disenchantment: The Guardian and Israel

Last updated

Disenchantment: The Guardian and Israel
Disenchantment, The Guardian and Israel.jpg
AuthorDaphna Baram
CountryUnited Kingdom
LanguageEnglish
Subject Israeli–Palestinian conflict
Published London
Publisher Guardian Books
Publication date
2004, 2008
Media typePrint (paperback)
Pages296
ISBN 9780852650905
956.94

Disenchantment: The Guardian and Israel is a 2004 book by Israeli journalist Daphna Baram. [1] Another edition was released in 2008 with a new foreword by British-Israeli historian and critic of Israel, Avi Shlaim. The work was commissioned by the British newspaper The Guardian in order to address questions about criticism the publication had received over its coverage of the State of Israel. [2]

Contents

Synopsis

The book examines the relationship between the liberal British daily newspaper The Guardian and the State of Israel. An early advocate and supporter of Israel, at a time when the conservative elements in the British press were much less supportive of Israel than they would go on to be, the paper has become more strongly critical due to the Israeli–Palestinian conflict, and actions of Israel such as ongoing building of Israeli settlements in the Israeli-occupied West Bank.

Reception

Critical reception has been mixed and the work has been cited as an example of work that examines newspaper coverage of the Middle East and the State of Israel. [3] The New Statesman reviewed the work alongside Greg Philo's Bad News From Israel and stated that Disenchantment was "the more interesting and readable" of the two. [4] The Economist also reviewed the work, writing "Over the decades, some Guardian commentators and reporters have been excessively partisan--and a few, from each side, have left or been eased out because of this. Far from glossing over such issues, Ms Baram lays bare the paper's internal quarrels. Indeed, this is the best part of her book". [5]

In contrast, the Jewish Quarterly and The Jerusalem Post both criticised the work, both questioning Baram's qualifications to impartially investigate and cover the issue. [6] [7] Norman Lebrecht also commented on the work, writing that Baram "exonerates the paper of anti-Zionism and anti-Semitism, but many in the Middle East will feel distinctly queasy at The Guardian's unremitting self-importance." [8]

Bryan Cheyette, a reviewer for The Guardian reviewed the book and while he did praise the "detailed interviews with most of the key Guardian players in relation to Israel since the 1970s" he also criticised Baram as having "something of a tin ear when it comes to the experiences of Jews as a minority in the diaspora." [9] [10]

Related Research Articles

New antisemitism is the concept that a new form of antisemitism which developed in the late 20th and early 21st centuries, tends to manifest itself as anti-Zionism. The concept is included in some definitions of antisemitism, such as the working definition of antisemitism and the 3D test of antisemitism. The concept dates to the early 1970s, although the identification of anti-Zionism with antisemitism has "long been de rigueur in Jewish communal and broader pro-Israel circles".

<i>Yated Neeman</i> (Israel) Hebrew-language daily newspaper based in Bnei Brak for a Haredi readership

Yated Ne'eman is a semi-major Israeli daily Hebrew language newspaper based in Bnei Brak. The Hebrew edition is published daily except on the Jewish Sabbath. A weekly English language edition was published in Israel and distributed in Israel, South Africa and Britain until December 2006.

<span class="mw-page-title-main">Gilad Atzmon</span> British jazz saxophonist, political activist, and writer (born 1963)

Gilad Atzmon is an Israeli-born British jazz saxophonist, novelist, political activist, and writer.

<span class="mw-page-title-main">Self-hating Jew</span> Pejorative label implying antisemitism

The terms "self-hating Jew", "self-loathing Jew" and auto-antisemite are pejorative terms used to describe a Jew whose viewpoints on any specific matter are perceived as antisemitic.

<span class="mw-page-title-main">Stephen Sizer</span> British priest

Stephen Robert Sizer is a priest in the Church of England. He is banned from serving as a priest until 2030. From 1997 to 2017, he was vicar of Christ Church, Virginia Water, in Surrey.

Engage is a British website, and briefly an online journal, that aims to help people counter the boycott Israel campaign. Engage describes its mission as to "challenge left and liberal antisemitism in the labour movement, in our universities and in public life."

Antony Loewenstein is an Australian-German freelance investigative journalist, author, and film-maker.

<span class="mw-page-title-main">Robert S. Wistrich</span> Professor at the Hebrew University of Jerusalem (1945–2015)

Robert Solomon Wistrich was a scholar of antisemitism, considered one of the world's foremost authorities on antisemitism.

David Hirsh is a Senior Lecturer in Sociology at Goldsmiths, University of London, and co-founder of Engage, a campaign against the academic boycott of Israel.

<span class="mw-page-title-main">Anti-Zionism</span> Opposition to Jewish nationalism

Anti-Zionism is opposition to Zionism. Although anti-Zionism is a heterogeneous phenomenon, all its proponents agree that the creation of the modern State of Israel, and the movement to create a sovereign Jewish state in the region of Palestine—a region partly coinciding with the biblical Land of Israel—was flawed or unjust in some way.

Antony Lerman is a British writer who specialises in the study of antisemitism, the Israeli–Palestinian conflict, multiculturalism, and the place of religion in society. From 2006 to early 2009, he was Director of the Institute for Jewish Policy Research, a think tank on issues affecting Jewish communities in Europe. From December 1999 to 2006, he was Chief Executive of the Hanadiv Charitable Foundation, renamed the Rothschild Foundation Europe in 2007. He is a founding member of the Jewish Forum for Justice and Human Rights, and a former editor of Patterns of Prejudice, a quarterly academic journal focusing on the sociology of race and ethnicity.

<span class="mw-page-title-main">Criticism of Israel</span> Disapproval towards the Israeli government

Criticism of Israel is a subject of journalistic and scholarly commentary and research within the scope of international relations theory, expressed in terms of political science. Israel has faced international criticism since its declaration of independence in 1948 relating to a variety of issues, many of which are centered around human rights violations in its occupation of the West Bank and the Gaza Strip.

This timeline of anti-Zionism chronicles the history of anti-Zionism, including events in the history of anti-Zionist thought.

Trials of the Diaspora: A History of Anti-Semitism in England is a 2010 book by British lawyer Anthony Julius. The book details the role played by antisemitism in the history of the United Kingdom. The book argues that British anti-Zionism developed out of antisemitism in the United Kingdom and utilizes many of the same antisemitic tropes in its arguments.

<i>Zionism in the Age of the Dictators</i> 1983 book by Lenni Brenner

Zionism in the Age of the Dictators is a 1983 work by the American free-lance journalist, outspoken pro-Palestinian activist, Trotskyist and Jewish author Lenni Brenner. The book makes the argument that Zionist leaders collaborated with fascism, particularly in Nazi Germany, in order to build up a Jewish presence in Palestine.

<i>The Lefts Jewish Problem</i> 2016 book by Dave Rich

The Left's Jewish Problem: Jeremy Corbyn, Israel and Anti‑Semitism is a 2016 book by Dave Rich. The book argues that new antisemitism is "masked as anti-Zionism" in left-wing politics.

There have been instances of antisemitism within the Labour Party of the United Kingdom (UK) since its establishment. Notable occurrences include canards about "Jewish finance" during the Boer War and antisemitic remarks from leading Labour politician Ernest Bevin. In the 2000s, controversies arose over comments made by Labour politicians regarding an alleged "Jewish lobby", a comparison by London Labour politician Ken Livingstone of a Jewish journalist to a concentration camp guard, and a 2005 Labour attack on Jewish Conservative Party politician Michael Howard.

The working definition of antisemitism, also called the International Holocaust Remembrance Alliance definition of antisemitism or IHRA definition, is a non-legally binding statement on what antisemitism is, that reads: "Antisemitism is a certain perception of Jews, which may be expressed as hatred toward Jews. Rhetorical and physical manifestations of antisemitism are directed toward Jewish or non-Jewish individuals and/or their property, toward Jewish community institutions and religious facilities." Accompanying the working definition, but of disputed status, are 11 illustrative examples whose purpose is described as guiding the IHRA in its work, seven of which relate to criticism of the Israeli government. As such, pro-Israeli organizations have been advocates for the worldwide legal adoption of the definition.

Zionist antisemitism or antisemitic Zionism refers to a phenomenon in which antisemites express support for Zionism and the State of Israel. In some cases, this support may be promoted for explicitly antisemitic reasons. Historically, this type of antisemitism has been most notable among Christian Zionists, who may perpetrate religious antisemitism while being outspoken in their support for Jewish sovereignty in Israel due to their interpretation of Christian eschatology. Similarly, people who identify with the political far-right, particularly in Europe and the United States, may support the Zionist movement because they seek to expel Jews from their country and see Zionism as the least complicated method of achieving this goal and satisfying their racial antisemitism.

<i>Jews Dont Count</i> 2021 book by David Baddiel

Jews Don't Count: How Identity Politics Failed One Particular Identity is a book by British comedian David Baddiel. First published on 4 February 2021 by TLS Books, the book discusses the status of antisemitism as a form of racism, particularly in left-wing politics. Baddiel argues that antisemitism is treated differently from other forms of racism, creating double standards and discrimination against Jews. The book covers a range of topics related to modern antisemitism and Jewish identity, including under-representation in popular media, relationships with Israel and Zionism, and the status of Jews as a minority group.

References

  1. Shindler, Colin (16 July 2004). "Has the Guardian deserted the Angels?". Jewish Chronicle. Archived from the original on 4 March 2016. Retrieved 14 May 2015.
  2. Herf, Jeffrey (2006). Anti-Semitism and Anti-Zionism in Historical Perspective. Routledge. p. 142. ISBN   978-0415400695 . Retrieved 14 May 2015.
  3. Negrine, Ralph (2013). "'Are Jews Who Fled Arab Lands to Israel Refugees, Too?' ( New York Times, 2003): The representation of Jewish migration from 'Arab lands' in Anglo-American newspapers, 1949–1957". Media History. 19 (4): 453. doi:10.1080/13688804.2013.844895. S2CID   162537296.
  4. LA GUARDIA, ANTON. "Chicken and egg". New Statesman. Retrieved 14 May 2015.
  5. "The long fall from grace; Covering Israel.(Disenchantment: The Guardian and Israel)(Book Review)". The Economist. 31 July 2004. Archived from the original on 16 April 2016. Retrieved 14 May 2015.
  6. Daniel Hochhauser. "Dangerous Disproportion?". Jewish Quarterly. Retrieved 14 May 2015.
  7. PFEFFER, ANSHEL (15 October 2004). "A paper's route". The Jerusalem Post. Archived from the original on 16 April 2016. Retrieved 14 May 2015.
  8. Lebrecht, Norman (27 August 2004). "Save us all from this terror on two wheels" . Evening Standard. Retrieved 14 May 2015.
  9. Cheyette, Bryan (24 July 2004). "What became of Zion?". The Guardian. Retrieved 14 May 2015.
  10. Cohen, Ben (Fall 2004). "The Persistence of Anti-Semitism on the British Left". Jewish Political Studies Review. 16 (3/4): 157–169. JSTOR   25834610.