Evolution of seed size

Last updated

The first seeded plants emerged in the late Devonian 370 million years ago. Selection pressures shaping seed size stem from physical and biological sources including drought, predation, seedling-seedling competition, optimal dormancy depth, and dispersal.

Contents

Double coconut -The world's largest known seed Coco de mer - BOT.2007.26.21.jpg
Double coconut -The world's largest known seed

History

Since the evolution of the first seeded plants ~370 million years ago, [1] the largest change in seed size was found to be at the divergence of gymnosperms and angiosperms ~325 million years ago, but overall, the divergence of seed size appears to take place relatively consistently through evolutionary time. [2] Seed mass has been found to be phylogenetically conservative [3] with most differences in mean seed mass within types of seed dispersal (dispersal modes) being phylogenetic. [4] This type of information gives us clues about how seed size evolved. [2] Dating fossilized seeds of various sizes and comparing them with the presence of possible animal dispersers and the environmental conditions of the time is another technique used to study the evolution of seed size. Environmental conditions appear to have had a larger influence on the evolution of seed size compared to the presence of animal dispersers. One example of seed size evolving to environmental conditions is thought to have been abundant, closed forest vegetation selecting for larger seed sizes during the Eocene epoch. [5] A general increase or decrease in seed size through time has not been found, but instead a fluctuation in seed size following the environmental conditions of the Maastrichtian, Paleocene, Eocene, Oligocene, Miocene, and Pliocene epochs. [5] Today we also see a pattern with seed size distribution and global environmental conditions where the largest mean seed size is found in tropical forests and a steep decrease in seed size takes places globally as vegetation type changes to non-forest. [6]

Mechanism

Modern seed sizes range from 0.0001 mg in orchid seeds to 42 kilograms (92 lb 10 oz) in double coconuts. [7] [2] Larger seeds have larger quantities of metabolic reserves in their embryo and endosperm available for the seedling [8] than smaller seeds, and often aid establishment under low resource availability. [9] However, smaller seeds can be produced in larger quantities which has the potential to produce more offspring and have better chances of some of the seeds dispersing into suitable habitat. [3] This seed size-number trade off [10] has led to the evolution of a wide range in size and number of seeds in response to environmental selection pressures.

Selective pressures

No single event, such as a large divergence in the phylogeny of seeded plants, is seen as the cause of major divergences in seed size. Rather, small events are thought to occur fairly consistently through time with minor evolutionary influence. [2]

Shade

Species growing in shaded environments tend to produce larger seeds and larger seeded species have higher seedling survivorship in low-light conditions. [11] [12] [9] [8] [13] [3] [14] [15] The increased metabolic reserves of larger seeds allows the first shoots to grow taller and leaves to grow broader more quickly in order to compete for what little sunlight is available. [9] A few large seeded trees that occur in closed canopy wooded areas such as old-growth forests are the many oak species, hickory, pecan, and butternut trees.

Drought

Small seeds are seen to be predominant in arid, desert environments. [16] In some desert systems the vast majority of annual seeds weigh between zero and two milligrams. [17] small seed size may be a favorable adaptation in desert plants for a couple reasons. Small seeds have been found to have the ability to store in dry environments for several years without desiccating. Also, in many cases, deserts have rainy seasons that provide opportunity for small seeds to germinate under conditions with ample external resources available. Due to the great importance that seeds germinate when water is available, seeds often sense the presence of water and use it as a cue to germinate. Also, many desert plants have evolved the ability to produce a fraction of their seeds to not germinate at the same time as the rest of the plant's seeds as a safe guard known as bet hedging in which if the majority of a plant's seeds germinate at one time and then die due to rain followed by drought, the potential for the plant to have successful offspring is not completely lost.

Predation

Granivors (those that feed on seeds and grains) can selectively eat either smaller or larger seeds, favoring seeds on the opposite side of the spectrum. Commonly, granivorous predation by rodents, which selectively feed on larger seeds, [18] leads to higher fitness of smaller seeds (e.g. kangaroo rats in desert systems selectively forage on the larger seeds in the seed bank. [17] Similarly, sometimes smaller seeds are selectively preyed upon such as with Australian granivorous ants which are only capable of carrying smaller seeds. [19]

Seedling-seedling competition

Competition between seedlings for limited resources can result selective pressures on seed size. In dense mats of competing seedlings, those from larger seeds have higher survivorship [8] due to their ability to more quickly grow taller shoots, broader leaves, and thus out-compete smaller seeded seedlings for resources. Germinated seedlings from larger seeds could also possibly outlive the smaller seeded seedlings which cannot live as long off their stored energy reserves. [9]

Optimal dormancy depth

If there is a selective pressure favoring the survival of seeds buried deeper in the soil, larger seed size may evolve because of their larger reserves of energy required to emerge from further depths. [20] One such pressure causing this type of selection is the recurrence of fires (e.g. in prairies the heat from a fire can damage or kill seeds near the surface of the soil but leave seeds buried deeper unharmed).

Dispersal

The smaller the seed, the further they can disperse, which can be beneficial for avoiding competition with siblings and the parent [21] as well as having better chances of some of the seeds dispersing into suitable habitat. [3] Dispersal may also lead to greater fitness in future generations if further dispersed individuals are more likely to cross pollinate with an unrelated individuals, leading to greater genetic variation. The type of seed dispersal evolved has been highly correlated to seed size in floras across the world. [22] In general, seeds smaller than 0.1 mg are often unassisted (wind dispersed), seeds larger than 100 mg are often dispersed by vertebrates or by water, and seeds between 0.1 and 100 mg are dispersed by a large variety of dispersal modes including dispersal by a great variety of animals. [3] [23]

Related Research Articles

<span class="mw-page-title-main">Seed</span> Embryonic plant enclosed in a protective outer covering

In botany, a seed is a plant embryo and food reserve enclosed in a protective outer covering called a seed coat (testa). More generally, the term "seed" means anything that can be sown, which may include seed and husk or tuber. Seeds are the product of the ripened ovule, after the embryo sac is fertilized by sperm from pollen, forming a zygote. The embryo within a seed develops from the zygote and grows within the mother plant to a certain size before growth is halted.

<span class="mw-page-title-main">Frugivore</span> Organism that eats mostly fruit

A frugivore is an animal that thrives mostly on raw fruits or succulent fruit-like produce of plants such as roots, shoots, nuts and seeds. Approximately 20% of mammalian herbivores eat fruit. Frugivores are highly dependent on the abundance and nutritional composition of fruits. Frugivores can benefit or hinder fruit-producing plants by either dispersing or destroying their seeds through digestion. When both the fruit-producing plant and the frugivore benefit by fruit-eating behavior the interaction is a form of mutualism.

<span class="mw-page-title-main">Biological dispersal</span> Movement of individuals from their birth site to a breeding site

Biological dispersal refers to both the movement of individuals from their birth site to their breeding site, as well as the movement from one breeding site to another . Dispersal is also used to describe the movement of propagules such as seeds and spores. Technically, dispersal is defined as any movement that has the potential to lead to gene flow. The act of dispersal involves three phases: departure, transfer, settlement and there are different fitness costs and benefits associated with each of these phases. Through simply moving from one habitat patch to another, the dispersal of an individual has consequences not only for individual fitness, but also for population dynamics, population genetics, and species distribution. Understanding dispersal and the consequences both for evolutionary strategies at a species level, and for processes at an ecosystem level, requires understanding on the type of dispersal, the dispersal range of a given species, and the dispersal mechanisms involved. Biological dispersal can be correlated to population density. The range of variations of a species' location determines expansion range.

<span class="mw-page-title-main">Seed dispersal</span> Movement or transport of seeds away from the parent plant

In spermatophyte plants, seed dispersal is the movement, spread or transport of seeds away from the parent plant. Plants have limited mobility and rely upon a variety of dispersal vectors to transport their seeds, including both abiotic vectors, such as the wind, and living (biotic) vectors such as birds. Seeds can be dispersed away from the parent plant individually or collectively, as well as dispersed in both space and time. The patterns of seed dispersal are determined in large part by the dispersal mechanism and this has important implications for the demographic and genetic structure of plant populations, as well as migration patterns and species interactions. There are five main modes of seed dispersal: gravity, wind, ballistic, water, and by animals. Some plants are serotinous and only disperse their seeds in response to an environmental stimulus. These modes are typically inferred based on adaptations, such as wings or fleshy fruit. However, this simplified view may ignore complexity in dispersal. Plants can disperse via modes without possessing the typical associated adaptations and plant traits may be multifunctional.

<span class="mw-page-title-main">Myrmecochory</span> Seed dispersal by ants

Myrmecochory ( ; from Ancient Greek: μύρμηξ, romanized: mýrmēks and χορεία khoreíā is seed dispersal by ants, an ecologically significant ant–plant interaction with worldwide distribution. Most myrmecochorous plants produce seeds with elaiosomes, a term encompassing various external appendages or "food bodies" rich in lipids, amino acids, or other nutrients that are attractive to ants. The seed with its attached elaiosome is collectively known as a diaspore. Seed dispersal by ants is typically accomplished when foraging workers carry diaspores back to the ant colony, after which the elaiosome is removed or fed directly to ant larvae. Once the elaiosome is consumed, the seed is usually discarded in underground middens or ejected from the nest. Although diaspores are seldom distributed far from the parent plant, myrmecochores also benefit from this predominantly mutualistic interaction through dispersal to favourable locations for germination, as well as escape from seed predation.

<span class="mw-page-title-main">Serotiny</span> Seed release in response to environment

Serotiny in botany simply means 'following' or 'later'.

<span class="mw-page-title-main">Ovary (botany)</span> Flowering plant reproductive part

In the flowering plants, an ovary is a part of the female reproductive organ of the flower or gynoecium. Specifically, it is the part of the pistil which holds the ovule(s) and is located above or below or at the point of connection with the base of the petals and sepals. The pistil may be made up of one carpel or of several fused carpels, and therefore the ovary can contain part of one carpel or parts of several fused carpels. Above the ovary is the style and the stigma, which is where the pollen lands and germinates to grow down through the style to the ovary, and, for each individual pollen grain, to fertilize one individual ovule. Some wind pollinated flowers have much reduced and modified ovaries.

Seed dormancy is an evolutionary adaptation that prevents seeds from germinating during unsuitable ecological conditions that would typically lead to a low probability of seedling survival. Dormant seeds do not germinate in a specified period of time under a combination of environmental factors that are normally conducive to the germination of non-dormant seeds.

<span class="mw-page-title-main">Seed predation</span> Feeding on seeds as a main or exclusive food source

Seed predation, often referred to as granivory, is a type of plant-animal interaction in which granivores feed on the seeds of plants as a main or exclusive food source, in many cases leaving the seeds damaged and not viable. Granivores are found across many families of vertebrates as well as invertebrates ; thus, seed predation occurs in virtually all terrestrial ecosystems. Seed predation is commonly divided into two distinctive temporal categories, pre-dispersal and post-dispersal predation, which affect the fitness of the parental plant and the dispersed offspring, respectively. Mitigating pre- and post-dispersal predation may involve different strategies. To counter seed predation, plants have evolved both physical defenses and chemical defenses. However, as plants have evolved seed defenses, seed predators have adapted to plant defenses. Thus, many interesting examples of coevolution arise from this dynamic relationship.

<i>Attalea</i> (plant) Genus of palms

Attalea is a large genus of palms native to Mexico, the Caribbean, Central and South America. This pinnately-leaved, non-spiny genus includes both small palms lacking an aboveground stem and large trees. The genus has a complicated taxonomic history, and has often been split into four or five genera based on differences in the male flowers. Since the genera can only be distinguished on the basis of their male flowers, the existence of intermediate flower types and the existence of hybrids between different genera has been used as an argument for keeping them all in the same genus. This has been supported by recent molecular phylogenies.

<span class="mw-page-title-main">Heterospory</span> The production of spores of two different sizes and sexes by several groups of land plants

Heterospory is the production of spores of two different sizes and sexes by the sporophytes of land plants. The smaller of these, the microspore, is male and the larger megaspore is female. Heterospory evolved during the Devonian period from isospory independently in several plant groups: the clubmosses, the ferns including the arborescent horsetails, and progymnosperms. This occurred as part of the process of evolution of the timing of sex differentiation.

<span class="mw-page-title-main">Diaspore (botany)</span> Plant seed or spore and tissues that aid dispersal

In botany, a diaspore is a plant dispersal unit consisting of a seed or spore plus any additional tissues that assist dispersal. In some seed plants, the diaspore is a seed and fruit together, or a seed and elaiosome. In a few seed plants, the diaspore is most or all of the plant, and is known as a tumbleweed.

<span class="mw-page-title-main">Plant ecology</span> The study of effect of the environment on the abundance and distribution of plants

Plant ecology is a subdiscipline of ecology that studies the distribution and abundance of plants, the effects of environmental factors upon the abundance of plants, and the interactions among plants and between plants and other organisms. Examples of these are the distribution of temperate deciduous forests in North America, the effects of drought or flooding upon plant survival, and competition among desert plants for water, or effects of herds of grazing animals upon the composition of grasslands.

<span class="mw-page-title-main">Dispersal vector</span> Transporters of biological dispersal units

A dispersal vector is an agent of biological dispersal that moves a dispersal unit, or organism, away from its birth population to another location or population in which the individual will reproduce. These dispersal units can range from pollen to seeds to fungi to entire organisms.

<i>Tachigali versicolor</i> Species of legume

Tachigali versicolor or the suicide tree is a species of tree found from Costa Rica to western Colombia. It is monocarpic, flowering only once before dying, which gives rise to its common name of the "suicide tree".

<i>Simarouba amara</i> Species of tree in the family Simaroubaceae

Simarouba amara is a species of tree in the family Simaroubaceae, found in the rainforests and savannahs of South and Central America and the Caribbean. It was first described by Aubl. in French Guiana in 1775 and is one of six species of Simarouba. The tree is evergreen, but produces a new set of leaves once a year. It requires relatively high levels of light to grow and grows rapidly in these conditions, but lives for a relatively short time. In Panama, it flowers during the dry season in February and March, whereas in Costa Rica, where there is no dry season it flowers later, between March and July. As the species is dioecious, the trees are either male or female and only produce male or female flowers. The small yellow flowers are thought to be pollinated by insects, the resulting fruits are dispersed by animals including monkeys, birds and fruit-eating bats and the seeds are also dispersed by leaf cutter ants.

<i>Platypodium elegans</i> Species of legume

Platypodium elegans, the graceful platypodium, is a large leguminous tree found in the Neotropics that forms part of the forest canopy. It was first described by Julius Rudolph Theodor Vogel in 1837 and is the type species of the genus. The tree has been known to grow up to 30 metres in height and have a trunk with a diameter up to 1 m at breast height. Its trunk has large holes in it, sometimes making it possible to see through the trunk. The holes provide a habitat for giant damselflies and other insects both when alive and once the tree has died and fallen over. It has compound leaves each of which is made up of 10–20 leaflets. Three new chemical compounds have been isolated from the leaves and they form part of the diet of several monkeys and the squirrel Sciurus ingrami. In Panama it flowers from April to June, the flowers contain only four ovules, but normally only one of these reaches maturity forming a winged seed pod around 10 cm long and weighing 2 g. During the dry season around a year after the flowers are fertilised, the seeds are dispersed by the wind and the tree loses it leaves. The seeds are eaten by agoutis and by bruchid beetle larvae. The majority of seedlings are killed by damping off fungi in the first few months of growth, with seedlings that grow nearer the parent trees being more likely to die. The seedlings are relatively unable to survive in deep shade compared to other species in the same habitat. Various epiphytes are known to grow on P. elegans with the cactus Epiphyllum phyllanthus being the most abundant in Panama. Despite having holes in its trunk which should encourage debris and seeds to collect, hemiepiphytes are relatively uncommon, meaning that animals are not attracted to it to feed and then defecate. It has no known uses in traditional medicine and although it can be used for timber, the wood is of poor quality.

Seed dispersal syndromes are morphological characters of seeds correlated to particular seed dispersal agents. Dispersal is the event by which individuals move from the site of their parents to establish in a new area. A seed disperser is the vector by which a seed moves from its parent to the resting place where the individual will establish, for instance an animal. Similar to the term syndrome, a diaspore is a morphological functional unit of a seed for dispersal purposes.

Janice Marjorie Lord is a New Zealand academic, a plant evolutionary biologist, and as of 2020 is an associate professor at the University of Otago, where she is the curator of the Otago Regional Herbarium.

Mark Westoby is an Australian evolutionary ecologist, emeritus professor at Macquarie University, and a specialist in trait ecology.

References

  1. Linkies, Ada; Graeber, Kai; Knight, Charles; Leubner-Metzger, Gerhard (2010-06-01). "The evolution of seeds". New Phytologist. 186 (4): 817–831. doi: 10.1111/j.1469-8137.2010.03249.x . ISSN   1469-8137. PMID   20406407.
  2. 1 2 3 4 Moles, Angela T.; Ackerly, David D.; Webb, Campbell O.; Tweddle, John C.; Dickie, John B.; Westoby, Mark (2005-01-28). "A Brief History of Seed Size". Science. 307 (5709): 576–580. Bibcode:2005Sci...307..576M. doi:10.1126/science.1104863. ISSN   0036-8075. PMID   15681384. S2CID   21159683.
  3. 1 2 3 4 5 Westoby, Mark; Leishman, Michelle; Lord, Janice (1996-09-30). "Comparative ecology of seed size and dispersal". Phil. Trans. R. Soc. Lond. B. 351 (1345): 1309–1318. doi:10.1098/rstb.1996.0114. ISSN   0962-8436.
  4. Lord, Janice; Westoby, Mark; Leishman, Michelle (1995). "Seed Size and Phylogeny in Six Temperate Floras: Constraints, Niche Conservatism, and Adaptation". The American Naturalist. 146 (3): 349–364. doi:10.1086/285804. JSTOR   2463112. S2CID   85147610.
  5. 1 2 Eriksson, Ove; Friis, Else Marie; Löfgren, Per; Schemske, Associate Editor: Douglas W. (2000). "Seed Size, Fruit Size, and Dispersal Systems in Angiosperms from the Early Cretaceous to the Late Tertiary". The American Naturalist. 156 (1): 47–58. doi:10.1086/303367. JSTOR   10.1086/303367. PMID   10824020. S2CID   4380232.{{cite journal}}: |first4= has generic name (help)
  6. Moles, Angela T.; Ackerly, David D.; Tweddle, John C.; Dickie, John B.; Smith, Roger; Leishman, Michelle R.; Mayfield, Margaret M.; Pitman, Andy; Wood, Jeff T. (2006). "Global patterns in seed size". Global Ecology and Biogeography. 16: 109–116. doi:10.1111/j.1466-8238.2006.00259.x.
  7. Harper, J. L.; Lovell, P. H.; Moore, K. G. (1970). "The Shapes and Sizes of Seeds". Annual Review of Ecology and Systematics. 1: 327–356. doi:10.1146/annurev.es.01.110170.001551. JSTOR   2096777.
  8. 1 2 3 Westoby, Mark; Jurado, Enrique; Leishman, Michelle (1992). "Comparative evolutionary ecology of seed size". Trends in Ecology & Evolution. 7 (11): 368–372. doi:10.1016/0169-5347(92)90006-w. PMID   21236070.
  9. 1 2 3 4 Leishman, Michelle R; Wright, Ian J; Moles, Angela T; Westoby, Mark (2000). 'The Evolutionary Ecology of Seed Size', in Seeds: The Ecology of Regeneration in Plant Communities. CABI. ISBN   9780851999470.
  10. Smith, Christopher C.; Fretwell, Stephen D. (1974). "The Optimal Balance between Size and Number of Offspring". The American Naturalist. 108 (962): 499–506. doi:10.1086/282929. JSTOR   2459681. S2CID   84149876.
  11. Saverimuttu, Tharman; Westoby, Mark (1996). "Seedling Longevity under Deep Shade in Relation to Seed Size". Journal of Ecology. 84 (5): 681–689. Bibcode:1996JEcol..84..681S. doi:10.2307/2261331. JSTOR   2261331.
  12. Salisbury, Edward J (1975). "Seed size and mass in relation to environment". Proc. R. Soc. Lond. B. 186 (1083): 83–88. doi:10.1098/rspb.1974.0039. ISSN   0080-4649. S2CID   84887532.
  13. Gross, Katherine L. (1984). "Effects of Seed Size and Growth Form on Seedling Establishment of Six Monocarpic Perennial Plants". Journal of Ecology. 72 (2): 369–387. Bibcode:1984JEcol..72..369G. doi:10.2307/2260053. JSTOR   2260053. S2CID   53588559.
  14. Salisbury, Edward James (1942). The Reproductive Capacity of Plants. G. Bell And Sons.
  15. Moles, Angela T.; Westoby, Mark (2004). "What Do Seedlings Die from and What Are the Implications for Evolution of Seed Size?". Oikos. 106 (1): 193–199. Bibcode:2004Oikos.106..193M. doi:10.1111/j.0030-1299.2004.13101.x. JSTOR   3548409.
  16. Mazer, Susan J. (1989-02-01). "Ecological, Taxonomic, and Life History Correlates of Seed Mass Among Indiana Dune Angiosperms". Ecological Monographs. 59 (2): 153–175. Bibcode:1989EcoM...59..153M. doi:10.2307/2937284. ISSN   1557-7015. JSTOR   2937284.
  17. 1 2 Chen, Ting C.; Valone, Thomas J. (2017-07-01). "Rodent granivory strengthens relationships between seed size and plant abundance in a desert annual community". Journal of Vegetation Science. 28 (4): 808–814. Bibcode:2017JVegS..28..808C. doi:10.1111/jvs.12529. ISSN   1654-1103. S2CID   91084191.
  18. Chen, Ting C.; Valone, Thomas J. (2017-07-01). "Rodent granivory strengthens relationships between seed size and plant abundance in a desert annual community". Journal of Vegetation Science. 28 (4): 808–814. Bibcode:2017JVegS..28..808C. doi:10.1111/jvs.12529. ISSN   1654-1103. S2CID   91084191.
  19. Hughes, Lesley; Westoby, Mark (1990-02-01). "Removal Rates of Seeds Adapted for Dispersal by Ants". Ecology. 71 (1): 138–148. Bibcode:1990Ecol...71..138H. doi:10.2307/1940254. ISSN   1939-9170. JSTOR   1940254.
  20. Bond, W. J.; Honig, M.; Maze, K. E. (1999). "Seed Size and Seedling Emergence: An Allometric Relationship and Some Ecological Implications". Oecologia. 120 (1): 132–136. Bibcode:1999Oecol.120..132B. doi:10.1007/s004420050841. JSTOR   4222367. PMID   28308044. S2CID   22426642.
  21. Venable, D. Lawrence (1992). "Size-Number Trade-Offs and the Variation of Seed Size with Plant Resource Status". The American Naturalist. 140 (2): 287–304. doi:10.1086/285413. JSTOR   2462610. S2CID   84934433.
  22. Leishman, Michelle R.; Westoby, Mark; Jurado, Enrique (1995). "Correlates of Seed Size Variation: A Comparison Among Five Temperate Floras". Journal of Ecology. 83 (3): 517–529. Bibcode:1995JEcol..83..517L. doi:10.2307/2261604. JSTOR   2261604.
  23. Hughes, Lesley; Dunlop, Michael; French, Kristine; Leishman, Michelle R.; Rice, Barbara; Rodgerson, Louise; Westoby, Mark (1994). "Predicting Dispersal Spectra: A Minimal Set of Hypotheses Based on Plant Attributes". Journal of Ecology. 82 (4): 933–950. Bibcode:1994JEcol..82..933H. doi:10.2307/2261456. JSTOR   2261456.