Feingold diet

Last updated

The Feingold diet is an elimination diet initially devised by Benjamin Feingold following research in the 1970s that appeared to link food additives with hyperactivity; by eliminating these additives and various foods the diet was supposed to alleviate the condition.

Contents

Popular in its day, the diet has since been referred to as an "outmoded treatment"; there is no good evidence that it is effective, [1] [2] and it is difficult for people to follow. [3]

Technique

The diet was originally based on the elimination of salicylate, artificial food coloring, and artificial flavors; [4] later on in the 1970s, the preservatives BHA, BHT, [5] and (somewhat later) TBHQ [6] were eliminated. Besides foods with the eliminated additives, aspirin- or additive-containing drugs and toiletries were to be avoided. Even today, parents are advised to limit their purchases of mouthwash, toothpaste, cough drops, perfume, and various other nonfood products to those published in the Feingold Association's annual Foodlist and Shopping Guide. [4] Some versions of the diet prohibit only artificial food coloring and additives. [7] According to the Royal College of Psychiatrists as of 2014 the diet prohibited a number of foods that contain salicylic acid including apples, cucumbers and tomatoes. [3]

Feingold stressed that the diet must be followed strictly and for an entire lifetime, and that whole families – not just the subject being "treated" – must observe the diet's rules. [7]

Effectiveness

Although the diet had a certain popular appeal, a 1983 meta-analysis found research on it to be of poor quality, and that overall there was no good evidence that it was effective in fulfilling its claims. [2]

In common with other elimination diets, the Feingold diet can be costly and boring, and thus difficult for people to maintain. [3]

In general, as of 2013 there is no evidence to support broad claims that food coloring causes food intolerance and ADHD-like behavior in children. [8] It is possible that certain food coloring may act as a trigger in those who are genetically predisposed, but the evidence is weak. [9] [10] [11]

Reception

For decades, the Feingold Program required a significant change in family lifestyle because families were limited to a narrow selection of foods. Such foods were sometimes expensive or had to be prepared "from scratch," greatly increasing the amount of time and effort a family must put into preparing a meal. [4] As more and more foods without the potentially offending additives are being produced and available in neighborhood supermarkets, this is much less a problem. [5]

While some fruits and a few vegetables are eliminated in the first weeks of the Program, they are replaced by others. Often, some or all of these items can be returned to the diet, once the level of tolerance is determined. [12]

History

Feingold was Chief of Pediatrics at Cedars of Lebanon Hospital in Los Angeles, CA, until 1951, when he became Chief of Allergy at Kaiser-Permanente Medical Center in San Francisco. [5] [13] He continued his work with children and adults with hyperactivity and allergy until his death at the age of 82, in 1982. [5] [14]

Since the 1940s, researchers worldwide had discussed cross-reactions of aspirin (a common salicylate) and tartrazine (FD&C Yellow #5). [5] [15] [16] Dr. Stephen Lockey [17] at the Mayo Clinic and later Feingold at Kaiser, hypothesized that eliminating both salicylates and synthetic food additives from patients' diets not only eliminated allergic-type reactions such as asthma, eczema and hives, [18] but also induced behavioral changes in some of their patients.

Feingold presented his findings at the annual conference of the American Medical Association in June 1973. [19] [20] This led to a controlled double-blind crossover study published in the August 1976 issue of Pediatrics . [21]

A two-week-long conference was arranged in January 1975, in Glen Cove, Long Island. There, the Nutrition Foundation attendees created what they called the National Advisory Committee. The committee widely published its preliminary report concluding that "no controlled studies have demonstrated that hyperkinesis is related to the ingestion of food additives." [5]

Related Research Articles

<span class="mw-page-title-main">Attention deficit hyperactivity disorder</span> Neurodevelopmental disorder

Attention deficit hyperactivity disorder (ADHD) is a neurodevelopmental disorder characterized by executive dysfunction occasioning symptoms of inattention, hyperactivity, impulsivity and emotional dysregulation that are excessive and pervasive, impairing in multiple contexts, and developmentally-inappropriate.

<span class="mw-page-title-main">Food coloring</span> Substance used to color food or drink

Food coloring, color additive or colorant is any dye, pigment, or substance that imparts color when it is added to food or beverages. Colorants can be supplied as liquids, powders, gels, or pastes. Food coloring is commonly used in commercial products and in domestic cooking.

<span class="mw-page-title-main">Quinoline Yellow WS</span> "Mixture of water-soluble organic compounds from Quinoline Yellow dye"

Quinoline Yellow WS is a mixture of organic compounds derived from the dye Quinoline Yellow SS. Owing to the presence of sulfonate groups, the WS dyes are water-soluble (WS). It is a mixture of disulfonates (principally), monosulfonates and trisulfonates of 2-(2-quinolyl)indan-1,3-dione with a maximum absorption wavelength of 416 nm.p. 119

<span class="mw-page-title-main">Reye syndrome</span> Syndrome characterized by acute brain damage and liver function problems

Reye syndrome is a rapidly worsening brain disease. Symptoms of Reye syndrome may include vomiting, personality changes, confusion, seizures, and loss of consciousness. While liver toxicity typically occurs in the syndrome, jaundice usually does not. Death occurs in 20–40% of those affected with Reye syndrome, and about a third of those who survive are left with a significant degree of brain damage.

<span class="mw-page-title-main">Tartrazine</span> Chemical compound

Tartrazine is a synthetic lemon yellow azo dye primarily used as a food coloring. It is also known as E number E102, C.I. 19140, FD&C Yellow 5, Yellow 5 Lake, Acid Yellow 23, Food Yellow 4, and trisodium 1-(4-sulfonatophenyl)-4-(4-sulfonatophenylazo)-5-pyrazolone-3-carboxylate.

<span class="mw-page-title-main">Sunset yellow FCF</span> Chemical compound used as colorant

Sunset yellow FCF is a petroleum-derived orange azo dye with a pH-dependent maximum absorption at about 480 nm at pH 1 and 443 nm at pH 13, with a shoulder at 500 nm. When added to foods sold in the United States, it is known as FD&C Yellow 6; when sold in Europe, it is denoted by E Number E110.

Food intolerance is a detrimental reaction, often delayed, to a food, beverage, food additive, or compound found in foods that produces symptoms in one or more body organs and systems, but generally refers to reactions other than food allergy. Food hypersensitivity is used to refer broadly to both food intolerances and food allergies.

Adult Attention Deficit Hyperactivity Disorder is the persistence of attention deficit hyperactivity disorder (ADHD) into adulthood. It is a neurodevelopmental disorder, meaning impairing symptoms must have been present in childhood, except for when ADHD occurs after traumatic brain injury. Specifically, multiple symptoms must be present before the age of 12, according to DSM-5 diagnostic criteria. The cutoff age of 12 is a change from the previous requirement of symptom onset, which was before the age of 7 in the DSM-IV. This was done to add flexibility in the diagnosis of adults. ADHD was previously thought to be a childhood disorder that improved with age, but recent research has disproved this. Approximately two-thirds of childhood cases of ADHD continue into adulthood, with varying degrees of symptom severity that change over time and continue to affect individuals with symptoms ranging from minor inconveniences to impairments in daily functioning.

<span class="mw-page-title-main">Erythrosine</span> Iodo-derivative of fluorone used as a pink dye

Erythrosine, also known as Red No. 3, is an organoiodine compound, specifically a derivative of fluorone. It is a pink dye which is primarily used for food coloring. It is the disodium salt of 2,4,5,7-tetraiodofluorescein. Its maximum absorbance is at 530 nm in an aqueous solution, and it is subject to photodegradation.

Cognitive disengagement syndrome (CDS) is a syndrome characterized by developmentally inappropriate, impairing, and persistent levels of decoupled attentional processing from the ongoing external context and resultant hypoactivity. Symptoms often manifest in difficulties with staring, mind blanking, absent-mindedness, mental confusion and maladaptive mind-wandering alongside delayed, sedentary or slow motor movements. To scientists in the field, it has reached the threshold of evidence and recognition as a distinct syndrome.

<span class="mw-page-title-main">Ponceau 4R</span> Chemical compound

Ponceau 4R is a synthetic colourant that may be used as a food colouring. It is denoted by E Number E124. Its chemical name is 1-(4-sulfo-1-napthylazo)-2-napthol-6,8-disulfonic acid, trisodium salt. Ponceau is the generic name for a family of azo dyes.

Benjamin F. Feingold was a pediatric allergist from California who proposed in 1973 that salicylates, artificial colors, and artificial flavors cause hyperactivity in children. Hyperactivity is now classified as Attention deficit hyperactivity disorder (ADHD).

<span class="mw-page-title-main">Allura Red AC</span> Chemical compound

Allura Red AC, also known as FD&C Red 40 or E129, is a red azo dye commonly used in food. It was developed in 1971 by the Allied Chemical Corporation, who gave the substance its name.

<span class="mw-page-title-main">Azorubine</span> Chemical compound

Azorubine is an azo dye consisting of two naphthalene subunits. It is a red solid. It is mainly used in foods that are heat-treated after fermentation. It has E number E122.

<span class="mw-page-title-main">Betanin</span> Chemical compound

Betanin, or beetroot red, is a red glycosidic food dye obtained from beets; its aglycone, obtained by hydrolyzing the glucose molecule, is betanidin. As a food additive, its E number is E162. As a food additive, betanin has no safety concerns.

<span class="mw-page-title-main">Salicylate sensitivity</span> Medical condition

Salicylate sensitivity is any adverse effect that occurs when a usual amount of salicylate is ingested. People with salicylate intolerance are unable to consume a normal amount of salicylate without adverse effects.

Attention deficit hyperactivity disorder management options are evidence-based practices with established treatment efficacy for ADHD. Approaches that have been evaluated in the management of ADHD symptoms include FDA-approved pharmacologic treatment and other pharmaceutical agents, psychological or behavioral approaches, combined pharmacological and behavioral approaches, cognitive training, neurofeedback, neurostimulation, physical exercise, nutrition and supplements, integrative medicine, parent support, and school interventions. Based on two 2024 systematic reviews of the literature, FDA-approved medications and to a lesser extent psychosocial interventions have been shown to improve core ADHD symptoms compared to control groups.

Alternative therapies for developmental and learning disabilities include a range of practices used in the treatment of dyslexia, ADHD, autism spectrum disorders, Down syndrome and other developmental and learning disabilities. Treatments include changes in diet, dietary supplements, biofeedback, chelation therapy, homeopathy, massage and yoga. These therapies generally rely on theories that have little scientific basis, lacking well-controlled, large, randomized trials to demonstrate safety and efficacy; small trials that have reported beneficial effects can be generally explained by the ordinary waxing and waning of the underlying conditions.

An elimination diet, also known as exclusion diet, is a diagnostic procedure used to identify foods that an individual cannot consume without adverse effects. Adverse effects may be due to food allergy, food intolerance, other physiological mechanisms, or a combination of these. Elimination diets typically involve entirely removing a suspected food from the diet for a period of time from two weeks to two months, and waiting to determine whether symptoms resolve during that time period. In rare cases, a health professional may wish to use an elimination diet, also referred to as an oligoantigenic diet, to relieve a patient of symptoms they are experiencing.

The ADHD Rating Scale (ADHD-RS) is a parent-report or teacher-report inventory created by George J. DuPaul, Thomas J. Power, Arthur D. Anastopoulos, and Robert Reid consisting of 18–90 questions regarding a child's behavior over the past 6 months. The ADHD Rating Scale is used to aid in the diagnosis of attention deficit hyperactivity disorder (ADHD) in children ranging from ages 5–17.

References

  1. ↑ Turka LA, Caplan A (July 2011). "What is the evidence for our standards of care?". J. Clin. Invest. 121 (7): 2530. doi:10.1172/JCI59185. PMC   3127439 . PMID   21737884.
  2. 1 2 Kavale KA, Forness SR (1983). "Hyperactivity and Diet Treatment: A Meta-Analysis of the Feingold Hypothesis". Journal of Learning Disabilities. 16 (6): 324–30. doi:10.1177/002221948301600604. ISSN   0022-2194. PMID   6886553. S2CID   41744679.
  3. 1 2 3 "Eating well and mental health". Royal College of Psychiatrists. January 2014.
  4. 1 2 3 Barrett S (March 11, 2002). "The Feingold Diet". Quackwatch. Retrieved 15 April 2021.
  5. 1 2 3 4 5 6 Smith, Matthew (2011). An alternative history of hyperactivity: Food additives and the' Feingold Diet. Rutgers University Press. ISBN   978-0813550169.
  6. ↑ Stevens LJ, Kuczek T, Burgess JR, Hurt E, Arnold LE (April 2011). "Dietary Sensitivities and ADHD Symptoms: Thirty-five Years of Research". Clinical Pediatrics. 50 (4): 279–93. doi:10.1177/0009922810384728. PMID   21127082. S2CID   17503227.
  7. 1 2 Kanarek RB (July 2011). "Artificial food dyes and attention deficit hyperactivity disorder". Nutr. Rev. 69 (7): 385–91. doi: 10.1111/j.1753-4887.2011.00385.x . PMID   21729092.
  8. ↑ Tomaska LD and Brooke-Taylor, S. Food Additives – General pp. 449–54 in Encyclopedia of Food Safety, Vol 2: Hazards and Diseases. Eds, Motarjemi Y et al. Academic Press, 2013. p. 452. ISBN   978-0123786135
  9. ↑ Millichap JG, Yee MM (February 2012). "The diet factor in attention-deficit/hyperactivity disorder". Pediatrics. 129 (2): 330–37. doi:10.1542/peds.2011-2199. PMID   22232312. S2CID   14925322.
  10. ↑ FDA. Background Document for the Food Advisory Committee: Certified Color Additives in Food and Possible Association with Attention Deficit Hyperactivity Disorder in Children: March 30–31, 2011
  11. ↑ "Scientific Opinion on the re-evaluation of Sunset Yellow FCF (E 110) as a food additive". EFSA Journal. 7 (11): 1330. 2009. doi: 10.2903/j.efsa.2009.1330 .
  12. ↑ Dumbrell, S.; Woodhill, J.M.; Mackie, L. & Leelarthaepin, B. (December 1978). "Is the Australian version of the Feingold diet safe?". The Medical Journal of Australia. 2 (12): 569–70. doi:10.5694/j.1326-5377.1978.tb131717.x. PMID   364258. S2CID   34426994.
  13. ↑ Feingold, B.F. (1975). Why Your Child is Hyperactive . Random House. ISBN   0-394-73426-2.
  14. ↑ Bourne, A (1982). "Obituary: Ben F. Feingold, MD" (PDF). Ecology of Disease. 1 (2/3): 199.
  15. ↑ Feingold, B.F. (1973). Introduction to clinical allergy. Charles C. Thomas. p. 157. ISBN   0-398-02797-8.
  16. ↑ Settipane GA, Pudupakkam RK. (1975). "Aspirin intolerance. III. Subtypes, familial occurrence, and cross-reactivity with tartarazine". Journal of Allergy and Clinical Immunology. 56 (3): 215–21. doi:10.1016/0091-6749(75)90092-5. PMID   1151014.
  17. ↑ Lockey, SD (September–October 1959). "Allergic reactions due to F D and C Yellow No. 5, tartrazine, an aniline dye used as a coloring and identifying agent in various steroids". Annals of Allergy. 17: 719–21. PMID   14417794.
  18. ↑ Lockey, SD Sr. (1977). "Hypersensitivity to tartrazine (FD&C Yellow No. 5) and other dyes and additives present in foods and pharmaceutical products". Annals of Allergy. 38 (3): 206–10. PMID   842907.
  19. ↑ J.G. Beall, Jr. (October 30, 1973). "Food Additives and Hyperactivity in Children" (PDF). Congressional Record - Senate: 35401–07.
  20. ↑ Feingold, Ben F. (1982). "The Role of Diet in Behaviour" (PDF). Ecology of Disease. 2 (2/3): 153–65. PMID   6090095.
  21. ↑ [ non-primary source needed ]Conners CK, Goyette CH, Southwick DA, Lees JM, Andrulonis PA (August 1976). "Food additives and hyperkinesis: a controlled double-blind experiment". Pediatrics. 58 (2): 154–66. PMID   781610.

Further reading

This page is based on this Wikipedia article
Text is available under the CC BY-SA 4.0 license; additional terms may apply.
Images, videos and audio are available under their respective licenses.