Florida House Bill H-837

Last updated

Florida House Bill H-837, also known as HB-837 or The Academic Freedom Bill of Rights, was a proposed bill in 2005 that would have allowed students to establish lawsuits against their professors and university for perceived intolerance of the student's beliefs. The bill could have also required professors to teach concepts that may have contradicted established facts, if the concept was considered a "serious scholarly" theory (such as Holocaust denial). [1] [2]

Contents

The bill was heavily criticized as an attack on free speech in academia, and raised concerns about potential abuse by those with fringe beliefs. [1] [3] It died on calendar in May 2005. [4]

History

H-837 was proposed by Republican Dennis Baxley (pictured in 2007). Dennis Baxley promotes a measure considered on the House.png
H-837 was proposed by Republican Dennis Baxley (pictured in 2007).

H-837 was one of many "academic freedom" bills proposed throughout the United States in the early 2000s. At the time, the ideological divide between Democrats and Republicans was widening, and many Democrats were highly critical of President George W. Bush and the wars in Afghanistan and Iraq. Neoconservative activist David Horowitz, believing that the amount of liberal college professors was stifling discussion of conservative beliefs, decided to found Students for Academic Freedom (a subgroup of his Center for the Study of Popular Culture). [5] Referencing a 1940 "academic freedom" document published by the American Association of University Professors, he drafted a "Student Bill of Rights" intending to protect students and faculty from discrimination or retaliation based on their political beliefs. [5] [6] Though the Academic Bill of Rights drew immediate backlash in academia, it spurred nationwide efforts to legislate "academic freedom" laws. [7] [6]

In 2004, Florida Representative Dennis Baxley (R-Ocala) began considering an Academic Bill of Rights after listening to Horowitz's speech at a conference. [6] Baxley had attended college in the 1970s, where he felt a professor criticized him for his creationist beliefs. [3] In February 2005, [2] with the support of Horowitz, Baxley proposed H-837, which was closely modeled after Horowitz's Academic Bill of Rights. [6] [1]

Proposed legislation

H-837 would have amended Florida Statute 1002.21 to guarantee "academic freedom" for students, and add Statute 1004.09, which would have laid out what rights students were granted. [2]

Statute 1004.09 would have legally mandated: [2]

  1. The right for students to expect "a broad range of scholarly opinion" at their academic institution; institutions should prioritize "the fostering of a plurality of serious scholarly methodologies and perspectives";
  2. Prohibition of retaliation by professors against students with different political beliefs via grading, recommendations, or other measures with academic or professional consequences;
  3. Prohibition of professors bringing up controversial subjects with "no relation to the subject of study" or "no legitimate pedagogical purpose";
  4. Prohibition of "infringement upon" a student's First Amendment rights and "freedom of conscience" by university administrators, student groups, or the academic institute's rules;
  5. Use of student fees by academic institutions on a "viewpoint-neutral basis", without lending credence to certain viewpoints;
  6. Professors "making [their] students aware of serious scholarly viewpoints other than their own";
  7. The right for academic faculty to receive or lose employment or tenure based on their abilities, not their personal beliefs, and;
  8. The right for students and all academic faculty to be informed of their academic rights.

If a student felt that their professor had targeted them or behaved in a way that was intolerant of the student's beliefs, H-837 would have given them grounds to file a lawsuit. [8] Some interpreted the bill as mandating professors to teach both sides of a subject without any complaints from students, but Baxley maintained in interviews that this was not part of the bill. [8] [9]

Horowitz's Academic Bill of Rights (and by extension, H-837) did not contain overtly politicized language. However, Democrats raised concerns about the partisan financial support, as well as the conservatism of the board of Students for Academic Freedom. [5]

Reaction

H-837 received national attention; though multiple states proposed similar bills, Florida was the sole state that seemed likely to pass it. [10] The bill primarily gathered support from Republicans and conservative student groups, including Students for Academic Freedom, who denied a political motivation. [1] Proponents asserted that H-837 would give students a more balanced education; conservative students and activists argued that only liberal viewpoints were being taught. [6] Supporters also rallied behind claims that conservative students were being targeted by liberal professors for "humiliation" and retaliation as a result of their beliefs, arguing that the Academic Freedom Bill of Rights would protect students from ideological discrimination. [7] (While both Baxley and Horowitz circulated claims of alleged retaliations, they declined to name students or professors involved.) [8] [6]

H-837 was discussed by many prominent politicians and academics, including Columbia University president Lee Bollinger (pictured in 2008). Lee Bollinger2.jpg
H-837 was discussed by many prominent politicians and academics, including Columbia University president Lee Bollinger (pictured in 2008).

Democrats and academics largely opposed the bill, citing the unclear language and government interference in situations handled by educational boards. [6] [1] [8] Many criticized it as an effort to frighten professors away from controversial topics or discussions, pointing out an overhanging threat of lawsuits would stifle discussions. [3] [6] Eleanor Sobel (D-Hollywood), who voted against the bill in the Choice & Innovation Committee, called it "the antithesis of academic freedom". [8] Dan Gelber (D-Miami Beach) pointed out the potential for abuse by students who believed in conspiracy theories or whose religious beliefs contradicted modern history or science; for instance, medical students whose beliefs did not allow contraception or blood transfusions. [8] Many Florida professors and university administrators spoke out in protest, including Thomas Auxter (the President of the United Faculty in Florida) [1] and Roy Weatherfield (the Florida Education Association's higher education director). [9] Auxter characterized H-837 as "a right-wing political takeover" of higher education, [1] and later testified about the unclear guidelines the bill would set, saying, "The standard will be the most easily offended student and whether or not that person will react against what you are saying". [10] While there was a general consensus that it was inappropriate for professors to push their own views on students or punish them for ideological disagreements, many academic faculty (including Columbia University president Lee Bollinger, in a speech making mention of the bill) stated that discipline for those offenses should be the burden of schools, not courts or legislators. [3] [9]

There was bipartisan uncertainty of the bill's necessity; Florida already has an academic Bill of Rights, and most universities have procedures to file grievances against professors who behaved in an intolerant or vengeful manner. Sobel referenced existing student protections in the form of laws and university policies, [8] and prominent Florida Republicans like Jeb Bush (who typically supported Baxley) and Tom Lee expressed doubt about the use of such a law. [11] In an interview with Democracy Now! , Weatherfield described H-837 as "a solution in search of a problem". [9] In addition, claims of anti-conservative discrimination on campus were often viewed with skepticism; many anecdotes lacked proof, and typically did not name students or professors involved. [12] [13] Nationally, professors who were accused of anti-conservative bias denied the allegations, asserting that details were left out or falsified; faculty members and student witnesses affirmed their statements. [14] [15] [16] Weatherfield shared with Democracy Now! that students infrequently filed grievance reports, [9] a statement corroborated by university presidents Bernie Machen (from University of Florida), T.K. Weatherall (from Florida State University), and Judy Genshaft (from University of South Florida). [13] Auxter, testifying against the bill on April 19, also noted the lack of basis for the bill: "What we've heard [from Horowitz] is anecdotes from other states. We have not heard examples in Florida. [...] [W]e have not heard of any investigations of the contentions he has made about people in other states." [10]

Both Baxley and Horowitz portrayed opposition to the bill as the work of a controlling liberal agenda. Baxley described liberal professors as "leftist totalitarians," "dictators," and "arrogant elitists", [8] and dubbed critics of the bill "inflexible". [1] Horowitz attributed disagreement to "lies" and a "malicious campaign" opposing him, describing it as "vitriolic and dishonest". [6]

Death of bill and subsequent legacy

H-837 received enough votes to progress to the Florida House of Representatives, but died on calendar in May 2005. [4] The St. Petersburg Times reported that Baxley intended to continue pursuing passage of the bill, and wanted to propose the bill again in 2006. Horowitz, however, claimed that H-837 was "still being considered" despite the ending of the legislative session. [6] Baxley did not re-propose an Academic Bill of Rights in the 2006 legislative session.

Nationally, Horowitz's proposed Academic Bill of Rights became increasingly unpopular. It was criticized by major academic and anti-censorship groups, including the American Association of University Professors, [17] American Historical Association, [18] and the National Coalition Against Censorship. [19] Horowitz himself also received criticism for sharing unverified stories of ideological discrimination from professors; at least one claim was heavily fabricated, and he later admitted to lacking evidence of two others. [6] [12] [16] No states had ratified his Academic Bill of Rights by 2005, [6] and Horowitz chose to pursue other forms of campus activism by 2006. [20]

Despite the failure of H-837, Florida continued pursuing academic freedom legislation. In April 2021, Baxley, now a member of the Florida Senate, voted in favor of HB-233, [21] an "intellectual freedom" law that allowed students to film perceived bias from their professors, and barred university faculty from censoring "uncomfortable" or "offensive" speech on campus. [22] The bill passed in the Florida Legislature. [23]

Related Research Articles

Stanley Eugene Fish is an American literary theorist, legal scholar, author and public intellectual. He is currently the Floersheimer Distinguished Visiting Professor of Law at Yeshiva University's Benjamin N. Cardozo School of Law in New York City. Fish has previously served as the Davidson-Kahn Distinguished University Professor of Humanities and a professor of law at Florida International University and is dean emeritus of the College of Liberal Arts and Sciences at the University of Illinois at Chicago.

<span class="mw-page-title-main">University of Florida</span> Public university in Gainesville, Florida

The University of Florida is a public land-grant research university in Gainesville, Florida. It is a senior member of the State University System of Florida. The university traces its origins to 1853 and has operated continuously on its Gainesville campus since September 1906.

<span class="mw-page-title-main">David Horowitz</span> American conservative activist and writer

David Joel Horowitz is an American conservative writer and activist. He is a founder and president of the right-wing David Horowitz Freedom Center (DHFC); editor of the Center's website FrontPage Magazine; and director of Discover the Networks, a website that tracks individuals and groups on the political left. Horowitz also founded the organization Students for Academic Freedom.

<span class="mw-page-title-main">Foundation for Individual Rights and Expression</span> American free speech organization

The Foundation for Individual Rights and Expression (FIRE), formerly known as the Foundation for Individual Rights in Education, is a non-profit civil liberties group founded in 1999 with the stated mission of protecting free speech rights on college campuses in the United States. FIRE was renamed in June 2022, with its focus broadened to speech rights in American society in general.

<span class="mw-page-title-main">New College of Florida</span> Public liberal arts college in Sarasota, Florida

New College of Florida is a public liberal arts college in Sarasota, Florida. It was founded in 1960 as a private institution known simply as New College, spent several years merged into the University of South Florida, and in 2001 became an autonomous college, the eleventh independent school of the State University System of Florida as the honors college for the state system. Upon achieving independence, the school adopted its current name: New College of Florida.

<span class="mw-page-title-main">Bill Morrow (California politician)</span> American politician

William Phillip "Bill" Morrow is a U.S. Republican politician from the state of California, who used to be in the California State Senate representing the 38th district which includes northern San Diego County and the cities of San Clemente and San Juan Capistrano in southern Orange County.

<i>The Professors</i> 2006 book by David Horowitz

The Professors: The 101 Most Dangerous Academics in America is a 2006 book by conservative American author and policy advocate David Horowitz. Contending that many academics in American colleges hold anti-American perspectives, Horowitz lists one hundred examples who he believes are sympathetic to terrorists and non-democratic governments.

Michael Bérubé is Edwin Erle Sparks Professor of Literature at Pennsylvania State University, where he teaches American literature, disability studies, and cultural studies. He is the author of several books on cultural studies, disability rights, liberal and conservative politics, and debates in higher education. From 2010 to 2017, he was the Director of the Institute for the Arts and Humanities at Penn State; from 1997 to 2001 he was the founding director of the Illinois Program for Research in the Humanities. He was the 2012 president of the Modern Language Association, and served as vice president from 2010–2011. He served two terms on the National Council of the American Association of University Professors from 2005 to 2011, and three terms on the AAUP's Committee A on Academic Freedom and Tenure from 2009 to 2018. He was a member of the International Advisory Board of the Consortium of Humanities Centers and Institutes for two terms, 2011-2017. Bérubé was named a University Scholar for research at the University of Illinois in 1995 and was awarded the Faculty Scholar medal for research from Penn State in 2012.

The Academic Bill of Rights (ABOR) is a document created and distributed by a branch of the David Horowitz Freedom Center, a think tank founded by the conservative writer David Horowitz. It has been criticized for using broad-based egalitarian principles and a self-identified "bipartisan" framework to promote what critics describe as an ideological agenda.

<span class="mw-page-title-main">David Horowitz Freedom Center</span> Non-profit organisation in the USA

The David Horowitz Freedom Center, formerly the Center for the Study of Popular Culture (CSPC), is a conservative anti-Islam foundation founded in 1988 by political activist David Horowitz and his long-time collaborator Peter Collier. It was established with funding from groups including the John M. Olin Foundation, the Bradley Foundation and the Scaife Foundation.

<span class="mw-page-title-main">Florida Legislative Investigation Committee</span> Anti-Communist committee that focused on homosexuals

The Florida Legislative Investigation Committee was established by the Florida Legislature in 1956, during the era of the Second Red Scare and the Lavender Scare. Like the more famous anti-Communist investigative committees of the McCarthy period in the United States Congress, the Florida committee undertook a wide-ranging investigation of allegedly subversive activities by academics, Civil Rights Movement groups, especially the NAACP, and suspected communist organizations.

<span class="mw-page-title-main">History of Florida State University</span>

The history of Florida State University dates to the 19th century and is deeply intertwined with the history of education in the state of Florida and in the city of Tallahassee. Florida State University, known colloquially as Florida State and FSU, is one of the oldest and largest of the institutions in the State University System of Florida. It traces its origins to the West Florida Seminary, one of two state-funded seminaries the Florida Legislature voted to establish in 1851.

<span class="mw-page-title-main">Dennis Baxley</span> American politician

Dennis K. Baxley is a state legislator in Florida who has served in the Florida Senate since 2016. A Republican, he represents the 12th district including Sumter County and parts of Lake County and Marion County in Central Florida. He previously served in the Florida House of Representatives, representing parts of Marion County from 2000 to 2007 and again from 2010 until his election to the Senate. He served on the Belleview City Commission and as its mayor.

A number of anti-evolution bills have been introduced in the United States Congress and State legislatures since 2001. Purporting to support academic freedom, supporters have contended that teachers, students, and college professors face intimidation and retaliation when discussing scientific criticisms of evolution, and therefore require protection. Critics of the legislation have pointed out that there are no credible scientific critiques of evolution. An investigation in Florida of the allegations of intimidation and retaliation found no evidence that it had occurred. The vast majority of the bills have been unsuccessful, with the one exception being Louisiana's Louisiana Science Education Act, which was enacted in 2008.

<span class="mw-page-title-main">History of the University of Florida</span>

The history of the University of Florida is firmly tied to the history of public education in the state of Florida. The University of Florida originated as several distinct institutions that were consolidated to create a single state-supported university by the Buckman Act of 1905. The oldest of these was the East Florida Seminary, one of two seminaries of higher learning established by the Florida Legislature. The East Florida Seminary opened in Ocala 1853, becoming the first state-supported institution of higher learning in the state of Florida. As it is the oldest of the modern University of Florida's predecessor institutions, the school traces its founding date to that year. The East Florida Seminary closed its Ocala campus at the outbreak of the American Civil War and reopened in Gainesville in 1866

A student bill of rights is a document that outlines beliefs or regulations regarding student rights, typically adopted by a student group, school, or government. These documents can be policies, laws, or statements of belief.

Academic bias is the bias or perceived bias of scholars allowing their beliefs to shape their research and the scientific community. It can refer to several types of scholastic prejudice, e.g., logocentrism, phonocentrism, ethnocentrism or the belief that some sciences and disciplines rank higher than others.

Michael Scott Adams was an American conservative political columnist, writer and professor of criminology at the University of North Carolina Wilmington. He became known for his outspoken opinions, frequently attracting controversy. When he did not receive a promotion to full professor, he filed a lawsuit against the university and eventually won. After many conflicts with students and national coverage of his controversial social media and blog posts, public pressure to have him removed grew and he was eventually asked to retire. Twenty-one days after reaching a retirement settlement with the university, he was found dead in his home with a self-inflicted gunshot wound to the head.

The political views of American academics began to receive attention in the 1930s, and investigation into faculty political views expanded rapidly after the rise of McCarthyism. Demographic surveys of faculty that began in the 1950s and continue to the present have found higher percentages of liberals than of conservatives, particularly among those who work in the humanities and social sciences. Researchers and pundits disagree about survey methodology and about the interpretations of the findings.

Higher education in the United States is an optional stage of formal learning following secondary education. Higher education, also referred to as post-secondary education, third-stage, third-level, or tertiary education occurs most commonly at one of the 4,360 Title IV degree-granting institutions, either colleges or universities in the country. These may be public universities, private universities, liberal arts colleges, community colleges, or for-profit colleges. US higher education is loosely regulated by several third-party organizations.

References

  1. 1 2 3 4 5 6 7 8 Marris, Emma (6 April 2005). "Professors bristle as states act to mould lecture content". Nature . Vol. 434, no. 7034. Archived from the original on 5 May 2021. Retrieved 5 May 2021.
  2. 1 2 3 4 "Florida House Bill 0837 (2005)". The Florida Senate. 2005. Retrieved 4 May 2021.
  3. 1 2 3 4 Jaschik, Scott (25 March 2005). "Academic Freedom Wars". Inside Higher Ed . Archived from the original on 30 October 2020. Retrieved 4 May 2021.
  4. 1 2 "The Florida Senate" . Retrieved 4 May 2021.
  5. 1 2 3 Jacobson, Jennifer (6 May 2005). "What Makes David Run" . The Chronicles of Higher Education. Archived from the original on 22 March 2021. Retrieved 6 May 2021.
  6. 1 2 3 4 5 6 7 8 9 10 11 12 Kumar, Anita (29 May 2005). "Taking the cause of the academic rights of the right". The St. Petersburg Times. Tallahassee. Archived from the original on 5 May 2021. Retrieved 4 May 2021.
  7. 1 2 Raffaele, Martha (22 January 2006). "Legislatures fight colleges' left-leaning political views". The Gainesville Sun. Archived from the original on 8 May 2021. Retrieved 8 May 2021.
  8. 1 2 3 4 5 6 7 8 Vanlandingham, James (23 March 2005). "Capitol bill aims to control "leftist" profs". The Independent Florida Alligator. Tallahassee. Archived from the original on 8 July 2007. Retrieved 4 May 2021.
  9. 1 2 3 4 5 Goodman, Amy (6 April 2005). "Conservative 'Academic Bill of Rights' Limits "Controversial Matter" in Classroom". Democracy Now! . Archived from the original on 12 December 2007. Retrieved 4 May 2021.
  10. 1 2 3 Auxter, Thomas (2016). "Organizing Faculty Unions in a Right-to-Work Environment". Journal of Collective Bargaining in the Academy. 8 (1): 8–12. Archived from the original on 14 July 2020. Retrieved 5 May 2021.
  11. ↑ Karp, David (6 April 2005). "Lawmaker aims to squelch political bias in college classes". The St. Petersburg Times. Tallahassee. Archived from the original on 2 December 2005. Retrieved 6 May 2021.
  12. 1 2 Jaschik, Scott (11 January 2006). "Retractions From David Horowitz". Inside Higher Ed . Philadelphia. Archived from the original on 13 January 2006. Retrieved 5 May 2021.
  13. 1 2 Karp, David (22 April 2005). "Lawmaker takes complaints about liberal bias to the top". The St. Petersburg Times. Tallahassee. Archived from the original on 29 March 2006. Retrieved 5 May 2021.
  14. ↑ Karp, David (7 April 2005). "Campus bias tale is called a lie". The St. Petersburg Times. Tallahassee. Archived from the original on 3 May 2005. Retrieved 5 May 2021.
  15. ↑ Jacobson, Jennifer (26 November 2004). "A Liberal Professor Fights a Label" . The Chronicles of Higher Education. Archived from the original on 7 May 2021. Retrieved 6 May 2021.
  16. 1 2 Jaschik, Scott (15 March 2005). "Tattered Poster Child". Inside Higher Ed . Archived from the original on 13 January 2006. Retrieved 4 May 2021.
  17. ↑ "Academic Bill of Rights". American Association of University Professors. 2003. Archived from the original on 26 January 2021. Retrieved 5 May 2021.
  18. ↑ Beito, David; Luker, Ralph; Johnson, Robert (1 March 2006). "The AHA's Double Standard on Academic Freedom". Perspectives on History. Archived from the original on 16 January 2021. Retrieved 4 May 2021.
  19. ↑ ""Academic Bill Of Rights" - A Wolf in Sheep's Clothing". Archived from the original on 23 January 2021. Retrieved 5 May 2021.
  20. ↑ Jaschik, Scott (16 November 2006). "Who Won the Battle of Pennsylvania?". Inside Higher Ed . Archived from the original on 1 October 2008. Retrieved 8 May 2021.
  21. ↑ "HB 233 Third Reading" (PDF). The Florida Senate. 7 April 2021. Retrieved 5 May 2021.
  22. ↑ Dailey, Ryan (19 March 2021). "Campus 'intellectual freedom' gains traction in Florida Legislature". The Miami Herald. Tallahassee. Archived from the original on 9 April 2021. Retrieved 5 May 2021.
  23. ↑ "Florida House Bill 233 (2021)". The Florida Senate. 2021. Retrieved 5 May 2021.
This page is based on this Wikipedia article
Text is available under the CC BY-SA 4.0 license; additional terms may apply.
Images, videos and audio are available under their respective licenses.