Forensic glass analysis

Last updated

Forensic glass analysis is the application and analysis of glass to determine details about a crime. Glass evidence comes in many forms in various types of criminal cases. Glass can be analyzed to understand its origin using comparative analysis which may include measurements relating to physical match, refractive index, density and elemental analysis. It is also possible to analyze glass fractures to better understand the angle, direction and sequence of force as well as the projectile used.

Contents

In case work

Glass analysis is applicable to a wide range of forensic cases. In burglary or rape cases, window pane may be broken and analyzed. [1] In assaults, broken glass bottles may be found and analyzed in addition to glass fragments that may remain on clothing. [1] Glass analysis is also applicable to motor vehicle crashes, particularly hit and run cases, as glass from headlights can be analyzed. [1]

Collection from crime scenes

Depending on the form of the evidence, glass analysis can be collected in several ways. When possible, it is preferred that the entire item of evidence, such as a glass fragment or sweater with glass shards, is collected. [2] Glass evidence can also take on the form of trace evidence. In these cases, trace evidence lifters, forensic vacuums or tweezers can aid in the collection of the glass evidence. [2] Small glass fragments or shards can be secured in a pharmacist's fold and in an envelope. [2] It is also important that the location from where the glass was recovered is noted. [1] When it is suspected that an individual has small glass fragments on their person, their hair can be combed and caught on examination paper in an attempt to recover potential glass fragments. [1] In addition to combing the hair, the individual can remove their clothes on examination paper which can then be sealed and saved for examination at a later time. [1]

Methods of analysis

Comparative analysis

It is possible to compare multiple glass fragments using the techniques described below in order to understand if the glass fragments can be excluded as originating from the same source.

Physical match

Two glass fragments may be physically matched with one another. This may exclude the glass fragments from having originated from a different source. [3]

Refractive index

The refractive index of a glass fragment may be determined and compared with that of another glass fragment in order to understand if they can be excluded from having originated from the same source. [3] The refractive index can be determined using immersion methods as well as automated methods. [3] Immersion methods entail the use of liquids with known refractive indices. The glass fragments are immersed in the liquids, often oils, and Becke lines are examined according to the Becke line test. [3] Automated methods entail a camera and computer which make measurements of glass fragments in varying temperatures. [3]

Density

The density of a glass fragment can be determined using a density meter. [3] The density of a glass fragment will depend on the batch characteristics and composition. Although, density is tested less frequently than refractive indices, it can be used to determine if two glass fragments more likely originated from a different source. [3]

Elemental analysis

Many techniques can be used to understand the elemental composition of a glass fragment. Glass fragments from the same source have the same elemental composition and thus, elemental analysis enables an analyst to understand if multiple glass fragments likely do or do not originate from the same source.

There are many techniques that can be used for elemental analysis of glass. These include scanning electron microscopy-x-ray spectroscopy, x-ray fluorescence spectroscopy, mass spectrometry, optical emission spectroscopy and inductively coupled plasma methods. [4]

Glass fractures

Radial and concentric fractures in glass fractures Glass fracture radial concentric.jpg
Radial and concentric fractures in glass fractures

Glass fractures can be analyzed in order to determine which side of the glass was force applied that ultimately resulted in its fracture. For example, determining which side of a window was smashed in order to cause it to break may help crime scene investigators understand if someone broke in through the window or broke out through it. On the other hand, if there are multiple fractures on a pane of glass, they can be analyzed to determine what was the order in which the fractures were made. Analysis of glass fractures may also provide insight about the direction through which the projectile came from and may provide hints about what the projectile was that cause the fracture.

When a projectile, such as a rock or bullet, hits a pane of glass, radial and concentric fractures form. These are often the key components of glass fracture analysis.

Projectile

When a high velocity projectile, such as a bullet, fractures a pane of glass, it can leave what is known as a cone fracture. [5] A cone fracture is a hole in a glass pane surrounded by radial and concentric fractures. The hole is narrower at the point of entry and widens towards the exit point, giving the appearance of a cone. [5]

Angle of force

The shape of the hole formed by a projectile may also give information about the angle through which the force was delivered. A symmetrical hole could be formed by a projectile hitting the glass at a 90 degree angle while elliptical holes can be formed by projectiles hitting a pane of glass from the left or right side. [5]

Direction of force

The side from which a glass fracture was made can be determined by examining the radial fractures of a glass fracture. The 3R rule is used to make a determination about which direction a fracture was formed from. The 3R rule states "radial fractures make right angles to the rear." By examining the radial fractures and the direction in which they form a right angle, the rear side of the pane of glass (opposite the side the force was applied) can be determined.

Glass fracture A was formed before B. This can be determined by examining the area outlined by the red arrow in which the radial fracture of B is interrupted by that of A. Glass fractures sequence of force.jpg
Glass fracture A was formed before B. This can be determined by examining the area outlined by the red arrow in which the radial fracture of B is interrupted by that of A.

Sequence of force

When multiple fractures are made to a pane of glass, it is possible to understand the order in which those fractures were made by examining the radial fractures. Radial fractures end when they cross paths with another existing fracture line, thereby producing a method to understand the order in which multiple fractures were made. [5]

History of Forensic Glass Analysis

Forensic glass analysis research has been conducted for many years. The first forensic book published on analyzing glass was written by Hans Gross [6] . This book focused on exit, entry and the order of multiple bullet holes in glass for reconstruction purposes [6] . Gross' research was confirmed in 1931 by Matwejeff when he also conducted experiments similar to Gross' and his own [6] . From his own research, he was the first to show Wallner lines, also shown as conchoidal or rib lines [6] . The first case in forensic glass fragments analysis was published by Marris when glass fragments found tied a suspect to the crime scene [6] . Based on the work by Marris and Matwejeff, F.G Tryhorn also published writing in this field that explained examinations of glass including chemical composition [6] . Further research in this field was done by Nelson and Revell in 1967, followed by Coleman and Goode who used neutron activity for element analysis [7] .

Many research projects and government groups continue to update and strengthen the field of forensic glass analysis [7] . An example of a group is the Scientific Working Group on Materials (SWGMAT) [7] . This group creates and creates analytical guild lines to improve glass analysis, beginning in the 1990s [7] . From laboratory trials to accepted methods, the field of forensic glass analysis is able to standardize emerging practices [7] .   

Related Research Articles

<span class="mw-page-title-main">Refractive index</span> Ratio of the speed of light in vacuum to that in the medium

In optics, the refractive index of an optical medium is a dimensionless number that gives the indication of the light bending ability of that medium.

<span class="mw-page-title-main">Scanning electron microscope</span> Electron microscope where a small beam is scanned across a sample

A scanning electron microscope (SEM) is a type of electron microscope that produces images of a sample by scanning the surface with a focused beam of electrons. The electrons interact with atoms in the sample, producing various signals that contain information about the surface topography and composition of the sample. The electron beam is scanned in a raster scan pattern, and the position of the beam is combined with the intensity of the detected signal to produce an image. In the most common SEM mode, secondary electrons emitted by atoms excited by the electron beam are detected using a secondary electron detector. The number of secondary electrons that can be detected, and thus the signal intensity, depends, among other things, on specimen topography. Some SEMs can achieve resolutions better than 1 nanometer.

<span class="mw-page-title-main">Inductively coupled plasma mass spectrometry</span> Type of mass spectrometry that uses an inductively coupled plasma to ionize the sample

Inductively coupled plasma mass spectrometry (ICP-MS) is a type of mass spectrometry that uses an inductively coupled plasma to ionize the sample. It atomizes the sample and creates atomic and small polyatomic ions, which are then detected. It is known and used for its ability to detect metals and several non-metals in liquid samples at very low concentrations. It can detect different isotopes of the same element, which makes it a versatile tool in isotopic labeling.

<span class="mw-page-title-main">Gemology</span> Science dealing with natural and artificial gemstone materials

Gemology or gemmology is the science dealing with natural and artificial gemstone materials. It is a geoscience and a branch of mineralogy. Some jewelers are academically trained gemologists and are qualified to identify and evaluate gems.

<span class="mw-page-title-main">Lithic reduction</span> Process of fashioning stones or rocks into tools and weapons

In archaeology, in particular of the Stone Age, lithic reduction is the process of fashioning stones or rocks from their natural state into tools or weapons by removing some parts. It has been intensely studied and many archaeological industries are identified almost entirely by the lithic analysis of the precise style of their tools and the chaîne opératoire of the reduction techniques they used.

<span class="mw-page-title-main">Ricochet</span> Rebound of a projectile off a surface

A ricochet is a rebound, bounce, or skip off a surface, particularly in the case of a projectile. Most ricochets are caused by accident and while the force of the deflection decelerates the projectile, it can still be energetic and almost as dangerous as before the deflection. The possibility of ricochet is one of the reasons for the common firearms safety rule "Never shoot a bullet at a flat, hard surface." Ricochets can occur with any caliber, but short or round ricocheting bullets may not produce the audible whine caused by tumbling irregular shapes. Ricochets are a hazard of shooting because, for as long as they retain sufficient velocity, ricocheting bullets or bullet fragments may cause collateral damage to animals, objects, or even the person who fired the shot.

Petrography is a branch of petrology that focuses on detailed descriptions of rocks. Someone who studies petrography is called a petrographer. The mineral content and the textural relationships within the rock are described in detail. The classification of rocks is based on the information acquired during the petrographic analysis. Petrographic descriptions start with the field notes at the outcrop and include macroscopic description of hand-sized specimens. The most important petrographer's tool is the petrographic microscope. The detailed analysis of minerals by optical mineralogy in thin section and the micro-texture and structure are critical to understanding the origin of the rock.

<span class="mw-page-title-main">Trace evidence</span> Type of evidence of physical contact

Trace evidence occurs when objects make contact, and material is transferred. This type of evidence is usually not visible to the naked eye and requires specific tools and techniques to be located and obtained. Due to this, trace evidence is often overlooked, and investigators must be trained to detect it. When it comes to an investigation trace evidence can come in many different forms and is found in a wide variety of cases. This evidence can link a victim to suspects and a victim or suspect to the crime scene.

<span class="mw-page-title-main">Polarimeter</span> Instrument for measuring optical rotation

A polarimeter is a scientific instrument used to measure optical rotation: the angle of rotation caused by passing linearly polarized light through an optically active substance.

<span class="mw-page-title-main">Refractometer</span> Measurement Tool

A refractometer is a laboratory or field device for the measurement of an index of refraction (refractometry). The index of refraction is calculated from the observed refraction angle using Snell's law. For mixtures, the index of refraction then allows the concentration to be determined using mixing rules such as the Gladstone–Dale relation and Lorentz–Lorenz equation.

<span class="mw-page-title-main">Optical mineralogy</span> Optical properties of rocks and minerals

Optical mineralogy is the study of minerals and rocks by measuring their optical properties. Most commonly, rock and mineral samples are prepared as thin sections or grain mounts for study in the laboratory with a petrographic microscope. Optical mineralogy is used to identify the mineralogical composition of geological materials in order to help reveal their origin and evolution.

Crime reconstruction or crime scene reconstruction is the forensic science discipline in which one gains "explicit knowledge of the series of events that surround the commission of a crime using deductive and inductive reasoning, physical evidence, scientific methods, and their interrelationships". Gardner and Bevel explain that crime scene reconstruction "involves evaluating the context of a scene and the physical evidence found there in an effort to identify what occurred and in what order it occurred." Chisum and Turvey explain that "[h]olistic crime reconstruction is the development of actions and circumstances based on the system of evidence discovered and examined in relation to a particular crime. In this philosophy, all elements of evidence that come to light in a given case are treated as interdependent; the significance of each piece, each action, and each event falls and rises on the backs of the others."

<span class="mw-page-title-main">Fractography</span> Study of the fracture surfaces of materials

Fractography is the study of the fracture surfaces of materials. Fractographic methods are routinely used to determine the cause of failure in engineering structures, especially in product failure and the practice of forensic engineering or failure analysis. In material science research, fractography is used to develop and evaluate theoretical models of crack growth behavior.

<span class="mw-page-title-main">Forensic geology</span>

Forensic geology is the study of evidence relating to materials found in the Earth used to answer questions raised by the legal system.

<span class="mw-page-title-main">Low-energy ion scattering</span>

Low-energy ion scattering spectroscopy (LEIS), sometimes referred to simply as ion scattering spectroscopy (ISS), is a surface-sensitive analytical technique used to characterize the chemical and structural makeup of materials. LEIS involves directing a stream of charged particles known as ions at a surface and making observations of the positions, velocities, and energies of the ions that have interacted with the surface. Data that is thus collected can be used to deduce information about the material such as the relative positions of atoms in a surface lattice and the elemental identity of those atoms. LEIS is closely related to both medium-energy ion scattering (MEIS) and high-energy ion scattering, differing primarily in the energy range of the ion beam used to probe the surface. While much of the information collected using LEIS can be obtained using other surface science techniques, LEIS is unique in its sensitivity to both structure and composition of surfaces. Additionally, LEIS is one of a very few surface-sensitive techniques capable of directly observing hydrogen atoms, an aspect that may make it an increasingly more important technique as the hydrogen economy is being explored.

Rutherford backscattering spectrometry (RBS) is an analytical technique used in materials science. Sometimes referred to as high-energy ion scattering (HEIS) spectrometry, RBS is used to determine the structure and composition of materials by measuring the backscattering of a beam of high energy ions (typically protons or alpha particles) impinging on a sample.

<span class="mw-page-title-main">Forensic materials engineering</span>

Forensic materials engineering, a branch of forensic engineering, focuses on the material evidence from crime or accident scenes, seeking defects in those materials which might explain why an accident occurred, or the source of a specific material to identify a criminal. Many analytical methods used for material identification may be used in investigations, the exact set being determined by the nature of the material in question, be it metal, glass, ceramic, polymer or composite. An important aspect is the analysis of trace evidence such as skid marks on exposed surfaces, where contact between dissimilar materials leaves material traces of one left on the other. Provided the traces can be analysed successfully, then an accident or crime can often be reconstructed. Another aim will be to determine the cause of a broken component using the technique of fractography.

<span class="mw-page-title-main">Detection of fire accelerants</span>

Detection of fire accelerants is the process that a fire investigator uses to determine if fire accelerants were used at a fire scene. This process involves a combination of both field work and laboratory analysis by fire investigators and chemists.

Mortuary archaeology is the study of human remains in their archaeological context. This is a known sub-field of bioarchaeology, which is a field that focuses on gathering important information based on the skeleton of an individual. Bioarchaeology stems from the practice of human osteology which is the anatomical study of skeletal remains. Mortuary archaeology, as well as the overarching field it resides in, aims to generate an understanding of disease, migration, health, nutrition, gender, status, and kinship among past populations. Ultimately, these topics help to produce a picture of the daily lives of past individuals. Mortuary archaeologists draw upon the humanities, as well as social and hard sciences to have a full understanding of the individual.

References

  1. 1 2 3 4 5 6 Gardner, Ross M.; Donna Krouskup (2021). Practical crime scene processing and investigation (Third ed.). Boca Raton. ISBN   978-1-032-09443-4. OCLC   1255870591.{{cite book}}: CS1 maint: location missing publisher (link)
  2. 1 2 3 Baxter, Everett (2015). Complete crime scene investigation handbook. Boca Raton. ISBN   978-1-4987-0144-0. OCLC   923845205.{{cite book}}: CS1 maint: location missing publisher (link)
  3. 1 2 3 4 5 6 7 Bottrell, Maureen C. (2009-04-01). "Forensic glass comparison: background information used in data interpretation" . Forensic Science Communications. 11 (2).
  4. Trejos, Tatiana; Koons, Robert; Becker, Stefan; Berman, Ted; Buscaglia, JoAnn; Duecking, Marc; Eckert-Lumsdon, Tiffany; Ernst, Troy; Hanlon, Christopher; Heydon, Alex; Mooney, Kim (2013-06-01). "Cross-validation and evaluation of the performance of methods for the elemental analysis of forensic glass by μ-XRF, ICP-MS, and LA-ICP-MS". Analytical and Bioanalytical Chemistry. 405 (16): 5393–5409. doi:10.1007/s00216-013-6978-y. ISSN   1618-2650. PMID   23673570. S2CID   19279412.
  5. 1 2 3 4 Harshey, Abhimanyu; Srivastava, Ankit; Yadav, Vijay Kumar; Nigam, Kriti; Kumar, Amit; Das, Tanurup (2017-12-07). "Analysis of glass fracture pattern made by .177" (4.5 mm) Caliber air rifle". Egyptian Journal of Forensic Sciences. 7 (1): 20. doi: 10.1186/s41935-017-0019-5 . ISSN   2090-5939. S2CID   32847303.
  6. 1 2 3 4 5 6 Kammrath, Brooke Weinger; Koutrakos, Andrew C.; McMahon, Meghann E.; Reffner, John A. (2016-06-27), Katz, Evgeny; Halámek, Jan (eds.), "The Forensic Analysis of Glass Evidence: Past, Present, and Future", Forensic Science (1 ed.), Wiley, pp. 299–336, doi:10.1002/9783527693535.ch14, ISBN   978-3-527-33894-8 , retrieved 2024-03-12
  7. 1 2 3 4 5 Almirall, Jose; Trejos, Tatiana (2015-12-18), Siegel, Jay A. (ed.), "Analysis of glass evidence", Forensic Chemistry (1 ed.), Wiley, pp. 228–272, doi:10.1002/9781118897768.ch6, ISBN   978-1-118-89772-0 , retrieved 2024-03-19