Frank Walus

Last updated

Frank Walus (1922-1994) was born in Germany of Polish parents and emigrated to the United States in 1963. He worked in a factory in the Chicago area and became US citizen in 1970. In 1973 he was accused of having been a Nazi who beat and killed Jews in Poland during World War II. [1] Prosecution was initiated by the US Immigration and Naturalization Service (INS) in 1977. He was convicted based upon questionable testimony in a bench trial before a judge who appeared visibly hostile to the defense. [2] An appeals court vacated the verdict and ordered a new trial before a different judge. By this time, the new Office of Special Investigations (OSI) had been established in the US Department of Justice. After conducting a lengthy and exhaustive investigation of witnesses and documents, OSI concluded that it "could not responsibly go forward with a new trial." OSI dropped the charges, expressed regret that they had ever been filed, and partially reimbursed Walus for his expenses. [3] [4]

Contents

Background

Immediately after World War II, Americans chose not to dwell upon the war's atrocities, and cold war threats caused Western governments to recruit former Nazis for intelligence work. This, along with U.S. immigration policies, made it relatively easy for former Nazis to enter the United States and become citizens. [5] [6] In the 1970's, growing awareness and concern about these "quiet neighbors" resulted in the establishment of US government organizations to identify, denaturalize, and deport them. The early work by the Special Litigation Unit (SLU) of the INS was regarded as ineffective and, according to legal scholar Lawrence Douglas, led "botched litigations." One of these was the Walus case. [7]

Walus expelled a boarder, Michael Alper, from his home in 1973 after a bitter argument. A year later, Alper told a Chicago Jewish agency that Walus had bragged about his work as a Nazi in Poland. The allegation ultimately reached Simon Wiesenthal, a well known Nazi hunter, who brought the matter to the attention of the INS. [8] Alper was Jewish and his parents had been killed by the Nazis. Nonetheless he and his wife had continued to live with Walus even after Walus' alleged disclosure about persecuting Jews. [9] [10] [11]

By 1976, the INS was under pressure to address public outcries about former Nazis in America. INS sent a grainy, washed-out 1959 photograph of Walus to the police in Israel requesting information. The police put an advertisement including Walus' name in local newspapers requesting any information Polish survivors might have. Some who came forward and viewed the photo said they recognized Walus as a Gestapo officer who had killed Jews in the Polish cities of Kielce and Częstochowa. In 1977, the US Attorney in Chicago filed suit to revoke Walus' citizenship on the basis that Walus had been a Gestapo officer who committed wartime atrocities and had lied in order to gain entry into the US. Once denaturalized, Walus could be deported. [12]

Trial

Denaturalization was a civil, not criminal matter and Walus was not entitled to a jury trial. Evidence was heard by eighty-three year old judge Julius Hoffman who had a history of injecting himself into cases before him. He interfered with defense attorney Robert Korenkiewicz's questioning of witnesses and declared that "the defendant did commit war atrocities" even before Korenkiewicz had begun presenting Walus' defense. [13]

The INS prosecution was almost entirely built upon witnesses who claimed to have seen Walus in Poland committing atrocities. No documents were presented to support that Walus was in Poland during the war or that he was ever a Gestapo officer. [14]

Walus asserted that he was not in Poland during the war, but was one of the millions of Poles sent to Germany to provide forced farm labor. There was documentary evidence from German archives that farmers had paid for Walus' health insurance there and that his forced service in Germany was continuous starting in 1940. He had worked on four or five farms, and the wives of the farmers where he had worked remembered his being there. Further, as a Pole he could not have been a member of the Gestapo, which restricted its number to members of the "master race" and to people taller than Walus' 5'4" height. [15]

The trial lasted seventeen days. Two mutually exclusive possibilities had been presented. Either Walus had been a Gestapo officer in Poland or a forced farm laborer in Germany. Hoffman decided upon the former, relying upon the eyewitness testimony from the persecuted Poles as well as the claims by former boarder Alper. Hoffman disregarded eyewitness testimony from defense eyewitnesses as well as the defense's documentary evidence. He issued his ruling in 1978 that Walus' citizenship be revoked. Shortly thereafter, the defense located five Polish forced laborers who would testify that Walus was with them in Germany during the war. Some old German residency papers proving Walus was in Germany in 1940 were also located. With this additional evidence, Walus' defense attorneys asked Hoffman for a new trial. He refused. [16] [17]

Appeal

The Seventh Circuit Court of Appeals heard oral argument from Walus' attorneys in 1979. It vacated Hoffman's verdict and ordered that there be a new trial, this time with a different judge. Their ruling noted Hoffman's "disturbing" behavior, especially his cutting off defense efforts to cross-examine witnesses. It also noted the weaknesses of the prosecution's case and observed that the newly found evidence would "almost certainly compel a different result." [18]

Further investigation

The case now came to the newly formed Office of Special Investigations of the Justice Department. Because of obvious weaknesses in the case for prosecution, OSI's new director, Allan Ryan, called for an exhaustive investigation of the evidence. It lasted nine months. OSI investigators traveled to Germany, Poland, and Israel to interview witnesses and search for documents. Efforts were made to locate Kielce and Częstochowa survivors in the US as well as overseas. A document analyst was retained in Germany. An OSI historian searched the US National Archives for records. The investigators concluded that witness testimony at the previous trial was of questionable reliability and that there was conflicting evidence about where Walus had been during the war. In light of the uncertainty, the OSI concluded that there was a strong possibility of mistaken identity and that it "could not responsibly go forward with a retrial." [19] [20] One of the two principal IOS investigators had even come to the conclusion that Walus was innocent. [21]

Not going forward to retry the case had some potentially negative consequences for OSI. Simon Wiesenthal had an interest in the case. The Israeli police had cooperated in providing evidence. Several Holocaust survivors had traveled to America from Israel and came to court to emotionally confront Walus, whom they believed to be their former tormentor. OSI had not yet won the confidence of the Jewish community, whose support could be important for the organization's success in prosecuting other cases. This was especially true since the bulk of the evidence regarding Nazi wartime atrocities lay behind the Iron Curtain, and OSI was getting little cooperation from officials in Moscow and Washington. This situation threatened the viability of OSI's mission. [22] [23] [24]

Decision and aftermath

OSI declined to retry Walus. The question then arose whether the government should express regret or even issue an apology to Walus. There was internal disagreement on this, and it was finally agreed that an expression of regret was appropriate. [25] OSI reimbursement of attorney's fees was generally prohibited by law, but Walus was awarded $34,000 to offset other costs he incurred. [26]

From its founding, OSI had been the object of criticism from various groups. It was clear from early on that achieving OSI's goals was going to have to involve a lot of public relations work as well as research and prosecution. [27] Eastern European nationality groups were concerned about OSI's mission since it could be expected to target some from their community. They opposed OSI's use of evidence from the USSR since it had an interest in discrediting Baltic State, Ukrainian, and other emigre groups and might well provide false information and forged documents to achieve their aims. [28] [29] These emigre groups also challenged the use of the lower standard of evidence involved in civil trials compared to criminal trials, [28] even though citizenship revocation and deportation were civil issues and US law at the time did not provide for criminal penalties for crimes committed on foreign soil unless against US citizens. [30] The emigres also feared that OSI might seek to deport anyone who had lied on their entry applications, not just the wartime persecutors that OSI sought to expel. [28] In contrast, Jewish groups were pressing for more determined action by OSI than INS had demonstrated. [31] These various groups viewed the original decision by INS to prosecute Walus, and then the decision by OSI not to retry him, as evidence to amplify their separate concerns about the work of the OSI. The press castigated the government for its original prosecution of Walus. [32] [33] On the other side, Lieut. Col. Menachem Russek of the Israeli national police, Israel's chief investigator of Nazi war crimes, sharply criticized the Department of Justice for not retrying the case. Nonetheless, he said the Israeli police would continue to cooperate with OSI in their efforts to find and deport former Nazis who committed wartime atrocities. [34]

As a result of the Walus case, concerns about mistaken identity led OSI to place greater emphasis upon documentary evidence to support eyewitness testimony in future prosecutions. Greater care was also taken in presenting photographic evidence to potential witnesses. [35] [36]

The personal cost of the litigation to Walus was high. In addition to assaults and receiving death threats, [37] [38] he paid over $60,000 for his defense. [39] He sold his house to pay for his attorneys and subsequently lived with his wife at the home of one of their children. [40]

Personal life

Walus was born 29 July 1922 to Polish parents residing in Germany [41] His father died in 1932, and his mother moved to the Kielce area in Poland. He was 17 when Poland was invaded by Germany in 1939, and he was forced to go to Germany to work on farms in the area around Neu-Ulm. After the war, he returned to Kielce for ten years, after which he and his wife emigrated to the United States. He worked in an automobile factory and bought a duplex in Chicago's southwest side. [42] Walus died of a heart attack in Chicago 17 August 1994. [43] [44] He had four children. [45]

Citations

  1. ↑ Johnson, Flora (10 May 1981). "The Nazi Who Never Was". The Washington Post. Retrieved 22 Mar 2021.
  2. ↑ Douglas, Lawrence (2016). The Right Wrong Man- John Demjanjuk and the Last Great Nazi War Crimes Trial. Princeton NJ and Oxford: Princeton University Press. p. 40-43. ISBN   978-0-691-12570-1 . Retrieved 22 Mar 2021.
  3. ↑ Ryan, Allan A., Jr. (1984). Quiet Neighbors- Prosecuting Nazi War Criminals In America . USA: Harcourt Brace Jovanovich. p. 210-17. ISBN   0-15-175823-9.
  4. ↑ Feigin, Judy and Mark M. Richard (December 2006). The Office of Special Investigations: Striving for Accountability in the Aftermath of the Holocaust (Report). US Department of Justice, Criminal Division. p. 71-100. Retrieved 22 Mar 2021.
  5. ↑ Ryan, p.19
  6. ↑ Douglas, p. 28
  7. ↑ Douglas, p. 39-40
  8. ↑ Johnson, "The Nazi Who Never Was"
  9. ↑ Johnson, "The Nazi Who Never Was"
  10. ↑ Ryan, p.210
  11. ↑ "United States of America, Plaintiff-appellee, v. Frank Walus, A/k/a Franciszek Walus, Defendant-appellant, 616 F.2d 283 (7th Cir. 1980)". Justia. 13 Feb 1980. Retrieved 22 Mar 2021.
  12. ↑ Ryan, p. 210-11
  13. ↑ Ryan, p. 213
  14. ↑ Ryan, p. 212
  15. ↑ Ryan, p. 211
  16. ↑ Ryan, p. 214-15
  17. ↑ Douglas, p. 41-42
  18. ↑ Douglas, p. 42
  19. ↑ Ryan, p, 214-15
  20. ↑ Feigin, Judy and Mark M. Richard (December 2006). The Office of Special Investigations: Striving for Accountability in the Aftermath of the Holocaust (Report). US Department of Justice, Criminal Division. p. 81-86. Retrieved 21 Mar 2021.
  21. ↑ Douglas, p. 42
  22. ↑ Douglas, p. 42-43
  23. ↑ Feigin p. 85, 88
  24. ↑ Pear, Robert (26 Jan 1981). "Israeli Assails Justice Dept. Decision on Accused Nazi". The New York Times. Retrieved 26 Nov 2015.
  25. ↑ Feigin, p. 87-88
  26. ↑ Douglas, p. 43
  27. ↑ Feigin p. 8
  28. 1 2 3 Raus, Juri (14 Feb 1982). "East European groups confer with Justice Department reps" (PDF). The Ukrainian Weekly. Retrieved 25 Nov 2015.
  29. ↑ Feigin p. 211-12
  30. ↑ Feigin p. 33
  31. ↑ Feigin p. 8
  32. ↑ Feigin, p. 88
  33. ↑ Johnson, "The Nazi Who Never Was"
  34. ↑ Pear, Robert (January 26, 1981). "Israeli Assails Justice Dept. Decision on Accused Nazi". New York Times. Retrieved 22 Mar 2021.
  35. ↑ Feign, p. 89-93
  36. ↑ Ryan, p. 216-17
  37. ↑ "Nazi Accusations Turn Life Into A Nightmare". New York Times. 1 May 1983. Retrieved 23 Mar 2021.
  38. ↑ Mogharei, Phoebe (7 Dec 2018). "From the Vault: The United States of America v. Frank Walus". Chicago Magazine. Retrieved 24 Mar 2021.
  39. ↑ Johnson, "The Nazi Who Never Was"
  40. ↑ Johnson, "The Nazi Who Never Was"
  41. ↑ Feigin, p. 71
  42. ↑ Johnson, "The Nazi Who Never Was"
  43. ↑ "Frank Walus Social Security Death Index". Social Security Death Index. Social Security Administration. 28 July 1917. Retrieved 24 Mar 2021.
  44. ↑ "Frank Walus". The Revisionist. Retrieved 23 Mar 2021.
  45. ↑ Johnson, "The Nazi Who Never Was"

Principal sources

Related Research Articles

Klaus Barbie SS-Hauptsturmführer, soldier and Gestapo member

Nikolaus "Klaus" Barbie was a German Nazi, known as the "Butcher of Lyon" for having personally tortured prisoners of the Gestapo—primarily Jews and members of the French Resistance—while stationed in Lyon under the collaborationist Vichy regime. After the war, United States intelligence services, which employed him for his anti-Marxist efforts, aided his escape to Bolivia, where he advised the regime on how to repress opposition through torture.

Nuremberg trials Series of military trials at the end of World War II

The Nuremberg trials were a series of military tribunals held following World War II by the Allied forces under international law and the laws of war. The trials were most notable for the prosecution of prominent members of the political, military, judicial, and economic leadership of Nazi Germany, who planned, carried out, or otherwise participated in the Holocaust and other war crimes. The trials were held in Nuremberg, Germany, and their decisions marked a turning point between classical and contemporary international law.

John Demjanjuk was a Ukrainian-American who served as a Trawniki man and Nazi camp guard at Sobibor extermination camp, Majdanek, and Flossenbürg. Demjanjuk became the center of global media attention in the 1980s, when he was tried and convicted after being misidentified as "Ivan the Terrible", a notoriously cruel watchman at Treblinka extermination camp. Shortly before his death, he was again tried and convicted as an accessory to 28,000 murders at Sobibor.

The pursuit of Nazi collaborators refers to the post-World War II pursuit and apprehension of individuals who were not citizens of the Third Reich at the outbreak of World War II but collaborated with the Nazi regime during the war. Hence, this article does not cover former members of the NSDAP and their fates after the war.

The Office of Special Investigations (OSI) of the U.S Justice Department was created in 1979 to identify and expel from the United States those who assisted Nazis in persecuting "any person because of race, religion, national origin, or political opinion." This involved gathering, verifying, and presenting in court eyewitness and documentary evidence of decades-old crimes. The evidence was incomplete and scattered around the world. Much of it was then in Eastern Europe, behind the Iron Curtain. Nonetheless, the OSI investigated 1,700 persons suspected of being involved in Nazi war crimes. Over 300 have been prosecuted with at least 100 stripped of their U.S. citizenship and 70 deported, the most recent in 2021. Others have been blocked from entering the U.S.

Bruno Streckenbach

Bruno Streckenbach was a German SS functionary during the Nazi era. He was the head of Administration and Personnel Department of the Reich Security Main Office (RSHA). Streckenbach was responsible for many thousands of murders committed by Nazi mobile killing squads known as Einsatzgruppen.

Dachau trials

The Dachau trials handled the prosecution of every war criminal captured in the U.S. military zones in Allied-occupied Germany and in Allied-occupied Austria, and the prosecutions of military personnel and civilian persons who committed war crimes against the American military and American citizens. The war-crime trials were held within the compound of the Dachau concentration camp by military tribunals authorized by the Judge Advocate General of the U.S. Third Army.

Operation Last Chance was launched July 2002 by the Simon Wiesenthal Center with its mission statement being to track down ex-Nazis still in hiding. Most of them were nearing the end of their lifetimes, hence the operation's name. Efraim Zuroff is director of the Wiesenthal Center in Jerusalem who serves as the Israeli liaison as well as overseer of this project, the focus of which is investigation, prosecution, and conviction of the last remaining Nazi war criminals and collaborators. Many have obtained citizenship in Canada and the United States under false pretences; usually by misrepresentation, omission, or falsification of their criminal past, specifically war crimes which rose to the level of crimes against humanity.

Valerian Trifa was a Romanian Orthodox cleric and former Nazi, who served as archbishop of the Romanian Orthodox Church in America and Canada. For part of his life, he was a naturalized citizen of the United States, until he was stripped of his American citizenship for lying about his involvement in the murder of hundreds of Jews during the Holocaust and World War 2.

A war crimes trial is the trial of persons charged with criminal violation of the laws and customs of war and related principles of international law committed during armed conflict.

The Central Office of the State Justice Administrations for the Investigation of National Socialist Crimes is Germany's main agency responsible for investigating war crimes during Nazi rule. The commission possesses the largest collection of files, documentation and materials concerning criminal activities during Nazi rule. The Central Office is located in Ludwigsburg.

Feodor Fedorenko SS guard at a concentration camp and war criminal

Feodor Fedorenko, or Fyodor Federenko was a war criminal serving at Treblinka extermination camp in German occupied Poland during World War II. As a former Soviet citizen admitted to the United States under a DPA visa (1949), Fedorenko became a naturalized U.S. citizen in 1970. He was discovered in 1977 and denaturalized in 1981. Subsequently, he was extradited to the USSR, sentenced there to death for treason against his nation and participation in the Holocaust, and was executed.

Josef Albert Meisinger

Josef Albert Meisinger, also known as the "Butcher of Warsaw", was a SS functionary in Nazi Germany. He held a position in the Gestapo and was a member of the Nazi Party. During the early phases of World War II Meisinger served as commander of Einsatzgruppe IV on Poland. From 1941 to 1945 he worked as liaison for the Gestapo at the German embassy in Tokyo. He was arrested in Japan in 1945, convicted of war crimes and was executed in Warsaw, Poland.

Sobibor trial

The Sobibor trial was a 1965–66 judicial trial in the West German prosecution of SS officers who had worked at Sobibor extermination camp; it was held in Hagen. It was one of a series of similar war crime trials held during the early and mid-1960s, such as the 1961 trial of Adolf Eichmann by Israel in Jerusalem, and the Frankfurt Auschwitz Trials of 1963–65, also held in West Germany. These trials heightened general public and international understanding of the extent of the crimes that had been perpetrated in occupied Poland some twenty years earlier by Nazi bureaucrats and persons acting as their executioners.

Allan A. Ryan (Jr.) is an American attorney, author and university and law school professor. He was born in Cambridge, Massachusetts, and graduated from Dartmouth College and magna cum laude from the University of Minnesota Law School. He served as a law clerk to Justice Byron White of the Supreme Court of the United States and as a captain in the U.S. Marine Corps. In the U.S. Justice Department, he was Assistant to the Solicitor General and from 1980 to 1983 Director of the Office of Special Investigations, Criminal Division, responsible for the investigation and prosecution of Nazi war criminals in the United States. Since 1985, he has been an attorney at Harvard University, first in the Office of General Counsel and since 2001 as Director of Intellectual Property, Harvard Business School Publishing.

Ivan the Terrible is the nickname given to a notorious guard at the Treblinka extermination camp during the Holocaust. The moniker alluded to Ivan IV, also known as Ivan the Terrible, the infamous Tsar of Russia. "Ivan the Terrible" gained international recognition following the 1986 John Demjanjuk case. By 1944, a cruel guard named "Ivan", sharing his distinct duties and extremely violent behavior with a guard named "Nicholas", was mentioned in survivor literature. John Demjanjuk was first accused of being Ivan the Terrible at the Treblinka concentration camp. Demjanjuk was found guilty of war crimes and was sentenced to death by hanging. Exculpatory material from Soviet archives was subsequently released, identifying Ivan the Terrible as one Ivan Marchenko leading the Supreme Court of Israel to acquit Demjanjuk in 1993. Demjanjuk was later extradited to Germany where he was convicted in 2011 of war crimes for having served at Sobibor extermination camp.

Otto von Bolschwing Officer in SS Sicherheitsdienst; CIA operative

Otto Albrecht Alfred von Bolschwing was a German SS-Hauptsturmführer in the Nazi Sicherheitsdienst (SD), Hitler's SS intelligence agency. After World War II von Bolschwing became a spy and worked for the Central Intelligence Agency (CIA) in Europe and later in California.

Johann Breyer was a onetime SS-Totenkopfverbände concentration and death camp guard and retired tool and die maker whom the United States Department of Justice Office of Special Investigations (OSI) unsuccessfully attempted to denaturalize and deport for his teenage service in the SS. His was considered the "most arcane and convoluted litigation in OSI history", owing to the convergence of three unusual legal factors in the case:

Chief Commission for the Prosecution of Crimes against the Polish Nation is a governmental agency created in 1945 in Poland. It is tasked with investigating German atrocities and communist ones. In 1999 it was transformed into the main organizational unit of the investigative department of the Institute of National Remembrance.

Aleksandras Lileikis Nazi official

Aleksandras Lileikis was the chief of the Lithuanian Security Police in Vilnius during the Nazi occupation of Lithuania and a perpetrator of the Holocaust in Lithuania. He signed documents handing at least 75 Jews in his control over to Ypatingasis būrys, a Lithuanian collaborationist death squad, and is suspected of responsibility in the murder of thousands of Lithuanian Jews. After the Soviet occupation of Lithuania, he fled to Germany as a displaced person. Refused permission to immigrate to the United States because of his Nazi past, he worked for the Central Intelligence Agency in the early 1950s. In 1955, his second application for permission to immigrate was granted and he settled in Norwood, Massachusetts, becoming a naturalized citizen in 1976. Eli Rosenbaum, an investigator for the Office of Special Investigations, uncovered evidence of Lileikis' war crimes; proceedings for his denaturalization were opened in 1994 and concluded with Lileikis being stripped of his United States citizenship. He returned to Lithuania, where he was charged with genocide in February 1998. It was the first Nazi war crimes prosecution in post-Soviet block of Europe. He died of a heart attack in 2000 before a verdict was reached.

This page is based on this Wikipedia article
Text is available under the CC BY-SA 4.0 license; additional terms may apply.
Images, videos and audio are available under their respective licenses.