Gottlieb v. Tropicana Hotel & Casino

Last updated
Gottlieb v. Tropicana Hotel & Casino
Pennsylvania-eastern.gif
Full case nameRena Gottlieb, et al.v. Tropicana Hotel and Casino v. Redland Insurance Co., et al.
DecidedJuly 5, 2000
Counsel for plaintiff(s)Feldman, Shepherd, Wohlgelernter
Holding
Participation in a promotional contest is sufficient consideration for a valid contract
Court membership
Judge(s) sitting Harvey Bartle III

Gottlieb v. Tropicana Hotel & Casino, 109 F. Supp. 2d 324 (2000) was a decision by the United States District Court for the Eastern District of Pennsylvania, holding that participation in a promotional contest is sufficient consideration for a valid contract. [1]

Contents

Background

Rena and Sheldon Gottlieb, who were residents of Pennsylvania, were vacationing at a rented apartment in Atlantic City, New Jersey during the summer of 1999. On July 24, 1999, following dinner with friends, the couple visited the Tropicana Casino. Rena Gottlieb was a member of the casino's "Diamond Club," which requires photo identification and a completed application form for signup. The "Diamond Club" is free to signup for, and the casino enters the member's information into their computer database, which is used for advertising purposes. Further, "Diamond Club" members are given a card, which is swiped every time a member plays one of the Tropicana's casino games. [2]

Once inside the Tropicana, Gottlieb waited in line for approximately five minutes to play the casino's Fun House Million Dollar Wheel Promotion, which offers a variety of prizes, including a $1 million payout. The Tropicana offers "Diamond Club" members one free spin on the wheel every day; Gottlieb used her membership card for the free spin. Gottlieb contends that the wheel landed on the $1 million prize, but the wheel operator intervened and reactivated the wheel with another member's card, which subsequently landed on a lesser prize of two show tickets. The Tropicana casino claims that the wheel never landed on $1 million, and the attendant never reactivated the wheel. [3]

Decision

Summary Judgment

The Court affirmed that participation in a contest is considered entering a contract. Since Gottlieb had to drive to the casino, wait in line to spin the wheel, and present her "Diamond Club" card to the casino attendant, she provided consideration to form a contract with the Tropicana Casino. Further, participation in the game provided entertainment for those at the casino, which benefited the Tropicana. [4]

Precedent for the ruling was also found in both New Jersey and Pennsylvania cases, including Lucky Calendar Co. v. Cohen and Cobaugh v. Klick-Lewis, Inc. [5]

Jury Trial

Since there was no factual evidence, Judge Bartle moved to a jury trial. Two eyewitnesses testified on behalf of Gottlieb claiming they had seen the wheel hit the $1 million jackpot. After a three-day trial, an eight-person jury came back ruling in favor of Gottlieb.

Related Research Articles

<span class="mw-page-title-main">Slot machine</span> Casino gambling machine

A slot machine, fruit machine, poker machine or pokies is a gambling machine that creates a game of chance for its customers. Slot machines are also known pejoratively as one-armed bandits because of the large mechanical levers affixed to the sides of early mechanical machines and the games' ability to empty players' pockets and wallets as thieves would.

<span class="mw-page-title-main">MGM Grand Las Vegas</span> Casino resort in Las Vegas, Nevada

The MGM Grand Las Vegas is a hotel and casino located on the Las Vegas Strip in Paradise, Nevada. The MGM Grand is the largest single hotel in the world with 6,852 rooms. It is also the third-largest hotel complex in the world by number of rooms and second-largest hotel resort complex in the United States behind the combined The Venetian and The Palazzo. When it opened in 1993, the MGM Grand was the largest hotel complex in the world.

<span class="mw-page-title-main">Tropicana Las Vegas</span> Casino hotel in Nevada, United States

The Tropicana Las Vegas is a casino hotel on the Las Vegas Strip in Paradise, Nevada. It is owned and operated by Bally's Corporation, on land leased from Gaming and Leisure Properties. It offers 1,467 rooms, a 50,000-square-foot (4,600 m2) gaming floor, and 72,000 sq ft (6,700 m2) of convention and exhibit space.

<span class="mw-page-title-main">Excalibur Hotel and Casino</span> Hotel and casino in Paradise, Nevada

Excalibur Hotel and Casino is a casino hotel on the Las Vegas Strip in Paradise, Nevada, in the United States. It is owned by Vici Properties and operated by MGM Resorts International.

<i>Winning Streak</i> (Irish game show) Irish TV series or program

Winning Streak is an Irish television game show. The show was broadcast weekly in Ireland between 1990 and 2020 on RTÉ One. Typical episodes of the show would see contestants take part in a number of games to win cars, holidays, and cash prizes up to €500,000.

<span class="mw-page-title-main">Tropicana Casino & Resort Atlantic City</span> Hotel and casino in Atlantic City, New Jersey

Tropicana Atlantic City, often referred to as The Trop, is a resort, casino hotel located on the beach and Boardwalk in Atlantic City, New Jersey. It is owned by Gaming and Leisure Properties and operated by Caesars Entertainment, and is the third largest hotel in New Jersey, with just under 2,400 guest rooms and the 200,000-square-foot shopping and entertainment complex, The Quarter. It has over 30 restaurants, 30 shops, 20 bars and lounges, 4 pools, the Tropicana Showroom, multiple spas, and an IMAX Theatre. In 2016, Tropicana completed over $200 million in renovations and additions, including a Multimedia Light and Sound Show, the addition of AtlantiCare LifeCenter Fitness, Garces restaurants, renovations to over 900 hotel rooms, and casino floor but Tropicana will continue investing. The Tropicana is the largest resort and casino on the boardwalk, with 2,364 rooms, 3,000 slot machines, 30 restaurants, and 30 shops, along with two 2,500-space parking garages, totaling over 5,000 parking spaces. In 2021-2023 Tropicana is said to complete renovations through these years, the renovations will include renovations to all 604 West Tower rooms, modernized elevators and escalators, pool enhancements, gaming space enhancements, and more undisclosed renovation projects.

<span class="mw-page-title-main">Tropicana Club</span> Cabaret in Ciudad de La Habana, Cuba

El Tropicana Night Club in Havana, Cuba located in a lush, six-acre estate tropical garden opened on December 30, 1939 at the Villa Mina in Marianao. It is located next door to the old Colegio de Belén, presently, the Instituto Técnico Militar.

<span class="mw-page-title-main">Racino</span> Gambling venue that offers both racing and casino games

A racino is a combined race track and casino. In some cases, the gambling is limited to slot machines, but many locations are beginning to include table games such as blackjack, poker, and roulette.

Columbia Sussex is a privately owned hotel company based in Crestview Hills, Kentucky. The company, owned by the Yung family, owns and operates hotels in various parts of the United States. The current president and founder is William J. Yung III.

<span class="mw-page-title-main">Pennsylvania Lottery</span> Lottery operated by the Commonwealth of Pennsylvania

The Pennsylvania Lottery is operated by the Commonwealth of Pennsylvania. The Lottery was created by the Pennsylvania General Assembly on August 26, 1971; two months later, Henry Kaplan was appointed as its first executive director. The Pennsylvania Lottery sold its first tickets on March 7, 1972 and drew its first numbers on March 15, 1972.

<span class="mw-page-title-main">Harrah's Lake Tahoe</span> Hotel and casino in Stateline, Nevada

Harrah's Lake Tahoe is a hotel and casino in Stateline, Nevada. Harrah's is branded with the name of its former owner and operator William F. Harrah. It is now owned by Vici Properties and operated by Caesars Entertainment. The 18-story tower and 512 rooms, plus 65,000 sq ft (6,000 m2) casino make it one of the largest resorts at South Lake Tahoe.

<span class="mw-page-title-main">Penn Entertainment</span> American gambling company

Penn Entertainment, Inc., formerly Penn National Gaming, is an American entertainment company and operator of integrated entertainment, sports content, and casino gaming. It operates 43 properties in 20 states, under brands including Hollywood Casino, Ameristar, and Boomtown. It also offers sports betting in 15 jurisdictions and online casino gaming in 5, under brands such as Barstool Sports and TheScore.

<span class="mw-page-title-main">Harveys Lake Tahoe</span> Resort and casino in Stateline, Nevada

Harveys Lake Tahoe is a hotel and casino located in Stateline, Nevada. It has 742 rooms and suites as well as six restaurants and a casino with 87,500 square feet (8,130 m2) of space. It also has a video arcade, wedding chapel, pool, convention center and a full-service health club. It is owned by Vici Properties and operated by Caesars Entertainment.

<span class="mw-page-title-main">The Bicycle Hotel & Casino</span>

The Bicycle Hotel & Casino is a poker cardroom in California.

<i>The Big Spin</i> Lottery game show for the state of California

The Big Spin is the California Lottery's first television game show.

Nemacolin is a four-season resort in Farmington, Fayette County, Pennsylvania. The resort is owned by Maggie Hardy, Owner and CEO of the 84 Lumber Company, and was founded by her father, Joseph Hardy.

<span class="mw-page-title-main">Atlantic Club Casino Hotel</span> Closed casino and hotel in Atlantic City, New Jersey

The Atlantic Club Casino Hotel, formerly known as Golden Nugget, Bally's Grand, The Grand, Atlantic City Hilton and ACH, is an abandoned hotel and casino located at the southern end of the boardwalk in Atlantic City, New Jersey, owned and operated by Colony Capital. It was the city's first and only "locals casino". The Atlantic Club permanently closed on January 13, 2014, at 12:01 AM, largely as a result of dwindling casino visitors to Atlantic City due to increased competition in neighboring states. A third of Atlantic City's boardwalk casinos closed the same year, the others being Revel, Trump Plaza, and Showboat. Redevelopment proposals include a water park.

<i>Wheel of Fortune</i> (American game show) American television game show

Wheel of Fortune is an American television game show created by Merv Griffin. The show has aired continuously since January 1975. It features a competition in which contestants solve word puzzles, similar to those in hangman, to win cash and prizes determined by spinning a giant carnival wheel. The current version of the series, which airs in nightly syndication, premiered on September 19, 1983. It stars Pat Sajak and Vanna White as hosts, who have hosted the nighttime version since its inception. The original version of Wheel was a network daytime series that ran on NBC from January 6, 1975, to June 30, 1989, and subsequently aired on CBS from July 17, 1989, to January 11, 1991; it returned to NBC on January 14, 1991, and was cancelled that year, ending on September 20, 1991.

Gaming and Leisure Properties, Inc. is a real estate investment trust (REIT) specializing in casino properties, based in Wyomissing, Pennsylvania. It was formed in November 2013 as a corporate spin-off from Penn National Gaming. The company owns 57 casino properties, all of which are leased to other companies.

<span class="mw-page-title-main">Caesars Entertainment</span> American gaming company

Caesars Entertainment, Inc., formerly Eldorado Resorts, Inc., is an American hotel and casino entertainment company founded and based in Reno, Nevada that operates more than 50 properties. Eldorado Resorts acquired Caesars Entertainment Corporation and changed its own name to Caesars Entertainment on July 20, 2020.

References

  1. "Gottlieb v. Tropicana Hotel & Casino". United States District Court, E.D. Pennsylvania. July 5, 2000.
  2. Emanuel Law Outlines: Contracts 8th Edition. Aspen Publishers. 2006. ISBN   9780735558175.
  3. Contracts, Keyed to Calamari, Perillo & Bender. Casenote Legal Briefs. March 30, 2005. ISBN   9780735571846.
  4. "Gottlieb v. Tropicana Hotel and Casino". CaseBriefs.com.
  5. "Litigating Casino Promotion Claims". Gaming Law Review. June 2002. doi:10.1089/109218802760019600.{{cite journal}}: Cite journal requires |journal= (help)