Haiti: Where Did the Money Go

Last updated
Haiti: Where Did the Money Go
Written byMichele Mitchell
Directed by Michele Mitchell
Country of originUnited States
Original languageEnglish
Production
ProducerMichele Mitchell
Running time52 minutes
Production company Film at Eleven Media
Original release
Release2012 (2012)

Haiti: Where Did the Money Go? is a 2012 Film at Eleven Media production that was produced, written and directed by Michele Mitchell. Shot in the aftermath of the 2010 Haiti earthquake, the documentary looks at what really happens with the money donated to help with disaster aid. Haiti: Where Did The Money Go? aired on PBS and won the 2013 Edward R. Murrow Award for News Documentary. [1]

Contents

Summary

Haiti: Where Did the Money Go seeks to discover where the funds raised for the relief effort after the 2010 earthquake in Haiti really went. Taking place ten months after the earthquake, and again 10 months after that, the film surveys the disaster relief efforts that NGOs have undertaken. It investigates whether the record-breaking amounts of money raised has been distributed appropriately. Despite the more than 9 billion public and private dollars raised for relief, [2] many people in Haiti still live in camps with inadequate food, water, shelter, and cleanliness.

The film travels to several camps in and around Port-au-Prince, and presents the unfortunate reality of life in Haiti since the earthquake. Haitians, employees of charitable organizations, doctors, and others relate their experiences with NGOs, both good and bad, regarding disaster relief. It becomes clear that despite some progress, the NGOs operate without accountability and inter organization communication, and the Haitians end up not receiving the help they were promised.

Synopsis

The film begins by discussing the astounding amount of money raised to aid Haiti. Americans alone donated 1.4 billion [3] in relief funds to NGOs in the year following the disaster. These organizations faced criticism in the past due to their unorganized responses to previous disasters. When the earthquake in Haiti struck, these aid groups envisioned a new system of organization, or “humanitarian aid 2.0,” that would provide effective and quick relief. Michele Mitchell travelled to Haiti for the first time in November 2010 to see if this had been carried out.

What she found was thousands of homeless Haitians living in camps with inadequate access to clean water, food, and latrines. Thousands of people shared full toilets that were not cleaned, lived in ripping tents on muddy and dirty grounds, and struggled to make money to feed their families.

It is in one of these camps that Michele met Wilma Vital, a mother of 2 whose business was destroyed in the earthquake. She expressed anger at the American Red Cross for helping those in other camps but not those in hers. Many other Haitians expressed similar sentiments; they believed that NGOs used the money they raised to fund themselves, hotels, restaurants instead of helping Haiti.

Michele interviewed many employees of NGOs working in Haiti. She questioned David Meltzer, who was in charge of international relief for the American Red Cross, the largest working NGO in Haiti. He, as well as Luke King of Catholic Relief Services, maintained that the money was being well spent and that the situation in Haiti was improving. But other NGO employees, like Julie Schindall from Oxfam America and Barth A. Green from Project Medishare, expressed that they were still in need of funds and resources from these larger NGOs to maintain their services.

While Michele was in Haiti, a hurricane was expected to hit the island. The government as well as NGOs encouraged Haitians living in the camps to evacuate. They expressed that they had nowhere else to go, and refused to move, preferring instead to wait out the storm in their tents. Following the storm, the lack of uncontaminated water caused a cholera outbreak, which was deadly to many in the camps. One reason for this is that the NGOs would not communicate with one another as to the needs of the Haitians, so inadequate or inappropriate supplies were sent.

20 months after the earthquake, Michele returned to Haiti to check on the progress of the relief efforts. Despite some improvements in housing at certain camps, thousands still lived in unsafe and unclean conditions. She checked back in with Wilma Vital, who with a husband, two children, and another baby on the way only had enough food to last for a few more days. Other Haitians expressed anger at those who come to visit and document their hardship but then do nothing to alleviate it.

Ultimately, the film provides a complex picture of NGOs, some of which work hard to provide services in difficult circumstances, others who seem to only benefit themselves in the “big business of emergency aid."

Awards

•2013 Gracie Award for Outstanding Investigative Program

•2012 CINE Golden Eagle

•2013 CINE Special Jury Award for Best Investigative Documentary

•2013 Edward R. Murrow Award for News Documentary

•2013 Women's International Film Festival Best Documentary Short

Related Research Articles

Operation Blessing International Relief and Development Corporation (OBI) is a faith-based non-profit organization headquartered in Virginia Beach, Virginia, United States. Founded in 1978, OBI operates in more than 90 countries, focusing on disaster relief, medical aid, clean water, hunger relief, community development, and orphan care programs.

<span class="mw-page-title-main">Humanitarian response to the 2004 Indian Ocean earthquake</span>

The humanitarian response to the 2004 Indian Ocean earthquake of a magnitude of 9.1 was prompted by one of the worst natural disasters of modern times. On 26 December 2004, the earthquake, which struck off the northwest coast of the Indonesian island of Sumatra, generated a tsunami that wreaked havoc along much of the rim of the Indian Ocean. Particularly hard-hit were the countries of Indonesia, India, Sri Lanka and Thailand. About 230,000 people were killed, tens of thousands more were injured, and 1.7 million became homeless and displaced.

The Disasters Emergency Committee (DEC) is an umbrella group of UK charities which coordinates and launches collective appeals to raise funds to provide emergency aid and rapid relief to people caught up in disasters and humanitarian crises around the world. Since being formed in 1963, the DEC has had strong relationships with major UK broadcasters in particular the BBC and ITV, who provide airtime to broadcast emergency appeals upon its recommendation. It is a member of the global Emergency Appeals Alliance, which reports that since its first television appeal in 1966, the DEC has raised over £1.4 billion.

<span class="mw-page-title-main">Catholic Relief Services</span> Humanitarian agency from the USA

Catholic Relief Services (CRS) is the international humanitarian agency of the Catholic community in the United States. Founded in 1943 by the Bishops of the United States, the agency provides assistance to 130 million people in more than 110 countries and territories in Africa, Asia, Latin America, the Middle East and Eastern Europe.

<span class="mw-page-title-main">Direct Relief</span> Charitable organization

Direct Relief is a nonprofit humanitarian organization whose mission is to improve the lives of people in poverty or emergency situations by providing the appropriate medical resources. The charity provides emergency medical assistance and disaster relief in the United States and internationally. The organization is headed by an independent board of directors and its president and CEO, Thomas Tighe.

Michele Mitchell is an American filmmaker, journalist and author best known for her on-camera reporting for PBS and CNN Headline News and her documentaries Haiti: Where Did the Money Go? and The Uncondemned (2015).

<span class="mw-page-title-main">Humanity First</span> International non-governmental organization

Humanity First is an international charity that provides disaster relief and long term development assistance to vulnerable communities in 52 countries across 6 continents. The organisation is run by volunteers with diverse skillsets across the world and has access to thousands of extra volunteers worldwide. Volunteer staff in all areas often pay their own expenses to support the international projects.

Americares is a global non-profit organization focused on health and development that responds to individuals affected by poverty, disaster, or crisis. The organization addresses poverty, disasters, or crises with medicine, medical supplies and health programs.

Giving Children Hope (GCHope), founded in 1993 by John Ditty and Juliana Reasor, is a faith-based non-profit organization that works to alleviate poverty, both domestically and internationally, through disaster relief, health and community development, vocational training and advocacy. The organization is currently headed by Executive Director Sean Lawrence and the Chairman of the Board Bill Barta.

IsraAID is an Israel-based non-governmental organization that responds to emergencies all over the world with targeted humanitarian help. This includes disaster relief, from search and rescue to rebuilding communities and schools, to providing aid packages, medical assistance, and post-psychotrauma care. IsraAID has also been involved in an increasing number of international development projects with focuses on agriculture, medicine, and mental health.

<span class="mw-page-title-main">Humanitarian response to the 2010 Haiti earthquake</span>

The response to the 2010 Haiti earthquake included national governments, charitable and for-profit organizations from around the world which began coordinating humanitarian aid designed to help the Haitian people. Some countries arranged to send relief and rescue workers and humanitarian supplies directly to the earthquake damage zones, while others sought to organize national fund raising to provide monetary support for the nonprofit groups working directly in Haiti. OCHA coordinates and tracks this on a daily basis. The information is disseminated through the UN news and information portal, ReliefWeb. As of September 5, 2013, ReliefWeb have reported a total relief funding of $3.5 billion given.

<span class="mw-page-title-main">2010 Haiti earthquake</span> Magnitude 7.0 Mw earthquake

The 2010 Haiti earthquake was a catastrophic magnitude 7.0 Mw earthquake that struck Haiti at 16:53 local time on Tuesday, 12 January 2010. The epicenter was near the town of Léogâne, Ouest department, approximately 25 kilometres (16 mi) west of Port-au-Prince, Haiti's capital.

<span class="mw-page-title-main">Humanitarian response by non-governmental organizations to the 2010 Haiti earthquake</span>

The humanitarian responses by non-governmental organizations to the 2010 Haiti earthquake included many organisations, such as international, religious, and regionally based NGOs, which immediately pledged support in the aftermath of the 2010 Haiti earthquake. Besides a large multi-contingency contribution by national governments, NGOs contributed significantly to both on-the-ground rescue efforts and external solicitation of aid for the rescue efforts.

This article describes humanitarian responses from "for-profit" organizations, such as business corporations, following the January 12, 2010, earthquake in Haiti.

Digicel Haiti Earthquake Relief Fund was established by Digicel after the January 12 earthquake to raise funds for the recovery/relief efforts in Haiti.

Community Organized Relief Effort, also known as CORE Response and formerly as J/P Haitian Relief Organization is a non-profit organization founded by actor Sean Penn and Ann Lee in response to the January 12, 2010 earthquake in Haiti. The organization was founded in 2010 and changed its name in 2019 to receive contracts and donations to work globally. In March 2020, CORE began administering free COVID-19 tests in the U.S. amid the COVID-19 pandemic.

Yéle Haiti, also known as Yéle and legally known as the Wyclef Jean Foundation, was a charitable organization established in 2001 by the Haitian musician Wyclef Jean, who was born in Haiti and has kept ties there. The charity was incorporated in the U.S. state of Illinois.

<span class="mw-page-title-main">BAPS Charities</span> International charitable organization

BAPS Charities is an international, religious, charitable organization that originates from the Bochasanwasi Akshar Purushottam Swaminarayan Sanstha (BAPS) with a focus on serving society. This focus on service to society is stated in the organization's vision, that "every individual deserves the right to a peaceful, dignified, and healthy way of life. And by improving the quality of life of the individual, we are bettering families, communities, our world, and our future." BAPS Charities carries out this vision through a range of programs addressing health, education, the environment, and natural disaster recovery. The organization's worldwide activities are funded through donations and are led by a community of over 55,000 volunteers who are mostly members of BAPS. The volunteers work with local communities and other charities and the organization's activities are mainly based out of their mandirs.

Sahana Software Foundation is a Los Angeles, California-based non-profit organization founded to promote free and open-source software (FOSS) for disaster and emergency management. The foundation's mission statement is to "save lives by providing information management solutions that enable organizations and communities to better prepare for and respond to disasters." The foundation's Sahana family of software products includes Eden, designed for humanitarian needs management; Vesuvius, focused on the disaster preparedness needs of the medical community; and legacy earlier versions of Sahana software including Krakatoa, descended from the original Sahana code base developed following the 2004 Indian Ocean tsunami. The word "Sahana" means "relief" in Sinhalese, one of two national languages of Sri Lanka.

<span class="mw-page-title-main">Corruption in Haiti</span> Institutional corruption in the country

Corruption in Haiti occurs at one of the worst rates in the world. Corruption is a scourge that corrodes all attempts to establish a rule of law, a sustainable democracy, and to improve the quality of life of Haiti's people.

References

  1. "2013 National Edward R. Murrow Award Winners". Radio Television Digital News Association. Retrieved 24 September 2014.
  2. "Haiti: Three Years After the Quake and Not Much Has Changed".
  3. "What Does Haiti Have to Show for $13 Billion in Earthquake Aid?". NBC News .