It's All About You (EP)

Last updated
It's All About You
Rebecca F and the Memes.jpg
EP by
Rebecca F. & The Memes
Released2006 (2006)
Recordedc. 2006
Genre Pop/rock

It's All About You is a four-song EP written and produced by singer, songwriter, and Chicago musician [1] Rebecca F.

Contents

Rebecca F.'s interest in the meme — "an idea, behavior, or style that spreads from person to person within a culture" [2] — led to the band name "Rebecca F. & The Memes." [3] In a 2006 interview, she said: "A meme is a cultural gene. [W]e humans by consensus determine what cultural information is valuable enough to pass from one generation to the next. The question is: What memes are we passing on in the modern world?" [3]

From 2000 to 2002 Rebecca F. was contracted to a development deal by R. Kelly for his vanity label Rockland Records during which time she recorded and produced her own songs. [4]

Track listing

No.TitleLength
1."Under the Big White Star"4:43
2."Juda"2:47
3."Derek"4:12
4."The Girl"5:20

"Judas" plagiarism lawsuit

The song "Juda", released on this album, was written by Rebecca F. and copyrighted in 1999. [5]

Lady Gaga and "Judas"

In August 2011, Rebecca F., born Rebecca Francescatti, filed a lawsuit in Illinois Northern District Court's Chicago Office known as Francescatti v. Germanotta et al. The complaint alleges: "Lady Gaga, her music labels, and one of the musicians who allegedly wrote 17 of Gaga's songs for her 'Born This Way' album are sued for copyright infringement, accused by Chicago composer and performing artist Rebecca Francescatti of using her 1999 copyright-protected work "Juda" in Gaga's Judas, purportedly via defendant Gaynor." [6]

Brian Joseph Gaynor, a member of DJ White Shadow, LLC, "collaborated with Lady Gaga in writing and producing 17 of 20 songs recorded" [7] on "Born This Way." Gaynor was the recording engineer and mixer for Rebecca F.'s album "It's All About You," which included the song "Juda. [4] "

"Judas" and Jennifer Lopez's "Invading My Mind"

Francescatti's law team entered evidence in December 2012 that Gaga used an additional unlicensed sample in "Judas" and then incorporated it into "Invading My Mind". They claimed that Lady Gaga asked Jennifer Lopez for a credit on "Invading My Mind" to "cover her tracks", suggesting that she did not even contribute to the song.

Francescatti's team claimed to "uncover text messages between Gaga and RedOne proving that she had stolen the sample loop used in both 'Judas' and 'Invading My Mind'". [8]

Summary judgment

In June 2014, Federal Judge Marvin Aspen (b. 1934) dismissed the lawsuit without trial through an award of Summary Judgment for lacking "ordinary observer" qualities:

The differences [between the two songs] so outweigh the purported similarities between the melodies that they cannot be said to be even remotely similar ... We agree with Defendants that the songs do not have common lyrics, the themes are different, and they do not sound at all alike musically ... Thus, we find the similarity of expression to be, quite clearly, ‘totally lacking.’ The (two songs) are so utterly dissimilar that reasonable minds could not differ as to a lack of substantial similarity between them. [9]

Judge Aspen ruled for the Plaintiff (Francescatti) that a reasonable juror could find that Germanotta had access to Francescatti's work. The judge described this "channel of communication" between the parties as a "nexus". He concludes that bassist Brian Gaynor worked on Francescatti's song before collaborating with Lady Gaga:

Although the parties dispute that Gaynor ever came into direct contact with Gaga, it is undisputed that Gaynor worked on the Francescatti Song ["Juda"] before he collaborated with Blair on material for Gaga's Born This Way album and that Gaynor and Blair received credit for contributions to the same album. [10]

Therefore Judge Aspen denied Germanotta et al.'s argument that there was no access between the parties. [11]

Judge Aspen concluded that certain elements of the Plaintiff's song that were alleged and argued to be points of infringement actually constituted evidence that Lady Gaga independently created Judas. Judge Aspen wrote:

Even if the expressions were similar, they are not protectable. First, the title of the Francescatti Song is not protectable. ...The word "Juda" is found in 243 song titles, and the word "Judas" is found in 2,139 song titles ... Moreover, the evidence suggests independent creation. ... The title "Juda" reflects Francescatti's relationship with an acquaintance and the betrayal of her father whereas "Judas" was inspired by Gaga's feelings toward a former boyfriend... Second, repetition of the songs' respective titles in the lyrics is unprotectable. ... ("Repetition is ubiquitous in popular music.") ... Many musicians have repeated a title lyric, and in particular "Juda" and "Judas," in songs that predate the two songs at issue here. ... In fact, Gaga herself on prior occasions has repeated her titles in her lyrics [e.g. in Alejandro, Poker Face and Bad Romance ]. ... Where an allegedly copied element of a work appears in the defendant's prior works, the presumption is that the defendant copied that element from herself, not the plaintiff.... Repetition of the titles in the songs' lyrics is therefore an unoriginal, unprotectable element." [10]

Responses to dismissal

One of the attorneys for Lady Gaga made the following statement:

Lady Gaga and her team are pleased that the court concluded, after a thorough analysis, that the lawsuit lacked any basis in law or fact." [12]

In a statement following Judge Aspen's ruling, Francescatti said her plight had been a "David versus Goliath struggle". [13]

Though I’m disappointed, I’m proud that I stood up for federally protected rights as a songwriter. Unfortunately this particular judge did not agree with my position. ... Throughout history, it’s been very difficult for individuals to go up against corporations and corporate interests. However I remain firm in my belief that I was correct to exercise my right to copyright protection afforded me in this fine country. [13]

Rolling Stone music writer Daniel Kreps observed:

Whenever music copycat cases like this land in the courtroom, it's extremely rare for the judge to side with the plagiarized party. [14]

Lady Gaga sues Rebecca F. for $1.4 million

In September 2014 Lady Gaga filed court documents to collect $1.4 million from Rebecca Francescatti (Rebecca F.). [15] The singer "claim[s] back close to $1.4 million that she paid her lawyers over the course of the three year case" and "has requested Rebecca foot the staggering bill." [16]

Rebecca F.'s response to the lawsuit, "Why You Should Care that Lady Gaga is Suing Me for $1.4 Million Dollars" [17] elucidates her copyright infringement allegations for the first time. In November 2014 she was forced to remove the essay from her website.

Harassment

Harassment of the "Juda" songwriter has been ongoing since August 2011. In response, Rebecca F. wrote and posted the YouTube single "I Don't Believe In Monsters" featuring snapshots of bullying comments, including death threats. [1] [18]

In an interview for her four-song self-released EP "It's All About You," F. said:

"Looking around, I sometimes feel like our current culture is built on exclusion. One group of people is "cool" or "hot" precisely because it does not include another group of people. Needless to say, I think that since we're all humans, we belong in the same group. I like the idea of inclusion, so maybe that's what you're hearing in the lyrics. [3]

Related Research Articles

<span class="mw-page-title-main">Happy Birthday to You</span> Birthday song

"Happy Birthday to You", or simply "Happy Birthday", is a song traditionally sung to celebrate a person's birthday. According to the 1998 Guinness World Records, it is the most recognized song in the English language, followed by "For He's a Jolly Good Fellow". The song's base lyrics have been translated into at least 18 languages. The melody of "Happy Birthday to You" comes from the song "Good Morning to All", which has traditionally been attributed to American sisters Patty and Mildred J. Hill in 1893, although the claim that the sisters composed the tune is disputed.

<i>Steinberg v. Columbia Pictures Industries, Inc.</i> 1987 lawsuit

Steinberg v. Columbia Pictures Industries, Inc., 663 F. Supp. 706 was a federal case in which artist Saul Steinberg sued various parties involved with producing and promoting the 1984 movie Moscow on the Hudson, claiming that a promotional poster for the movie infringed his copyright in a magazine cover, View of the World from 9th Avenue, he had created for The New Yorker.

<span class="mw-page-title-main">Beautiful, Dirty, Rich</span> 2008 promotional single by Lady Gaga

"Beautiful, Dirty, Rich" is a song by American singer–songwriter Lady Gaga from her debut studio album, The Fame (2008). It was released as a promotional single from the album on September 16, 2008. Written by the singer and its producer Rob Fusari in 2006, it is an uptempo dance-pop and disco-funk song that makes heavy use of synthesizers. The lyrics focus on Gaga's experiences as a struggling artist in the Lower East Side.

Music plagiarism is the use or close imitation of another author's music while representing it as one's own original work. Plagiarism in music now occurs in two contexts—with a musical idea or sampling. For a legal history of the latter see sampling.

<span class="mw-page-title-main">Marvin Aspen</span> American judge (born 1934)

Marvin E. Aspen is a senior United States district judge of the United States District Court for the Northern District of Illinois.

<i>Lady Gaga: Queen of Pop</i> 2010 biography by Emily Herbert

Lady Gaga: Queen of Pop is a biography of American singer Lady Gaga. It was written by Emily Herbert and published in the United Kingdom by John Blake Publishing Ltd. The book was published by Overlook Press in the United States with the title Lady Gaga: Behind the Fame. Additional versions under the title Lady Gaga: Queen of Pop were published in 2010 by Wilkinson Publishing of Melbourne in Australia and by Gardners Books in the United Kingdom. The book discusses Gaga's early life when she was known as Stefani Joanne Angelina Germanotta from her birth in 1986, and chronicles her education at Convent of the Sacred Heart in New York, her early visits to nightclubs with her mother to perform at open-mic events, and her brief foray into the Tisch School of the Arts, leading up to her first experience of fame. Germanotta took the name "Lady Gaga" from the song "Radio Ga Ga" by the rock group Queen; she released her first album The Fame in 2008. Lady Gaga: Queen of Pop describes the musician's success in the industry, noting her business collaborations and appearance on the cover of Rolling Stone in 2009.

"Teeth" is a song recorded by American singer Lady Gaga. The track appears on The Fame Monster (2009), her second major release and her third EP. The song was written by Gaga, Taja Riley, Pete Wyoming Bender, and Teddy Riley, and produced by Gaga and Teddy Riley. It has an oral theme and has been called a "perverse" march and an ode to sadomasochism. "Teeth" peaked at number 107 on the UK Singles Chart and received a mixed reception from critics. Gaga performed the song during The Monster Ball Tour (2009–2011) and her 2017 Coachella set. In 2013, Riley sued Gaga for US$500,000 and punitive damages over the songwriting credits, saying he was not given 25 percent of royalties as he had been promised.

<span class="mw-page-title-main">Judas (Lady Gaga song)</span> 2011 single by Lady Gaga

"Judas" is a song by American singer Lady Gaga, recorded for her second studio album, Born This Way (2011). It was released by Interscope Records on April 15, 2011, as the second single from the album. Written and produced by Lady Gaga and Nadir "RedOne" Khayat, it is an electro house song about a woman in love with a man who betrayed her. It embodies the incidents that have haunted Gaga in the past, and its core meaning refers to the negative parts of her life that she cannot escape. Gaga has further explained that the song was also about honoring one's inner darkness in order to bring oneself into the light. The artwork for the single was designed by Gaga in Microsoft Word. In spite of a polarizing impact on several religious groups, the song was generally well received by critics, who likened the song to "Bad Romance" with some noting it should have been the album's lead single.

<span class="mw-page-title-main">Hair (Lady Gaga song)</span> 2011 promotional single by Lady Gaga

"Hair" is a song recorded by American singer Lady Gaga for her second studio album, Born This Way (2011). Written and produced by herself and Nadir "RedOne" Khayat, "Hair" was released worldwide digitally on May 16, 2011, as a promotional single from the album, as part of the iTunes Store's "Countdown to Born This Way" release. This was after the previous promotional release, "The Edge of Glory", was made the third single from the album.

"Government Hooker" is a song by American singer Lady Gaga from her second studio album, Born This Way (2011). Gaga co-wrote and co-produced the song with Fernando Garibay and DJ White Shadow, with additional production of DJ Snake. "Government Hooker" was a previously unused demo track Shadow had produced with DJ Snake. Recording sessions took place in 2010 at the Studio at the Palms in Las Vegas, Nevada.

<span class="mw-page-title-main">Bloody Mary (song)</span> 2022 single by Lady Gaga

"Bloody Mary" is a song by American singer Lady Gaga recorded for her second studio album Born This Way (2011). Gaga, Fernando Garibay, and Paul "DJ White Shadow" Blair wrote and produced it; Clinton Sparks also received a producer credit. "Bloody Mary" is an electropop song with elements of synth-pop and trance, and features Gregorian chants. Although the song's title is an epithet mostly associated with the English queen Mary Tudor, Gaga assumes the role of biblical figure Mary Magdalene in its lyrics, whom she considered a "feminine force" she had worshiped since her childhood in a Catholic girls school. It is one of several tracks on the album with religious themes.

"Invading My Mind" is a song recorded by American entertainer Jennifer Lopez for her seventh studio album Love? (2011). It was written by RedOne, AJ Junior, BeatGeek, Teddy Sky, Bilal "The Chef", Jimmy Joker and produced by RedOne, Lopez, Lady Gaga, BeatGeek, Jimmy Joker and Kuk Harrell. "Invading My Mind" is an uptempo song that speaks of being overcome with a feeling that's "attacking, invading my mind".

"Electric Chapel" is a song recorded by American singer Lady Gaga for her second studio album, Born This Way (2011). Written and produced by Gaga and DJ White Shadow, the recording premiered on Facebook gaming app FarmVille, as did the album's fifth single, "Marry the Night". Gaga revealed on Twitter that "Electric Chapel" was written in Australia and finished on her tour bus in Europe. She recorded it channeling the vocals of bands like Duran Duran, and singers Cher and Billy Idol.

"Artpop" is a song by American singer Lady Gaga from her third studio album of the same name. She co-wrote and co-produced the song with Paul "DJ White Shadow" Blair, Nick Monson, and Dino Zisis. "Artpop" was the first song developed for the album and led the composers to pursue other avenues of musical production. Described as the backbone of the record, Gaga did not want to experiment with the production of "Artpop", as she believed it to have an infinite aspect in it.

"Aura" is a song recorded by American singer Lady Gaga for her third studio album, Artpop (2013). She co-wrote and co-produced the track with Zedd and the psychedelic trance duo Infected Mushroom. Initially entitled "Burqa", an Infected Mushroom demo is the song's backbone. "Aura", which explores different facets of the singer, is a mariachi and EDM song with Western guitar and Middle Eastern musical influences and a dance production. Lyrically, it equates the life of a celebrity and stardom with religious oppression and subjugation.

Jennifer Nelson is an American documentary filmmaker, based in New York, known for successfully suing the company Warner/Chappell Music for false claims of copyright to the song "Happy Birthday to You", thereby clarifying its public domain status in the US.

<span class="mw-page-title-main">Joanne (Lady Gaga song)</span> 2017 single by Lady Gaga

"Joanne" is a song recorded by American singer Lady Gaga from her fifth studio album of the same name. It was released as the album's third official single on December 22, 2017 in Italy, and a piano version, titled "Joanne ", followed in the rest of the world on January 26, 2018. The track was written and produced by Gaga and Mark Ronson, with additional production from BloodPop. Inspired by the singer's late aunt, Joanne Germanotta, the song became a focal point for the musical direction of the album. Gaga intended the song to have a healing effect for those dealing with loss and pain.

"Why Did You Do That?" is a song recorded by American singer Lady Gaga for the 2018 film A Star Is Born and released on the soundtrack of the same name. It was written by Gaga with Diane Warren, Mark Nilan Jr., Nick Monson and Paul "DJWS" Blair, and produced by all but Warren. The song appears in the film during a sequence when Gaga's character, Ally, performs on Saturday Night Live, watched by her husband Jackson. Later Jackson berates Ally for selling out with the song's trite lyrics, but she defends it. "Why Did You Do That?" was written to evoke both a retro and a modern feel, and was recorded while Gaga was on her Joanne World Tour.

<span class="mw-page-title-main">Free Woman</span> 2021 single by Lady Gaga

"Free Woman" is a song by American singer and songwriter Lady Gaga recorded for her sixth studio album Chromatica (2020). Gaga co-wrote it with the song's producers BloodPop, Axwell and Johannes Klahr. "Free Woman" was released as the album's fifth track, several weeks after a high-quality demo version of the song was leaked onto the Internet. It is a Eurohouse and Eurodance song that draws influences from the music of the 1990s. Gaga was inspired by her real life events; the song talks about her coping with post-traumatic stress disorder (PTSD), from which she suffered after being sexually assaulted by a music producer. Gaga also wanted to celebrate her LGBT+ fans; she wrote the song especially with the trans community in mind. The song's lyrics talk about reclaiming one's identity and answer the question "what does it mean to be a free woman?".

References

  1. 1 2 "Artist Suing Lady Gaga Says She's Getting Death Threats". NBC Chicago. 2013-01-18. Retrieved 2013-10-16.
  2. ↑ "Meme | Definition of Meme by Merriam-Webster". Merriam-Webster . 24 December 2023.
  3. 1 2 3 Augustyn, Allison (February 9, 2006). "Memes Spread Sound". Pioneer Press.
  4. 1 2 https://web.archive.org/web/20131112051036/http://mcir.usc.edu/inplay/Documents/Gaga%20Complaint.pdf. Archived from the original (PDF) on November 12, 2013.{{cite web}}: Missing or empty |title= (help)
  5. ↑ "Francescatti v. Germanotta et al". Justia Dockets & Filings. Retrieved 2013-10-16.
  6. ↑ Justia Dockets & Filing entry on the 2011 lawsuit
  7. ↑ "Courthouse News Service". Courthouse News Service. Archived from the original on February 18, 2011.
  8. ↑ Daniels, Colin (January 17, 2013). "Jennifer Lopez dragged into Lady GaGa 'Judas' plagiarism lawsuit". Digital Spy. Hachette Filipacchi Médias. Retrieved January 19, 2013.
  9. ↑ "Lady Gaga didn't rip off Chicago musician, federal judge rules". Chicago Tribune. 2014-06-18.
  10. 1 2 FRANCESCATTI v. GERMANOTT | No. 11 CV 5270. | 20140618a52 | Leagle.com
  11. ↑ Johnson, Ted (2014-06-18). "Lady Gaga's 'Judas' Didn't Rip Off Songwriter's 'Juda,' Federal Judge Rules". Variety.
  12. ↑ "Lady Gaga attorney applauds federal judge's ruling". Chicago Tribune. 2014-06-18.
  13. 1 2 "Chicago - Chicago : News : Politics : Things To Do : Sports". Chicago Sun-Times. Archived from the original on 2014-10-05. Retrieved 2014-06-21.
  14. ↑ "Lady Gaga '"Judas"' Plagiarism Lawsuit Dismissed – Rolling Stone". Rolling Stone .
  15. ↑ "Lady Gaga -- Attacks Songwriter Who Sued Her ... with a Vengeance | TMZ.com". TMZ .
  16. ↑ http://entertainment.xin.msn.com/en/celebrity/buzz/hollywood/lady-gaga-claims-dollar14m-from-plagiarism-lawsuit%5B%5D
  17. ↑ WHY YOU SHOULD CARE THAT LADY GAGA'S SUING ME FOR $1.4 MILLION | Rebecca F.
  18. ↑ "Lady Gaga-Rebecca Francescatti Lawsuit: Chicago Artist Suing Star Says She's Getting Death Threats". Huffington Post. 2013-01-18. Retrieved 2013-03-05.
This page is based on this Wikipedia article
Text is available under the CC BY-SA 4.0 license; additional terms may apply.
Images, videos and audio are available under their respective licenses.