 | |||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||
| Date | December 13, 1991 | ||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||
|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| Venue | Convention Hall, Atlantic City, New Jersey, U.S. | ||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||
| Title(s) on the line | IBF middleweight title | ||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||
| Tale of the tape | |||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||
| |||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||
| Result | |||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||
| Split draw (115–113, 112–116, 114–114) | |||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||
James Toney vs. Mike McCallum was a professional boxing match contested on December 13, 1991, for the IBF middleweight title. [1]
Promoter Bob Arum, looking to begin the process of unifying the three major world titles in order to crown an undisputed middleweight champion, organized a unification bout between reigning IBF middleweight champion James Toney and WBA middleweight champion Mike McCallum. However, these plans were derailed when the WBA stepped in, refused to sanction Toney–McCallum fight and ordered that McCallum instead defend his title against mandatory challenger Steve Collins, whom McCallum had soundly defeated the previous year. McCallum asked the WBA for an exception to purse Toney, but the WBA requested McCallum pay them $30,000 from his purse, an additional $35,000 for an exception fee and finally $50,000 to Collins' manager in order for them to allow him to face Toney first. [2] McCallum declined the WBA's terms and instead opted to continue on with his fight against Toney, allowing the WBA to strip him of the title. [3] The vacant WBA middleweight title would be decided the following April with the number-one ranked Collins facing number-two contender Reggie Johnson with Johnson winning by majority decision. [4]
In a closely contested fight, Toney and McCallum fought to a split draw with one judge scoring the fight in Toney's favor 116–112, the other scoring the fight for McCallum 115–113 and the third scoring it even 114–114. Though the fight was close, Toney seemed to land the harder punches, especially in the later rounds, while McCallum was effective in the early portion of the fight and had a lead on two of the scorecards before Toney rallied to take the final three rounds to secure a draw and keep his title. Toney came close to ending the fight in the 12th and final round, hammering McCallum twice with left hooks that dislodged McCallum's mouthpiece and left him on wobbly legs, though McCallum was able to survive the round. The two fighters were almost even in landed punches, with McCallum scoring 343 of his 890 thrown punches and Toney landing 340 of his 823 punches. [5]
At the post-fight press conference, an altercation erupted between Toney and McCallum's lawyer Milt Chawsky. After Bob Arum suggested Toney had been robbed by the judges, Chawsky took exception telling Arum "I'm not going to let you disrespect my fighter." Toney, taking exception to Chawsky's interjection exchanged words with Chawsky and had to be restrained by security to prevent him from physically confronting him. [6] A rematch between Toney and McCallum would take place the following year on August 29, 1992.
Confirmed bouts: [7]
| Weight Class | Weight | vs. | Method | Round | Notes | ||
|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| Middleweight | 160 lbs. | James Toney | vs. | Mike McCallum | D | 12/12 | Note 1 |
| Welterweight | 147 lbs. | Charles Murray | def | Livingstone Bramble | UD | 10/10 | |
| Super Middleweight | 168 lbs. | Bernard Hopkins | def. | Willie Kemp | UD | 10/10 | |
| Heavyweight | 200+ lbs. | Riddick Bowe | def. | Elijah Tillery | TKO | 4/10 |
| Country | Broadcaster |
|---|---|
 United Kingdom | Sky Sports |
 United States | HBO |
James Nathaniel Toney is an American former professional boxer who competed from 1988 to 2017. He held multiple world championships in three weight classes, including the International Boxing Federation (IBF) and lineal middleweight titles from 1991 to 1993, the IBF super middleweight title from 1993 to 1994, and the IBF cruiserweight title in 2003. Toney also challenged twice for a world heavyweight title in 2005 and 2006, and was victorious the first time but was later stripped due to a failed drug test. Overall, he competed in fifteen world title fights across four weight classes.
Mike McCallum is a Jamaican former professional boxer who competed from 1981 to 1997. He held world championships in three weight classes, including the WBA super welterweight title from 1984 to 1988, the WBA middleweight title from 1989 to 1991, and the WBC light heavyweight title from 1994 to 1995.
Stephen Collins is an Irish former professional boxer who competed from 1986 to 1997. Known as the Celtic Warrior, Collins is the most successful male Irish boxer in recent professional boxing history, having held the WBO middleweight and super-middleweight titles simultaneously and never losing a fight as champion.
Reggie Dwayne Johnson is an American former professional boxer who competed from 1984 to 2008. He is a two-weight world champion, having held the WBA middleweight title from 1992 to 1993, and the IBF light heavyweight title from 1998 to 1999.
Artur Asilbekovich Beterbiev is a Russian and Canadian professional boxer. He has held the undisputed championship in the light-heavyweight division since October 2024, as well as the Ring magazine and International Boxing Organization (IBO) titles.
Chris Byrd vs. Evander Holyfield was a professional boxing match contested on December 14, 2002 for the vacant IBF heavyweight championship.
John Ruiz vs. Roy Jones Jr., billed as Never Take A Heavyweight Lightly, was a professional boxing match contested on March 1, 2003 for the WBA heavyweight championship. The fight took place at the Thomas & Mack Center on the campus of UNLV in Paradise, Nevada.
James Toney vs. Roy Jones Jr., billed as The Uncivil War, was a professional boxing match held on November 18, 1994, for the IBF super middleweight championship.
Roy Jones Jr. vs. Mike McCallum, billed as Fire on Ice, was a professional boxing match contested on November 22, 1996 for the interim WBC light heavyweight championship. It was Jones' first fight in the light heavyweight division.
John Ruiz vs. James Toney was a professional boxing match contested on April 30, 2005, for the WBA heavyweight championship.
Evander Holyfield vs. James Toney, billed as "The War on October 4", was a professional boxing match contested on October 4, 2003.
Thomas Hearns vs. James Kinchen was a professional boxing match contested on November 4, 1988, for the NABF and the inaugural WBO super middleweight titles.
Darrin Van Horn vs. Iran Barkley, billed as Champions and Olympians was a professional boxing match contested on January 10, 1992, for the IBF super middleweight title.
Iran Barkley vs. James Toney, billed as Two Angry Men, was a professional boxing match contested on February 13, 1993, for the IBF super middleweight title.
Michael Nunn vs. James Toney, billed as Rumble on the Riverbank, was a professional boxing match contested on May 10, 1991, for the IBF middleweight title.
Michael Nunn vs. Sumbu Kalambay, billed as Premier Battle, was a professional boxing match contested on March 25, 1989, for the IBF middleweight title. The fight won The Ring magazine's inaugural knockout of the year award for 1989.
Michael Nunn vs. Marlon Starling was a professional boxing match contested on April 14, 1990, for the IBF middleweight title.
Frank Tate vs. Michael Nunn, billed as Power Struggle, was a professional boxing match contested on July 28, 1988, for the IBF middleweight title.
James Toney vs. Mike McCallum II, billed as Once Is Not Enough, was a professional boxing match contested on August 29, 1992, for the IBF middleweight title.
Jimmi Bredahl vs. Oscar De La Hoya was a professional boxing match contested on March 5, 1994 for the WBO super featherweight title.