Charles Lambert Flynn | |
---|---|
Born | August 23, 1966 [1] |
Died | April 4, 1989 (age 22) |
Nationality | American |
Other names | Chip |
On April 4, 1989, 22-year-old Charles Lambert "Chip" Flynn was killed by his ex-girlfriend Kim Hallock in Brevard County, Florida. Flynn died from a gunshot wound. Hallock claims that an African-American man named Crosley Alexander Green was responsible for Flynn's death. Green was found guilty of Flynn's murder and placed on death row. He was eventually removed from death row. After having his conviction vacated by federal court in 2018, Green was released from prison on house arrest, pending the 11th Circuit Court of Appeals decision to either retry or overturn his conviction based on the prosecutors withholding evidence in his original trial. Green's conviction was reinstated in March 2022. [2]
Before the killing, Flynn had just exited a relationship with Kim Hallock. Hallock was hurt by the split. [3] Flynn was also living with his parents and was in a relationship. [4] Green was a minor drug dealer who had just been recently released from Madison Correctional Institution having been convicted of robbery. [4] [5] He was also the carer for his family after his parents died. [4]
On April 3, 1989, around 10:00, Hallock encountered Charles Flynn at her house. [4] They would later drive to a park in Mims, Florida where they would smoke marijuana and have sex. [6] [5] Later at the local baseball field, Holder Park, Hallock and Flynn were sitting in his truck, when Hallock says she notified Flynn of Crosley Green's presence, to which, she says, he rolled up the windows. [4] According to Hallock, Green was armed at the time. [4] Hallock would also take out the gun in the glove compartment and place it near her. [4] Green then reportedly tied Flynn's hands with a shoelace, forced Hallock to give him money and drove them to a Florida citrus grove, all while holding a gun on Hallock and Flynn. [4] Hallock stated that they were robbed at 11:00 and taken to the grove in Flynn's truck at 12:10. [3] Hallock asserted that Flynn attempted to plead with Green, asking that he let Hallock go. [7] She said that Green forced them to keep their heads down as he drove, [7] and that while crouching she attempted to untie Flynn's restraints. [7]
By Hallock's account, after they reached the grove Green removed Hallock from the truck and verbally abused her, such as calling her a slut. [4] [7] According to her statement, Flynn, hands still tied, retrieved the gun from the car and fired "five or six gunshots." [4] Hallock, unaware if Flynn shot Green, [7] fled the scene; driving three miles, past a hospital, a pay phone, the house she shared with her parents and other houses before arriving to the house of a friend of Flynn's—David Stroup—to call for help. [4] [8]
Around 40 minutes after fleeing the scene, Hallock called the police at 01:13. [3] The officers dispatched to the scene were two Brevard County officers, sergeant Diane Clark and deputy Mark Rixey. [3] Due to the unclear directions given by Hallock, it took them 30 minutes to find Flynn; they initially went to the wrong location. [3] Clarke had sent another deputy to gain relevant information from her, in response to which she was reportedly uncooperative. [3]
Upon arriving at the grove, Clarke and Rixey found Flynn. His hands were tied, and he had a single gunshot wound to the chest. [3] The first words he said to them were "Get me outta here. I wanna go home." At no point did he mention a robbery or an assailant. [3] During two separate occasions Flynn stopped breathing while they waited for an ambulance. Clarke, in response, tried to resuscitate him. [3] Flynn died before the ambulance arrived. [4] [lower-alpha 1] Flynn's parents soon arrived at the scene, but police did not let them intervene. [3]
At the scene, there was no obvious evidence of a third party. Only fingerprints belonging to Hallock and Flynn were discovered, the only gun found was the one belonging to Flynn, no gunshot residue was seen on Flynn's hands, and the only bullet found was the one that killed him, [10] [11] which may have originated from his own gun. [11]
After Hallock gave a recorded statement to police in which she identified the assailant as a black man and after receiving a tip from a friend of Flynn's—Tim Curtis—the police's prime suspect became Green. [3] [4] [12] Curtis would later admit to lying about knowing Green to be the killer. [12]
Hallock was later shown a photo lineup of six photos (Green included). Green's photo was smaller and darker than the other pictures and positioned so "that your eyes are normally drawn to are right in the middle", according to Green's appellate attorney. [4] Despite Hallock only being "pretty sure" Green was the suspect she managed to identify him. [5] Green was arrested on June 8, 1989, and charged with kidnapping, robbery and murder. [4] [5]
During the trial, which took place from August to September 1989, [5] prosecutors displayed shoeprints which they attributed to Green. Assistant State's Attorney Christopher White, who put forward the claim, stated that a police dog alerted them of the scent of those prints and they tracked that scent to the vicinity of a house where Crosley Green sometimes stayed. [4] According to Green's first appellate attorneys, White could not produce any evidence of these claims, and no fingerprints, fibers, hair or blood originating from Green were found at the scene. [4] [13] The attorneys also said that the shoeprints were later found to be one size larger than Green wore, and the shoeprint did not match the actual shoe tread found at the scene. [13] It would later be revealed that exculpatory evidence had not been turned over to the defense, a potential violation of the defendant's Brady rights. [5]
Later on in the trial, prosecutors put forward three witnesses who claimed Crosley had confessed to them. [4] One of the accusers was Crosley Green's own sister, Sheila Green. Sheila would later recant her statement, saying that she was pressured to commit perjury by police who threatened to never let her see her children again. The other accusers shared similar stories, as they also recanted later on. [4] [5] One witness in support of Green was put forward. [3]
Green was offered a plea deal in which he would admit guilt and receive no more than 22 years. He refused to take the deal, asserting that he did not kill Charles Flynn. On September 5, 1990, after 3 hours of deliberation, the all-white jury found Green guilty of first-degree murder; he was later sentenced to death. [4] [9] In 2019, the U.S. Middle District Court of Florida deemed this ruling to be unconstitutional. [8]
In April 1993, Defense attorney Rob Parker filed a motion for a new trial. This motion was denied, [5] as Green's conviction was upheld by the Florida Supreme Court in 1994. [13]
In the early summer of 1999, Chicago investigator Paul Ciolino and four other investigators began to review the case (without pay) and interview witnesses, jurors, and others connected to the case, per request of Nan Webb, a Viera housewife and anti-death penalty activist. [5] [9] They had previously made contact with Webb in 1996. [9] Ciolino would meet with Assistant State's Attorney Christopher White and Brevard County Sheriff Phil Williams to discuss the case and aid in the investigation. [5] Ciolino and the investigators discovered evidence discounting the shoeprints and witness testimonies, [lower-alpha 2] and also learned that the truck which Green reportedly hijacked was a manual stick, which Green could not drive. [12] [13] Due to this evidence, the investigators were able to instigate an independent state investigation of the case. [13] [12]
In 2000, the state of Florida conducted their own investigation. In the investigation, they tested new items for the possibility of DNA. A report from CBS in the same year stated that no DNA evidence had been found that connected Green to the murder. [12] Later reports, however, found that weak DNA evidence found in the truck could have possibly originated with Green or a member of his family. [5] This evidence has been suggested to belong to Green's brother, O'Connor, a friend of Tim Curtis, who in turn was the previous owner of the vehicle. [3]
In 2002, Green's attorneys continued to appeal his case, hoping to win a new trial. In 2003, Green was given a hearing by Florida Judge Bruce Jacobus. In 2005, Green's death sentence was thrown out. This appeal was challenged by the Florida Supreme Court in June 2007. In October of that year, the Florida Supreme Court upheld Green's conviction but stated that he should be resentenced. Green received a life sentence the following year. In 2010, Green's attorneys again petitioned for a new trial. This petition was ultimately denied in 2011 despite two new alibi witnesses being brought forward. [5]
In January 2016, a petition for a new trial was declined due to allegedly missing a deadline. [4] Later that year, Green's attorneys filed a motion for a new trial, arguing that there existed evidence of prosecutorial misconduct. [5] U.S. District Judge Roy Dalton Jr. denied the claim, saying it was time-barred. In 2017, Green's attorneys won an appeal with the 11th Circuit Court of Appeals, stating that Dalton's ruling was illegitimate because of a technicality. [5] In 2018, Green was given a new trial due to prosecutor Christopher White withholding evidence from Green's main attorneys. [5] This trial was appealed by the State of Florida and ultimately halted. [11] In December 2019, Florida Today reported that Green had won a new trial. [5] They later reported that this trial was appealed. [8]
On March 12, 2020, Green's and state attorneys discussed with the US Court of Appeals if the lower court order for a new trial will be upheld. [14] Green's case was expected to be reviewed by a panel of the 11th Circuit, U. S. Court of Appeals sometime in late 2020. [11]
Crosley Alexander Green | |
---|---|
Born | September 11, 1957 |
Criminal charge | First-Degree murder |
Penalty | Death; commuted to life imprisonment with the possibility of parole |
Nationality | American |
Relatives | 7 [3] |
Since his arrest, Green has repeatedly declared his innocence. [13] Upon being questioned by police for the murder of Flynn, Green stated that he watched a baseball game at Holder Park and was at his girlfriend's house and a party on the night in question. [3] [13] [9] Green again restated his innocence in interviews conduct by CBS News in 2015 and 2020. [15] [16] Since his conviction Green's Attorney's have found alibi witnesses willing to corroborate Green's story. Assistant State's Attorney Christopher White however raised questions of their credibility. [4] In 2020 Defense attorney Jeane Thomas stated that there exists at least eight alibi witnesses who can support Green being at the party. [3]
Many other people have come out in support of Green as well. Paul Ciolino, a private investigator hired to prove Green's innocence, believes that he is, in fact, innocent and that "Crosley Green is systematic of the problem we have with the death penalty with this country". [9] Tim Curtis, who first accused Green of being the killer, is now convinced of his innocence. [12] Private detective Joe Moura also believes Green to be innocent. Stating that there is no evidence to tie Green to the murder, Seth Miller, who leads the Innocence Project of Florida, has stated that there is "clear evidence of [Green's] innocence". [4]
Sergeant. J. Wallace of Hardee Correctional Institution, while not calling Green innocent, did state that he doesn't think "Mr. Green poses any threat to society". [8]
Green's remaining family has come out in support of him. [3]
Many questions have arisen regarding the story put forward by police. One focus is on Green's ability to drive the car while holding Hallock and Flynn at gunpoint. Ciolino further elaborated on this point by saying:
"Crosley Green, who allegedly abducts [these] people in this truck, drives this truck, shifts this truck, turns the lights on in the truck, is touching the glass on the truck, is touching the right fender, touching the left fender; there is no fingerprints, there is no footprints...Unless Crosley Green is Casper the ghost in disguise, then he couldn't have committed this crime." [12]
Curtis shared a similar sentiment, saying that "You cannot get in that truck and take off without it stalling," and that "You had to grab the truck literally to climb up in it. It wasn't like an automobile. You had to open the door and climb up in it. You couldn't do it without putting your hands on the truck. Impossible." [12] During Ciolino's investigation, he raised more questions, asking, "How could you come out of this truck with your hands tied behind your back, firing a weapon?". [12] Rob Parker, Green's defense attorney, also questioned how Hallock would've been able to identify Green when the scene was pitch black, and Hallock saw him for no more than 30 seconds. [12]
Significantly, the story which Hallock gave to police had several inconsistencies and subsequent alterations to it. In her statement to police, Hallock described Green as having long, Jheri-curled hair which covered his ears. [4] [12] Green at the time had a buzz cut. [12] She described the gun allegedly used by Green as a semi-automatic despite no shell casing being found at the scene. [11] She reported that Green made her tie Flynn's hands, then later claimed that Green did the tying by himself. [11] She reported hearing five to six gunshots, yet the only bullet found was in the victim's chest, and no shell casings were recovered. [4]
Kim Hallock was never treated as a suspect, and as such never underwent basic procedures such as being checked for gunshot residue, being photographed for injuries, or having her clothes collected. [3] [15] The first responders, Police officers Diane Clarke and Mark Rixey, believe her to likely be responsible for Flynn's death. [11] Clarke and Rixely have noted Hallock's behavior after the shooting, the lack of physical evidence tying Green to the crime scene, the only bullet found at the scene and Flynn's comments upon their arrival. [5] [lower-alpha 3] Assistant State's Attorney Christopher White denied these claims but admits that further examination could have been done. [15] [16]
Both White and Clarke have suggested that possibility of the shooting being an accident committed by Hallock, followed by a cover story concocted by her and her erstwhile boyfriend. [4]
Robert Baltovich is a Canadian man who was wrongly convicted in 1992 of the murder of his girlfriend, Elizabeth Bain, in Scarborough, Ontario, Canada. He spent eight years in prison and nearly another decade trying to clear his name, before being found not guilty in a retrial on April 22, 2008.
Barry Michael George is an English man who was found guilty of the murder of English television presenter Jill Dando and whose conviction was overturned on appeal.
The M25 Three were Raphael Rowe, Michael George Davis, and Randolph Egbert Johnson, who were jailed for life at the Old Bailey in March 1990 after being wrongfully convicted of murder and burglary. The name was taken from the location of the crimes, which were committed around the M25, London's orbital motorway, during the early hours of 16 December 1988. The original trial took place between January and February 1990, resulting in all three being convicted of the murder of Peter Hurburgh, causing grievous bodily harm with intent to Timothy Napier and several robberies. Each was sentenced to life imprisonment for the murder and given substantial sentences for the other offences. The convictions were overturned in July 2000. All three men have consistently maintained their innocence.
Anthony Porter was a Chicago resident known for having been exonerated in 1999 of the murder in 1982 of two teenagers on the South Side of the city. He was convicted and sentenced to death in 1983, and served 17 years on death row. He was exonerated following introduction of new evidence by Northwestern University professors and students from the Medill School of Journalism as part of their investigation for the school's Innocence Project. Porter's appeals had been repeatedly rejected, including by the US Supreme Court, and he was once 50 hours away from execution.
Wrongful execution is a miscarriage of justice occurring when an innocent person is put to death by capital punishment. Cases of wrongful execution are cited as an argument by opponents of capital punishment, while proponents say that the argument of innocence concerns the credibility of the justice system as a whole and does not solely undermine the use of the death penalty.
David Ray Camm is a former trooper of the Indiana State Police (ISP) who spent 13 years in prison after twice being wrongfully convicted of the murders of his wife, Kimberly, and his two young children at their home in Georgetown, Indiana, on September 28, 2000. He was released from custody in 2013 after his third trial resulted in an acquittal. Charles Boney is currently serving time for the murders of Camm's wife and two children.
This is a list of notable overturned convictions in the United States.
Walter "Johnny D." McMillian was a pulpwood worker from Monroeville, Alabama, who was wrongfully convicted of murder and sentenced to death. His conviction was wrongfully obtained, based on police coercion and perjury. In the 1988 trial, under a controversial Alabama doctrine called "judicial override", the judge imposed the death penalty, although the jury had voted for a sentence of life imprisonment.
Rolando Cruz is an American man known for having been wrongfully convicted and sentenced to death, along with co-defendant Alejandro Hernandez, for the 1983 kidnapping, rape, and murder of 10-year-old Jeanine Nicarico in DuPage County, Illinois. The police had no substantive physical evidence linking the two men to the crime. Their first trial was jointly in 1987, and their statements were used against each other and a third defendant.
The Commission on Proceedings Involving Guy Paul Morin—known as the Kaufman Commission or the Morin Inquiry—was a 1996 royal commission appointed by the Government of Ontario to address the wrongful conviction in 1992 of Guy Paul Morin for the murder of Christine Jessop on 3 October 1984, for which he was exonerated by DNA evidence on 23 January 1995.
Odin Leonardo John Lloyd was a semi-professional American football player who was murdered by Aaron Hernandez, a former tight end for the New England Patriots of the National Football League, in North Attleborough, Massachusetts, on June 17, 2013. Lloyd's death made international headlines following Hernandez's association with the investigation as a suspect. Lloyd had been a linebacker for a New England Football League (NEFL) semi-professional football team, the Boston Bandits, since 2007.
Ryan W. Ferguson is an American man who spent nearly 10 years in prison after being wrongfully convicted of a 2001 murder in his hometown of Columbia, Missouri. At the time of the murder, Ferguson was a 17-year-old high-school student.
Investigating Innocence is a nonprofit wrongful conviction advocacy organization that provides criminal defense investigations for inmates in the United States. Investigating Innocence was founded in 2013 by private investigator Bill Clutter to assist nationwide Innocence Project groups in investigating innocence claims. "Once we have a case that meets our criteria, we'll put private investigators to work on it. A lot of these cases need investigators," said Kelly Thompson, executive director of Investigating Innocence. Prior to his work on Investigating Innocence, Clutter was one of the founders of the Illinois Innocence Project. Investigating Innocence also has a board composed of exonerees that reviews incoming cases.
Barry Allan Beach is an American who was sentenced to 100 years in prison without parole in 1984 for the 1979 murder of Kimberly Nees in Poplar, Montana. During the years following his conviction, Beach gained support from influential state and national advocates who said his murder confession, the lynchpin of his conviction, was coerced. In 2015, his sentence was commuted to time served, plus ten years on probation.
Making a Murderer is an American true crime documentary television series written and directed by Laura Ricciardi and Moira Demos. The show tells the story of Steven Avery, a man from Manitowoc County, Wisconsin, who served 18 years in prison (1985–2003) after his wrongful conviction for the sexual assault and attempted murder of Penny Beerntsen. He was later charged with and convicted of the 2005 murder of Teresa Halbach. The connected story is that of Avery's nephew Brendan Dassey, who was accused and convicted as an accessory in the murder of Halbach.
Alissa Leanne Bjerkhoel is an American litigation coordinator at the California Innocence Project (CIP), a law school clinic that investigates cases of factual innocence while training law students. Bjerkhoel was born in Truckee, California, and later graduated from California Western School of Law (CWSL) after previously obtaining a B.A. degree She has been an attorney with CIP since 2008. Bjerkhoel has served as counsel for CIP on numerous criminal cases, and achieved the legal exoneration of a number of convicted prisoners. Bjerkhoel serves as CIP's in-house DNA expert and also serves as a panel attorney with the nonprofit law firms Appellate Defenders, Inc. (ADI) and Sixth District Appellate Program (SDAP). She is a member of the American Academy of Forensic Sciences. Bjerkhoel has won a number of awards.
On the night of September 6, 2018, 26-year-old accountant Botham Jean was murdered in Dallas, Texas, by off-duty Dallas Police Department patrol officer Amber Guyger, who entered Jean's apartment and fatally shot him. Guyger, who said that she had entered Jean's apartment believing it was her own and believed Jean to be a burglar, was initially charged with manslaughter. The absence of a murder charge led to protests and accusations of racial bias because Jean—an unarmed black man—was killed in his own home by a white off-duty officer who had apparently disregarded police protocols. On November 30, 2018, Guyger was indicted on a charge of murder. On October 1, 2019, she was found guilty of murder, and was sentenced to ten years' imprisonment the following day. The ruling was upheld on appeal in 2021.
Bill Clutter is an American private investigator, wrongful conviction advocate, and author. He is the co-founder of the Illinois Innocence Project and founder of the national wrongful conviction organization Investigating Innocence. His work on the Donaldson v. Central Illinois Public Service Company case led him to write the book Coal Tar: How Corrupt Politics and Corporate Greed Are Killing America's Children, which is the story of an epidemic of neuroblastoma in Taylorville, Illinois, caused by exposure to coal tar.
Christopher Vaughn is an American man convicted of the murder of his wife, Kimberly, and the couple's three children in June 14, 2007. All four members of the family were shot in their SUV while on the way to a Springfield, IL waterpark. Christopher sustained minor injuries to his wrist and leg while the other four sustained fatal gunshot wounds. Prosecutors alleged that he shot his family to live in the Canadian wilderness. Vaughn maintains his innocence and claims that Kimberly shot her family before committing suicide. Wrongful Conviction advocacy group Investigating Innocence is investigating the case.
Kevin Keith is an American prisoner and former death row inmate from Ohio who was convicted of the 1994 triple-homicide that killed Marichell Chatman, her daughter Marchae, and Linda Chatman. In 2022, his case received international attention due to claims of innocence and controversy surrounding his trial and conviction highlighted on a podcast hosted by Kim Kardashian titled The System: The Case of Kevin Keith.