Kirkendall effect

Last updated December 07, 2024

The Kirkendall effect is the motion of the interface between two metals that occurs due to the difference in diffusion rates of the metal atoms. The effect can be observed, for example, by placing insoluble markers at the interface between a pure metal and an alloy containing that metal, and heating to a temperature where atomic diffusion is reasonable for the given timescale; the boundary will move relative to the markers.

History

The Kirkendall effect was discovered by Ernest Kirkendall and Alice Smigelskas in 1947, in the course of Kirkendall's ongoing research into diffusion in brass.^[2] The paper in which he discovered the famous effect was the third in his series of papers on brass diffusion, the first being his thesis. His second paper revealed that zinc diffused more quickly than copper in alpha-brass, which led to the research producing his revolutionary theory. Until this point, substitutional and ring methods were the dominant ideas for diffusional motion. Kirkendall's experiment produced evidence of a vacancy diffusion mechanism, which is the accepted mechanism to this day. At the time it was submitted, the paper and Kirkendall's ideas were rejected from publication by Robert Franklin Mehl, director of the Metals Research Laboratory at Carnegie Institute of Technology (now Carnegie Mellon University). Mehl refused to accept Kirkendall's evidence of this new diffusion mechanism and denied publication for over six months, only relenting after a conference was held and several other researchers confirmed Kirkendall's results.^[2]

Kirkendall's experiment

A bar of brass (70% Cu, 30% Zn) was used as a core, with molybdenum wires stretched along its length, and then coated in a layer of pure copper. Molybdenum was chosen as the marker material due to it being very insoluble in brass, eliminating any error due to the markers diffusing themselves. Diffusion was allowed to take place at 785 °C over the course of 56 days, with cross-sections being taken at six times throughout the span of the experiment. Over time, it was observed that the wire markers moved closer together as the zinc diffused out of the brass and into the copper. A difference in location of the interface was visible in cross sections of different times. Compositional change of the material from diffusion was confirmed by x-ray diffraction.^[1]

Diffusion mechanism

Early diffusion models postulated that atomic motion in substitutional alloys occurs via a direct exchange mechanism, in which atoms migrate by switching positions with atoms on adjacent lattice sites.^[3] Such a mechanism implies that the atomic fluxes of two different materials across an interface must be equal, as each atom moving across the interface causes another atom to move across in the other direction.

Another possible diffusion mechanism involves lattice vacancies. An atom can move into a vacant lattice site, effectively causing the atom and the vacancy to switch places. If large-scale diffusion takes place in a material, there will be a flux of atoms in one direction and a flux of vacancies in the other.

The Kirkendall effect arises when two distinct materials are placed next to each other and diffusion is allowed to take place between them. In general, the diffusion coefficients of the two materials in each other are not the same. This is only possible if diffusion occurs by a vacancy mechanism; if the atoms instead diffused by an exchange mechanism, they would cross the interface in pairs, so the diffusion rates would be identical, contrary to observation. By Fick's 1st law of diffusion, the flux of atoms from the material with the higher diffusion coefficient will be larger, so there will be a net flux of atoms from the material with the higher diffusion coefficient into the material with the lower diffusion coefficient. To balance this flux of atoms, there will be a flux of vacancies in the opposite direction—from the material with the lower diffusion coefficient into the material with the higher diffusion coefficient—resulting in an overall translation of the lattice relative to the environment in the direction of the material with the lower diffusion constant.^[3]

Macroscopic evidence for the Kirkendall effect can be gathered by placing inert markers at the initial interface between the two materials, such as molybdenum markers at an interface between copper and brass. The diffusion coefficient of zinc is higher than the diffusion coefficient of copper in this case. Since zinc atoms leave the brass at a higher rate than copper atoms enter, the size of the brass region decreases as diffusion progresses. Relative to the molybdenum markers, the copper–brass interface moves toward the brass at an experimentally measurable rate.^[1]

Darken's equations

Shortly after the publication of Kirkendall's paper, L. S. Darken published an analysis of diffusion in binary systems much like the one studied by Smigelskas and Kirkendall. By separating the actual diffusive flux of the materials from the movement of the interface relative to the markers, Darken found the marker velocity $v$ to be^[4] $v=(D_{1}-D_{2}){\frac {dN_{1}}{dx}},$ where $D_{1}$ and $D_{2}$ are the diffusion coefficients of the two materials, and $N_{1}$ is an atomic fraction. One consequence of this equation is that the movement of an interface varies linearly with the square root of time, which is exactly the experimental relationship discovered by Smigelskas and Kirkendall.^[1]

Darken also developed a second equation that defines a combined chemical diffusion coefficient $D$ in terms of the diffusion coefficients of the two interfacing materials:^[4] $D=N_{1}D_{2}+N_{2}D_{1}.$ This chemical diffusion coefficient can be used to mathematically analyze Kirkendall effect diffusion via the Boltzmann–Matano method.

Kirkendall porosity

One important consideration deriving from Kirkendall's work is the presence of pores formed during diffusion. These voids act as sinks for vacancies, and when enough accumulate, they can become substantial and expand in an attempt to restore equilibrium. Porosity occurs due to the difference in diffusion rate of the two species.^[5]

Pores in metals have ramifications for mechanical, thermal, and electrical properties, and thus control over their formation is often desired. The equation^[6] $X^{K}=(a_{1}\Delta C_{1}^{\circ }+a_{2}\Delta C_{2}^{\circ }+\dots +a_{n-1}\Delta C_{n-1}^{\circ }){\sqrt {t}},$ where $X^{K}$ is the distance moved by a marker, $a$ is a coefficient determined by intrinsic diffusivities of the materials, and $\Delta C^{\circ }$ is a concentration difference between components, has proven to be an effective model for mitigating Kirkendall porosity. Controlling annealing temperature is another method of reducing or eliminating porosity. Kirkendall porosity typically occurs at a set temperature in a system, so annealing can be performed at lower temperatures for longer times to avoid formation of pores.^[7]

Examples

In 1972, C. W. Horsting of the RCA Corporation published a paper which reported test results on the reliability of semiconductor devices in which the connections were made using aluminium wires bonded ultrasonically to gold-plated posts. His paper demonstrated the importance of the Kirkendall effect in wire bonding technology, but also showed the significant contribution of any impurities present to the rate at which precipitation occurred at the wire bonds. Two of the important contaminants that have this effect, known as Horsting effect (Horsting voids) are fluorine and chlorine. Both Kirkendall voids and Horsting voids are known causes of wire-bond fractures, though historically this cause is often confused with the purple-colored appearance of one of the five different gold–aluminium intermetallics, commonly referred to as "purple plague" and less often "white plague".^[8]

Related Research Articles

<span class="mw-page-title-main">Sintering</span> Process of forming and bonding material by heat or pressure

Sintering or frittage is the process of compacting and forming a solid mass of material by pressure or heat without melting it to the point of liquefaction. Sintering happens as part of a manufacturing process used with metals, ceramics, plastics, and other materials. The atoms/molecules in the sintered material diffuse across the boundaries of the particles, fusing the particles together and creating a solid piece.

Brazing is a metal-joining process in which two or more metal items are joined by melting and flowing a filler metal into the joint, with the filler metal having a lower melting point than the adjoining metal.

Neutron radiation is a form of ionizing radiation that presents as free neutrons. Typical phenomena are nuclear fission or nuclear fusion causing the release of free neutrons, which then react with nuclei of other atoms to form new nuclides—which, in turn, may trigger further neutron radiation. Free neutrons are unstable, decaying into a proton, an electron, plus an electron antineutrino. Free neutrons have a mean lifetime of 887 seconds.

<span class="mw-page-title-main">Electromigration</span> Movement of ions in an electrical field

Electromigration is the transport of material caused by the gradual movement of the ions in a conductor due to the momentum transfer between conducting electrons and diffusing metal atoms. The effect is important in applications where high direct current densities are used, such as in microelectronics and related structures. As the structure size in electronics such as integrated circuits (ICs) decreases, the practical significance of this effect increases.

In materials science, creep is the tendency of a solid material to undergo slow deformation while subject to persistent mechanical stresses. It can occur as a result of long-term exposure to high levels of stress that are still below the yield strength of the material. Creep is more severe in materials that are subjected to heat for long periods and generally increases as they near their melting point.

In chemical physics, atomic diffusion is a diffusion process whereby the random, thermally-activated movement of atoms in a solid results in the net transport of atoms. For example, helium atoms inside a balloon can diffuse through the wall of the balloon and escape, resulting in the balloon slowly deflating. Other air molecules have lower mobilities and thus diffuse more slowly through the balloon wall. There is a concentration gradient in the balloon wall, because the balloon was initially filled with helium, and thus there is plenty of helium on the inside, but there is relatively little helium on the outside. The rate of transport is governed by the diffusivity and the concentration gradient.

A reactor pressure vessel (RPV) in a nuclear power plant is the pressure vessel containing the nuclear reactor coolant, core shroud, and the reactor core.

A crystal is a solid material whose constituent atoms, molecules, or ions are arranged in an orderly repeating pattern extending in all three spatial dimensions. Crystal growth is a major stage of a crystallization process, and consists of the addition of new atoms, ions, or polymer strings into the characteristic arrangement of the crystalline lattice. The growth typically follows an initial stage of either homogeneous or heterogeneous nucleation, unless a "seed" crystal, purposely added to start the growth, was already present.

In metallurgy, selective leaching, also called dealloying, demetalification, parting and selective corrosion, is a corrosion type in some solid solution alloys, when in suitable conditions a component of the alloys is preferentially leached from the initially homogenous material. The less noble metal is removed from the alloy by a microscopic-scale galvanic corrosion mechanism. The most susceptible alloys are the ones containing metals with high distance between each other in the galvanic series, e.g. copper and zinc in brass. The elements most typically undergoing selective removal are zinc, aluminium, iron, cobalt, chromium, and others.

<span class="mw-page-title-main">Coble creep</span> Mechanism of crystalline solid deformation

In materials science, Coble creep, a form of diffusion creep, is a mechanism for deformation of crystalline solids. Contrasted with other diffusional creep mechanisms, Coble creep is similar to Nabarro–Herring creep in that it is dominant at lower stress levels and higher temperatures than creep mechanisms utilizing dislocation glide. Coble creep occurs through the diffusion of atoms in a material along grain boundaries. This mechanism is observed in polycrystals or along the surface in a single crystal, which produces a net flow of material and a sliding of the grain boundaries.

Diffusivity, mass diffusivity or diffusion coefficient is usually written as the proportionality constant between the molar flux due to molecular diffusion and the negative value of the gradient in the concentration of the species. More accurately, the diffusion coefficient times the local concentration is the proportionality constant between the negative value of the mole fraction gradient and the molar flux. This distinction is especially significant in gaseous systems with strong temperature gradients. Diffusivity derives its definition from Fick's law and plays a role in numerous other equations of physical chemistry.

Damage mechanics is concerned with the representation, or modeling, of damage of materials that is suitable for making engineering predictions about the initiation, propagation, and fracture of materials without resorting to a microscopic description that would be too complex for practical engineering analysis.

<span class="mw-page-title-main">Diffusion</span> Transport of dissolved species from the highest to the lowest concentration region

Diffusion is the net movement of anything generally from a region of higher concentration to a region of lower concentration. Diffusion is driven by a gradient in Gibbs free energy or chemical potential. It is possible to diffuse "uphill" from a region of lower concentration to a region of higher concentration, as in spinodal decomposition. Diffusion is a stochastic process due to the inherent randomness of the diffusing entity and can be used to model many real-life stochastic scenarios. Therefore, diffusion and the corresponding mathematical models are used in several fields beyond physics, such as statistics, probability theory, information theory, neural networks, finance, and marketing.

The effective diffusion coefficient of a diffusant in atomic diffusion of solid polycrystalline materials like metal alloys is often represented as a weighted average of the grain boundary diffusion coefficient and the lattice diffusion coefficient. Diffusion along both the grain boundary and in the lattice may be modeled with an Arrhenius equation. The ratio of the grain boundary diffusion activation energy over the lattice diffusion activation energy is usually 0.4–0.6, so as temperature is lowered, the grain boundary diffusion component increases. Increasing temperature often allows for increased grain size, and the lattice diffusion component increases with increasing temperature, so often at 0.8 T_melt, the grain boundary component can be neglected.

The grain boundary diffusion coefficient is the diffusion coefficient of a diffusant along a grain boundary in a polycrystalline solid. It is a physical constant denoted $, and it is important in understanding how grain boundaries affect atomic diffusivity. Grain boundary diffusion is a commonly observed route for solute migration in polycrystalline materials. It dominates the effective diffusion rate at lower temperatures in metals and metal alloys. Take the apparent self-diffusion coefficient for single-crystal and polycrystal silver, for example. At high temperatures, the coefficient is the same in both types of samples. However, at temperatures below 700 °C, the values of with polycrystal silver consistently lie above the values of with a single crystal.$

<span class="mw-page-title-main">Lattice diffusion coefficient</span> Atomic diffusion within a crystalline lattice

In condensed matter physics, lattice diffusion refers to atomic diffusion within a crystalline lattice, which occurs by either interstitial or substitutional mechanisms. In interstitial lattice diffusion, a diffusant, will diffuse in between the lattice structure of another crystalline element. In substitutional lattice diffusion, the atom can only move by switching places with another atom. Substitutional lattice diffusion is often contingent upon the availability of point vacancies throughout the crystal lattice. Diffusing particles migrate from point vacancy to point vacancy by the rapid, essentially random jumping about. Since the prevalence of point vacancies increases in accordance with the Arrhenius equation, the rate of crystal solid state diffusion increases with temperature. For a single atom in a defect-free crystal, the movement can be described by the "random walk" model.

The strength of metal oxide adhesion effectively determines the wetting of the metal-oxide interface. The strength of this adhesion is important, for instance, in production of light bulbs and fiber-matrix composites that depend on the optimization of wetting to create metal-ceramic interfaces. The strength of adhesion also determines the extent of dispersion on catalytically active metal. Metal oxide adhesion is important for applications such as complementary metal oxide semiconductor devices. These devices make possible the high packing densities of modern integrated circuits.

In metallurgy, the Darken equations are used to describe the solid-state diffusion of materials in binary solutions. They were first described by Lawrence Stamper Darken in 1948. The equations apply to cases where a solid solution's two components do not have the same coefficient of diffusion.

In materials science, Nabarro–Herring creep is a mechanism of deformation of crystalline materials that occurs at low stresses and held at elevated temperatures in fine-grained materials. In Nabarro–Herring creep, atoms diffuse through the crystals, and the rate of creep varies inversely with the square of the grain size so fine-grained materials creep faster than coarser-grained ones. NH creep is solely controlled by diffusional mass transport.

Diffusion bonding or diffusion welding is a solid-state welding technique used in metalworking, capable of joining similar and dissimilar metals. It operates on the principle of solid-state diffusion, wherein the atoms of two solid, metallic surfaces intersperse themselves over time. This is typically accomplished at an elevated temperature, approximately 50-75% of the absolute melting temperature of the materials. A weak bond can also be achieved at room temperature. Diffusion bonding is usually implemented by applying high pressure, in conjunction with necessarily high temperature, to the materials to be welded; the technique is most commonly used to weld "sandwiches" of alternating layers of thin metal foil, and metal wires or filaments. Currently, the diffusion bonding method is widely used in the joining of high-strength and refractory metals within the aerospace and nuclear industries.

References

1 2 3 4 Smigelskas, A. D.; Kirkendall, E. O. (1947). "Zinc Diffusion in Alpha Brass". Trans. AIME. 171: 130–142.
1 2 Nakajima, Hideo (1997). "The Discovery and Acceptance of the Kirkendall Effect: The Result of a Short Research Career". JOM. 49 (6): 15–19. Bibcode:1997JOM....49f..15N. doi:10.1007/bf02914706. S2CID 55941759 . Retrieved 28 April 2013.
1 2 Bhadeshia, H.K.D.H. "The Kirkendall Effect". University of Cambridge. Retrieved 28 April 2013.
1 2 Darken, L. S. (February 1948). "Diffusion, Mobility, and Their Interrelation through Free Energy in Binary Metallic Systems". Trans. AIME. 175: 194.
↑ Seitz, F. (May 1953). "On the porosity observed in the Kirkendall effect". Acta Metallurgica. 1 (3): 355–369. doi:10.1016/0001-6160(53)90112-6.
↑ Son, Yoon-Ho; J. E. Morral (November 1989). "The Effect of Composition on Marker Movement and Kirkendall Porosity in Ternary Alloys". Metallurgical Transactions A. 20A (11): 2299–2303. Bibcode:1989MTA....20.2299S. doi:10.1007/BF02666665. S2CID 137088474.
↑ Cogan, S. F.; S. Kwon; J. D. Klein; R. M. Rose (May 1983). "Fabrication of Large Diameter External-Diffusion Processed Nb₃Sn Composites". IEEE Transactions on Magnetics. Mag-19 (3): 1139–1142. Bibcode:1983ITM....19.1139C. doi:10.1109/tmag.1983.1062517.
↑ "Contamination-Enhanced Growth of Au/Al Intermetallic and Horsting Voids". NASA. Retrieved 28 April 2013.

External links

Aloke Paul, Tomi Laurila, Vesa Vuorinen and Sergiy Divinski, Thermodynamics, Diffusion and the Kirkendall effect in Solids, Springer, Heidelberg, Germany, 2014.
Kirkendall Effect: Dramatic History of Discovery and Developments by L.N. Paritskaya Archived 2016-03-14 at the Wayback Machine
Interdiffusion and Kirkendall Effect in Cu-Sn Alloys Archived 2018-05-17 at the Wayback Machine
Visual demonstration of the Kirkendall effect

This page is based on this Wikipedia article
Text is available under the CC BY-SA 4.0 license; additional terms may apply.
Images, videos and audio are available under their respective licenses.

[original_journal-1] 1 2 3 4 Smigelskas, A. D.; Kirkendall, E. O. (1947). "Zinc Diffusion in Alpha Brass". Trans. AIME. 171: 130–142.

[JOM_history-2] 1 2 Nakajima, Hideo (1997). "The Discovery and Acceptance of the Kirkendall Effect: The Result of a Short Research Career". JOM. 49 (6): 15–19. Bibcode:1997JOM....49f..15N. doi:10.1007/bf02914706. S2CID 55941759 . Retrieved 28 April 2013.

[Cambridge-3] 1 2 Bhadeshia, H.K.D.H. "The Kirkendall Effect". University of Cambridge. Retrieved 28 April 2013.

[Darken-4] 1 2 Darken, L. S. (February 1948). "Diffusion, Mobility, and Their Interrelation through Free Energy in Binary Metallic Systems". Trans. AIME. 175: 194.

[porosity-5] Seitz, F. (May 1953). "On the porosity observed in the Kirkendall effect". Acta Metallurgica. 1 (3): 355–369. doi:10.1016/0001-6160(53)90112-6.

[equation-6] Son, Yoon-Ho; J. E. Morral (November 1989). "The Effect of Composition on Marker Movement and Kirkendall Porosity in Ternary Alloys". Metallurgical Transactions A. 20A (11): 2299–2303. Bibcode:1989MTA....20.2299S. doi:10.1007/BF02666665. S2CID 137088474.

[7] Cogan, S. F.; S. Kwon; J. D. Klein; R. M. Rose (May 1983). "Fabrication of Large Diameter External-Diffusion Processed Nb₃Sn Composites". IEEE Transactions on Magnetics. Mag-19 (3): 1139–1142. Bibcode:1983ITM....19.1139C. doi:10.1109/tmag.1983.1062517.

[8] "Contamination-Enhanced Growth of Au/Al Intermetallic and Horsting Voids". NASA. Retrieved 28 April 2013.

[1]

[2]

[3]

[4]

[5]

[6]

[7]

[8]