| Portrait | Name Electoral district (Birth–Death) | Term of office | Party | 
|---|
 |  John Gilbert Higgins  MHA for St. John's East  (1891–1963) | 1949–1951 |  |  Progressive Conservative  | 
 |  Peter John Cashin  MHA for Ferryland  (1890–1977) | 1951–1953 |  |  Progressive Conservative  | 
 |  Malcolm Mercer Hollett  MHA for St. John's West  (1891–1985) | 1953–1959 |  |  Progressive Conservative  | 
 |  James Greene  MHA for St. John's East  (1928–2014) | 1960–1966 |  |  Progressive Conservative  | 
 |  Noel Murphy  MHA for Humber East  (1915–2005) | 1966 |  |  Progressive Conservative  | 
 |  Gerry Ottenheimer  [a]  MHA for St. John's East  (1934–1998) | 1967–1969 |  |  Progressive Conservative  | 
 |  Anthony Joseph Murphy  [b]  MHA for St. John's East  (1913–1996) | 1969–1971 |  |  Progressive Conservative  | 
 |  Frank Moores  MHA for Humber West  (1933–2005) | 1971–1972 |  |  Progressive Conservative  | 
    |  Joey Smallwood  MHA for Placentia East  (1900–1991) | 1972 |  |  Liberal  | 
 |  Edward Roberts  MHA for White Bay North  (1940–2022) | 1972–1977 |  |  Liberal  | 
 |  Steve Neary  [c]  MHA for LaPoile  (1925–1996) | 1977 |  |  Liberal  | 
 |  Bill Rowe  MHA for Twillingate (born 1942) | 1977–1979 |  |  Liberal  | 
    |  Don Jamieson  MHA for Bellevue  (1921–1986) | 1979–1980 |  |  Liberal  | 
 |  Len Stirling  MHA for Bonavista North  (1937–2024) | 1980–1982 |  |  Liberal  | 
 |  Steve Neary  [d]  MHA for LaPoile  (1925–1996) | 1982–1984 |  |  Liberal  | 
 |  Leo Barry  MHA for Mount Scio  (born 1943) | 1984–1987 |  |  Liberal  | 
 |  Roger Simmons  [e]  MHA for Fortune-Hermitage (born 1939) (Interim) | 1987 |  |  Liberal  | 
 |  Clyde Wells  MHA for Windsor-Buchans (born 1937) | 1987–1989 |  |  Liberal  | 
 |  Tom Rideout  MHA for Baie Verte-Springdale  (born 1948) | 1989–1991 |  |  Progressive Conservative  | 
 |  Len Simms  MHA for Grand Falls-Windsor-Buchans  (born 1943) | 1991–1995 |  |  Progressive Conservative  | 
 |  Lynn Verge  MHA for Humber East  (born 1951) | 1995–1996 |  |  Progressive Conservative  | 
 |  Loyola Sullivan  MHA for Ferryland  (born 1949) | 1996–1998 |  |  Progressive Conservative  | 
 |  Ed Byrne  MHA for Kilbride  (born 1963) | 1998–2001 |  |  Progressive Conservative  | 
    |  Danny Williams  [1]  MHA for Humber West  (born 1949) | 2001–2003 |  |  Progressive Conservative  | 
    |  Roger Grimes  [2]  MHA for Exploits  (born 1950) | 2003–2005 |  |  Liberal  | 
 |  Gerry Reid  MHA for The Isles of Notre Dame  (born 1954) | 2005–2007 |  |  Liberal  | 
    |  Yvonne Jones  [3]  MHA for Cartwright-L'Anse au Clair  (born 1968) (Interim) | 2007–2010 |  |  Liberal  | 
 |  Kelvin Parsons  [4]  MHA for Burgeo and La Poile  | 2010–2011 |  |  Liberal  | 
    |  Yvonne Jones  MHA for Cartwright-L'Anse au Clair  (born 1968) | 2011–2012 |  |  Liberal  | 
    |  Dwight Ball  MHA for Humber Valley  (born 1957) | 2012–2013 |  |  Liberal  | 
 |  Eddie Joyce  [5]  MHA for Bay of Islands  | 2013 |  |  Liberal  | 
    |  Dwight Ball  MHA for Humber Valley  (born 1957) | 2013–2015 |  |  Liberal  | 
    |  Paul Davis  [6]  MHA for Topsail-Paradise  (born 1961) | 2015–2018 |  |  Progressive Conservative  | 
    |  David Brazil  MHA for Conception Bay East - Bell Island  (born 1963) (Interim) | 2018 |  |  Progressive Conservative  | 
    |  Ches Crosbie  [7]  MHA for Windsor Lake  (born 1953) | 2018–2021 |  |  Progressive Conservative  | 
    |  David Brazil  [8]  MHA for Conception Bay East - Bell Island  (born 1963) (Interim) | 2021–2023 |  |  Progressive Conservative  | 
    |  Tony Wakeham  [9]  MHA for Stephenville-Port au Port  | 2023–2025 |  |  Progressive Conservative  | 
 |  John Hogan  MHA for Windsor Lake  | 2025–present |  |  Liberal  |