Judges who have served on the Vice Admiralty Court in New South Wales between 1787 and 1911 include :
| Position | Name | Appointment commenced | Appointment ended | Term in office | Comments | Notes |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| Judge Commissary | Robert Ross | 18 April 1787 | ||||
| Francis Grose | ||||||
| Joseph Foveaux | 7 August 1798 | 7 August 1798 | Appointment refused | |||
| Henry Waterhouse | 15 August 1798 | |||||
| William Paterson | 20 March 1799 | |||||
| George Johnston | 20 November 1804 | |||||
| Edward Abbott | 19 February 1808 | |||||
| Ellis Bent | 10 August 1811 | 10 November 1815 | 4 years, 92 days | |||
| John Wylde | 26 July 1816 | |||||
| Sir Francis Forbes | 31 October 1825 | 1 July 1837 | 11 years, 243 days | Chief Justice of New South Wales (1823−1837) | [2] | |
| John Kinchela | 7 May 1840 | |||||
| Sir James Dowling | 18 August 1841 | 27 September 1844 | 3 years, 40 days | Chief Justice of New South Wales (1837−1844) | [3] | |
| Sir Alfred Stephen [a] | 7 October 1844 | 5 November 1873 | 29 years, 29 days | Chief Justice of New South Wales (1844−1873) | [5] | |
| Sir James Martin | 19 November 1873 | 4 November 1886 | 12 years, 350 days | Chief Justice of New South Wales (1873−1886) | [6] | |
| Sir Frederick Darley | 29 November 1886 | 4 January 1910 | 23 years, 36 days | Chief Justice of New South Wales (1886-1910) | ||
| Sir William Cullen | 28 January 1910 | 1 July 1911 | 1 year, 154 days | Chief Justice of New South Wales (1910-1925) | ||
| Deputy Commissary | Ellis Bent | 25 June 1810 | ||||
| John Kinchela | September 1837 | November 1840 | 3 years, 32–90 days | Acting judge of the Supreme Court (1836−1837) | ||
| Samuel Milford | 1 August 1844 | 26 May 1865 | 20 years, 298 days | Master in Equity (Supreme Court) (1843−1855) | [7] [8] | |
| Alfred Cheeke | 10 September 1869 | Judge of the Supreme Court (1865−1876) | [9] | |||
| Peter Faucett | 15 September 1879 | 10 years, 5 days | Judge of the Supreme Court (1865−1888) | [9] [10] | ||
| Sir William Windeyer | 15 September 1879 | Acting judge & judge of the Supreme Court (1879−1896) | [10] | |||
| Sir William Owen | 24 September 1897 | Judge of the Supreme Court (1887−1908) | ||||
| Philip Street | 29 July 1908 | Judge of the Supreme Court (1907−1934) | ||||
| Surrogate Judge | William à Beckett | 15 September 1841 | Solicitor General (1841−1844) | |||
| Samuel Milford | 3 March 1843 | Master in Equity (Supreme Court) (1843−1855) | ||||
| William Carter | 22 February 1847 | Master in Equity (Supreme Court) (1841−1843) | ||||
| Herman Milford | ||||||
| Henry Stephen [a] | 21 December 1857 | [11] | ||||
| William Cary | 11 January 1858 | |||||
| William Hallam Wilkinson | 6 August 1864 | Deputy Judge District Court (1868–1870, 1874) | ||||
| Joseph Innes | 1872 | Solicitor General (1872−1873) |