Lucina C. Broadwell

Last updated

Lucina Courser Broadwell was murdered in Barre, Vermont, United States on May 4, 1919. [1]

Contents

The killing of a 29-year-old mother of three shocked and consumed the community of 17,000 during the summer and fall of 1919. Her death was considered "one of the most horrendous crimes to take place in Vermont up to that time." [2] Mrs. Broadwell's body was buried in Johnson, Vermont, on May 7, 1919. [3] The case continues to inspire writers and theorists.

Early life

Little is known about Lucina Courser Broadwell's early life. Lucina was born on July 26, 1889. [1] She was raised by her parents, Mr. and Mrs. George Courser, in Johnson, Vermont.

In 1910, Lucina married Harry Broadwell, a carpenter, and moved to Barre in 1915. [4] They had three children, Doris, Hildred, and Wendell. [5] At the time of her murder, Lucina was described as "[a] woman . . . of rather slight build, probably not weighing over 110 pounds [6] and being about five feet, three inches tall. [7] She was of rather dark complexion and with regular features with the exception of prominent cheekbones." [8]

Murder

On the morning of May 4, 1919, at approximately 7:30, Harold Jackson, a resident of Brookfield, Vermont, came across Broadwell's body while on a morning walk. The body was lying face down in the Wheelock garden, off North Main Street. When found, the corpse was clothed only in "shoes, stockings, and kid gloves." [9] Her clothing, hat, pocketbook, and Waltham watch were found within several feet of the body. [10] The murder scene has been described as follows:

Her hat was found 8 feet from her body; her Waltham watch 13 feet away, and her empty pocketbook, 5 feet beyond that. The gold watch, with its closed case and clasp, was etched with the initials L.P.C., her maiden name: Lucina Phillips Courser. When thrown from her body, the watch was still running. . . . There were clothes, including what were called "corsets," under the body. A pile of other clothing was tossed in a heap nearby. Some of these articles were torn and when they were picked up, several buttons fell to the ground. [10]

Lucina's hands were tied behind her back with one of her undergarments. [11] A portion of her undergarments and a man's white handkerchief were tied around her neck; it was apparent from the marks on her neck that she had been strangled. [11]

Investigation

The State of Vermont hired James R. Wood, Jr., of the Wood Detective Agency (Boston) to conduct an investigation into the murder. Wood was considered a "Chief Detective" and was considered "the best known detective in New England." [12] Wood and his team had arrived in Barre on May 7, the same day as Lucina's funeral, before her body was transferred to Johnson for burial. [13] At the end of the investigation Wood stated that the Broadwell case was "one of the strongest circumstantial cases ever tried." [14]

When Wood arrived in Barre, he met with Frank C. Archibald, the Vermont Attorney General, and other local officials. [15] It had already been deduced that Lucina had been murdered at the Buzzell Hotel and her body moved to the garden where it was ultimately found. Wood interviewed Harry Broadwell, because at that time, it was largely believed that Harry killed Lucina. Wood, however, quickly dismissed this theory since Harry had "a perfect alibi" for all of his activities the night of the murder. [16] Harry did reveal that he believed his wife was "sporty." [17] Wood quickly identified George R. Long as a person of interest. Long, at that time, was a resident of the Parker house. Harry had told Wood that he suspected Lucina was having an affair with a resident of the Parker house. [18] When initially questioned, Long denied having met Lucina. [18]

Wood also followed another lead provided by Harry Broadwell. Harry had told Wood that Lucina had a good friend by the name of Grace Grimes, who had relocated to the Boston area. Wood immediately had his office locate Grace. When interviewed, Grace confirmed that she often corresponded with Lucina by letter and that her most recent letter was from the day of the murder. In the letter, Lucina wrote about meeting a lodger of Mrs. Isabelle Parker's named George. [19] During the interview with Grace it surfaced that Parker ran a brothel and hosted "so-called cheating parties." [20] Lucina had participated on numerous occasions. [21]

Upon his return to Vermont, Wood interviewed Isabelle Parker, who admitted that Lucina had been at her house the night of the murder and met with Long. There was evidence that Lucina and Long had dinner together and her autopsy showed that she had eaten approximately one hour before her murder. [22] A search of Parker's house revealed the "Famous Red Book", which listed her customers, "many prominent people, both male and female, of Barre, Vermont." [22] Wood deduced how Parker operated her brothel in downtown Barre:

She would go about Barre and get a line of the different men and women who were inclined to be a little sporty. For example, if she knew I was a married man and like to step out, she would make it her business to form my acquaintance and eventually tell me that a certain woman, either married or single, was infatuated with me and would like to meet me. She would invite me down toher [sic] house at a certain time and tell me to come in the back door and when I arrived, would introduce me to some woman, either married or single, whom she had told the same story to that she had told me, namely she would tell the woman that I desired to meet her. In that way she would bring the couples together and they would have their parties there, and naturally the men would pay her something for the use of the room or rooms. [23]

One week after Broadwell's body was found, Wood questioned Long once again. After disclosing what Parker admitted to, Long finally confessed to knowing Lucina, but denied murdering her. [24]

Wood's investigation proved invaluable to the Broadwell prosecution team. It was Wood who found two major clues:

  1. A tire track beside the street curb near where the body was found, and
  2. The owner of the handkerchief that was tied around Lucina's neck. [25]

The tire track was eventually traced back to a car rented by Long. The handkerchief's owner, Eddie Barron, testified at Long's trial that the handkerchief had been given to Long by Barron. [25]

In addition, Wood's entire interview with Long would also be read to the jury during the trial. [26]

Wood kept very detailed notes. At one point in his report he stated that he "had become disgusted and had left Vermont." [20] He also recorded how the local officials "told me they thought I was crazy and thought I had been on a wild goose chase." [20] Another example of how Wood included details about his own experiences intermixed with his investigation is his discussion of his first night in Vermont:

I then spent the entire night at work alone on this case. I visited the lot where the body was found, visited the Buzzell Hotel, studied the lightening conditions and decided then that Mrs. Broadwell wasnot [sic] killed in the Buzzell Hotel. I returned to the hotel shortly before breakfast, no one knowing that I had been working all night. [20]

Arrests and trials

On May 15, George Long and Isabelle Parker were arrested and taken to the Washington County jail in Montpelier. [27] Arraignments took place on May 16 and both Long and Parker were assigned attorney J. Ward Carver for their defense. [28] Earle Davis represented the State. The grand jury hearing was scheduled for June 5. [29] During the period between the arraignments and the grand jury proceedings, it was found that George Long was actually George Rath, and had only taken the name "Long" before moving to Vermont. It was alleged that he had an extensive criminal record. [30] On June 11, Long and Parker were indicted by the grand jury. [31]

Trial of George R. Long

George Long's trial began on October 7, 1919, at 9 a.m. with jury selection. [32] On October 10, opening statements were made by the prosecution and the defense, with a courtroom filled to capacity. [33] On October 20, Long's second statement to authorities was read into evidence at the trial. In this statement he admitted to paying Lucina for sexual relations and Mrs. Parker for providing the room. [34] On October 24, Daisy Luce testified that she spoke with George Long the morning that Lucina's body was discovered. During this conversation, Long stated: "There would be one less woman in Barre." [35]

Long's trial lasted one month before it went to the jury. There were a hundred witnesses. [26] In its closing statement, the defense argued that Long had no motive to kill Lucina since they were intimate partners. [36] The prosecution, on the other hand, demonized Long, referring to him as a "thing." [37] The prosecution relied heavily on the circumstantial evidence provided by the Wood Detective Agency. [38] On October 31, the judge gave the jury its instructions. [39] That afternoon, the jury came back with its verdict. At 3:30, the jury announced that George Long was found guilty of the second-degree murder of Lucina C. Broadwell. Sentencing was set for November 5, at which time he was ordered to serve a term of life imprisonment. [40]

After sentencing, Long was moved to the Windsor State Prison to serve his sentence. He appealed his case with exceptions made during the trial. In 1922, the Vermont Supreme Court held in State v. Long that "[t]he record shows a brutal killing--one unmistakably indicating cool depravity of heart and wanton cruelty." [41] Long's appeal was denied.

Trial of Isabelle Parker

Once the Long trial concluded, Isabelle Parker became the court's focus. Parker, while initially implicated in Lucina's murder, was only charged with "conducting a house of ill fame." [42] Parker pleaded guilty to the charge and was sentenced to two to four years imprisonment. Due to her health, officials allowed her to remain free while she petitioned the governor for clemency. Her petition was denied on April 23, 1920, and she began her sentence on April 26. [43] Parker served 2.5 years. She died on September 5, 1922. [43]

Public interest and legacy

Lucina's murder captivated the residents of Barre, and indeed the entire state of Vermont. There were almost daily reports on the murder, its investigation, and the trials of Long and Parker, in the Barre Daily Times throughout the summer and fall of 1919.

In 1990, Richard Bottamini published "The Bawdy House Murder" in The Central Vermont Magazine, which gives a concise history of the murder and the subsequent trial of George Long.

In 2006, Vermont historian Patricia Belding published One Less Woman, a book that chronicles the events following Lucina's murder. Belding's book relies heavily on the newspaper reports of the Barre Daily Times for information regarding the murder and the trials of both Long and Parker. The book also provides pictures of the main players in the book, as well as the actual murder scene.

In a 2020 podcast, Jill Lepore, a history professor at Harvard University and a writer for The New Yorker magazine, revisited the case and the original file transcripts and concluded that whether he was guilty or not, Long was convicted on moral grounds: not because of any material evidence, but because he had provided a contraceptive to Mrs. Broadwell, had sex with her, and lied about it. [26]

See also

Related Research Articles

<span class="mw-page-title-main">Barre (city), Vermont</span> City in Vermont, United States

Barre is the most populous city in Washington County, Vermont, United States. As of the 2020 census, the municipal population was 8,491. Popularly referred to as "Barre City", it is almost completely surrounded by "Barre Town", which is a separate municipality.

<span class="mw-page-title-main">Emmett Till</span> African American lynching victim (1941–1955)

Emmett Louis Till was an African American boy who was abducted, tortured, and lynched in Mississippi in 1955 at the age of 14, after being accused of offending a white woman, Carolyn Bryant, in her family's grocery store. The brutality of his murder and the acquittal of his killers drew attention to the long history of violent persecution of African Americans in the United States. Till posthumously became an icon of the civil rights movement.

<span class="mw-page-title-main">Murder of George Campbell</span>

Phoebe Campbell was a Canadian woman who was hanged for the murder of her husband.

Mack Charles Parker was an African-American victim of lynching in the United States. He had been accused of raping a pregnant white woman in northern Pearl River County, Mississippi. Three days before he was to stand trial, Parker was kidnapped from his jail cell in the Pearl River County Courthouse by a mob, beaten and shot. His body was found in the Pearl River, 20 miles west of Poplarville, 10 days later. Following an investigation by the Federal Bureau of Investigation, the men who killed him were released. Despite confessions, no one was ever indicted for the killing. Historian Howard Smead called the killing the "last classic lynching in America."

<span class="mw-page-title-main">Harry Oakes</span> Canadian-British philanthropist

Sir Harry Oakes, 1st Baronet was a British gold mine owner, entrepreneur, investor and philanthropist. He earned his fortune in Canada and moved to the Bahamas in the 1930s for tax purposes. Though American by birth, he became a British citizen and was granted the hereditary title of baronet in 1939.

<span class="mw-page-title-main">Hall–Mills murder case</span> American murder case

The Hall–Mills murder case involved Edward Wheeler Hall, an Episcopal priest, and Eleanor Mills, a member of his choir with whom he was having an affair, both of whom were murdered on September 14, 1922, in Somerset, New Jersey, United States. Hall's wife and her brothers were accused of committing the murders, but were acquitted in a 1926 trial. In the history of journalism, the case is largely remembered for the vast extent of newspaper coverage it received nationwide; it has been regarded as an example of a media circus. It would take the Lindbergh kidnapping trial in the 1930s to eclipse the high profile of the Hall-Mills case.

<span class="mw-page-title-main">Martha Rendell</span> Last woman executed in Western Australia

Martha Rendell was the last woman to be hanged in Western Australia, for the murder of her de facto husband's son, Arthur Morris, in 1908. She was also suspected of killing his two daughters, Annie and Olive, by swabbing their throats with hydrochloric acid. Although the children died slow and agonizing deaths, they had been treated by a number of doctors during their illness, only one of whom expressed any doubts about their deaths.

<span class="mw-page-title-main">Louise Peete</span> American serial killer

Louise Peete was a convicted American serial killer. Peete was first convicted of the 1920 murder of wealthy mining engineer Jacob C. Denton, and was sentenced to life in prison in 1921. She was paroled in April 1939. In May 1945, Peete was convicted a second time for murdering her employer, Margaret Logan, and was sentenced to death. She was executed in April 1947, making her the second of only four women to be executed in the California gas chamber.

It is possible to convict someone of murder without the purported victim's body in evidence. However, cases of this type have historically been hard to prove, often forcing the prosecution to rely on circumstantial evidence, and in England there was for centuries a mistaken view that in the absence of a body a killer could not be tried for murder. Developments in forensic science in recent decades have made it more likely that a murder conviction can be obtained even if a body has not been found.

<i>The Case of the Howling Dog</i> 1934 film by Alan Crosland

The Case of the Howling Dog is a 1934 American mystery film directed by Alan Crosland, based on the 1934 novel of the same name by Erle Stanley Gardner. It is first in a series of six Perry Mason films Warner Bros. made between the years 1934 and 1937.

Mary Mabel Bennett Rogers was the last woman legally executed by Vermont. Rogers was hanged for the 1902 murder of her husband, Marcus Rogers.

<span class="mw-page-title-main">Gerald Parker</span> American serial killer on death row

Gerald Parker is an American serial killer who raped and murdered five women in Orange County, California. A sixth victim, who was pregnant at the time of the attack, survived, but her child was delivered stillborn. The crimes took place in 1978 and 1979, but Parker was not identified as the killer until 1996. Parker confessed to the murders, and was sentenced to death on January 21, 1999. Following his conviction, another man, Kevin Lee Green, who had been charged with the attack of the pregnant woman who survived and who was his wife at the time had served 16 years in prison; he was subsequently exonerated and released.

<span class="mw-page-title-main">Eugene Falleni</span> Italian-Australian transgender man and convicted murderer

Eugene Falleni was an Italian-Australian transgender man convicted of the 1917 murder of his first wife.

<i>No Hands on the Clock</i> 1941 film by Frank McDonald

No Hands on the Clock is a 1941 American comedy mystery film directed by Frank McDonald starring Chester Morris as detective Humphrey Campbell. The cast also included Jean Parker and Rose Hobart. It was produced by Pine-Thomas Productions and released by Paramount Pictures.

<span class="mw-page-title-main">Sharon Kinne</span> American woman convicted of two murders

Sharon Kinne, also known as Jeanette Pugliese and in Mexico as La Pistolera, is an American murderer and prison escapee who was convicted in Mexico for one murder and is suspected of two others in the United States, one for which she was acquitted at trial. As of 2023, Kinne is the subject of the longest currently outstanding arrest warrant for murder in the history of Kansas City, Missouri, and one of the longest outstanding felony warrants in U.S. history.

Sheila LaBarre is an American murderer and possible serial killer. She was sentenced to two consecutive life sentences, with no prospect of parole after being convicted of killing two men, Kenneth Countie and Michael Deloge, in Epping, New Hampshire. At the time of the crimes, LaBarre lived in Epping on a farm.

The Richmond child murder was the case of Amy Gregory who was convicted in 1895 of strangling to death her daughter, Frances Maud Gregory, whose dead body was found on the ice in the Old Deer Park, Richmond, England. She was granted a reprieve from execution by the Home Secretary.

<span class="mw-page-title-main">Killing of Atatiana Jefferson</span> 2019 police manslaughter of a woman in Fort Worth, Texas

Atatiana Koquice Jefferson, a 28-year-old woman, was fatally shot inside her home by a police officer in Fort Worth, Texas, United States, in the early morning of October 12, 2019. Police arrived at her home after a neighbor called a non-emergency number, stating that Jefferson's front door was open. Police body camera footage showed officers walking outside the home with flashlights for a few minutes then one officer yells, "Put your hands up! Show me your hands!", while discharging his weapon through a window. Police found a handgun near Jefferson's body, which according to her eight-year-old nephew, she was pointing toward the window before being shot. On October 14, 2019, Officer Aaron Dean, the shooter, resigned from the Fort Worth Police Department and was arrested on a murder charge. On December 20, 2019, Dean was indicted for murder. Jefferson was black and the officer who shot her is white, prompting news outlets to compare Jefferson's shooting to the September 2018 murder of Botham Jean in nearby Dallas.

<span class="mw-page-title-main">Murders of Harry and Megan Tooze</span> Unsolved murder case in Wales

The murders of Harry and Megan Tooze, also known as the Llanharry murders, were the high-profile killings of an elderly couple at their remote Ty Ar y Waun farm near Llanharry, Rhondda Cynon Taf, Wales, United Kingdom, on 26 July 1993. The couple were shot dead at point blank range with a shotgun in an execution-style killing, and their killer had attempted to hide their bodies in the cowshed of the farm. Their best china was found mysteriously laid out on the table in the farmhouse as if the couple were expecting a guest, and their lunch was found cooked but not eaten on the stove. It was described by the lead detective in charge of the case as the "most baffling" case he had investigated.

<span class="mw-page-title-main">Murder of Elizabeth McCabe</span> High profile murder case, 1980

The murder of Elizabeth McCabe was the infamous murder of a 20-year-old woman in Dundee, Scotland in February 1980. The case is one of Scotland's most notorious unsolved murders, and led to one of Scotland's largest manhunts. McCabe had disappeared after a night out at Teazer's Disco in Dundee city centre, and was found strangled to death two weeks later in Templeton Woods on the outskirts of the city. This was only 11 months after another woman, 18-year-old prostitute Carol Lannen, had been found dead only 150 yards away in the same woods, leading to the killings being labelled the Templeton Woods murders in the press and causing many to fear that there was a serial killer at large in the city at the time, although police have not linked the murders.

References

  1. 1 2 Lucina Broadwell's Certificate of Death, Barre Clerk's Office, Washington County, State of Vermont.
  2. ↑ Belding, Patricia W., One Less Woman, A Vermont Murder: 1919 (2006), p. 2.
  3. ↑ Woman was Strangled and Naked Body Left in Garden Off Main St., Barre Daily Times, May 5, 1919, at 1.
  4. ↑ Belding, p. 9.
  5. ↑ Bottamini, Richard, "The Bawdy House Murder", Central Vermont Magazine (Winter 1990), p. 43.
  6. ↑ 7 stone 12 lbs or 50kg
  7. ↑ 162cm
  8. ↑ Belding, p. 7.
  9. ↑ Belding, p. 2-3.
  10. 1 2 Belding, p. 6.
  11. 1 2 Bottamini, p. 42.
  12. ↑ Belding, p. 23.
  13. ↑ Belding, p. 12, 23.
  14. ↑ Investigation of Lucina Broadwell Murder by James Wood, Jr., p. 2, available at the Harvard Law School Library.
  15. ↑ Wood Investigation, p. 4.
  16. ↑ Wood Investigation, p. 4-6.
  17. ↑ Wood Investigation, p. 5.
  18. 1 2 Wood Investigation, p. 7.
  19. ↑ Wood Investigation, p. 8.
  20. 1 2 3 4 Wood Investigation, p. 9.
  21. ↑ Wood Investigation, p. 8-9.
  22. 1 2 Wood Investigation, p. 10.
  23. ↑ Wood Investigation, p. 11.
  24. ↑ Wood Investigation, p. 12.
  25. 1 2 Bottamini, p. 43.
  26. 1 2 3 Jill Lepore, The Case of the Blue Bottle, The Last Archive podcast
  27. ↑ Belding, pp. 25-26.
  28. ↑ Belding, pp. 30-31.
  29. ↑ Belding, p. 37.
  30. ↑ Belding, p. 36.
  31. ↑ Belding, p. 41.
  32. ↑ Belding, pp. 48-49.
  33. ↑ Belding, p. 50.
  34. ↑ Belding, p. 78.
  35. ↑ Belding, p. 109.
  36. ↑ Belding, p. 132.
  37. ↑ Belding, p. 135.
  38. ↑ Belding, pp. 136-37.
  39. ↑ Belding, p. 138.
  40. ↑ Belding, p. 141.
  41. ↑ State v. Long, 95 Vt. 485, 115 A.734, 739 (1922).
  42. ↑ Belding, p. 151.
  43. 1 2 Belding, p. 161.
This page is based on this Wikipedia article
Text is available under the CC BY-SA 4.0 license; additional terms may apply.
Images, videos and audio are available under their respective licenses.