Manitoba Grain Act

Last updated
Manitoba Grain Act
Wagons loaded with bags of grain, awaiting delivery to elevators in Brandon, circa 1888.jpg
Wagons loaded with bags of grain, awaiting delivery to elevators in Brandon, circa 1888
Government of Canada
Enacted byGovernment of Canada
Enacted1900
Summary
Regulations applying to storage, trade and shipping of grain
Status: Repealed

The Manitoba Grain Act was an act passed by the Federal government of Canada in 1900 to protect the interests of grain farmers against abuses by the grain storage and trading companies and the railways. Although well-intentioned the act was flawed, and a series of amendments were required before the more effective Canada Grain Act of 1912 was passed.

Contents

Background

After 1878 the governments of Canada implemented policies to encourage development of grain farming in the prairie province of Manitoba and the Northwest Territories of Saskatchewan, Assiniboia and Alberta. These included setting up protective tariffs, encouraging settlement on the prairies and building a transcontinental railway, the Canadian Pacific Railway (CPR). The agricultural community would produce cash crops for export, and would buy Canadian industrial products. [1] There was inherent tension between the farmers, who wanted to get the highest possible price for their crops, and the grain dealers, who wanted to pay as little as possible. [1]

By 1890 the grain traders had started to consolidate into large companies such as Ogilvie, Northern and Dominion. [2] There were 447 working elevators in the prairie provinces in 1899. Of these 95 were owned by two large milling companies and 206 by three line elevator companies. 120 were owned by individual millers and grain companies, and 26 by farmer-owned companies. The farmers' elevators had difficulty obtaining sufficient volume for economies of scale in grain storage and handling. The large companies could force them out of business by paying excessive prices where the farmers operated elevators, balanced by lower prices elsewhere. [3] The companies took large deductions from the farmers to allow for impurities in the grain (dockage), loss of grain during loading (shrinkage) and transportation costs. Farmers suspected they were colluding over prices, although this was not proved. [2]

Farmers began to complain about the grain traders' practices, and the government established a Royal Commission to investigate the situation. [1] The commission of 1899 held hearings in the main grain belt centers and market centers. The commission also reviewed the practices and regulations of the grain trade in Minnesota, and many features of the Minnesota legislation were included in the recommendations. [3] The commission found, "a vendor of grain is at present subjected to an unfair and excessive dockage for his grain at the time of sale. ... doubts exist as to the fairness of the weights allowed or used by the owners of elevators." The commission said the elevator companies had an unfair monopoly "by refusing to permit the erection of flat warehouses where standard elevators are situated" so they could "keep the price of grain below its true market value to their own benefit." The report recommended legislation, "there being no rules laid down for the regulations of the grain trade other than those made by the railway companies and the elevator owners." [4]

Legislation

The Manitoba Grain Act was passed in 1900, a well-meaning effort to solve the problems identified by the Royal Commission. [4] It was meant to regulate and supervise the trade in grain to ensure fair practices and fair prices. [1] A Warehouse Commissioner was appointed to administer the statute. Grain handling facilities were required to be licensed. [4] Rules and regulations covered dockage, weights, grades, and special binning. [2] Section 18 of the act stated, "In no case, shall grain of different grades be mixed together while in store." This was to ensure that quality and thus prices were maintained. The provision was supported by the traders. [5]

Recommendations incorporated into the act requiring the railways to provide loading platforms free of charge, giving farmers the right to build and use flat warehouses, with the railways forced to provide sites and sidings. [3] The farmers were thus no longer forced to sell to elevators from which the grain would be bulk loaded. However, the farmers had to fill a car completely, which was beyond the capacity of many, and to load within a specified period of time. The loading regulation remained in force until 1970. [2] The elevator companies were required to guarantee the grades of stored grain, and give statements of the grade and weight of all the grain they received. [3]

Results and amendments

Soon after passage of the act in 1900 the North West Elevator Association was organized by the grain dealers. Ostensibly the purpose was to provide an efficient method of deciding on grain prices and sending them to the managers of the local elevators, but the farmers saw the association as an anti-competitive cartel. [6]

The act did not solve the farmers' problem. In 1901 there was a bumper crop in Western Canada. Farmers in the Northwest Territories found that the traders and CPR were not complying with the act. [1] The railway companies were giving the elevator companies precedence over individual farmers in receiving cars, in effect forcing farmers to sell through the companies. [4] About seventy farmers met in Indian Head, Saskatchewan in November 1901, resulting in the birth of the Territorial Grain Growers' Association (TGGA), a non-political lobby group. [1] The delegates at the February 1902 meeting of the TGGA approved three recommendations proposed by William Richard Motherwell for changes to the Grain Act. [7] These were:

That section 42 of the Manitoba Grain Act be amended to empower the Warehouse Commissioner to compel all railway companies to erect every loading platform approved by the said Commissioner within thirty days after said approval is given and in default the Commissioner shall have power to impose penalties on such defaulting railway, and collect same through the courts, and that this amendment come into force on May 1, 1902. [8]

That railway companies be compelled to provide farmers with cars to be loaded direct from vehicles, at all stations, irrespective of there being an elevator, warehouse or loading platform at such station or not.

That the Grain Act be amended making it the duty of the railway agent, when there is a shortage of cars, to apportion the available cars in the order in which they are applied for, and that in case such cars are misappropriated by applicants not entitled to them, the penalties of the act be enforced against such parties.

The recommendations were debated in the House of Commons on 17 March 1902 and passed as amendments to the Manitoba Grain Act with little modification on 19 May 1902. The act was also amended to require the CPR to cover the cost of land and sidings when anyone within forty miles of a siding applied to build a flat warehouse, and to build a loading platform when ten farmers formally applied for one. However, the act did not ensure enforcement. During the bumper harvest of 1902 there was again a shortage of cars, and CPR was clearly favoring the elevator companies in allocating the available cars. [9] Motherwell and Peter Dayman went to Winnipeg to complain to CPR, where they were told that the railway was having difficulty adapting to the rapid growth in wheat production. [10]

In the fall of 1902 the TGGA took CPR to court for violating the act's requirements for distributing cars, and won the case, which was confirmed by the supreme court. [6] The Manitoba Grain Growers' Association (MGGA) was formed at a meeting on March 3–4, 1903 in Brandon, Manitoba. [11] In 1903 two officers of the MGGA accompanied Motherwell and J.B. Gillespie of the TGGA to Ottawa where they met with representatives of the railways and grain companies to tighten up the wording of the Manitoba Grain Act. The new text was introduced as an amendment to the act which was passed that year. [12] With the passage of the amendments to the act the TGGA had achieved its primary objective, and lost some of its momentum. [13]

The farmers still felt that their livelihood was in the control of the grain companies, railways and manufacturers in the east. There were many stories of price fixing. In 1906 the farmers created the collectively owned Grain Growers' Grain Company, which had a seat on the Winnipeg Grain Exchange, to sell their crop on the open market and pay dividends. At first the company had no elevators, so it still had to make arrangements for storage with the elevator companies. [2] Eventually the act of 1900 and additional regulations were consolidated in the Canada Grain Act of 1912. This legislation was profoundly influenced by farmers' leaders such as Edward Alexander Partridge of Sintaluta and William Richard Motherwell of Abernathy. [14]

Related Research Articles

Grain elevator Grain storage building

A grain elevator is an agrarian facility complex designed to stockpile or store grain. In grain trade, the term "grain elevator" also describes a tower containing a bucket elevator or a pneumatic conveyor, which scoops up grain from a lower level and deposits it in a silo or other storage facility.

Canadian Wheat Board

The Canadian Wheat Board was a marketing board for wheat and barley in Western Canada. Established by the Parliament of Canada on 5 July 1935, its operation was governed by the Canadian Wheat Board Act as a mandatory producer marketing system for wheat and barley in Alberta, Saskatchewan, Manitoba, and a small part of British Columbia. It was illegal for any farmer in areas under the CWB's jurisdiction to sell their wheat and barley through any other channel than the CWB. Although often called a monopoly, it was actually a monopsony since it was the only buyer of wheat and barley. It was a marketing agency acting on behalf of Western Canadian farmers, passing all profits from its operation back to farmers. Its market power over wheat and barley marketing was referred to as the "Single Desk".

Sintaluta Town in Saskatchewan, Canada

Sintaluta is a small town in Saskatchewan, Canada. The current population of Sintaluta is approximately 119 people according to the 2016 Canadian Census. The town is located about 85 km east of Regina. The town is located on the north side of the Trans-Canada Highway.

Alberta Wheat Pool

The Alberta Wheat Pool was the first of Canada's wheat farmer co-operatives in 1923.

Saskatchewan Wheat Pool Canadian grain handling company

The Saskatchewan Wheat Pool was a grain handling, agri-food processing and marketing company based in Regina, Saskatchewan. The Pool created a network of marketing alliances in North America and internationally which made it the largest agricultural grain handling operation in the province of Saskatchewan. Before becoming Viterra, SWP had operated 276 retail outlets and more than 100 grain handling and marketing centres. The Saskatchewan Wheat Pool operated under the name of AgPro in the prairie provinces of Manitoba and Alberta. Begun as a co-operative in the 1920s, the company became a publicly traded corporation in the 1990s. After the 2007 takeover of its competitor, Winnipeg-based Agricore United, the Pool name was retired. The merged company operated under the name Viterra until 2013, when it was acquired by Glencore International.

Goodwater, Saskatchewan Village in Saskatchewan, Canada

Goodwater is a village in the Canadian province of Saskatchewan within the Rural Municipality of Lomond No. 37 and Census Division No. 2. The village is located approximately 50 km (31 mi) south of the City of Weyburn. Goodwater is located on Treaty 4 land, negotiated between the Cree, Saulteaux, and Assiniboine first peoples, and Alexander Morris, second Lieutenant Governor of Manitoba (1872–1877). Goodwater is currently part of the Souris - Moose Mountain federal riding.

Love, Saskatchewan Village in Saskatchewan, Canada

Love is a village in the Canadian province of Saskatchewan within the Rural Municipality of Torch River No. 488 and Census Division No. 14. The village is northeast of the City of Prince Albert and about 48 km (30 mi) south of Prince Albert National Park boundaries and 16 km (9.9 mi) south of Torch River Provincial Forest.

Wheat pools in Canada

A wheat pool is a co-operative that markets grain on behalf of its farmer-members.

The Warner elevator row is a group of four historic wood-cribbed grain elevators standing in a row from south to north alongside the Canadian Pacific Railway line from Great Falls, Montana to Lethbridge, Alberta at the east entrance of the village of Warner, Alberta, Canada. At one time, the row had at least seven elevators.

The Manitoba Grain Growers' Association (MGGA) was a farmer's association that was active in Manitoba, Canada in the first two decades of the 20th century. It provided a voice for farmers in their struggle with grain dealers and the railways, and was influential in obtaining favorable legislation. The MGGA supported the Grain Growers' Grain Company, a cooperative of prairie farmers, and its organ the Grain Growers' Guide. At first it remained neutral politically, but in 1920 it restructured as the United Farmers of Manitoba in preparation for becoming a political party.

Saskatchewan Grain Growers Association

The Saskatchewan Grain Growers' Association (SGGA) was a farmer's association that was active in Saskatchewan, Canada in the early 20th century. It was a successor to the Territorial Grain Growers' Association, and was formed in 1906 after Saskatchewan became a province. It provided a voice for farmers in their struggle with grain dealers and the railways, and was influential in obtaining favorable legislation. The association initially resisted calls to create a farmer-owned marketing company. Later it did support formation of the Saskatchewan Co-operative Elevator Company. The SGGA helped the Saskatchewan Wheat Pool, a cooperative marketing organization, to become established in 1924. In 1926 the SGGA merged with the more radical Farmers' Union of Canada, which had earlier split from the SGGA, to create the United Farmers of Canada,

The Territorial Grain Growers' Association (TGGA) was a farmer's association that was active in Western Canada at the start of the 20th century, in what was then the Northwest Territories and later became Saskatchewan and Alberta. It provided a voice for farmers in their struggle with grain dealers and the railways, and was influential in obtaining favorable legislation. After Alberta and Saskatchewan became provinces the TGGA was succeeded by the Alberta Farmers' Association and the Saskatchewan Grain Growers' Association.

The Alberta Farmers' Association (AFA) was a farmer's association that was active in Alberta, Canada from 1905 to 1909. It was formed from the Alberta branch of the Territorial Grain Growers' Association (TGGA) when Alberta became a province in 1905. It provided a voice for farmers in their struggle with grain dealers and the railways. In January 1909 it merged with the Canadian Society of Equity to form the United Farmers of Alberta.

Edward Alexander Partridge

Edward Alexander Partridge was a Canadian teacher, farmer, agrarian radical, businessman and author. He was born in Ontario but moved to Saskatchewan where he taught and then became a farmer. He was active in the Territorial Grain Growers' Association (TGGA), founded in 1902, which addressed various problems with the Western Canada grain market. He founded the cooperative Grain Growers' Grain Company, the predecessor of the United Grain Growers, and the Grain Growers' Guide, a widely distributed weekly paper. His "Partridge Plan" was a broad and visionary proposal for addressing a wide range of farmers' issues, eliminating many abuses caused by the near-monopoly of grain elevator companies, and resulted in important reforms by the provincial governments. Patridge was named a National Historic Person in 2018.

<i>The Grain Growers Guide</i>

The Grain Growers' Guide was a newspaper published by the Grain Growers' Grain Company (GGGC) in Western Canada for grain farmers between 1908 and 1936. It reflected the views of the grain growers' associations. In its day it had the highest circulation of any farm paper in the region.

George Fisher Chipman

George Fisher Chipman was a Canadian journalist who edited the Grain Growers' Guide for many years. The paper was the official organ of the provincial grain growers' associations in the Canadian prairies, and became the mostly widely circulated farmers' paper in the region.

Grain Growers Grain Company

The Grain Growers' Grain Company (GGGC) was a farmers' cooperative founded in the prairie provinces of western Canada in 1906. The GGGC met strong resistance from existing grain dealers. It was forced off the Winnipeg Grain Exchange and almost failed. With help from the Manitoba government it regained its seat on the exchange, and soon had a profitable grain trading business. The company founded the Grain Growers' Guide, which became the most popular farmer's newspaper in the region. In 1912 the GGGC began operating inland and terminal grain elevators, and in 1913 moved into the farm supply business. The GGGC was financially secure and owned or operated almost 200 elevators as well as 122 coals sheds and 145 warehouses by the time it merged with the Alberta Farmers' Co-operative Elevator Company to form the United Grain Growers in 1917.

James William Scallion

James William Scallion was an Irish-born Canadian teacher, farmer and agrarian activist. He was the founder of the Manitoba Grain Growers' Association.

Saskatchewan Co-operative Elevator Company

The Saskatchewan Co-operative Elevator Company (SCEC) was a farmer-owned enterprise that provided grain storage and handling services to farmers in Saskatchewan, Canada between 1911 and 1926, when its assets were purchased by the Saskatchewan Wheat Pool.

Alberta Farmers Co-operative Elevator Company

The Alberta Farmers' Co-operative Elevator Company (AFCEC) was a farmer-owned enterprise that provided grain storage and handling services to farmers in Alberta, Canada between 1913 and 1917, when it was merged with the Manitoba-based Grain Growers' Grain Company (GGGC) to form the United Grain Growers (UGG).

References

    1. 1 2 3 4 5 6 Knuttila 2011.
    2. 1 2 3 4 5 Nicholson 2003.
    3. 1 2 3 4 USDA 1928, p. 8.
    4. 1 2 3 4 Friesen 2012.
    5. ↑ Manitoba Agricultural Museum Release 2014.
    6. 1 2 USDA 1928, p. 9.
    7. ↑ Dick 2008, p. 202.
    8. ↑ Dick 2008, p. 202–203.
    9. ↑ Dick 2008, p. 203.
    10. ↑ Dick 2008, p. 203–204.
    11. ↑ Goldsborough 2013.
    12. ↑ Dick 2008, p. 204.
    13. ↑ Dick 2008, p. 209.
    14. ↑ Klippenstein 2014.

    Sources

    This page is based on this Wikipedia article
    Text is available under the CC BY-SA 4.0 license; additional terms may apply.
    Images, videos and audio are available under their respective licenses.