McCleary v. Washington

Last updated

McCleary v. State of Washington
Seal of the Supreme Court of Washington.png
Full case name
  • Mathew and Stephanie McCleary, on their own behalf and on behalf of Kelesy and Carter McCleary, their two children in Washington’s public schools; Robert and Patty Venema, on their own behalf and on behalf of Halie and Robbie Venema, their two children in Washington’s public schools; and Network For Excellence in Washington Schools (“NEWS”), a state wide coalition of community groups, public school districts, and education organizations, Respondents/Cross-Appellants, v. State of Washington, Appellant/Cross-Respondent.
Court Washington Supreme Court
DecidedJanuary 5, 2012
Citation(s)269 P.3d 227; 173 Wash. 2d 477; 276 Ed. Law Rep. 1011
Case history
Appealed from King County Superior Court
Court membership
Chief judge Gerry L. Alexander
Associate judges Tom Chambers, Mary Fairhurst, Charles W. Johnson, James M. Johnson, Barbara Madsen, Susan Owens, Debra L. Stephens, Charles K. Wiggins
Case opinions
Decision byDebra L. Stephens
ConcurrenceCharles W. Johnson, Tom Chambers, Susan Owens, Mary E. Fairhurst, Charles K. Wiggins, Gerry L. Alexander
Concur/dissentBarbara A. Madsen, joined by James M. Johnson

Mathew and Stephanie McCleary et al., v. State of Washington (short form: McCleary v. Washington), commonly known as the McCleary Decision, [1] was a lawsuit against the State of Washington. The case alleged that the state, in the body of the state legislature, had failed to meet the state constitutional duty (in Article IX, Section 1) "to make ample provision for the education of all children residing within its borders." [2]

Contents

King County Superior Court

Judge John Erlick sided with the Plaintiffs, stating that the State was indeed failing to adequately provide for basic education, saying "State funding is not ample, it is not stable, and it is not dependable." [3]

Washington State Supreme Court

On January 5, 2012, the Supreme Court agreed with the opinion of the King County Superior Court that the State was not fulfilling its obligation to fully fund education in the state, [4] with some justices dissenting in part on the question of continued judicial oversight. [5]

Subsequent developments

In the 2013 Legislative Session, the State Legislature increased school funding by 11.4% to a total of $15.2 billion. They also passed three major reform bills in an attempt to further comply with the McCleary ruling. [6]

Despite these changes, the Supreme Court did not find the State in compliance. On January 9, 2014 the Supreme Court issued an order setting a deadline of April 30, 2014 for the legislature to come up with an adequate funding plan. [7]

On August 13, 2015, the Supreme Court ordered a $100,000 a day fine. This money was to be placed in a special account that would be used to benefit public education. [8] The Court also urged the Governor at the time, Jay Inslee, to call a special session of the legislature to pass a funding plan to bring the State into compliance. [9]

On June 7, 2018, the Supreme Court declared the state had fully covered the funding of basic education, lifting the contempt order and $100,000 a day fine, ending any judicial oversight of the case. [10] [11]

In the McCleary ruling, the Supreme Court cited teacher pay as a primary issue with the failure of the state to fund public education. [12] In response to the court's satisfaction with the state's amended funding models, the state teacher's union, Washington Education Association, promoted the increase in state public school funding as justification to increase teacher salaries, [13] and sponsored multiple teacher's strikes to demand them. [14]

On April 11, 2019, at least one school district (Spokane Public Schools) announced significant staffing cuts, which it tied directly to the McCleary decision. [15] Although the decision increased state funding of school districts it also reduced funding from local levies [16] resulting in a projected shortfall of almost $31 million for the district in the 2019-20 school year. The net staff reduction of about 8% represented 325 paid positions, impacted either through layoff or reduction in hours. [17]

The court identified low teacher salaries as one of the basic components (along with class size) of an ample education. Teacher salaries have risen since McCleary, and as of 2023, average teacher salaries are the fifth highest of any state [18] . Overall spending on education is among the top 20 states. [19]

Related Research Articles

Brown v. Board of Education of Topeka, 347 U.S. 483 (1954), was a landmark decision by the U.S. Supreme Court which ruled that U.S. state laws establishing racial segregation in public schools are unconstitutional, even if the segregated schools are otherwise equal in quality. The decision partially overruled the Court's 1896 decision Plessy v. Ferguson, which had held that racial segregation laws did not violate the U.S. Constitution as long as the facilities for each race were equal in quality, a doctrine that had come to be known as "separate but equal". The Court's unanimous decision in Brown, and its related cases, paved the way for integration and was a major victory of the civil rights movement, and a model for many future impact litigation cases.

<span class="mw-page-title-main">Education in the United States</span> Overview of the educational system in the United States

In the United States, education is provided in public and private schools and by individuals through homeschooling. State governments set overall educational standards, often mandate standardized tests for K–12 public school systems and supervise, usually through a board of regents, state colleges, and universities. The bulk of the $1.3 trillion in funding comes from state and local governments, with federal funding accounting for about $260 billion in 2021 compared to around $200 billion in past years.

Separate but equal was a legal doctrine in United States constitutional law, according to which racial segregation did not necessarily violate the Fourteenth Amendment to the United States Constitution, which nominally guaranteed "equal protection" under the law to all people. Under the doctrine, as long as the facilities provided to each race were equal, state and local governments could require that services, facilities, public accommodations, housing, medical care, education, employment, and transportation be segregated by race, which was already the case throughout the states of the former Confederacy. The phrase was derived from a Louisiana law of 1890, although the law actually used the phrase "equal but separate".

<span class="mw-page-title-main">Jay Inslee</span> Governor of Washington since 2013

Jay Robert Inslee is an American politician, lawyer, and economist who has served as the 23rd governor of Washington since 2013. A member of the Democratic Party, he served as a member of the U.S. House of Representatives from 1993 to 1995 and again from 1999 to 2012, and was a candidate for the 2020 Democratic presidential nomination. He is the longest-serving current governor in the United States.

<span class="mw-page-title-main">NAACP Legal Defense and Educational Fund</span> Organization in New York, United States

The NAACP Legal Defense and Educational Fund, Inc. is an American civil rights organization and law firm based in New York City.

<span class="mw-page-title-main">Rob McKenna</span> 17th Attorney General of Washington

Robert Marion McKenna is an American lawyer and politician who served as the 17th attorney general of Washington from 2005 to 2013 after serving on the Metropolitan King County Council from 1996 to 2005. A member of the Republican Party, he ran for Governor of Washington in 2012, losing to Democrat Jay Inslee.

<span class="mw-page-title-main">East Central University</span> Public university in Ada, Oklahoma

East Central University is a public university in Ada, Oklahoma. It is part of Oklahoma's Regional University System. Beyond its flagship campus in Ada, the university has courses available in McAlester, Shawnee, and Durant, as well as online courses. Founded as East Central State Normal School in 1909, its present name was adopted in 1985. Some of its more prominent alumni include former Microsoft COO B. Kevin Turner, Modernist painter Leon Polk Smith, former NFL player Mark Gastineau, past governors Robert S. Kerr and George Nigh, former U.S. Representative Lyle Boren, Oklahoma Supreme Court Justice Tom Colbert, and U.S. Army General James D. Thurman.

Missouri v. Jenkins, 515 U.S. 70 (1995), is a case decided by the United States Supreme Court. On June 12, 1995 the Court, in a 5–4 decision, reversed a district court ruling that required the state of Missouri to correct intentional racial discrimination in Kansas City schools by funding salary increases and remedial education programs.

The Campaign for Fiscal Equity (CFE) was a not-for-profit advocacy organization that sought to protect and promote the constitutional right to a sound basic education for all public school students in the State of New York. Under the leadership of Michael A. Rebell, the organization filed and won the landmark "CFE v. State of New York" lawsuit, which successfully argued that the state's school finance system under-funded New York City public schools and denied its students their constitutional right.

<span class="mw-page-title-main">Lisa Brown (Washington politician)</span> American politician (born 1956)

Lisa Jo Brown is an American politician and educator who is the current mayor of Spokane, Washington. She previously served as the director of the Washington State Department of Commerce. A member of the Democratic Party, Brown has served in both houses of the Washington State Legislature, including eight years as the first Democratic female majority leader of the Washington State Senate. She has also served as the chancellor of Washington State University Spokane, a position she stepped down from in order to mount an unsuccessful campaign for the U.S. House.

<span class="mw-page-title-main">Bob Ferguson (politician)</span> 18th Attorney General of Washington

Robert Watson Ferguson is an American lawyer and politician serving as the 18th attorney general of Washington. A member of the Democratic Party, he was first elected in 2012 and re-elected in 2016 and 2020. Prior to serving as attorney general, Ferguson was a member of the King County Council.

<span class="mw-page-title-main">Arizona Department of Education</span> State agency

Arizona Department of Education (ADE) is a state-level department tasked in Arizona with oversight of public education from kindergarten to secondary school. The ADE is run by an elected Arizona Superintendent of Public Instruction.

Formal education in Mississippi began in the early 19th century with private schools and academies, a public education system was founded during the Reconstruction era, by the biracial legislature led by the Republican Party. Throughout its history, Mississippi has produced notable education inequalities due to racial segregation and underfunding of black schools, as well as rural zoning and lack of commitment to funding education.

<span class="mw-page-title-main">Doug Ducey</span> Governor of Arizona from 2015 to 2023

Douglas Anthony Ducey is an American businessman and politician who was the 23rd governor of Arizona from 2015 to 2023. A member of the Republican Party, Ducey was CEO of the ice cream parlor chain Cold Stone Creamery from 1995 to 2007 and was Arizona State Treasurer from 2011 to 2015.

<span class="mw-page-title-main">Tony Evers</span> Governor of Wisconsin since 2019

Anthony Steven Evers is an American educator and politician serving as the 46th governor of Wisconsin since 2019. A member of the Democratic Party, he served as Wisconsin's Superintendent of Public Instruction from 2009 to 2019.

<span class="mw-page-title-main">Chad Magendanz</span> American politician

Chad Lee Magendanz is an American software developer and politician. A Republican, he served two terms in the Washington House of Representatives for the 5th district, comprising much of the eastern third of King County. Magendanz was the ranking member on the House Education Committee and served on the House Appropriations and House Technology and Economic Development committees. He previously served as the Issaquah School Board president. Magendanz was endorsed by The Seattle Times in 2012, 2014, 2018, and 2022 and consistently received an Outstanding rating from the Municipal League of King County. He is currently running for Superintendent of Public Instruction.

<i>Vergara v. California</i> 2012 California state court case

Vergara v. California was a lawsuit in the California state courts which dealt with a child's right to education and to instruction by effective teachers. The suit was filed in May 2012 by lawyers on behalf of nine California public school student plaintiffs. It alleged that several California statutes on teacher tenure, layoffs, and dismissal violated the Constitution of California by retaining some "grossly ineffective" teachers and thus denying equal protection to students assigned to the teachers. Furthermore, according to the complaint, the statutes had a disparate impact on poor and minority students, who were more likely to be assigned to a grossly-ineffective teacher.

Carver Junior College, in Cocoa, Florida, was established by the Brevard County Board of Public Instruction in 1960 to serve black students, at the same time that it founded Brevard Junior College, now Eastern Florida State College, for white students. It was named for the black agricultural researcher George Washington Carver. Like 10 of Florida's other 11 black junior colleges, it was founded as a result of a 1957 decision by the Florida Legislature to preserve racial segregation in education, mandated under the 1885 Constitution that was in effect until 1968. More specifically, the Legislature wanted to show, in response to the unanimous Supreme Court decision mandating school integration, that the older standard of "separate but equal" educational facilities was still viable in Florida. Prior to this legislative initiative, the only publicly funded colleges for negro or colored students were Florida A&M University, in Tallahassee, and Booker T. Washington Junior College, in Pensacola.

The Public Records Act (PRA) is a law of the U.S. state of Washington requiring public access to all records and materials from state and local agencies. It was originally passed as a ballot initiative by voters in 1972 and revised several times by the state legislature. The definition of public records, especially concerning the state legislature, was subject to several legal challenges in the decades since the law was passed.

Senate Bill 151, also known as SB 151, is a pension bill passed on March 29, 2018, by the Kentucky Senate and the Kentucky House of Representatives. The bill includes increases for cost of living, ends the inviolable contract for new teachers hired after January 1, 2019, and requires employees hired between 2003 and 2008 to pay an additional 1 percent of their pay for health care benefits in retirement. The bill received numerous criticism, especially from teachers. The bill was overturned on December 13, 2018, by the Kentucky Supreme Court as unconstitutional, which prevented the bill from going into effect on January 1, 2019.

References

  1. O'Sullivan, Joseph (January 27, 2017). "McCleary fix? Senate GOP wants to change teacher pay, how schools are funded". Seattle Times . Retrieved May 6, 2017.
  2. "Education - Preamble.", Washington State Constitution, art. IX, sec. 1, August 23, 1889, retrieved May 6, 2017
  3. "Court's Findings of Fact & Conclusions of Law", King County Superior Court, CONCLUSION, February 4, 2010, retrieved January 29, 2019
  4. McCleary v. Washington, 84362-7 (majority) ( Washington Supreme Court January 5, 2012).
  5. McCleary v. Washington, 84362-7 (concurrence/dissent) ( Washington Supreme Court January 5, 2012).
  6. "Overview of the McCleary decision", Washington Policy Center, January 21, 2014, retrieved February 3, 2019
  7. Supreme Court Order re: McCleary, et al. v. State (PDF), January 9, 2014, retrieved February 3, 2019
  8. Supreme Court Order No. 84362-7 - McCleary v. State of Washington (PDF), January 9, 2014, retrieved February 3, 2019
  9. Santos, Melissa; Schrader, Jordan (August 13, 2015). "Court fines state government $100,000 per day for failure to fund education". Tacoma News Tribune . Retrieved February 3, 2019.
  10. Supreme Court Order No. 84362-7 (PDF), June 7, 2018, retrieved February 3, 2019
  11. O'Sullivan, Joseph (June 7, 2018). "Washington Supreme Court ends long-running McCleary education case against the state". The Seattle Times . Retrieved February 3, 2019.
  12. Morton, Neal (February 6, 2017). "How the complex history of teacher pay in Washington slows down education funding solutions". Seattle Times . Retrieved June 25, 2023.
  13. "McCleary victory: Billions for Washington K-12 public schools and students". Washington Education Association. August 9, 2022. Retrieved June 25, 2023.
  14. Whittenberg, Jake (September 6, 2018). "This is the most teacher strikes in Washington state since 1983". KING 5 News . Retrieved June 25, 2023.
  15. Associated Press (April 12, 2019). "Spokane schools blames McCleary laws for deficit, layoffs" . Retrieved June 25, 2023.
  16. "For school systems, McCleary decision gave with one hand and took with the other". The Spokesman-Review . September 9, 2018. Retrieved April 12, 2019.
  17. "'This is a scary day': 325 employees laid off from Spokane Public Schools". KREM (TV) . April 11, 2019. Retrieved April 12, 2019.
  18. https://www.king5.com/article/news/education/washington-state-school-funding-mccleary/281-56eace14-fded-46c0-a1e8-2105d2cb7974
  19. https://www.king5.com/article/news/education/washington-state-school-funding-mccleary/281-56eace14-fded-46c0-a1e8-2105d2cb7974