Mitenand Initiative

Last updated

The Solidarity for a new policy on foreigners popular initiative (also known as the Mitenand Initiative) was a Swiss federal popular initiative, rejected by the voters and cantons on 5 April 1981.

Contents

Content

The initiative calls for several amendments to Article 69th of the Federal Constitution, which defines the country's policy on foreigners and their status. Among these amendments, the initiative calls for the abolition of seasonal worker status, the right to automatic renewal of residence permits, and freedom of choice in employment and place of residence, while restricting immigration. [1] .

The full text of the initiative can be consulted on the website of the Swiss Federal Chancellery [2] .

Background

Historical context

Between 1950 and 1978, the percentage of the foreign population in Switzerland rose from 5% to 14.4% of the total population [3] . This increase, mainly due to the arrival of workers from southern Europe, led to the launch of several initiatives known as the "initiatives against foreign overpopulation", presented by various far-right movements, including National Action led by Zurich deputy James Schwarzenbach [4] .These initiatives were all rejected in votes held on 7 June 1970 [5] , 20 October 1974 [6] , and 13 March 1977 [7] , [8] .

The present initiative was launched in response to these proposals to limit the number of foreigners.

Collection of signatures and submission of the initiative

The collection of the required 100,000 signatures began at the end of October 1974 (the exact date has not been preserved). On 20 October 1977, the initiative was submitted to the Swiss Federal Chancellery, which declared it valid on 8 November [9] .

Discussions and recommendations of the authorities

Both the Federal Assembly [10] and the Federal Council [11] recommended rejection of the initiative. In its message to the Assembly, the Federal Council acknowledged the positive aspect of the initiators' desire to improve the legal status of foreigners. However, according to him, several measures called for in this initiative “go too far,” thus justifying its rejection. As an indirect counterproposal, the government is presenting a revision of the law on foreigners, which is currently being finalized.

Vote

Put to a vote on 5 April 1981, the initiative was rejected by all 20 6/2 cantons and by 83.8% of voters [12] . The table below details the results by canton: [13]

CantonYes (%)
Zürich 15.6
Bern 13.6
Lucerne 12.7
Uri 10.1
Schwyz 11.1
Obwalden 8.6
Nidwalden 9.8
Glarus 7.1
Zug 12.3
Fribourg 24.2
Solothurn 13.3
Basel-Stadt 18.8
Basel-Landschaft 18.0
Schaffhausen 15.2
Appenzell Ausserrhoden 10.5
Appenzell Innerrhoden 7.1
St. Gallen 10.1
Graubünden 8.8
Aargau 11.8
Thurgau 10.4
Ticino 18.2
Vaud 24.7
Valais 13.0
Neuchâtel 30.5
Geneva 24.1
Jura 44.3

Aftermath

In line with the government's proposal, and following the popular rejection of this initiative, the federal chambers approved a new version of the law a few months after the vote. However, this revision was challenged in a referendum by National Action, which considered it made Switzerland too attractive to foreigners wishing to settle there. It was submitted to popular vote [14] and rejected on 6 June 1982 [15] , forcing the authorities to come up with a new proposal. This eventually entered into force on 16 December 2005 under the name "Federal Act on Foreign Nationals" (FNIA) [16]

References

  1. "Votation populaire du 5 avril 1981" (in French). Federal Chancellery. Retrieved 4 January 2026.
  2. "Texte de l'initiative populaire fédérale «être solidaires en faveur d'une nouvelle politique à l'égard des étrangers»" (in French). Federal Chancellery. Retrieved 4 January 2026.
  3. Message du Conseil fédéral à l'Assemblée fédérale concernant l'initiative populaire «contre la pénétration étrangère» [Message of the Federal Council to the Federal Assembly on the popular initiative "against foreign overpopulation"] (in French). Vol. II. Feuille fédérale. 17 August 1967. pp. 69–122. Retrieved 4 January 2026.
  4. Fiala, Pierre (March 1984). "Le consensus patriotique, face cachée de la xénophobie" [The patriotic consensus, hidden face of xenophobia]. Mots (in French). 8 (1): 17–41. doi:10.3406/mots.1984.1138 . Retrieved 4 January 2026.
  5. "Volksabstimmung vom 07.06.1970 – Eidgenössische Volksinitiative «gegen die Überfremdung» – Tableau récapitulatif" [Popular vote of 7 June 1970 – Federal popular initiative "against foreign overpopulation" – Summary table] (in German). Swiss Federal Chancellery. Retrieved 4 January 2026.
  6. "Votation populaire du 20.10.1974 – Eidgenössische Volksinitiative «pour la limitation de l'immigration étrangère» – Tableau récapitulatif" [Popular vote of 20 October 1974 – Federal popular initiative "for the limitation of foreign immigration" – Summary table] (in French). Swiss Federal Chancellery. Retrieved 4 January 2026.
  7. "Votation populaire du 13.03.1977 – Initiative populaire du Parti républicain «pour la protection de la Suisse» (4e initiative contre l'emprise étrangère) – Tableau récapitulatif" [Popular vote of 13 March 1977 – Republican Party popular initiative "for the protection of Switzerland" (4th initiative against foreign overpopulation) – Summary table] (in French). Swiss Federal Chancellery. Retrieved 4 January 2026.
  8. "Votation populaire du 13.03.1977 – Initiative populaire «pour une limitation du nombre annuel des naturalisations» (5e initiative contre l'emprise étrangère) – Tableau récapitulatif" [Popular vote of 13 March 1977 – Popular initiative "for limiting the annual number of naturalisations" (5th initiative against foreign overpopulation) – Summary table] (in French). Swiss Federal Chancellery. Retrieved 4 January 2026.
  9. "Initiative populaire fédérale 'être solidaires en faveur d'une nouvelle politique à l'égard des étrangers'" [Federal popular initiative 'To be in solidarity for a new policy towards foreigners'] (in French). Swiss Federal Chancellery. Retrieved 4 January 2026.
  10. Arrêté fédéral du 21 octobre 1980 portant soumission aux Chambres fédérales de l'initiative populaire fédérale «être solidaires en faveur d'une nouvelle politique à l'égard des étrangers»[Federal decree of 21 October 1980 submitting the federal popular initiative "To be in solidarity for a new policy towards foreigners" to the Federal Chambers] (in French). Vol. III. Feuille fédérale. 21 October 1980. pp. 715 ff.
  11. Message du Conseil fédéral du 13 novembre 1979 relatif à l'initiative populaire fédérale «être solidaires en faveur d'une nouvelle politique à l'égard des étrangers»[Message of the Federal Council of 13 November 1979 on the federal popular initiative "To be in solidarity for a new policy towards foreigners"] (in French). Vol. III. Feuille fédérale. 13 November 1979. pp. 605 ff.
  12. "Votation populaire du 5 avril 1981 – Initiative populaire «être solidaires en faveur d'une nouvelle politique à l'égard des étrangers» – Tableau récapitulatif" [Popular vote of 5 April 1981 – Federal popular initiative "To be in solidarity for a new policy towards foreigners" – Summary table] (in French). Swiss Federal Chancellery. Retrieved 4 January 2026.
  13. "Votation populaire du 5 avril 1981 – Initiative populaire «être solidaires en faveur d'une nouvelle politique à l'égard des étrangers» – Résultats dans les cantons" [Popular vote of 5 April 1981 – Federal popular initiative "To be in solidarity for a new policy towards foreigners" – Results in the cantons] (in French). Swiss Federal Chancellery. Retrieved 4 January 2026.
  14. "Explications du Conseil fédéral – Votation populaire du 6 juin 1982" [Explanations of the Federal Council – Popular vote of 6 June 1982](PDF) (in French). Swiss Federal Chancellery. 1982. pp. 16–17. Retrieved 4 January 2026.
  15. "Votation populaire du 06.06.1982 – Loi fédérale sur le séjour et l'établissement des étrangers – Tableau récapitulatif" [Popular vote of 6 June 1982 – Federal Act on the Residence and Settlement of Foreigners – Summary table] (in French). Swiss Federal Chancellery. Retrieved 4 January 2026.
  16. "RS 142.20 Loi fédérale du 16 décembre 2005 sur les étrangers et l'intégration (LEI)" [SR 142.20 Federal Act of 16 December 2005 on Foreign Nationals and Integration (FNIA)] (in French). Swiss Federal Chancellery (Fedlex – The Publication Platform for Federal Law). 16 December 2005. Retrieved 4 January 2026.