Murder of Darlene VanderGiesen

Last updated

Murder of Darlene VanderGiesen
Location Sioux Falls, South Dakota, U.S.
DateFebruary 1, 2006;18 years ago (2006-02-01)
Attack type
Murder
Deaths1
PerpetratorDaphne Wright
VerdictGuilty
Convictions
Sentence Life imprisonment without the possibility of parole

Darlene Kay VanderGiesen (died February 1, 2006) was a Deaf American woman murdered in Sioux Falls, South Dakota. Initially reported missing, her dismembered remains were later recovered in rural Rock County, Minnesota, and in the Sioux Falls landfill. Her cause of death could not be officially determined but was ruled to either have been due to suffocation or blunt force trauma.

Contents

Daphne Wright, the ex-girlfriend of VanderGiesen's friend, was convicted of first-degree murder and kidnapping on April 11, 2007. The investigation revealed that VanderGiesen had been taken to Wright's home, where she had been murdered, burned, and dismembered with a chainsaw. Wright was the first woman in South Dakota history to face the death penalty, but following the trial, she was sentenced to life imprisonment without possibility of parole.

Background and disappearance

Darlene Kay VanderGiesen [1] was originally from Kansas but raised in Rock Valley, Iowa. She graduated from the Iowa School for the Deaf in 1983 and moved to Sioux Falls, South Dakota, in 1992. She was active in the South Dakota Association for the Deaf and played softball on a deaf club team. [2]

In September 2004, Sallie Collins moved into an apartment complex in Sioux Falls. Collins, who is deaf, chose the location because many of the residents were also deaf. One such resident was VanderGiesen, and the two began a friendship. [3] Daphne Wright, Collins's girlfriend, reportedly became jealous of the friendship, although it remained platonic. [4] [5] Wright argued with VanderGiesen weeks before the murder, accusing her of attempting to break up the couple. [6] Wright also sent emails, insulting VanderGiesen and warning her to stay away from Collins. [7] Sometime later, VanderGiesen told her family that the two had reconciled and that they were friends again. [8]

On February 1, 2006, VanderGiesen left her job [9] and met Wright at a local Pizza Hut parking lot and entered her car, under the expectation the two would be planning a Valentine's Day surprise for Collins. This was the last time VanderGiesen was seen alive. [10]

Investigation

VanderGiesen was reported missing to the Sioux Falls Police Department on February 3 [11] after failing to show up to work for two days. [7] [9] Her abandoned car was found in the Pizza Hut parking lot, with her keys, wallet, and identification missing. [3] Initially, police and VanderGiesen's family worried that she might have been taken by a man she had met on the Internet. [8] Police interviewed a male acquaintance but ruled out his involvement. [8] [12]

Family and friends congregated at VanderGiesen's apartment, where they interacted with Wright. VanderGiesen's mother recalled, "She came to me and told me who she was. She gave me a hug, and she said she was sorry that Darlene was missing, that they were friends and she would be praying that we would find Darlene soon". [7] VanderGiesen's sister showed police the emails that Wright had sent. The emails were traced to Wright's home but were sent using a pseudonym. [13] Another acquantance told police about the argument. [9] Police conducted a search warrant at Wright's home on February 7 and turned up multiple pieces of evidence, [9] including bone and tissue fragments in the basement that were later identified as VanderGiesen's through DNA testing. [5] [7]

On February 10, Wright was arrested at a Sioux Falls Hotel. [9] During questioning, Wright admitted to the feud with VanderGiesen and to sending the emails [14] but said they had reconciled and denied involvement in the murder. [7] Wright was charged with aggravated kidnapping, first-degree murder, and second-degree murder. [15] At her arraignment on February 14, Wright pleaded not guilty. [1] The state sought the death penalty, making Wright the first woman in South Dakota history to face capital punishment. [5]

On February 11 and 21, partial remains belonging to VanderGiesen were recovered from the Sioux Falls landfill. [16] [5] Her body had been partially burned and dismembered at the torso and legs. [17] [18] On March 28, additional remains were located in Rock County, Minnesota, in a ditch on the side of Rock County 6. [11] [16] A plastic bag had been tied around her head. [16] An autopsy reported that either blunt force trauma to the back of VanderGiesen's head or suffocation may have been the cause of death. [5]

DNA taken from VanderGiesen's remains was matched to samples taken from Wright's shirt, car, and basement, and a carpet discarded at a Sioux Falls landfill. [17] Wright's roommate testified that she witnessed Wright removing the carpet after VanderGiesen disappeared. [17] Receipts were found suggesting Wright purchased a chainsaw, as well as trash bags found with VanderGiesen's remains. [5] Blankets recovered at both the landfill and in Rock County, as well as a rope tied around VanderGiesen's neck, matched those in Wright's home. [16]

Prior to trial, Wright underwent a psychological evaluation, which assessed her reading level equivalent to that of a third grader and found that she had limited verbal communication. The psychologist noted although Wright was fluent in American Sign Language (ASL), the language had limited signs for legal concepts, further complicated by Wright being prelingually deaf. [19]

Trial

The trial took place at the U.S. Courthouse, Sioux Falls. Sioux Falls Federal Building 35.jpg
The trial took place at the U.S. Courthouse, Sioux Falls.

Jury selection lasted four weeks. Jurors were asked questions pertaining to their views on race (Wright is African American; VanderGiesen was white), sexual orientation, deafness, and capital punishment. [6] The defense questioned the composition of the jury selection pool, as none of the 150 were African American. [7] The selected jury consisted of 11 women and 1 man. [18]

The trial began on April 2, 2007, [6] presided over by Circuit Court Judge Brad Zell. [7] An ASL interpreter was provided for Wright. Several deaf audience members attended the trial, and a transcript was broadcast on a screen in the courtroom. [5]

The prosecution argued that Wright had killed VanderGiesen in a fit of rage, jealous of VanderGiesen's friendship with Wright's former lover. [5] The prosecution requested to show a video of a pig being dismembered with the same type of chainsaw used in the crime, [16] but this was denied. [20] The defense attempted unsuccessfully to block images of VanderGiesen's remains and all testimony pertaining to dismemberment. [7] An Ace Hardware cashier testified that Wright had purchased a chainsaw and oil for the blade on February 3. A detective corroborated that marks on the basement floor corresponded with the use of a chainsaw, and that investigators smelled petroleum when fresh paint in the basement was lifted. [21]

The defense argued that there was a lack of evidence tying Wright to the murder, and that although the emails were insulting, they were not threats, [7] and criticized lack of DNA testing on other evidence. [16]

The defense argued that the death penalty would be cruel and unusual punishment and that it would violate the Eighth Amendment, [22] saying although Wright was intelligent, her communication was hindered by her deafness, [6] and that being deaf since childhood placed her at a disadvantage to defend herself. [22] The defense compared her deafness to mental impairment. [4] Circuit Court Judge Brad Zell cited three previous death penalty sentencings imposed on deaf defendants. [6]

On April 11, after eight hours of deliberation, [4] the jury found Wright guilty of all three counts. [23] The prosecution said Wright deserved the death penalty for the dismemberment, calling it "the act of a depraved mind". [24] Wright's defense argued that she had only carried out the burning and dismemberment as a practical means of disposing or the body rather than "for some perverse pleasure". [18] Instead of the death penalty, she was sentenced on April 18 [18] to two life sentences without parole, to be served concurrently, [23] and was transferred to the South Dakota Women's Prison. [4]

Appeals

In 2009, Wright's attorneys filed an appeal against her conviction, citing insufficient interpretation accommodations, errors in the jury selection process, double jeopardy concerns, that Wright had not been read her Miranda Rights early enough, and certain evidence allowed in the court proceedings. [25] [26] The appeal was rejected and Wright's conviction upheld on June 24. [27] [28]

Wright filed a writ of habeas corpus in 2010, seeking a new judge to review the case and citing ineffective assistance of counsel. [29]

Reactions and aftermath

Initially, fears spread amongst the local deaf community that VanderGiesen had been targeted due to her deafness. [9] A vigil was held for VanderGiesen following the announcement of her death. [30] VanderGiesen was buried in her hometown of Rock Valley, Iowa. [6] In 2009, the VanderGiesen family published a book about Darlene's life. Proceeds were donated to the Furniture Mission in Sioux Falls. [31]

Although VanderGiesen was heterosexual, [18] the media dubbed the case a "lesbian love triangle". [22] The case sparked conversation about capital punishment against deaf defendants. [22]

The forensic analysis used in the murder, particularly of the use of the chainsaw, was presented at the annual American Academy of Forensic Sciences conference in 2010. Investigators tested a chainsaw similar to the one used in the murder on a pig to determine how much blood spatter might have been created. Their findings were published in the Journal of Forensic Sciences in 2009. [20]

The murder and subsequent trial were covered in a 2010 episode of Forensic Files in the show's 14th season, entitled "Hear No Evil". [8] The murder was also featured in an episode of Deadly Women during the show's 3rd season.

Related Research Articles

<span class="mw-page-title-main">Murder of Laci Peterson</span> 2002 murder of an American woman in California

Laci Denise Peterson was an American woman murdered by her husband, Scott Lee Peterson, while eight months pregnant with their first child. She disappeared in 2002, from the couple's home in Modesto, California, after which Scott reported her missing. The next year, her remains and those of her unborn son, whom the couple had planned to name Conner, were discovered on the shores of San Francisco Bay; subsequently, Scott was arrested and charged with two counts of murder. In 2004, Scott was found guilty of the first-degree murder of Laci and the second-degree murder of Conner.

<span class="mw-page-title-main">Anna Mae Aquash</span> First Nations activist (1945–1975)

Annie Mae Aquash was a First Nations activist and Mi'kmaq tribal member from Nova Scotia, Canada. Aquash moved to Boston in the 1960s and joined other First Nations and Indigenous Americans focused on education and resistance, and police brutality against urban Indigenous peoples. She was part of the American Indian Movement, participated in several occupations, and participated in the 1973 Wounded Knee incident at the Pine Ridge Indian Reservation, United States.

<span class="mw-page-title-main">Murder of Helle Crafts</span> Danish flight attendant murdered by her husband, airline pilot Richard Crafts

Helle Crafts was a Danish flight attendant who was murdered by her husband, Eastern Air Lines pilot Richard Crafts. Her death led to the state of Connecticut's first murder conviction without the victim's body.

<span class="mw-page-title-main">Winnie Ruth Judd</span> Convicted American murderer (1905–1998)

Winnie Ruth Judd, born Winnie Ruth McKinnell, also known as Marian Lane, was a medical secretary in Phoenix, Arizona, who was accused of murdering her friends, Anne LeRoi and Sarah Samuelson, in October 1931. The murders were discovered when Judd transported the victims' bodies, one of which had been dismembered, from Phoenix to Los Angeles, California, by train in trunks and other luggage, causing the press to name the case the "Trunk Murders". Judd allegedly committed the murders to win over the affections of Jack Halloran, a prominent Phoenix businessman.

<span class="mw-page-title-main">Ipswich serial murders</span> Series of murders in England during 2006

The Ipswich serial murders, commonly known as the work of the Suffolk Strangler, took place between 30 October and 10 December 2006, during which time the bodies of five murdered sex workers were discovered at different locations near Ipswich, Suffolk, England. Their bodies were discovered naked but there were no signs of sexual assault. Two of the victims, Anneli Alderton and Paula Clennell, were confirmed to have been killed by asphyxiation. A cause of death for the other victims, Gemma Adams, Tania Nicol and Annette Nicholls, was not established.

Capital punishment is a legal penalty in the U.S. state of South Dakota.

<span class="mw-page-title-main">Karen Schreier</span> American judge (born 1956)

Karen Elizabeth Schreier is a senior United States district judge of the United States District Court for the District of South Dakota and was the 36th United States Attorney for the District of South Dakota.

<span class="mw-page-title-main">Crumbles murders</span> Either of two 1920s murder cases in England

The Crumbles Murders are two separate and unrelated crimes which occurred on a shingle beach located between Eastbourne and Pevensey Bay, England—locally referred to as "the Crumbles"—in the 1920s. The first of these two murders is the 1920 bludgeoning murder of 17-year-old Irene Munro, committed by two men: Jack Field and William Gray. The second murder to occur upon the Crumbles is the 1924 murder of 38-year-old Emily Kaye, who was murdered by her lover, Patrick Mahon.

Jennifer Lee Daugherty was an American woman who was torture-murdered in Greensburg, Pennsylvania as an act of revenge in February 2010. Daugherty, who was mentally disabled, was tortured and murdered before being wrapped in Christmas decorations, put inside a garbage can, and dumped in the parking lot of Greensburg-Salem Middle School.

In February 2009, Heather Strong was kidnapped and murdered in Marion County, Florida. Emilia Lily Carr, a rival for the affections of a man Strong was married to, came under suspicion. Carr denied any guilt and alleged her statements were coerced. Carr was nevertheless found guilty in December 2010 and sentenced to death by lethal injection in February 2011. Carr was one of five women on death row in the state of Florida. On May 19, 2017, Emilia Carr was re-sentenced to life without parole. Joshua Fulgham was similarly convicted of first-degree murder and kidnapping in the death. At a separate trial, where he pled guilty, Joshua Fulgham received two consecutive sentences of life in prison for his involvement in Strong's murder.

<span class="mw-page-title-main">Babes in the Wood murders (Brighton)</span> Murder of two girls near Brighton in 1986

The Babes in the Wood Murders were the murders of two nine-year-old girls, Nicola Fellows and Karen Hadaway, on 9 October 1986, by a 20-year-old local roofer, Russell Bishop in Wild Park, Moulsecoomb, Brighton, Sussex, England. Bishop was tried and acquitted in 1987. The case remained open until 10 December 2018, when Bishop was found guilty of the murders in a second trial. The investigation into the two girls' murders is the largest and longest-running inquiry ever conducted by Sussex Police.

<span class="mw-page-title-main">Denny Sanford Premier Center</span> Indoor arena in Sioux Falls, South Dakota, U.S.

The Denny Sanford Premier Center is an indoor arena in Sioux Falls, South Dakota. The building is located at 1201 North West Avenue, and is connected to the Sioux Falls Arena and Sioux Falls Convention Center. The Arena's naming rights partners, and largest sponsors, are Sanford Health, First Premier Bank and Premier Bankcard.

<span class="mw-page-title-main">Murder of Travis Alexander</span> 2008 murder of an American man in Mesa, Arizona

Travis Victor Alexander was an American salesman who was murdered by his ex-girlfriend, Jodi Ann Arias, in his house in Mesa, Arizona while in the shower. Arias was convicted of first-degree murder on May 8, 2013, and sentenced to life in prison without the possibility of parole on April 13, 2015.

The 1973 Gitchie Manitou murders involved an attack on a group of five teenagers at Gitchie Manitou State Preserve in Lyon County, Iowa. Four of the teenagers were killed and a fifth was kidnapped and raped. Brothers Allen, James, and David Fryer were later convicted of the crimes and sentenced to life in prison. The attack took place on November 17, 1973.

The murder of Dale Harrell occurred after he was fatally attacked on January 14, 2009, by his wife Marissa-Suzanne "Reese" DeVault in Maricopa County, Arizona. Her trial made national and global headlines. The case was noted as being very similar to that of the murder of Travis Alexander by Jodi Arias, with whom DeVault was in contact and whose murder trial occurred in the same courthouse one year earlier. Though she faced the possibility of a death penalty for her crime, DeVault was sentenced to life in prison. She is imprisoned at Perryville within the Arizona Department of Corrections.

<span class="mw-page-title-main">Marvin Gabrion</span> American murderer on death row

Marvin Charles Gabrion is an American murderer, rapist, and suspected serial killer convicted of the 1997 kidnapping and murder of 19-year-old Rachel Timmerman, of Cedar Springs, Michigan. Timmerman and her 11-month-old daughter, Shannon, disappeared two days before Gabrion was set to stand trial on rape charges filed by Rachel the previous summer. Rachel's body was found in Oxford Lake, weighted down by cinder blocks. Shannon remains missing, but is presumed deceased. Although Gabrion was not tried for killing Shannon, court documents describe her murder as “virtually undisputed.”

The South Dakota Women's Prison is located in Pierre, South Dakota, U.S., and is part of the Solem Public Safety Center run by the South Dakota Department of Corrections. The facility includes the prison grounds and building, offices, and law enforcement agencies.

Chester Allan Poage was an American man who was kidnapped, tortured, and murdered by three men in Spearfish, South Dakota, on March 13, 2000. Elijah Page, Briley Piper, and Darrell Hoadley were convicted of the torture and murder of Poage. Page and Piper were sentenced to death, while Hoadley was sentenced to life in prison. Page was executed by lethal injection on July 11, 2007, becoming the first person to be executed in South Dakota since 1947. Piper remains on death row and is the only person left on death row in South Dakota.

The execution of Charles Rhines occurred on November 4, 2019, at the South Dakota State Penitentiary in Sioux Falls, South Dakota. Rhines was executed for the 1992 murder of Donnivan Schaefer, whom he killed during a burglary at a doughnut shop in Rapid City. His execution generated attention due to claims that the jury had sentenced him to death because he was gay and that his death sentence was tainted by anti-gay bias. Rhines remains the most recent person executed in South Dakota.

<span class="mw-page-title-main">Deaths of Arnold Archambeau and Ruby Bruguier</span> 1992 deaths in South Dakota, United States

Just before dawn on the morning of December 12, 1992, Arnold Archambeau and Ruby Bruguier, aged 20 and 18 respectively, left a car Archambeau had been driving following an accident at an intersection near Lake Andes, South Dakota, United States. They left Bruguier's 17-year-old cousin, Tracy Dion, in the car without any explanation as to where they might be going, and their whereabouts remained unknown for the next three months. One woman told police later that she had seen Archambeau at a New Year's Eve party, but their families never saw the couple, who had a young child together.

References

  1. 1 2 "Woman makes first court appearance on murder charge". Rapid City Journal. Associated Press. February 14, 2006. p. B4. Retrieved September 1, 2024– via Newspapers.com.
  2. ↑ Harriman, Peter (February 26, 2006). "Co-workers, friends fill church for VanderGiesen funeral". Argus Leader. pp.  1B, 7B . Retrieved September 1, 2024.
  3. 1 2 State v. Wright (2009), ¶ 2.
  4. 1 2 3 4 Penn, Denise (May 2007). "Lesbian Convicted of 'Chainsaw Murder' Jury Spares Her Life". Lesbian News. 32 (10): 11. EBSCOhost   25023663 . Retrieved September 1, 2024.
  5. 1 2 3 4 5 6 7 8 Walker, Carson (April 3, 2007). "Woman accused in dismemberment slaying first to face death penalty in S.D." Standard-Times. Retrieved August 31, 2024.
  6. 1 2 3 4 5 6 "Testimony starts Monday in Sioux Falls dismemberment trial". West Central Tribune. Sioux Falls. March 30, 2007. Retrieved August 31, 2024.
  7. 1 2 3 4 5 6 7 8 9 "Deaf black lesbian accused of chainsaw murder". The Sydney Morning Herald . April 10, 2007. Retrieved August 31, 2024.
  8. 1 2 3 4 "Hear No Evil". Forensic Files. Season 14. Episode 2. September 24, 2010. truTV.
  9. 1 2 3 4 5 6 Haugen, Dan (February 11, 2006). "Woman arrested in killing". Argus Leader. pp.  1A, 5A . Retrieved September 1, 2024– via Newspapers.com.
  10. ↑ State v. Wright (2009), ¶ 3.
  11. 1 2 "Human remains found, believed to be those of deaf woman". The Globe . Beaver Creek. March 28, 2006. Retrieved August 31, 2024.
  12. ↑ Haugen, Dan (February 20, 2006). "Experts: Women as killers rare". Argus Leader. pp.  1A, 4A . Retrieved September 1, 2024– via Newspapers.com.
  13. ↑ State v. Wright (2009), ¶ 4.
  14. ↑ State v. Wright (2009), ¶ 6.
  15. ↑ State v. Wright (2009), ¶ 9.
  16. 1 2 3 4 5 6 "Sioux Falls, S.D. / Jury gets graphic details about body". Twin Cities Pioneer Press. Associated Press. April 5, 2007. Retrieved August 31, 2024.
  17. 1 2 3 "Coroner: Blow to head or suffocation killed woman". The Dispatch / The Rock Island Argus . Associated Press. April 9, 2007. Retrieved August 31, 2024.
  18. 1 2 3 4 5 "Deaf woman sentenced to life in prison". NBC News. Associated Press. April 18, 2007. Retrieved August 31, 2024.
  19. ↑ State v. Wright (2009), ¶ 10.
  20. 1 2 Verges, Josh (January 10, 2009). "Chain saw test was key to case, a forensics first". Argus Leader. pp.  1A, 4A . Retrieved September 1, 2024.
  21. ↑ "Chain saw sale at center of South Dakota deaf love-triangle murder trial". The Columbus Dispatch. April 5, 2007. Retrieved August 31, 2024.
  22. 1 2 3 4 "Should the Deaf Get Death?". ABC News. February 7, 2009. Retrieved March 31, 2024.
  23. 1 2 State v. Wright (2009), ¶ 16.
  24. ↑ "South Dakota Woman Sentenced to Life in Prison For Dismembering Ex-Lover's Friend". Fox News. Sioux Falls. Associated Press. April 19, 2007. Retrieved August 31, 2024.
  25. ↑ State v. Wright (2009), ¶ 17.
  26. ↑ Gruchow, Matthew (March 26, 2009). "Deaf murder convict argues unfair trial". Argus Leader. pp.  1A, 5A . Retrieved September 1, 2024– via Newspapers.com.
  27. ↑ State v. Wright, 24531 (S.D.June 24, 2009).
  28. ↑ Brokaw, Chet (June 26, 2009). "Deaf woman's convictions upheld". Rapid City Journal. Pierre. p. A4. Retrieved September 1, 2024– via Newspapers.com.
  29. ↑ Hult, John (September 28, 2010). "Inmate pursuing case reconsideration". Argus Leader. p. 2A. Retrieved September 1, 2024– via Newspapers.com.
  30. ↑ Brandert, Melanie (February 11, 2006). "Thoughts, prayers go out". Argus Leader. pp. 5A. Retrieved September 1, 2024– via Newspapers.com.
  31. ↑ "Parents write book about murdered daughter". Foster's Daily Democrat . Associated Press. April 4, 2009. Retrieved August 31, 2024.

Further reading

This page is based on this Wikipedia article
Text is available under the CC BY-SA 4.0 license; additional terms may apply.
Images, videos and audio are available under their respective licenses.