Necktie paradox

Last updated
Two neckties Greater Manchester Metrolink neckties.jpg
Two neckties

The necktie paradox is a puzzle and paradox with a subjective interpretation of probability theory describing a paradoxical bet advantageous to both involved parties. The two-envelope paradox is a variation of the necktie paradox.

Contents

Statement of paradox

Two persons, each given a necktie, start arguing over who has the cheaper one. The person with the more expensive necktie must give it to the other person.

The first person reasons as follows: winning and losing are equally likely. If I lose, then I will lose the value of my necktie. But if I win, then I will win more than the value of my necktie. Therefore, the wager is to my advantage. The second person can consider the wager in exactly the same way; thus, paradoxically, it seems both persons have the advantage in the bet. [1]

See also

References

  1. Brown, Aaron C. (1995). "Neckties, Wallets, and Money for Nothing". Journal of Recreational Mathematics . 27 (2): 116–122.