Overview and Scrutiny

Last updated

Overview and Scrutiny is a function of local authorities in England and Wales. It was introduced by the Local Government Act 2000 which created separate Executive and Overview and Scrutiny functions within councils. [1]

Contents

Councils operating executive arrangements are required to create an Overview and Scrutiny Committee which is composed of councillors who are not on the Executive Committee, or Cabinet, of that council. Overview and Scrutiny Committees are required to meet the rules on proportionality defined in the Local Government And Housing Act 1989 (i.e. the committee must reflect the respective sizes of the political groups on the council). Councils in England which use the committee system are not required to establish an overview and scrutiny committee, but may do so if they wish. [1]

There is no national standard or prescription on the committee structure that councils adopt to satisfy these legislative requirements. A wide variety of designations and structures are in use, ranging from single committees to multiple committees with sub-committees. Structures have no significant impact on the overall effectiveness of the scrutiny function in individual authorities. [2]

The law relating to overview and scrutiny is slightly different in England, Wales and Northern Ireland. In Scotland, councils all operate under the committee system, although some incorporate policy development groups which perform similar functions to overview and scrutiny committees. [3]

Overview and Scrutiny in England

Scrutiny may, under the Local Government Act 2000 (as amended in 2011), investigate any issue which "affects the area or the area's inhabitants". [4]

Summary of powers and responsibilities

In England, overview and scrutiny committees may:

Scrutiny committees also have powers in relation to certain other partner organisations [8] - in particular local NHS bodies [9] and community safety partnerships. Such bodies are under various obligations to respond or have regard to these recommendations. Scrutiny holds general powers of oversight on flood risk management although detailed regulations relating to such matters have now expired. [10]

By law, Overview and Scrutiny must have the right to 'call-in' [11] decisions – i.e. ask the decision-maker to think again, or to refer the decision to the full council if it is believed that the decision-maker has taken a decision in contravention of the council's budget or policy framework. [11] To be called in, decisions usually need to be "key decisions". [12]

There is usually a window of five working days between the notification of the decision (when it is placed on public deposit) when a call-in can be requested. Again, this varies from authority to authority.

Scrutiny in combined authorities

Combined authorities must have overview and scrutiny committees as part of the governance scheme agreed by Government and confirmed by way of each authority's bespoke Order. The powers of combined authority overview and scrutiny committees are broadly analogous to those of local authorities but the strategic nature of business in combined authorities means that, in order to be effective, scrutiny needs to look quite different. [13] Some combined authority scrutiny committees have struggled with quoracy (having enough members present for the meeting to formally transact business). [14]

Statutory guidance and the importance of culture

In 2017 the House of Commons Communities and Local Government Select Committee conducted on inquiry into local government scrutiny. [15] In response to this inquiry Government committed to the production of refreshed guidance to local authorities and combined authorities on overview and scrutiny, which was published in May 2019. [16] [17] This guidance focused on the importance of culture, and the attitude and mindset of those in executive and other leadership positions, in ensuring scrutiny's overall effectiveness. The importance of organisational and political culture to effective overview and scrutiny has also been highlighted by the Centre for Governance and Scrutiny. [18] [19]

Overview and scrutiny in Wales

The Local Government (Wales) Measure sets out governance requirements for Welsh authorities. Welsh councils must operate executive arrangements and therefore must have overview and scrutiny committees. The powers of those committees are similar to those in England, although there are some differences, particularly in respect of powers over partners (termed as "designated persons").

The Well-being of Future Generations (Wales) Act 2015 means that public bodies are having to think differently about the long-term sustainability of the design and delivery of services: this in turn has implications for the planning and prioritisation of scrutiny work. A Future Generations Framework for Scrutiny has been produced to support this. [20]

The Wales Audit Office has carried out sustained work to support the improvement of scrutiny in Welsh local authorities. Audit work in the 22 Welsh local authorities in 2017/18 led to the production in 2019 of a checklist to guide improvement. [21]

Overview and scrutiny in Northern Ireland

The Local Government (Northern Ireland) Act 2014 allowed new councils to choose between a number of governance options, one of which involves an executive/scrutiny split. Powers for these committees broadly reflect the powers of overview and scrutiny committees in England and Wales. As of 2020 no Northern Ireland council has chosen to adopt a governance model which incorporates overview and scrutiny.

General issues

Some themes are common to all jurisdictions where overview and scrutiny systems operate.

Culture, and parity of esteem

Research on scrutiny at a national level (principally in the UK Parliament [22] ) has highlighted 'parity of esteem' as an important component for scrutiny to be effective. This is replicated at a local level. [19] Different councils can rely on a very different quality and level of support from their respective leaderships; the fact that scrutiny is dependent for resourcing on decision's made by the authority's administration leaves it particularly exposed where this positive culture of scrutiny does not exist. An effective culture of support for scrutiny is a necessary prerequisite for overall effectiveness.

Pre-decision scrutiny/in-year monitoring

Many councils have a procedure for inspection of proposals by members on Overview and Scrutiny committees before the Executive brings final proposals to council, a process known as "pre-decision scrutiny". This may happen a few weeks before a decision comes to be decided by Cabinet, or months earlier where an issue is being considered more fundamentally and options are being developed. [23]

Scrutiny often has a role in in-year performance and finance monitoring, which it undertakes alongside the audit function of the authority.

Policy development and review

Overview and Scrutiny Committees in many councils undertake in-depth reviews of particular issues of relevance to local people.

This work is carried out in order to influence the council's Cabinet, and other local partners. Work like this is usually carried out in informal "task and finish" groups. These look at topics defined by a formal committee on the basis of that committee's work programme, gathering evidence from a range of internal and external witnesses (including the public) before reporting back to the commissioning committee, and ultimately the council's Cabinet, with formal recommendations. The Cabinet is under a duty to respond to recommendations made by scrutiny committees. A number of external partners must "have regard to" such recommendations.

Task and finish groups can take place over many months, or they can be much shorter. Some councils choose to conduct significant amounts of policy development work 'in committee', and/or at one-off meetings. [24]

Scrutiny work which aims to develop and review policy tends to constitute the bulk of work considered most effective.

Public service reform and the partnership dynamic

Common to both the English and Welsh jurisdictions, particularly since 2010, has been the acceleration in the development of formal and informal partnership working at local level. [23] [25]

This has led to a more outward-looking approach to scrutiny work, with councillors looking at issues as they affect local people rather than carrying out oversight of the council as an institution. The potential expansion of scrutiny's role has led to some challenges in prioritisation, and the management of resources, to ensure that the function is investigating the right issues at the right time, and in the right way. [26]

As councils have changed their operating models, scrutiny has also had to change its way of working - this might involve greater use of commissioning, [27] or conversely more effective commercialisation of council operated services. [28]

Criticisms and shortcomings

There have been numerous criticisms of overview and scrutiny since its inception. Former Secretary of State John Denham described it in 2009 as "the lion that has failed to roar". [29] In 2017, the Communities and Local Government Select Committee reported that there was room for improvement in "too many" local authorities. [30]

The Francis inquiry [31] into the Stafford Hospital scandal revealed that concerns expressed to the local scrutiny committee with responsibility for health issues had not been taken up and investigated. The inquiry report suggested that scrutiny needed to be properly supported to carry out a central role in a more robust accountability framework within the NHS, to prevent those events recurring.

Scrutiny is not well resourced in a number of councils. [32] It relies on the council's Cabinet for its budget (there is no independent funding mechanism). The presence of the Democratic Services Committee, and the Head of Democratic Services as a statutory role, in Welsh authorities, affords some protection, as does the presence of the statutory scrutiny officer in upper tier and unitary English authorities.

Support

Local support

Scrutiny committees are assisted by council employees (officers), often called "scrutiny officers". These officers are generally tasked with providing policy and research support to councillors. Sometimes they are also responsible for organising and administering meetings. The average number of scrutiny officers per council has been steadily declining since 2010 although this does not correlate with a decline in scrutiny's overall effectiveness. [32]

National support

The Local Government Association provides a grant to the Centre for Governance and Scrutiny [33] to provide advice, guidance and support to local authorities around scrutiny and good governance.

See also

Related Research Articles

In England, local authorities are required to adopt one of three types of executive arrangements, which govern how decisions will be made within the council. Before the passing of the Localism Act 2011 there were two principal modes of executive arrangements, namely the "leader and cabinet" and the "elected mayor and cabinet" models. A third option "elected mayor and council manager" was withdrawn in 2007. Since 2012, principal authorities have been allowed to adopt the "committee system" form of governance.

Senedd Devolved parliament of Wales

The Senedd, officially known as the Welsh Parliament in English and Senedd Cymru in Welsh, is the devolved, unicameral legislature of Wales. A democratically elected body, it makes laws for Wales, agrees certain taxes and scrutinises the Welsh Government. It is a bilingual institution, with both Welsh and English being the official languages of its business. From its creation in May 1999 until May 2020, the Senedd was known as the National Assembly for Wales.

Welsh Government Devolved government of Wales

The Welsh Government is the devolved government of Wales. The government consists of ministers, who attend cabinet meetings, and deputy ministers who do not, and also of a counsel general. It is led by the first minister, usually the leader of the largest party in the Senedd, who selects ministers and deputy ministers with the approval of the Senedd. The government is responsible for tabling policy in devolved areas for consideration by the Senedd and implementing policy that has been approved by it.

Local government in England System of state administration on a local level in England

The pattern of local government in England is complex, with the distribution of functions varying according to the local arrangements.

Directly elected mayors in England and Wales Local government executive leaders in England and Wales

Directly elected mayors in England and Wales are local government executive leaders who have been directly elected by the people who live in a local authority area. The first such political post was the mayor of London, created as the executive of the Greater London Authority in 2000 as part of a reform of the local government of Greater London. Since the Local Government Act 2000, all of the several hundred principal local councils in England and Wales are required to review their executive arrangements.

The Local Government Act 2000 (c.22) is an Act of the Parliament of the United Kingdom that reformed local government in England and Wales. Its principal purposes are:

East Hertfordshire District Council

East Hertfordshire District Council is the local authority for the East Hertfordshire non-metropolitan district of England, the United Kingdom. East Hertfordshire covers most of the eastern third of Hertfordshire, in the East of England region. The council area includes the county town of Hertford, the district's largest town Bishop's Stortford, Ware, Sawbridgeworth, Buntingford and neighbouring villages.

Fire services in the United Kingdom British fire and rescue services

The fire services in the United Kingdom operate under separate legislative and administrative arrangements in England and Wales, Northern Ireland, and Scotland.

A Welsh Government sponsored body (WGSB) is a non-departmental public body directly funded by the Welsh Government. Under the Government of Wales Act 1998 the bodies were sponsored by the National Assembly for Wales and were known as an Assembly sponsored public body, and this was changed by the Schedule 3 of the Wales Act 2017 which amended the Government of Wales Act 2006.

Cheshire West and Chester Borough and Unitary authority in England

Cheshire West and Chester is a unitary authority with borough status in the ceremonial county of Cheshire, England. It was established on 1 April 2009 as part of the 2009 local government changes, by virtue of an order under the Local Government and Public Involvement in Health Act 2007. It superseded the boroughs of Ellesmere Port and Neston and Vale Royal and the City of Chester; its council assumed the functions and responsibilities of the former Cheshire County Council within its area. The remainder of ceremonial Cheshire is composed of Cheshire East, Halton and Warrington.

Review of the role and effectiveness of non-executive directors was a report chaired by Derek Higgs on corporate governance commissioned by the UK government, published on 20 January 2003. It reviewed the role and effectiveness of non-executive directors and of the audit committee, aiming at improving and strengthening the existing Combined Code.

Telford and Wrekin Council

Telford and Wrekin Council is the local authority of Telford and Wrekin in Shropshire, England. It is a unitary authority, having the powers of a non-metropolitan county and district council combined. The district of Telford and Wrekin was granted borough status in 2002, though the council does not ordinarily include "Borough" in its name.

Government of the United Kingdom Central government of the United Kingdom of Great Britain and Northern Ireland

The Government of the United Kingdom, domestically referred to as Her Majesty's Government, is the central government of the United Kingdom of Great Britain and Northern Ireland. The government is led by the prime minister who selects all the other ministers. The country has had a Conservative-led government since 2010, with successive prime ministers being the then leader of the Conservative Party. The prime minister and their most senior ministers belong to the supreme decision-making committee, known as the Cabinet.

Greater Manchester Combined Authority

The Greater Manchester Combined Authority (GMCA) is a combined authority for Greater Manchester, England. It was established on 1 April 2011 and consists of 11 members; 10 indirectly elected members, each a directly elected councillor from one of the ten metropolitan boroughs that comprise Greater Manchester together with the directly elected Mayor of Greater Manchester. The authority derives most of its powers from the Local Government Act 2000 and Local Democracy, Economic Development and Construction Act 2009, and replaced a range of single-purpose joint boards and quangos to provide a formal administrative authority for Greater Manchester for the first time since the abolition of the Greater Manchester County Council in 1986.

Separation of powers in the United Kingdom

The concept of the separation of powers has been applied to the United Kingdom and the nature of its executive, judicial and legislative functions. Historically, the apparent merger of the executive and the legislature, with a powerful Prime Minister drawn from the largest party in parliament and usually with a safe majority, led theorists to contend that the separation of powers is not applicable to the United Kingdom. However, in recent years it does seem to have been adopted as a necessary part of the UK constitution.

West Yorkshire Combined Authority

The West Yorkshire Combined Authority (WYCA) is the combined authority for West Yorkshire in England. It was established by statutory instrument under the Local Democracy, Economic Development and Construction Act 2009 on 1 April 2014. It is a strategic authority with powers over transport, economic development and regeneration. The metro-mayor of the authority is Tracy Brabin.

North of Tyne Combined Authority Local government body in north east England

The North of Tyne Combined Authority is the combined authority for the historic county boundaries of Northumberland, North East England. The authority came into being on 2 November 2018 under the statutory name Newcastle upon Tyne, North Tyneside and Northumberland Combined Authority. The three local authorities previously formed part of the North East Combined Authority. For transport policy the two combined authorities come together to form the North East Joint Transport Committee.

2021 United Kingdom local elections Elections in the United Kingdom

Local elections in England and Wales were held on 6 May 2021 for more than 145 English local councils for around 5,000 seats, thirteen directly elected mayors in England, and 39 police and crime commissioners in England and Wales. There were also elections to the Scottish Parliament, Senedd and London Assembly, the last in conjunction with the London mayoral election.

The Flood and Water Management Act 2010 (c.29) is a UK Act of Parliament relating to the management of the risk concerning flooding and coastal erosion. The Act aims to reduce the flood risk associated with extreme weather, compounded by climate change. It created the role of Lead Local Flood Authority, which is the local government authority responsible for managing flood risk in the local government area. The Act gave new powers to local authorities, the Environment Agency, The Welsh Ministers and water companies.

References

  1. 1 2 s9JA, Local Government Act 2000, http://www.legislation.gov.uk/ukpga/2011/20/schedule/2/part/1/enacted
  2. ↑ "2012/13 Annual Survey of Overview and Scrutiny in Local Government" (CfPS, 2013), http://www.cfps.org.uk/publications?item=7334&offset=0
  3. ↑ For example, Edinburgh, http://www.edinburgh.gov.uk/meetings
  4. ↑ s9F et seq, Local Government Act 2000, http://www.legislation.gov.uk/ukpga/2011/20/schedule/2/part/1/enacted
  5. ↑ The Local Authorities (Executive Arrangements) (Meetings and Access to Information) (England) Regulations 2012, http://www.legislation.gov.uk/uksi/2012/2089/made
  6. ↑ s9FA(8) and (9), Local Government Act 2000, http://www.legislation.gov.uk/ukpga/2011/20/schedule/2/part/1/enacted
  7. ↑ s9F(2)(d) and (e), Local Government Act 2000, http://www.legislation.gov.uk/ukpga/2011/20/schedule/2/part/1/enacted
  8. ↑ s9FF, s9FI, Local Government Act 2000, http://www.legislation.gov.uk/ukpga/2011/20/schedule/2/part/1/enacted
  9. ↑ Department of Health, "Advice to local authorities on scrutinising health services", https://www.gov.uk/government/publications/advice-to-local-authorities-on-scrutinising-health-services
  10. ↑ Centre for Governance and Scrutiny, "Flooding scrutiny regulations no longer in force", https://www.cfgs.org.uk/flooding-scrutiny-regulations-no-longer-in-force/
  11. 1 2 s9F(4), Local Government Act 2000
  12. ↑ Ones which have a particularly significant financial impact or which affect several council wards, Regulation 8, Local Authorities (Executive Arrangements) (Meetings and Access to Information) (England) Regulations 2012, http://www.legislation.gov.uk/uksi/2012/2089/regulation/8/made
  13. ↑ Centre for Governance and Scrutiny (2017), "Overview and scrutiny in combined authorities: a plain English guide", https://www.cfgs.org.uk/overview-and-scrutiny-in-combined-authorities-a-plain-english-guide/
  14. ↑ Centre for Governance and Scrutiny, "Quoracy issues in combined authority scrutiny", https://www.cfgs.org.uk/quoracy-issues-in-combined-authority-scrutiny/
  15. ↑ "Overview and scrutiny in local government - UK Parliament". Archived from the original on 2017-11-06.
  16. ↑ MHCLG, "Overview and scrutiny: statutory guidance", https://www.gov.uk/government/publications/overview-and-scrutiny-statutory-guidance-for-councils-and-combined-authorities
  17. ↑ Centre for Governance and Scrutiny, "Statutory guidance published",
  18. ↑ Centre for Governance and Scrutiny, "Culture, governance and collaboration", https://www.cfgs.org.uk/culture-governance-and-collaboration/
  19. 1 2 Centre for Governance and Scrutiny, "The good scrutiny guide", https://www.cfgs.org.uk/the-good-scrutiny-guide/
  20. ↑ Future Generations Commissioner for Wales, "Future Generations Framework for Scrutiny", https://futuregenerations.wales/resources_posts/future-generations-framework-for-scrutiny/
  21. ↑ Wales Audit Office, "Six steps to help make scrutiny 'fit for the future'", https://www.audit.wales/sites/default/files/press_releases/local-government-scrutiny-2019-checklist-eng.pdf
  22. ↑ House of Commons Liaison Committee (2019), "Effectiveness and influence of the select committee system", https://publications.parliament.uk/pa/cm201719/cmselect/cmliaisn/1860/1860.pdf
  23. 1 2 Centre for Governance and Scrutiny (2019), "The good scrutiny guide", https://www.cfgs.org.uk/the-good-scrutiny-guide/
  24. ↑ Such as in Hertfordshire, http://www.hertsdirect.org/your-community/havesay/scrutiny/
  25. ↑ Welsh Government (2017), "Guidance for local authority scrutiny committees on the scrutiny of public service boards", https://gov.wales/sites/default/files/publications/2019-02/guidance-on-the-scrutiny-of-public-services-boards.pdf
  26. ↑ "To pick or not to pick: A question of work planning - Centre For Public Scrutiny". Archived from the original on 2020-01-01.
  27. ↑ Centre for Governance and Scrutiny (2015), "The change game", https://www.cfgs.org.uk/the-change-game/
  28. ↑ Centre for Governance and Scrutiny/APSE, "Risk and commercialisation: a guide for councillors", https://www.cfgs.org.uk/risk-and-commercialisation-a-guide-for-scrutiny-councillors/
  29. ↑ "Denham's 'transfer of power' disappoints local government | Public Finance".
  30. ↑ "House of Commons - Effectiveness of local authority overview and scrutiny committees - Communities and Local Government Committee".
  31. ↑ "『市川で探さなきゃ。』おすすめ塾・予備校ランキング：料金費用相場・口コミ評判・中学/高校/大学受験 – とある科学の学習塾".
  32. 1 2 Centre for Governance and Scrutiny (2017), "Annual survey of overview and scrutiny in local government", https://www.cfgs.org.uk/local-government-scrutiny-2017-18-annual-scrutiny-survey-results/
  33. ↑ "Home - Centre for Governance and Scrutiny".
This page is based on this Wikipedia article
Text is available under the CC BY-SA 4.0 license; additional terms may apply.
Images, videos and audio are available under their respective licenses.