| Year | Champion | Score | Runner-up | Venue / city | MVP | Ref. |
|---|
| 1991 | Colgate (1) | 4–2 ( a.e.t. ) | Army | Clinton Field • West Point, NY | Caroline Chambers, Colgate | |
| 1992 | Colgate(2) | 3–1 | Army | Christy Flicker, Colgate | |
| 1993 | Army(1) | 5–4 ( a.e.t. ) | Colgate | Varsity Field • Hamilton, NY | Tara Williams, Army | |
| 1994 | Colgate(3) | 3–1 | Army | Lindsay Barnett, Colgate | |
| 1995 | Colgate(4) | 6–0 | Navy | West Field • Lewisburg, PA | Jennifer Hughes, Colgate | |
| 1996 | Colgate(5) | 3–2 ( a.e.t. ) | Army | Varsity Field • Hamilton, NY | |
| 1997 | Colgate(6) | 4–1 | Army | Molly Ryan, Colgate | |
| 1998 | Colgate (7) | 1–0 | Navy | Dewey Field • Annapolis, MD | Angela Puliafico, Colgate | |
| 1999 | Colgate(8) | 2–0 | Navy | Van Doren Field • Hamilton, NY | Andrea Licari, Colgate | |
| 2000 | Holy Cross (1) | 1–0 | Colgate | Colleen Cushing, Holy Cross | |
| 2001 | Bucknell (1) | 2–1 ( a.e.t. ) | Navy | Warner Facility • Annapolis, MD | Lauren Schwarz, Bucknell | |
| 2002 | American (1) | 2–1 | Colgate | Clinton Field • West Point, NY | Anabel Jimenez, American | |
| 2003 | Navy(1) | 4–1 | American | Reeves Field • Washington, D.C. | Amelia Sheveland, Navy | |
| 2004 | Colgate(9) | 2–0 | Lehigh | Van Doren Field • Hamilton, NY | Kelly Kuss, Colgate | |
| 2005 | Bucknell(2) | 3–1 | Army | Ulrich Complex • Bethlehem, PA | Shannon Curd, Bucknell | |
| 2006 | Navy(2) | 1–0 | Colgate | Varsity Soccer Field • Lewisburg, PA | Shelly Moeller, Navy | |
| 2007 | Navy(3) | 1–0 | Bucknell | Brigtte Fox, Navy | |
| 2008 | Army(2) | 1–0 ( a.e.t. ) | Navy | Warner Facility • Annapolis, MD | Sarah Goss, Army | |
| 2009 | Colgate(10) | 1–0 ( a.e.t. ) | American | Van Doren Field • Hamilton, NY | Jillian Arnault, Colgate | |
| 2010 | Lehigh(1) | 1–0 | Army | Clinton Field • West Point, NY | Lauren Mains, Lehigh | |
| 2011 | Army(3) | 2–0 | Navy | Van Doren Field • Hamilton, NY | Joey Molacek, Army | |
| 2012 | Colgate(11) | 1–0 | Navy | Glenn Warner Facility • Annapolis, MD | Ashley Walsh, Colgate | |
| 2013 | Boston University (1) | 1–0 | Navy | Andrea Green, Boston University | |
| 2014 | Boston University(2) | 2–1 | Colgate | Beyer-Small '76 Field • Hamilton, NY | Kai Miller, Boston University | |
| 2015 | Boston University(3) | 1–0 | Bucknell | Nickerson Field • Boston, MA | Clare Pleuler, Boston University | [2] |
| 2016 | Bucknell(3) | 2–1 ( a.e.t. ) | Boston University | Emmitt Field • Lewisburg, PA | Cora Climo, Bucknell | [3] |
| 2017 | Bucknell(4) | 3–2 | Navy | Glenn Warner Facility • Annapolis, MD | Kendall Ham, Bucknell | [4] |
| 2018 | Boston University(4) | 1–0 | Lehigh | Nickerson Field • Boston, MA | Anna Heilferty, Boston University | [5] |
| 2019 | Navy(4) | 2–1 | Army | Glenn Warner Facility • Annapolis, MD | Carolyn Mang, Navy | [6] |
| 2020 | Navy(5) | 1–1 (4–1 p) | Colgate | Beyer-Small '76 Field • Hamilton, NY | Kristina Dzhandzhapanyan, Navy | [7] |
| 2021 | Bucknell(5) | 1–0 | Boston University | Nickerson Field • Boston, MA | Teresa Deda, Bucknell | [8] |
| 2022 | Bucknell(6) | 0–0 (3–1 p) | Army | Clinton Field • West Point, NY | Rylee Donaldson, Bucknell | [9] |
| 2023 | Bucknell(7) | 0–0 (4–3 p) | Army | Jenna Hall, Bucknell | [10] [11] |
| 2024 | Boston University(5) | 1–1 (8–7 p) | Bucknell | Emmitt Field • Lewisburg, PA | Morgan Weaver, Boston University | [12] [13] |
| 2025 | Army(4) | 3–2 | Boston University | Nickerson Field • Boston, MA | Sabrina Rogers, Army | [14] |
