Pennsylvania Declaration

Last updated
Gilded funerary mask, Egypt, Ptolemaic or Roman period (post-300 BCE), Penn Museum Gilded cartonnage funerary mask produced after 300 BCE (Ptolemaic or Roman Period) Penn Museum 02.jpg
Gilded funerary mask, Egypt, Ptolemaic or Roman period (post-300 BCE), Penn Museum

The Pennsylvania Declaration was a statement of ethics issued by the University of Pennsylvania Museum of Archaeology and Anthropology on April 1, 1970. It affirmed that the Penn Museum would no longer acquire objects that lacked provenance or collection histories. The declaration aimed to distinguish the Penn Museum's collection practices from illegal antiquity trading while maintaining trust with countries where the university engaged in field research. [1] This declaration marked the first time that a museum had taken formal steps to guarantee the ethical acquisition of materials and to deter looting and illicit antiquities trading. Froelich Rainey, director of the Penn Museum, presented the declaration at the meeting of the United Nations Educational, Scientific, and Cultural Organization (UNESCO), in conjunction with the issue of its treaty known as the 1970 Convention on the Means of Prohibiting and Preventing the Illicit Import, Export and Transfer of Ownership of Cultural Property. [2]

Contents

Background

The Penn Museum was established in 1887 to house artifacts from archaeological and anthropological expeditions which the University of Pennsylvania sponsored around the world. Before World War II, when many countries still allowed the exportation of newly excavated archaeological materials, Penn acquired large collections in the course of these excavations. Penn Museum excavations are well-documented, and the Penn Museum Archives now preserve extensive records associated with them. [1]

Aside from acquiring materials through excavations, the Penn Museum also received objects from donors and through purchase from private collectors. In 1966, the Penn Museum bought a collection of gold believed to be from site of Troy, now in Turkey; the seller was George Allen, a private antiquities dealer. Museum directors tasked underwater archaeologist George Bass, assistant curator of the Mediterranean Section, with writing a report on the collection. [3] However, the objects lacked archaeological records and Bass was only able to make tentative suppositions based on their physical properties. Bass and the rest of the curation team at the museum concluded that collecting objects of this nature would undermine the credibility and development of archaeological scholarship and threaten future field research. The curators agreed to stop collecting objects without collection histories and archaeological records – without clear provenance – while the university was still sponsoring expeditions in the field. [4] Against this context, and determined to set policy, Penn Museum director Froelich Rainey worked with colleagues to develop the Pennsylvania Declaration. [2]

UNESCO and the Pennsylvania Declaration

In 1969, UNESCO had invited Froelich Rainey, in his capacity as director of the Penn Museum, to aid in drafting the Convention on the Means of Prohibiting and Preventing the Illicit Import, Export and Transfer of Ownership of Cultural Property. Rainey had hoped to “establish a ‘uniform antiquities law’ throughout the world”.  He accepted the offer to participate. During preliminary deliberations with other members of the UNESCO team, however, Rainey realized that the UNESCO convention would lack legal accountability and would not suffice in ending looting, regulating the importation of cultural material, and providing guidelines for legal trade. This realization influenced his decision to draft the separate Pennsylvania Declaration. [4]

Although the United States government committed to follow UNESCO's 1970 Convention, its terms were not incorporated into U.S. law until 1983, with the Convention on Cultural Property Implementation Act. After 1970, t account for gaps in legal implementation, private and public organizations revised, developed, and clarified policies regarding illegal antiquities. [2]

Subsequent Efforts and Revisions

The International Council of Museums adopted a policy later in 1970 outlining an "Ethics of Acquisition" stating that "there must be a full, clear and satisfactory documentation in relation to the origin of any object to be acquired whether the object is classified as a work of art or an object of archaeology, ethnology, or of national and natural history”. Within the decade, related organizations followed suit by issuing similar policies and updates. These emendations included the “1970 resolution of the AIA, the 1971 resolution of the SAA, the 1972 resolution of the American Anthropological Association, the 1973 Joint Professional Policy on Museum Acquisitions of the American Association of Museums (AAM), and the joint 1973 resolution of the International Council of Museums (ICOM) Committee on Ethnography and the International Union of Anthropological and Ethnological Sciences.” Among individual museums, for example, the Field Museum of Natural History in Chicago and Harvard University adopted comparable policies in 1971. [2]

In 1978, the Penn Museum issued a policy to build on the Pennsylvania Declaration. [5] The new policy stated that the museum would ‘‘’not knowingly acquire, by gift, bequest, exchange or purchase, any materials known or suspected to be illegally exported from their countries of origin; nor will they knowingly support this illegal trade by authenticating or expressing opinions concerning such material and will actively discourage the collection of such material, exhibiting such material in The University Museum, or loaning University Museum objects to exhibitions of illegally acquired objects in other museums." The Penn Museum also reserved the right to refuse to loan objects to museums or other institutions suspected of having knowingly violated the 1970 Convention.” [2]

Related Research Articles

Ban Chiang Archaeological site in north-east Thailand

Ban Chiang is an archaeological site in Nong Han District, Udon Thani Province, Thailand. It has been a UNESCO World Heritage Site since 1992. Discovered in 1966, the site attracted interest due to its ancient, red pottery. Beginning in 2003, it gained international attention when the United States Department of Justice prosecuted smugglers and museums for trafficking in Ban Chiang antiquities.

University of Pennsylvania Museum of Archaeology and Anthropology

The University of Pennsylvania Museum of Archaeology and Anthropology—commonly called the Penn Museum—is an archaeology and anthropology museum that is part of the University of Pennsylvania. It is located on Penn's campus in the University City neighborhood of Philadelphia, at the intersection of 33rd and South Streets.

Antiquities

Antiquities are objects from antiquity, especially the civilizations of the Mediterranean: the Classical antiquity of Greece and Rome, Ancient Egypt and the other Ancient Near Eastern cultures. Artifacts from earlier periods such as the Mesolithic, and other civilizations from Asia and elsewhere may also be covered by the term. The phenomenon of giving a high value to ancient artifacts is found in other cultures, notably China, where Chinese ritual bronzes, three to two thousand years old, have been avidly collected and imitated for centuries, and the Pre-Columbian cultures of Mesoamerica, where in particular the artifacts of the earliest Olmec civilization are found reburied in significant sites of later cultures up to the Spanish Conquest.

Archaeological ethics refers to the moral issues raised through the study of the material past. It is a branch of the philosophy of archaeology. This article will touch on human remains, the preservation and laws protecting remains and cultural items, issues around the globe, as well as preservation and ethnoarchaeology.

Collection (artwork)

A museum is distinguished by a collection of often unique objects that forms the core of its activities for exhibitions, education, research, etc. This differentiates it from an archive or library, where the contents may be more paper-based, replaceable and less exhibition oriented, or a private collection of art formed by an individual, family or institution that may grant no public access. A museum normally has a collecting policy for new acquisitions, so only objects in certain categories and of a certain quality are accepted into the collection. The process by which an object is formally included in the collection is called accessioning and each object is given a unique accession number.

Repatriation (cultural heritage) return of stolen art to the original owners or heirs

Repatriation is the return of art or cultural heritage, often referring to ancient or looted art, to their country of origin or former owners. The disputed cultural property items are physical artifacts of a group or society that were taken from another group usually in an act of looting, whether in the context of imperialism, colonialism or war. The contested objects vary widely and include sculptures, paintings, monuments, objects such as tools or weapons for purposes of anthropological study, and human remains.

American Council for Cultural Policy (ACCP) was a not-for-profit organization formed in 2002 by a group of politically influential antiquities dealers, collectors and lawyers in the United States, with its headquarters in New York and representatives in Washington D.C.. The goal of the organization was described by Ashton Hawkins as "informing the public on arts issues." The organization is now defunct and its website (culturalpolicycouncil.org) has been removed from the web. Some of its members now actively take part in Cultural Policy Research Institute.

Hagop Kevorkian Armenian-American archeologist, connoisseur of art and collector

Hagop Kevorkian was an Armenian-American archeologist, connoisseur of art, and collector, originally from Kayseri, who graduated from the American Robert College in Istanbul, settled in New York City in the late 19th century, and helped America acquire a taste for Eastern artifacts.

George Fletcher Bass was an American archaeologist. An early practitioner of underwater archaeology, he co-directed the first expedition to entirely excavate an ancient shipwreck at Cape Gelidonya in 1960 and founded the Institute of Nautical Archaeology in 1972.

Oscar White Muscarella

Oscar White Muscarella is an American archaeologist and former Senior Research Fellow at the Metropolitan Museum of Art, where he worked for over 40 years before retiring in 2009. He specializes in the art and archaeology of the Ancient Near East, in particular Ancient Persia and Anatolia. Muscarella is an untiring opponent of the Looting of ancient sites and has earned a reputation as the conscience of the discipline. He received his Ph.D. from the University of Pennsylvania in 1965.

The antiquities trade is the exchange of antiquities and archaeological artifacts from around the world. This trade may be illicit or completely legal. The legal antiquities trade abides by national regulations, allowing for extraction of artifacts for scientific study whilst maintaining archaeological and anthropological context. The illicit antiquities trade involves non-scientific extraction that ignores the archaeological and anthropological context from the artifacts.

What in the World? is a 1951 to 1955 television quiz show hosted by Dr. Froelich Rainey in which the scholar-contestants tried to identify artifacts. The objects were primarily archaeological in nature, but also consisted of fossils, ethnographic items and more. It premiered on October 7, 1951 on CBS. The first, and one of the most successful shows of its type, it confounded critics by running for 15 years and influenced successors such as the BBC's Animal, Vegetable, Mineral? and others. The music of the opening and closing were taken from Ottorino Respighi's "Fountains of Rome" featuring the dissonant beginning of the Fontana de Tritone section. The music accompanying the beginning of each segment, with the artifact to be discussed emerging mysteriously from a cloud of smoke, was taken from a variety of sources, usually 20th century compositions such as Stravinsky's "The Rite of Spring" or Debussy's "Syrinx".

Froelich Gladstone Rainey was an American anthropologist and Director of the University of Pennsylvania Museum of Anthropology and Archaeology from 1947 to 1977. Under his leadership, the Penn Museum announced the Pennsylvania Declaration, ending the purchase system of acquiring antiquities and artifacts that had, in practice, encouraged looting from historical sites. In the early 1950s Rainey also devised and hosted the popular "What in the World?" television gameshow, which highlighted the museum's collections and involved notable scholars and celebrities of the day. In 1975, in recognition of his role at the University of Alaska Fairbanks, where he had served as the university's first professor of anthropology from 1935 to 1942, Rainey's Cabin on the campus was listed on the National Register of Historic Places.

Hiram M. Hiller Jr. American physician

Hiram Milliken Hiller Jr., was an American physician, medical missionary, explorer, and ethnographer. He traveled in Oceania and in South, Southeast, and East Asia, returning with archeological, cultural, zoological, and botanical specimens and data for museums, lectures and publications. His notes and collections provide valuable information about those regions and their people from the late 19th century. In later life, he was involved in the study of polio during the epidemics that hit the United States in the early 20th century.

UNIDROIT Convention on Stolen or Illegally Exported Cultural Objects

UNIDROIT Convention on Stolen or Illegally Exported Cultural Objects is the international treaty on the subject of cultural property protection. It attempts to strengthen the main weaknesses of the 1970 UNESCO Convention on the Means of Prohibiting and Preventing the Illicit Import, Export and Transfer of Ownership of Cultural Property. The UNIDROIT Convention seeks to fight the illicit trafficking of cultural property by modifying the buyer's behaviour, obliging him/her to check the legitimacy of their purchase.

George Byron Gordon (1870–1927) was a Canadian-American archaeologist, who graduated from Harvard University in 1894. While studying at Harvard, he participated in excavations at Copan in Honduras under the direction of John G. Owens in 1891. Following Owens’ death in the field, Gordon took command of the Copan expeditions from 1894 to 1895 and in 1900–1901. After his time in Honduras, George Byron Gordon was hired by the University of Pennsylvania where he led two expeditions to Alaska in 1905 and 1907. He spent the remainder of his twenty-four year employment at the University of Pennsylvania collecting antiquities for the University of Pennsylvania Museum of Archaeology and Anthropology’s North American collections, and he remains one of the museum’s largest contributors of North American artifacts.

Collections management (museum) Process of overseeing a collection, including acquisition, curation, and deaccessioning

Collections management involves the development, storage, and preservation of collections and cultural heritage. The primary goal of collections management is to meet the needs of the individual collector or collecting institution's mission statement, while also ensuring the long-term safety and sustainability of the cultural objects within the collector's care. Collections management, which consists primarily of the administrative responsibilities associated with collection development, is closely related to collections care, which is the physical preservation of cultural heritage. The professions most influenced by collections management include collection managers, registrars, and archivists.

The Cultural Heritage Center of the American Bureau of Educational and Cultural Affairs specializes in the protection and preservation of the world's ancient and historic monuments and archeological sites.

"Found in collection" (FIC) is a term used by a museum to refer to "undocumented objects that remain without status after all attempts to reconcile them to existing records of permanent collection and loan objects are completed". Despite the best efforts of museum staff, museums often have FIC items. This term was developed so that collections with incomplete provenance would be handled ethically and with transparency. Depending on the paperwork and information accompanying the material, the museum has several choices in how to proceed.

Sara Yorke Stevenson

Sara Yorke Stevenson was an American archaeologist specializing in Egyptology, one of the founders of the University of Pennsylvania Museum of Archaeology and Anthropology, suffragist and women's rights activist, and a columnist for the Philadelphia Public Ledger.

References

  1. 1 2 Alessandro Pezzati, with Jane Hickman and Alexandra Fleischman, “A Brief History of the Penn Museum”, Expedition, 54:3 (2012), pp. 3-19
  2. 1 2 3 4 5 Gerstenblith, Patty, "The Meaning of 1970 for the Acquisition of Archaeological Objects, 38 J. Field Archaeology 364 (2013)" (2013). College of Law Faculty Publications. Paper 1359. http://via.library.depaul.edu/law-faculty-pubs/1359
  3. George Bass, “Troy and Ur: Gold Links Between Two Ancient Capitals”, Expedition, 8:4 (1966), pp. 26-39
  4. 1 2 Pezzati, Alessandro. “The Pennsylvania Declaration.” Expedition 52:2, 2010, p. 4, www.penn.museum/documents/publications/expedition/PDFs/52-2/from%20the%20archives.pdf.
  5. “The Pennsylvania Declaration: Decision of Curators of the University Museum, University of Pennsylvania, April 1, 1970”, Expedition, 22:3 (1980), p. 3