Re Culleton (No 2)

Last updated

Re Culleton (No 2)
Coat of Arms of Australia.svg
Court High Court of Australia as the Court of Disputed Returns
Full case nameIn the matter of questions referred to the Court of Disputed Returns pursuant to section 376 of the Commonwealth Electoral Act 1918 (Cth) concerning Senator Rodney Norman Culleton
Decided3 February 2017
Citation(s) [2017] HCA 4, 263 CLR 176
Transcript(s)
Court membership
Judge(s) sitting Kiefel, Bell, Gageler, Keane & Nettle JJ

Re Culleton (No 2) [1] was a significant Australian court case, decided in the High Court of Australia sitting as the Court of Disputed Returns on 3 February 2017. The case was an influential decision concerning the construction of Section 44(ii) of the Constitution, which held that Rod Culleton's conviction for larceny meant that he was incapable of being chosen as a Senator and the subsequent annulment of that conviction did not operate retroactively to deny the legal effect to the conviction from the time that it was recorded. [2]

Contents

Background

Culleton was declared one of the elected Senator for Western Australia as the lead candidate on the Pauline Hanson's One Nation ticket during the 2016 federal election, which was held on 2 July 2016. At that time, he had been convicted in absentia on a larceny charge over a vehicle key in New South Wales, but had not yet been sentenced. [3]

Criminal charge

In April 2014, Culleton was involved in a dispute with a tow truck driver in Guyra, New South Wales. The tow truck driver was attempting to repossess a truck and the key to the tow truck went missing. Culleton was charged with larceny in relation to the missing key. When the matter came before the local court in March 2016 Culleton was not present, saying he did not have time to travel to the Court as he was required to be in court in Western Australia the day before on unrelated larceny charges. Culleton was convicted in his absence. [2] He successfully applied for the conviction be set aside, [3] with the conviction being annulled on 8 August 2016. [4] Culleton then pleaded guilty to the offence, and was ordered to pay the truck driver's costs with no conviction being recorded. [5]

Section 44 of the Constitution

Under section 44(ii) of the Constitution, any person who "has been convicted and is under sentence, or subject to be sentenced, for any offence punishable under the law of the Commonwealth or of a State by imprisonment for one year or longer" shall (section 44 continues) "be incapable of being chosen or of sitting as a senator or a member of the House of Representatives". [6] Previous time in prison was not a disqualification and there have been numerous politicians who had spent time in prison before their election. [7] The High Court had previously observed that the disqualification is not simply for the conviction for an offence, nor serving time in prison. The disqualification required both conviction and that the person was imprisoned at the time or awaiting sentence. [8] The WA larceny charge did not give rise to any question of disqualification as Culleton had only been charged and had not been convicted. At the time of Culleton's nomination and election, he had been convicted for the New South Wales offence but had not been sentenced.

A former colleague lodged a petition with the High Court (sitting as the Court of Disputed Returns), claiming that Culleton was not able to nominate for the election as he was convicted and awaiting sentence in New South Wales at the time of the election. [9] Subsequently, the Australian Government asked the Senate to also refer the matter to the High Court; the reference included a request to determine what should be done if Culleton's seat were found to be vacant. [10] The primary issues before the High Court concerned the effect of the subsequent annulment of Culleton's conviction and whether Culleton was subject to be sentenced to a term of imprisonment for one year or longer.

Judgment

On 3 February 2017, the High Court determined the Senate reference, unanimously finding that Culleton had been ineligible for election to the Senate. At the time of the 2016 election he was subject to being sentenced to imprisonment for up to two years, which under Constitution section 44(ii) rendered him ineligible for election. This had not been affected by the subsequent annulment of the finding of guilt; the annulment had operated only from the time of the annulment. The vacancy should be filled by a special count of the ballot papers. Any directions necessary to give effect to the conduct of the special count should be made by a single Justice. However, the Court anticipated that a simple recount, as if Culleton had not been a candidate, would make the votes cast for him (so far as they were "above the line", which was 96% of them) would flow through to the next One Nation candidate. The Court ordered, as the Commonwealth had previously agreed, that most (with specific exceptions) of Culleton's costs of the action would be borne by the Commonwealth (Culleton had initially represented himself, but eventually he had been provided with counsel). [1] [11] [12]

The majority stated, in an introductory summary of their judgment (with which Nettle J differed only as to reasoning): [13]

Senator Culleton was a person who had been convicted and was subject to be sentenced for an offence punishable by imprisonment for one year or longer at the date of the 2016 election. That was so, both as a matter of fact and as a matter of law. The subsequent annulment of the conviction had no effect on that state of affairs. It follows from s 44(ii) that Senator Culleton was "incapable of being chosen" as a Senator. In the result, there is a vacancy in the representation of Western Australia in the Senate for the place for which Senator Culleton was returned.

Result

Culleton had been found ineligible for election to the Senate. His vacancy was filled by a countback of the ballot papers in Western Australia, on the basis that Culleton's name was not on the paper. As had been anticipated, the recount resulted in votes cast for him, including the "above the line" votes (which were 96% of his vote) flowed through to the next One Nation candidate, which was Peter Georgiou, Culleton's brother-in-law. Georgiou's election was confirmed on 10 March [14] and he was sworn in on 27 March 2017. [15]

The government has demanded repayment by Culleton, as "a debt to the Commonwealth", of payments he had received while disqualified, and indicated it might also seek repayment of superannuation payments, other entitlements and staff payments.

Related Research Articles

Pauline Hansons One Nation Political party in Australia

Pauline Hanson's One Nation, also known as One Nation or One Nation Party, is a political party in Australia. One Nation was founded in 1997, by member of parliament Pauline Hanson and her advisors David Ettridge and David Oldfield after Hanson was disendorsed as a federal candidate for the Liberal Party of Australia. The disendorsement came before the 1996 federal election because of comments she made about Indigenous Australians. Hanson sat as an independent for one year before forming Pauline Hanson's One Nation.

In the Parliament of Australia, a casual vacancy arises when a member of either the Senate or the House of Representatives:

A suspended sentence is a legal term for a judge's delaying of a defendant's serving of a sentence after they have been found guilty, in order to allow the defendant to perform a period of probation. If the defendant does not break the law during that period, and fulfills the particular conditions of the probation, the judge usually dismisses the sentence.

The criminal law of Australia is the body of law made, recognised and applied in Australia that relates to crime. Most criminal law is made and administered by the individual states and territories of Australia. However, a body of criminal law is also made and administered by the federal government. Criminal law may be differentiated from civil law, which in Australia relates to non-criminal law including civil wrongs, contract law, much of property law and other areas that concern the rights and duties of individuals amongst themselves.

Court of Disputed Returns (Australia) Special electoral jurisdiction of the High Court of Australia

The Court of Disputed Returns in Australia is a special jurisdiction of the High Court of Australia. This jurisdiction was initially established by Part XVI of the Commonwealth Electoral Act 1902 and is now contained in Part XXII of the Commonwealth Electoral Act 1918. The High Court sitting as the Court of Disputed Returns hears challenges regarding the validity of federal elections. The jurisdiction is twofold: (1) on a petition to the Court by an individual with a relevant interest or by the Australian Electoral Commission, or (2) on a reference by either house of the Commonwealth Parliament.

William Robert Wood is a UK-born Australian who has campaigned on peace and justice issues. He was elected to the Australian Parliament in the 1987 elections as Senator for New South Wales, however the High Court subsequently declared his election was invalid as he was not an Australian citizen at the time.

Section 44 of the Australian Constitution lists the grounds for disqualification on who may become a candidate for election to the Parliament of Australia. It has generally arisen for consideration by the High Court sitting in its capacity as the Court of Disputed Returns. It has been reviewed several times, but has not been amended. Following several disqualifications under sub-section 44(i), a new review of the whole section was instituted on 28 November 2017.

Anthony James Fels is a former Liberal Member of Parliament. He was the member of the Western Australian Legislative Council representing the Agricultural Region from 2005 to 2009, representing the Liberal Party (2005–2008) and later the Family First Party (2008–2009). In 2007, Fels was found to be in contempt of Parliament by a select committee report for giving false answers to a parliamentary inquiry. Despite attempts from the Liberal Party to remove Fels, he resigned from the Liberal Party in August 2008, and attempted to form his own party called People Against Daylight Saving. He later joined Family First. He was leader of WA Family First before they merged with the Australian Conservatives.

Murray Patrick Watt is an Australian politician. He is a member of the Australian Labor Party (ALP) and has been a Senator for Queensland since the 2016 federal election, He previously served in the Queensland Legislative Assembly from 2009 to 2012.

Section 46 of the Constitution of Australia provides a penalty for a Senator or member of the House of Representatives who sits while constitutionally ineligible or disqualified from holding that position.

Members of the Australian Senate, 2016–2019 Wikipedia list article

This is a list of members of the Australian Senate following the 2016 Australian federal election held on 2 July 2016. The election was held as a consequence of a double dissolution in which both houses of parliament were dissolved. Ordinarily, only half of the senators terms end at each election. In this case, all 76 senators were elected. At the first sitting following the election, half of the senators representing each of the six states of Australia were allocated six-year terms to end on 30 June 2022, with the remainder allocated three-year terms to end on 30 June 2019. The terms of senators from the Australian Capital Territory and the Northern Territory end on the day of the next federal election.</ref>

Results of the 2016 Australian federal election (Senate)

The 2016 Australian federal election in the Senate was part of a double dissolution election held on Saturday 2 July to elect all 226 members of the 45th Parliament of Australia, after an extended eight-week official campaign period. It was the first double dissolution election since the 1987 election and the first under a new voting system for the Senate that replaced group voting tickets with optional preferential voting.

Rodney Norman Culleton is an Australian politician who was sworn in and sat as a Senator for Western Australia following the 2016 federal election. At that time he was a member of the Pauline Hanson's One Nation party, but on 18 December 2016 he resigned from the party to sit as an independent.

Panagiotis "Peter" Georgiou is a former Australian politician, who served as a Senator for Western Australia between 2017 and 2019. He was the second candidate on the Senate ticket for Pauline Hanson's One Nation party in the 2016 Australian federal election. The lead candidate on the ticket was Rod Culleton, Georgiou's brother-in-law. Culleton was declared to have been elected to the Senate when the writs were returned. However, the High Court, sitting as the Court of Disputed Returns, ruled on 3 February 2017 that Culleton had been ineligible to be elected at the time of the election. A consequence of that ruling was that a special recount of the votes was undertaken, as if Culleton had not been on the ballot, and Georgiou was elected in his place. Georgiou was sworn in as a Senator on 27 March 2017.

45th Parliament of Australia federal parliamentary term in Australia from 2016 to 2019

The 45th Parliament of Australia was a meeting of the legislative branch of the Australian federal government, composed of the Australian Senate and the Australian House of Representatives. It met in Canberra from 30 August 2016 to 4 April 2019. The 2016 general election held on 2 July gave the Coalition of the Liberal and National Parties control of the House, albeit with a slimmer majority than the 44th Parliament, allowing their leader Malcolm Turnbull to stay in office as the 29th Prime Minister of Australia. During the term of the parliament, the government slipped into minority due to defections and by-elections. The leadership of the government also changed during the parliament, when Scott Morrison replaced Turnbull as Liberal Leader and Prime Minister in August 2018. The 45th Parliament was officially dissolved by the Governor-General Sir Peter Cosgrove at 8:29 a.m. on 11 April 2019.

2017–18 Australian parliamentary eligibility crisis Crisis over the eligibility of members of the Parliament of Australia over citizenship

Starting in July 2017, the eligibility of several members of the Parliament of Australia to be elected was questioned. Referred by some as a "constitutional crisis", fifteen sitting politicians were ruled ineligible by the High Court of Australia or resigned pre-emptively. The situation arose from section 44(i) of the Australian Constitution, which prohibits parliamentarians from having allegiance to a foreign power, especially citizenship. On that basis, the High Court previously held that dual citizens are ineligible for election unless they have taken "reasonable steps" to renounce the foreign citizenship before nomination.

Hollie Alexandra Hughes is an Australian politician who was elected as a Senator for New South Wales at the 2019 federal election. She is a member of the Liberal Party.

The Great Australian Party Australian political party

The Great Australian Party is a political party in Australia. The party was formally registered by the Australian Electoral Commission (AEC) on 7 April 2019 and is associated with former senator Rod Culleton who had been elected in the 2016 Australian federal election as a senator for Western Australia, but subsequently found to have been ineligible and was disqualified.

References

  1. 1 2 Re Culleton (No 2) [2017] HCA 4 , 263 CLR 176. Judgment summary (PDF), High Court, 3 February 2017
  2. 1 2 Blackshield, T (6 February 2017). "Incapable of being chosen". AusPubLaw.org.
  3. 1 2 Chang, Charis (1 August 2016). "Pauline Hanson's surprises keep on coming". News Limited. Australian Associated Press. Retrieved 2 August 2016.
  4. "One Nation senator conviction set aside". SBS. Australian Associated Press. 8 August 2016. Retrieved 8 August 2016.
  5. "One Nation Senator Rod Culleton pleads guilty to larceny, avoids conviction". ABC. 25 October 2016. Retrieved 2 November 2016.
  6. Constitution (Cth) s 44 Disqualification.
  7. Holland, I (2003). "Crime and Candidacy". Parliament of Australia.
  8. Nile v Wood [1987] HCA 62 , (1987) 167 CLR 133.
  9. Day, Lauren (25 August 2016). "One Nation's Rod Culleton faces court challenge over eligibility for Senate seat". 7.30 . ABC . Retrieved 29 August 2016.
  10. Karp, Paul (2 November 2016). "Government challenges election of One Nation senator Rod Culleton". The Guardian. Retrieved 4 November 2016.
  11. "Submissions, Case C15/2016". High Court of Australia. 3 February 2017. Retrieved 7 February 2017.
  12. Remeikis, Amy (3 February 2017). "Rodney Culleton was never legally elected to Senate, High Court rules". The Sydney Morning Herald. Retrieved 4 February 2017.
  13. Re Culleton [No 2] [2017] HCA 4 at [4] per Kiefel, Bell, Gageler & Keane JJ.
  14. Silva, Kristian; Anderson, Stephanie (10 March 2017). "One Nation: Rod Culleton's brother-in-law Peter Georgiou confirmed as replacement". ABC News . Retrieved 10 March 2017.
  15. "One Nation senator Peter Georgiou sworn in". News.com.au. 27 March 2017. Archived from the original on 27 March 2017.