Red Butte Creek oil spill

Last updated
Red Butte Creek oil spill
Red Butte Creek oil spill
Location Red Butte Creek
Salt Lake City, Utah
Coordinates 40°45′58″N111°49′35″W / 40.76619°N 111.82647°W / 40.76619; -111.82647
Date11 June 2010 – 12 June 2010
Cause
CauseRuptured pipeline
Operator Chevron Corporation
Spill characteristics
Volume33,000 L (7,300 imp gal; 8,700 US gal)
Area Red Butte Creek, Jordan River, Liberty Park
Shoreline impacted5 km (3.1 mi)

The Red Butte Creek oil spill was caused by a rupture in a medium crude oil pipeline that occurred on June 11 and 12 2010. The Chevron Pipeline (CPL) is 10 inches in diameter and runs from western Colorado to a Chevron Corporation oil refinery near Salt Lake City Utah. [1] A half-inch diameter hole in the pipeline was caused by an electrical arc from high voltage power lines to a metal fence post buried a few inches above the pipeline.

Contents

Description

Red Butte Creek is an urban stream that is heavily controlled by dams and reservoirs. It flows through natural channels, urban parks (including the lake in Liberty Park), and buried culverts, emptying into the Jordan River. [2] Oil began spewing from the pipeline sometime around 10 pm local time that Friday in the vicinity of Red Butte Garden in Salt Lake City. Several hours after detection of pressure reduction in the line, the broken pipe was discovered flowing 50 to 60 US gallons (190 to 230 L; 42 to 50 imp gal) of oil per minute into the Red Butte Creek. Roughly 800 barrels (33,600 gallons) of oil were released, approximately 400 were recovered on land, and 400 entered into the creek. [3] Crews contained the flow before it was able to reach the Great Salt Lake. Three miles of the creek were significantly oiled and required cleanup treatment. [2] Oil began spewing from the pipeline sometime around 10 pm local time that Friday in the vicinity of Red Butte Garden in Salt Lake City. Residents were immediately warned to stay away from Red Butte Canyon, and Liberty Park was shut down for the day. [1] Clean up efforts were conducted by the Chevron Corporation along with the city of Salt Lake's Fire Department, Police Department, and Public Utilities Department. [4] Crews used absorbent booms and created dams to contain the majority of the spill. [1] Utilizing many oilfield service companies, including 221 personnel, two-thirds of the total spill was recovered within the first week of the rupture. Affected wildlife were transported to Hogle Zoo for treatment. As of 9 September 2010 a total of 778 of the 800 barrels were accounted for through recovery from water, soil removal, and evaporation. [3] It is worth noting that this spill occurred amidst the responses to the BP Deepwater Horizon and the Kalamazoo River spill. The Red Butte Creek spill received reduced attention despite it being one of the largest to occur in Region 8 in some time. [2] In addition, the proximity of permanent residences leads to a greater potential impact on public health in the area. [2]

The Geographic Area

Red Butte Creek in Salt Lake City, Utah is a narrow rocky creek between City Creek to the north and Emigration Creek to the south. It is divided into two parts by the Red Butte Gardens, namely Upper Butte Creek and Lower Butte Creek. Lower Red Butte Creek passes through urban areas and discharges into Liberty Park Lake at Liberty Park. This portion of the creek was affected by the spill. One of the Lower Creek's functions is as an urban stormwater conveyance system. [5] The Red Butte Reservoir regulates the flow of Lower Butte Creek. High flow instances affect the distribution of chemicals as well as biotic communities within the creek. [5] Approximately 50 to 86 percent of the soils lining the banks of Red Butte have severe erosion potential. [5]

Vegetation

The most common trees along the streamside are box elder and cottonwood as well as the Siberian elm, which was an introduced invasive species. [5] Canopy cover is generally high, but it is visibly reduced in the lower urban areas. [5] Common shrub species include red osier dogwood, twinberry honeysuckle, and narrow leaf willow with Woods' rose common on upper portions of slopes. [5]

Wildlife

A managed population of native Bonneville cutthroat trout inhabits the Upper Red Butte Creek while there are no reports of the Lower Butte Creek supporting a fishery (aside from the few trout likely stocked by residents for fishing). [5] In the affected area more than 30 different species of birds have been observed along with deer, raccoon, and skunk along the urban creek bed. [5]

Impact of the Spill

The Red Butte Creek oil spill rendered several city-owned lands unusable during 2010. These lands included Liberty Park, Miller Park, Sunnyside Park, and various trails and infrastructure, which lost income due to the spill. The stormwater sewer system in the area was physically damaged by the oil release and system and had to be repaired. [6] A thick, tacky substance was clinging to rocks, soil, fish, and birds in the riparian corridor where the spill occurred. Roughly 300 birds, mostly Canada geese, were oiled along with reports of dead fish along the waterway. [7] The birds were herded into temporary corrals and transported to the Hogle zoo for cleaning. [8] Some may even need to be transferred to a wildlife rehabilitation center. [8] In addition, A local fish known as the June sucker fish reportedly endangered in since 1986 inhabits the Butte Creek Reservoir and could have also been affected by the spill. [7]

Reactions

Drastically different reactions about the spill and cleanup efforts are circling. US Representative Jim Matheson believes Chevron "is responding very aggressively to [the spill]… they know there is a heightened concern among people in this country about oil spills…they understand it's in their best interest to do everything they can to fix this." [7] Salt Lake City Mayor, Ralph Becker, attests that he "will do all [he] can to ensure our city's natural assets are restored…the city is not going to rest until we see the cleanup through." [7] Local residents, however, are less hopeful. Those who live along the creek saw it turn black over a day. One resident even stated "Whatever is in that creek will die…I have so little faith in the oil companies to take care of this." [7]

Cleanup Efforts

Unified Command (UC), consisting of the U.S. Environmental Protection Agency (EPA), five state and county agencies, and the Responsible Party (RP), determined the priority of the cleanup effort would be the "macro-invertebrate community in the sediment and the large trees and vegetation along the shore." [2] This focus led the team to select a low-impact response method to minimize erosion of the bank. [2] The UC decided that leaving some staining on rocks and culverts was acceptable if it meant protection of the riparian corridor and the vegetated canopy. [2] The UC knew the local ecosystem due to a recent survey of the riparian area, which facilitated consensus on a cleanup endpoint. [2]

Responsibility

The CPL is primarily responsible for the cleanup efforts of the Red Butte Creek area. The company has expended approximately $26,886,000 as of July 31, 2011, on remediation efforts. [6] A huge concern of the cleanup effort was that it be done correctly. Removing oil can create a multitude of problems if it is not handled properly. Oil forced into the creek beds and soils can destroy the natural habitat that a host of wildlife depends on. [1] The substance also affects waterfowl's natural water resilience and can contaminate algae, which is eaten by the animals and fish in the stream. [1] Chevron sent in an investigation team from Houston and a special hotline has been set up to field complaints and questions from residents. [1]

Methods

Response measures included maintaining boom operations and deploying emergency response equipment. [5] The primary method of cleanup for the creek was to flood and drain the impacted area twice through manipulation of the many dams and reservoirs along its path. [2] Workers on foot would flush the channel banks using backpack sprayers and floating pumps following each intentional flooding. Restoration of the riparian corridor included restoring vegetation, stabilizing banks, and re-introducing native trout. [5] Surface water, sediment, and bank samples were analyzed for total petroleum hydrocarbons (TPH), volatile organic compounds, semi-volatile organic compounds and grain size and total organic carbon in soil and sediments. [5] Reference creeks expected to have similar environmental conditions as Lower Red Butte Creek in the absence of the incident were used to characterize a reasonable endpoint state for cleanup efforts. [5]

Habitat Restoration

Several biotas were considered of high interest in maintaining the natural flow of in-creek and riparian habitats. Some in-creek biota include aquatic plants, invertebrates, fish, amphibians, and benthic macroinvertebrates, while biota essential to the riparian ecosystem were reptiles, waterfowl, and mammals. [5] If these guilds are maintained the habitat is expected to successfully recover. [5] The number of species and the complexity of biological communities render complete assessment of all biota impossible. Indicator species were used to infer potential adverse impacts to the population as a whole. [5] Indicator species for the Lower Red Butte Creek environmental assessment include the mallard, the spotted sandpiper, the muskrat and the raccoon. [5] The mallard was used to assess potential risk to birds that consume riparian emergent plants, while the sandpiper was used to assess risk for birds consuming benthic macroinvertebrates. [5] Substances of direct concern for offsetting the survival of these biota included pollution in surface water, creek bed sediments and creek soil. [5]

Settlement

While the Red Butte Creek oil spill has had severe environmental effects on areas of Salt Lake City, another oil spill occurred in December of the same year. [6] The damages from both spills were assessed and Chevron agreed to a settlement payout of $4.5 million. [6] The breakdown of this payment is as follows: The City of Salt Lake: $508,000, The Department of Environmental Quality (DEQ): $462,853, The University of Utah: $1,304,000, Liberty Park Lake: expenditure of $2,300,000 for restoration, third parties: $929,000, civil penalty to PHMSA: $424,000, and mitigation of wildlife impacts: $100,000. [6]

Pipeline Safety in the Salt Lake Valley Report

Concern over the reoccurrence of an environmental disaster of this magnitude left some questioning the regulation of all Utah pipelines. [9] A report was commissioned by Salt Lake City and released by the nonprofit, national Pipeline Safety Trust. [9] Presentation of this report occurred on Wednesday, September 12 from 5:15 – 6:30 p.m. at the Chase Mill at Tracy Aviary. [10] Mayor Becker invited the public to listen to Carl Weimer, executive director of the Pipeline Safety Trust in Bellingham, Washington present his findings and recommendations for the area. [10]

Problems with Utah Pipeline Regulation

The report claimed that state and federal regulators could do more to ensure pipeline safety. It calls for oil companies to be more forthcoming in regards to pipeline operations and inspections. [9] In addition, municipalities can take more responsibility in training first responders in case of such an event. The report places most of the blame on the state of Utah itself. The report reads, "Although the federal government is responsible for setting minimum pipeline safety standards, Utah can adopt additional or stricter safety standards." [11] Suggestions for the state legislature include expanding state authority to incorporate all hazardous liquid pipelines and interstate gas transmissions, creating a citizen pipeline safety advisory committee to work with the pipeline industry and regulators on a regular basis, and require excavators and underground utility operators to report all incidents of damage to a pipeline to the Division of Public Utilities. [11] In addition to state legislature improvement, local governments in the Salt Lake Valley could adopt recommendations regarding planning near pipelines from Pipelines and Informed Planning Alliance (PIPA) Report to include at minimum a consultation zone and inclusion of transmission pipelines on planning and zoning maps, ensure emergency response teams have the required equipment, information and training to respond in case of a pipeline emergency, and develop an evacuation plan should an emergency occur. [11] Many improvements to the system are suggested in the report, as there is high probability of another pipeline failure in Utah. From 2002 to 2011 there were 10 reported incidents of failure in the pipeline systems. [11]

Future Prospects

In addition to the public report Salt Lake City held a two-hour "Pipeline 101" workshop along with a two-day pipeline safety conference. [10] Chevron looked into the possibility of rerouting the pipeline that was built in the 1950s. [12] The reroute would take the pipeline outside the city limits, but its placement would them be on more rugged terrain. In addition, if a break in the pipeline did occur there would be limited access to mend it. [12] The pipeline is not shut down forever. A 24-hour test under high-pressure conditions deemed it usable. Chevron is going to let the oil flow once again through the Red Butte Creek area. [13]

See also

Related Research Articles

<span class="mw-page-title-main">Kalamazoo River</span> River in Michigan

The Kalamazoo River is a river in the U.S. state of Michigan. The river is 130 miles (210 km) long from the junction of its North and South branches to its mouth at Lake Michigan, with a total length extending to 178 miles (286 km) when one includes the South Branch. The river's watershed drains an area of approximately 2,020 square miles (5,200 km2) and drains portions of ten counties in southwest Michigan: Allegan, Barry, Eaton, Van Buren, Kalamazoo, Calhoun, Jackson, Hillsdale, Kent and Ottawa. The river has a median flow of 1,863 cubic feet per second (52.8 m3/s) at New Richmond, upstream from its mouth at Saugatuck and Douglas.

<span class="mw-page-title-main">Yellowstone River</span> River in the western United States

The Yellowstone River is a tributary of the Missouri River, approximately 692 miles (1,114 km) long, in the Western United States. Considered the principal tributary of upper Missouri, via its own tributaries it drains an area with headwaters across the mountains and high plains of southern Montana and northern Wyoming, and stretching east from the Rocky Mountains in the vicinity of Yellowstone National Park. It flows northeast to its confluence with the Missouri River on the North Dakota side of the border, about 25 miles (40 km) west of Williston.

<span class="mw-page-title-main">Jordan River (Utah)</span> River feeding the Great Salt Lake, US

The Jordan River is a 51.4-mile-long (82.7 km) river in the U.S. state of Utah. Regulated by pumps at its headwaters at Utah Lake, it flows northward through the Salt Lake Valley and empties into the Great Salt Lake. Four of Utah's six largest cities border the river: Salt Lake City, West Valley City, West Jordan, and Sandy. More than a million people live in the Jordan Subbasin, part of the Jordan River watershed that lies within Salt Lake and Utah counties. During the Pleistocene, the area was part of Lake Bonneville.

The Calnev Pipeline is a 550-mile (890 km) long buried refined oil products pipeline in the United States, owned by Kinder Morgan Energy Partners. The pipeline consists of two parallel lines, the larger, has a diameter of 14 inches (360 mm) and the smaller one has a diameter of 8 inches (200 mm). The lines carry gasoline, jet fuel, and diesel fuel from Los Angeles, California, refineries as far as Nellis Air Force Base south of North Las Vegas, Nevada. It carries approximately 128,000 barrels per day (20,400 m3/d). Jet fuel from the pipeline is also delivered to the Harry Reid International Airport tank farm in Paradise. Additional terminal facilities are located in Barstow, California.

The Greenpoint oil spill is one of the largest oil spills ever recorded in the United States. Located around Newtown Creek in the Greenpoint neighborhood of Brooklyn, New York City, between 17 and 30 million US gallons of oil and petroleum products have leaked into the soil from crude oil processing facilities over a period of several decades. The spill was first noticed in 1978, and soil vapor tests were still reported as returning positive in 2008.

<span class="mw-page-title-main">Johnson Creek (Willamette River tributary)</span> Creek in Oregon, USA

Johnson Creek is a 25-mile (40 km) tributary of the Willamette River in the Portland metropolitan area of the U.S. state of Oregon. Part of the drainage basin of the Columbia River, its catchment consists of 54 square miles (140 km2) of mostly urban land occupied by about 180,000 people as of 2012. Passing through the cities of Gresham, Portland, and Milwaukie, the creek flows generally west from the foothills of the Cascade Range through sediments deposited by glacial floods on a substrate of basalt. Though polluted, it is free-flowing along its main stem and provides habitat for salmon and other migrating fish.

The Central Utah Project is a United States federal water project that was authorized for construction under the Colorado River Storage Project Act of April 11, 1956, as a participating project. In general, the Central Utah Project develops a portion of Utah's share of the yield of the Colorado River, as set out in the Colorado River Compact of 1922.

<span class="mw-page-title-main">Liberty Park (Salt Lake City)</span> Public park in Utah, US

Liberty Park is a popular public urban park in Salt Lake City, Utah. It is the city's second-largest public park, at 80 acres (32 ha), being surpassed only by Sugar House Park which has 110.5 acres (44.7 ha). The park features a pond with two islands, and is also the location of Tracy Aviary. The park is listed on the National Register of Historic Places (NRHP) and it includes the Isaac Chase Mill, which is also NRHP-listed.

<span class="mw-page-title-main">Area of Critical Environmental Concern</span>

Areas of Critical Environmental Concern (ACEC) is a conservation ecology program in the Western United States, managed by the Bureau of Land Management (BLM). The ACEC program was conceived in the 1976 Federal Lands Policy and Management Act (FLPMA), which established the first conservation ecology mandate for the BLM. The FLPMA mandate directs the BLM to protect important riparian corridors, threatened and endangered species habitats, cultural and archeological resources, as well as unique scenic landscapes that the agency assesses as in need of special management attention.

<span class="mw-page-title-main">Red Butte Creek (Salt Lake County, Utah)</span> Natural watercourse in Salt Lake County, Utah, United States

Red Butte Creek is a small stream whose headwaters are found in the northeast part of Salt Lake County, Utah, United States. It flows west through the Red Butte Garden and Arboretum, by the University of Utah, Fort Douglas and flows southwesterly to Salt Lake City’s Liberty Park. With 7.25 sq mi (18.8 km2) of watershed, Red Butte Canyon is the smallest canyon of the seven canyons in eastern Salt Lake County. Its elevation ranges from 5,000 to 8,000 ft above sea level.

<span class="mw-page-title-main">Kalamazoo River oil spill</span> 2010 oil spill in Calhoun County, Michigan, US

The Kalamazoo River oil spill occurred in July 2010 when a pipeline operated by Enbridge burst and flowed into Talmadge Creek, a tributary of the Kalamazoo River near Marshall, Michigan. A 6-foot (1.8 m) break in the pipeline resulted in one of the largest inland oil spills in U.S. history. The pipeline carries diluted bitumen (dilbit), a heavy crude oil from Canada's Athabasca oil sands to the United States. Cleanup took five years. Following the spill, the volatile hydrocarbon diluents evaporated, leaving the heavier bitumen to sink in the water column. Thirty-five miles (56 km) of the Kalamazoo River were closed for clean-up until June 2012, when portions of the river were re-opened. On March 14, 2013, the Environmental Protection Agency (EPA) ordered Enbridge to return to dredge portions of the river to remove submerged oil and oil-contaminated sediment.

This is a list of notable events relating to the environment in 2010. They relate to environmental law, conservation, environmentalism and environmental issues.

<span class="mw-page-title-main">2013 Mayflower oil spill</span>

The 2013 Mayflower oil spill occurred on March 29, 2013, when the Pegasus Pipeline, owned by ExxonMobil and carrying Canadian Wabasca heavy crude from the Athabasca oil sands, ruptured in Mayflower, Arkansas, about 25 miles (40 km) northwest of Little Rock releasing about 3,190 barrels of oil. Approximately 3,190 barrels of oil and water mix was recovered. Twenty-two homes were evacuated. The United States Environmental Protection Agency (EPA) classified the leak as a major spill.

<span class="mw-page-title-main">Berry Corporation</span> American petroleum company

Berry Corporation is a company primarily engaged in hydrocarbon exploration in California, the Uintah Basin, and the Piceance Basin. As of December 31, 2021, the company had 97 million barrels of oil equivalent (590,000,000 GJ) of estimated proved reserves, of which 87% was petroleum and 13% was natural gas. The company also offers oil well services and electricity sales.

<span class="mw-page-title-main">Silver Bow Creek</span>

Silver Bow Creek is a 26-mile-long (42 km) headwater stream of the Clark Fork (river) originating within the city limits of Butte, Montana, from the confluence of Little Basin and Blacktail Creeks. A former northern tributary, Yankee Doodle Creek, no longer flows directly into Silver Bow Creek as it is now captured by the Berkeley Pit. Silver Bow Creek flows northwest and north through a high mountain valley, passing east of Anaconda, Montana, where it becomes the Clark Fork at the confluence with Warm Springs Creek.

<span class="mw-page-title-main">Refugio oil spill</span> 2015 pipeline leak on the coast of California

The Refugio oil spill on May 19, 2015, contaminated one of the most biologically diverse areas of the West Coast of the United States with 142,800 U.S. gallons of crude oil. The corroded pipeline that caused the spill closed indefinitely, resulting in financial impacts to the county estimated as high as $74 million as it and a related pipeline remained out of service for three years. The cost of the cleanup was estimated by the company to be $96 million with overall expenses including expected legal claims and potential settlements to be around $257 million.

A major oil spill from the Colonial Pipeline in a nature reserve near Huntersville, North Carolina, United States, began on July 27, 2020. The spill resulted in approximately 2,000,000 U.S. gallons (7,600,000 L) of gasoline discharge and led to a cleanup effort that is still ongoing and expected to continue for several years. Several sources have noted that the spill is one of the largest in the history of the United States, with EnergyWire calling it "the largest U.S. gasoline pipeline spill on record".

References

  1. 1 2 3 4 5 6 Amy Joi O'Donoghue; Josh Smith (June 12, 2010). "Oil spill in Red Butte Creek threatens waters, wildlife". The Deseret News. Archived from the original on June 18, 2010. Retrieved 14 June 2010.{{cite news}}: CS1 maint: multiple names: authors list (link)
  2. 1 2 3 4 5 6 7 8 9 Whelan, Ann; Clark, Josie; Andrew, Gary; Mighel, Jacqueline; Benggio, Bradford. "International Oil Spill Conference Proceedings: Developing Cleanup Endpoints for Inland Oil Spills". doi: 10.7901/2169-3358-2014.1.1267 .{{cite journal}}: Cite journal requires |journal= (help)
  3. 1 2 Robinson, Brent; Shibata, Mark; Mulhearn, Sandra (June 2012). "Working Draft Screening Level Ecological Risk Assessment: Lower Red Butte Creek, Salt Lake City, Utah" (PDF). Utah Department of Environmental Quality. Retrieved 30 November 2014.
  4. ↑ "Settlement Agreement between Utah Water Quality Board and Chevron Pipe Line Company" (PDF). slcgov.com/oilspill. Utah Water Quality Board. Retrieved 30 November 2014.
  5. 1 2 3 4 5 6 7 8 9 10 11 12 13 14 15 16 17 18 Robinson, Brent; Shibata, Mark; Mulhearn, Sandra. "Working Draft Screening Level Ecological Risk Assessment: Lower Red Butte Creek, Salt Lake City, Utah" (PDF). Utah Department of Environmental Quality. Retrieved 30 November 2014.
  6. 1 2 3 4 5 "Settlement Agreement between Utah Water Quality Board and Chevron Pipe Line Company" (PDF). slcgov.com/oilspill. Utah Water Quality Board. Retrieved 30 November 2014.
  7. 1 2 3 4 5 "Red Butte Creek spill." Oil Spill Intelligence Report, vol. 33, no. 26, 17 June 2010, pp. 3+. Gale Business: Insights, link.gale.com/apps/doc/A231091451/GBIB?u=marriottlibrary&sid=bookmark-GBIB&xid=b1d3292d. Accessed 17 July 2023.
  8. 1 2 O'Dooghue, Ami Joi; Smith, Josh (12 June 2010). "Oil Spill in Red Butte Creek threatens waters, wildlife". Desert News. Archived from the original on November 5, 2012. Retrieved 1 December 2014.
  9. 1 2 3 Weimer, Carl. "Pipeline Safety in the Salt Lake Valley" (PDF). www.slcdocs.com/. Pipeline Safety Trust. Retrieved 30 November 2014.
  10. 1 2 3 Raymond, Art. "Public to Receive Pipeline Report Following 2010 Spills" (PDF). Salt Lake City Government. Retrieved 30 November 2014.
  11. 1 2 3 4 Weimer, Carl. "Pipeline Safety in the Salt Lake Valley" (PDF). Pipeline Safety Trust. Retrieved 30 November 2014.
  12. 1 2 Berry, Dr. Joseph K. "Independent Evaluation of Reroute Study of Chevron's Rangely Pipeline to Salt Lake City Refineries" (PDF). slcgov.com. Retrieved 2 December 2014.
  13. ↑ Fahys, Judy. "Red Butte Creek oil pipeline set to reopen". America's Intelligence Wire. Retrieved 1 December 2014.
This page is based on this Wikipedia article
Text is available under the CC BY-SA 4.0 license; additional terms may apply.
Images, videos and audio are available under their respective licenses.