Rue Nitot

Last updated

The Rue Nitot meeting was an important First World War event, when the British Empire delegates at the Peace Conference in Versailles got together to register the harsh terms of the Treaty of Versailles, and tried to soften the conditions for peace with Germany. The meeting was held at Prime Minister David Lloyd George's flat, 23 Rue Nitot, in Paris, on June 1, 1919. [1]

Contents

Background

When Germany asked for peace in the early fall of 1918, it asked for peace terms based on President Woodrow Wilson's Fourteen Points. [2] However, the Fourteen Points, made public on January 8, 1918, were constructed without input from the Allies, and issued without their knowledge. [3] [4] This particularly irked the British, who objected to a "Freedom of the Seas" passage, as they maintained a full land and sea blockade on Germany, which violated Wilson's second point. [5] The Fourteen Points were used as the basis, or starting point, of peace negotiations, although the Germans were told by President Wilson, on November 5, and later by Marshal Ferdinand Foch at the signing of the November 11th armistice, that financial reparations were also in order. [6] [7]

As one of the harsh conditions meted out by the French, the Germans were not allowed to participate on the peace negotiations. This surprised the American and English peace plan delegates, who believed in a "New World", or "Wilsonian" peace, and not an "Old World" European peace. However, Prime Minister Clemenceau made it known that the Germans were the aggressors and criminals in this war, and "What kind of justice would be served if the vanquished were allowed to sit at the table, on an equal footing with the victors?" In the end, a team of German delegates were allowed to receive a draft of the treaty, and they were given two weeks (extended to three) to suggest changes to it. [8] Those suggestions were made at the end of May 1919, and the purpose of the Rue Nitot meeting was to discuss those changes. [9]

The Meeting

German Delegates Receiving the Draft Treaty, May 7, 1919 The German Delegates Receiving the Draft of the Treaty of Versailles, May 7, 1919.png
German Delegates Receiving the Draft Treaty, May 7, 1919
The British Empire Objects to the Treaty of Versailles, June 1, 1919 England Objects to the Treaty of Versailles, June 1, 1919.png
The British Empire Objects to the Treaty of Versailles, June 1, 1919

One of the British objections to the peace treaty was the French demand for a permanent land barrier to exist between France and Germany. [10] The barrier, to be "a neutral zone" twenty miles wide and patrolled by the Allied nations, [11] was meant to prevent a future German invasion of France. The matter was dropped when Prime Minister Lloyd George and President Wilson promised France a joint military guarantee on March 14, 1919. [12] [13] However, it was raised again in April, [14] with the French requesting a 15 year occupation. Eventually, the matter was decided in France's favor, with permanent neutrality for the Rhineland established in 1925 (see external link: Locarno).

Two other conditions from France included excluding Germany from the League of Nations, and denying it a most favored nation trading status.

However, probably the most difficult issue was reparations. The French wanted the Germans to pay for the damage caused to France and Belgium during World War I, and for this a team of accountants were brought to Versailles to fix a price on the war. Every death carried a price, as did every wounded, every animal killed, and all material devastation was tallied. What the Germans couldn't pay from its treasury would be exacted by appropriating raw materials by the trainload, specifically coal, chemicals and dyestuffs. In all, the tally came to $13.75 Billion ($233 Billion in 2023 dollars). [15] When Germany eventually defaulted on its payments in 1922, there were rumors that two trainloads of German toys were shipped to France during Christmastime.

When the Secretary of State for War, Winston Churchill, said, "The hatred of France for Germany was something more than human", South African Prime Minister Louis Botha reminded everyone that on this day, seventeen years ago, the English, represented by Lord Milner, got together with the Boers to sign a peace treaty that ended the Boer War. "On that occasion it was moderation which had saved South Africa for the British Empire, and he hoped on this occasion that it would be moderation which would save the world." [16] [17]

The empire delegates unanimously authorized Lloyd George to go back to the Big Four and ask for modifications to the peace terms. The areas of disagreement were on reparations, the Rhineland occupation, Germany's membership in the League of Nations, its frontiers with Poland, and scores of other smaller but irritating “pin prick” matters, like the renaming of rivers.

When Lloyd George met with Georges Clemenceau, he informed him that if these matters can't be resolved, and if Germany fails to sign the peace treaty (which appeared likely), that the British Empire would no longer enforce its naval blockade on Germany (which deprived civilians of food), and that the British Army would not take part in an occupation of Germany. [18] [19]

Consequences

Adolf Hitler, Time Magazine cover, April 13, 1936 Adolph Hitler, Time Magazine cover, April 13, 1936.png
Adolf Hitler, Time Magazine cover, April 13, 1936

When the Council of Four met on June 2 and were given the British ultimatum, they were upset. [20] [21] The treaty had been largely written by them (President Wilson played a lead role in the construction of its framework back in January), they were tired, and they did not want to redo the work. In his memoirs, Lloyd George said he wasn't asking for large concessions, only those that brought the treaty in line with Wilson's Fourteen Points. Afterwards, all President Wilson could say was, "Reparations weren't specifically excluded from the Fourteen Points, so they were allowed." [22]

When the Germans received the draft treaty on May 7, they were shocked to learn that they were expected to accept it without the opportunity to negotiate. On June 16, after weeks of attempts at negotiation, the Allies presented the final version of their conditions for peace, which were virtually unchanged from the first draft. [23] Germany was given seven days to accept the treaty or face renewed hostilities. After Minister President Philipp Scheidemann resigned in protest, two delegates were sent to Paris, and the treaty was signed at 3 pm on June 28, 1919. [24] Lloyd George, not knowing if they would appear, made them sign first, before the other 66 plenipotentiaries. [25]

One of the twenty-five points laid out by the German Workers' Party (DAP) in early 1920 was to refute the Treaty of Versailles. During his rise in politics in the 1920s, Adolf Hitler always referred to the Treaty of Versailles as "the Versailles diktat" (see external link, same). After the hardliners in France, Georges Clemenceau and Ferdinand Foch, died in 1929, a younger generation of politicians rose in France who agreed with the English that the terms of Versailles were too tough, and a series of concessions occurred with the Locarno Treaties, resulting in Germany entering the League of Nations, being granted a most favored nation trading status, and allowing its border with Poland to be open to negotiation. Also, reparations were partially forgiven in 1924, with the Dawes Plan, and again in 1929 with the Young Plan. Concessions in the latter half of the 1920's became known as "The Spirit of Locarno". However, with the ascendancy of Adolf Hitler to power as Chancellor in 1933, and President (Führer) in 1934, concessions became appeasement with his territorial demands. When Hitler reoccupied the Rhineland with soldiers on March 7, 1936, in defiance of Locarno, [26] the Allies, remembering the horrors and bloodshed of World War I, were paralyzed. Until the invasion of Czechoslovakia on March 15, 1939, conservatives in England hoped that Hitler, a rising star in the media, [27] was just playing into nationalistic fever, and that all was well.

Related Research Articles

<span class="mw-page-title-main">Treaty of Versailles</span> One of the treaties that ended World War I

The Treaty of Versailles was a peace treaty signed on 28 June 1919. As the most important treaty of World War I, it ended the state of war between Germany and most of the Allied Powers. It was signed in the Palace of Versailles, exactly five years after the assassination of Archduke Franz Ferdinand, which led to the war. The other Central Powers on the German side signed separate treaties. Although the armistice of 11 November 1918 ended the actual fighting, and agreed certain principles and conditions including the payment of reparations, it took six months of Allied negotiations at the Paris Peace Conference to conclude the peace treaty. Germany was not allowed to participate in the negotiations before signing the treaty.

<span class="mw-page-title-main">Georges Clemenceau</span> Prime Minister of France, 1906–1909 and 1917–1920

Georges Benjamin Clemenceau was a French statesman who served as Prime Minister of France from 1906 to 1909 and again from 1917 until 1920. A key figure of the Independent Radicals, he was a strong advocate of separation of church and state, and the amnesty of the Communards exiled to New Caledonia. Clemenceau, a physician turned journalist, played a central role in the politics of the Third Republic.

<span class="mw-page-title-main">Fourteen Points</span> 1918 U.S. peace proposals after World War I

The Fourteen Points was a statement of principles for peace that was to be used for peace negotiations in order to end World War I. The principles were outlined in a January 8, 1918 speech on war aims and peace terms to the United States Congress by President Woodrow Wilson. However, his main Allied colleagues were skeptical of the applicability of Wilsonian idealism.

<i>Peacemakers</i> (book)

Peacemakers: The Paris Peace Conference of 1919 and Its Attempt to End War (2001) is a historical narrative about the events of the Paris Peace Conference of 1919. It was written by the Canadian historian Margaret MacMillan with a foreword by the American diplomat Richard Holbrooke. The book has also been published under the titles Paris 1919: Six Months That Changed the World and Peacemakers: Six Months That Changed the World.

<span class="mw-page-title-main">Locarno Treaties</span> 1925 territorial settlements between the Allies of WWI and the new European states

The Locarno Treaties were seven agreements negotiated in Locarno, Switzerland, from 5 to 16 October 1925 and formally signed in London on 1 December, in which the First World War Western European Allied powers and the new states of Central and Eastern Europe sought to secure the post-war territorial settlement, in return for normalizing relations with the defeated German Reich. It also stated that Germany would never go to war with the other countries. Locarno divided borders in Europe into two categories: western, which were guaranteed by the Locarno Treaties, and eastern borders of Germany with Poland, which were open for revision.

<span class="mw-page-title-main">Paris Peace Conference (1919–1920)</span> Meeting of the Allied Powers after World War I

The Paris Peace Conference was a set of formal and informal diplomatic meetings in 1919 and 1920 after the end of World War I, in which the victorious Allies set the peace terms for the defeated Central Powers. Dominated by the leaders of Britain, France, the United States and Italy, the conference resulted in five treaties that rearranged the maps of Europe and parts of Asia, Africa and the Pacific Islands, and also imposed financial penalties. Germany, Austria-Hungary, Turkey and the other losing nations were not given a voice in the deliberations; this later gave rise to political resentments that lasted for decades. The arrangements made by this conference are considered one of the great watersheds of 20th-century geopolitical history.

<span class="mw-page-title-main">Alfred Milner, 1st Viscount Milner</span> British statesman and colonial administrator (1854–1925)

Alfred Milner, 1st Viscount Milner, was a British statesman and colonial administrator who played a very important role in the formulation of British foreign and domestic policy between the mid-1890s and early 1920s. From December 1916 to November 1918, he was one of the most important members of Prime Minister David Lloyd George's War cabinet.

<span class="mw-page-title-main">Violet Milner, Viscountess Milner</span> English socialite (1872–1958)

Violet Georgina Milner, Viscountess Milner was an English socialite of the Victorian and Edwardian eras and, later, editor of the political monthly National Review. Her father was close friends with Georges Clemenceau, she married the son of Prime Minister Salisbury, Lord Edward Cecil, and after his death, Alfred Milner, 1st Viscount Milner.

<span class="mw-page-title-main">Article 231 of the Treaty of Versailles</span> Beginning of the 1919 treatys reparations section

Article 231, often known as the "War Guilt" clause, was the opening article of the reparations section of the Treaty of Versailles, which ended the First World War between the German Empire and the Allied and Associated Powers. The article did not use the word guilt but it served as a legal basis under which Germany was to pay reparations for damages caused during the war.

<i>The Economic Consequences of the Peace</i> 1919 book by John Maynard Keynes

The Economic Consequences of the Peace (1919) is a book written and published by the British economist John Maynard Keynes. After the First World War, Keynes attended the Paris Peace Conference of 1919 as a delegate of the British Treasury. At the conference as a representative of the British Treasury and deputy to the Chancellor of the Exchequer on the Supreme Economic Council he had publicly urged and secretly arranged on behalf of 'Rosie' Wemyss for a discontinuing of the food blockade of Germany but became ill and on his return found that there was 'no hope' of an economically sustainable settlement, and so resigned. In this book, he presents his arguments for a much less onerous treaty for a wider readership, not just for the sake of German civilians but for the sake of the economic well-being of all of Europe and beyond, including the Allied Powers, which the Treaty of Versailles and its associated treaties endangered.

<span class="mw-page-title-main">James Harbord</span> United States Army general

Lieutenant General James Guthrie Harbord was a senior officer of the United States Army and president and chairman of the board of RCA. During World War I, he served from mid-1917 to mid-1918 as chief of staff of the American Expeditionary Forces (AEF), commanded by General John J. Pershing, before commanding a brigade and briefly a division and then the Services of Supply of the AEF. In the former role he was, in the words of former soldier-turned historian David T. Zabecki,

The U.S. Army's first modern operational-level chief of staff in a combat theater, and he would be the model for all others who followed. He played a key role in developing the staff structure and organization used throughout the U.S. military to this day, as well as by most NATO countries. He was one of the most influential U.S. Army officers of the early 20th century.

The Supreme War Council was a central command based in Versailles that coordinated the military strategy of the principal Allies of World War I: Britain, France, Italy, the United States, and Japan. It was founded in 1917 after the Russian Revolution and with Russia's withdrawal as an ally imminent. The council served as a second source of advice for civilian leadership, a forum for preliminary discussions of potential armistice terms, later for peace treaty settlement conditions, and it was succeeded by the Conference of Ambassadors in 1920.

The Treaty of Guarantee was an agreement in which the United Kingdom and the United States guaranteed the French border against future German aggression. It came out of a proposal by British Prime Minister David Lloyd George at the Paris Peace Conference in 1919, after World War I, as a compromise to French Marshal Ferdinand Foch's insistence for the French-German border to be pushed back to the Rhine. Foch felt that the new border would prevent another German invasion into France.

<span class="mw-page-title-main">Big Four (World War I)</span> Four top Allied powers of World War I

The Big Four or the Four Nations refer to the four top Allied powers of World War I and their leaders who met at the Paris Peace Conference in January 1919. The Big Four is also known as the Council of Four. It was composed of Georges Clemenceau of France, David Lloyd George of the United Kingdom, Vittorio Emanuele Orlando of Italy, and Woodrow Wilson of the United States.

<span class="mw-page-title-main">Doullens Conference</span>

The Doullens Conference was held in Doullens, France, on 26 March 1918 between French and British military leaders and governmental representatives during World War I. Its purpose was to better co-ordinate their armies' operations on the Western Front in the face of a dramatic advance by the German Army which threatened a breakthrough of their lines during the war's final year. It occurred due to Lord Alfred Milner, a member of the British War Cabinet, being dispatched to France by Prime Minister Lloyd George, on 24 March, to assess conditions on the Western Front, and to report back.

<span class="mw-page-title-main">Heavenly Twins (Sumner and Cunliffe)</span>

The Heavenly Twins was the name assigned to two British delegates, the Judge Lord Sumner and the Banker Lord Cunliffe, during the 1919 Treaty of Versailles negotiations who were to set the terms of the peace to be imposed on Germany following the end of World War I. The two lords, together with the Prime Minister of Australia Billy Hughes, were responsible for presenting the British and British Dominions' case concerning the amount of compensatory payments, or war reparations, that were to be extracted from Germany.

The Fontainebleau Memorandum is the name given to a document written by British Prime Minister David Lloyd George and his advisers during the Paris Peace Conference, 1919 that was drafting the Treaty of Versailles. It was titled ‘Some Considerations for the Peace Conference Before They Finally Draft Their Terms, March 25th, 1919’.

<span class="mw-page-title-main">Dury, Compiègne and Abbeville meetings</span>

The Dury, Compiègne and Abbeville meetings were held by the Allies during World War I to address Operation Michael, a massive German assault on the Western Front on 21 March 1918 which marked the beginning of the Kaiser's Spring Offensive. Since the fall of 1917, a stalemate had existed on the Western Front. However, German victory against Russia in 1917, due to the Russian Revolution and the signing of the Treaty of Brest-Litovsk, freed up German armies on the Eastern Front for use in the west. During the winter of 1917-1918, approximately 50 German divisions in Russia were secretly transported by train to France for use in a massive, final attack to end the war. The battle that followed, Operation Michael, totally surprised the Allies and nearly routed the French and English armies from the field. The meetings below were held under these dire circumstances.

<span class="mw-page-title-main">Minister of Blockade</span> World War I

The onset of the 20th Century saw England as the world's foremost naval and colonial power, supported by a 100,000-man army designed to fight small wars in its outlying colonies. Since the Napoleonic Wars nearly a century earlier, Britain and Europe enjoyed relative peace and tranquility. The onset of World War I caught the British Empire by surprise. As it increased the size of its army through conscription, one of its first tasks was to impose a complete naval blockade against Germany. It was not popular in the United States. However, it was very important to England.

References

Footnotes

  1. Lloyd George, David, "The Truth About the Peace Treaties, Vol. I", pg. 688
  2. Lloyd George, David, "War Memoirs of David Lloyd George, Vol. VI", pg. 139
  3. Roskill, Stephen, "Hankey, Man of Secrets, Vol. I", pg. 481
  4. Owen, Frank, "Tempestuous Journey: Lloyd George, His Life and Times", pgs. 493-494
  5. Lloyd George, David, "The Memoirs of David Lloyd George, Vol. V", pg. 42
  6. Nicolson, Harold, "Peacemaking 1919", pg. 12
  7. Mott, Bentley, "The Memoirs of Marshal Foch", pg. 527, pgs. 543-544, pg. 554
  8. O'Brien, "Milner", pg. 336
  9. Lloyd George, David, "The Truth About the Peace Treaties, Vol. I", pgs. 682-688
  10. Lloyd George, David, "The Truth About the Peace Treaties, Vol. I", pgs. 132-136, pgs. 286-287, pgs. 726-728
  11. Lloyd George, David, "The Truth About the Peace Treaties, Vol. I", pg. 710
  12. Lloyd George, David, "The Truth About the Peace Treaties, Vol. I", pg. 403
  13. Owen, pg. 545
  14. Lloyd George, David, "The Truth About the Peace Treaties, Vol. I", pgs. 424-427
  15. The New York Times, "Current History" Magazine, January 1921, pg. 493
  16. MacMillan, Margaret, "Paris: 1919, Six Months that Changed the World", pg. 469
  17. Lloyd George, David, "The Truth About the Peace Treaties, Vol. I", pgs. 713-714
  18. Lloyd George, David, "The Truth About the Peace Treaties, Vol. I", pg. 711
  19. MacMillan, pg. 470
  20. Lloyd George, David, "The Truth About the Peace Treaties, Vol. I", pg. 720
  21. MacMillan, pg. 470
  22. O'Brien, pg. 330
  23. "Kabinett Scheidemann, Einleitung IV" [Scheidemann Cabinet, Introduction IV]. Das Bundesarchiv (in German). Retrieved 20 August 2013.
  24. Shirer, William, "The Rise and Fall of the Third Reich", pg. 59
  25. O'Brien, pg. 338
  26. Shirer, pg. 291
  27. Time Magazine, "Armistice & After", July 8, 1940, pg. 24

See also