Saint Louis (biography)

Last updated
Saint Louis
Saint Louis (1996) cover.jpg
Cover art for the 2009 English translation
Author Jacques Le Goff
TranslatorGareth Evan Gollrad
LanguageFrench
Subject Biography, medieval history
Publisher Éditions Gallimard
(First edition)
University of Notre Dame Press
(English translation)
Publication date
23 January 1996 [1]
Published in English
15 January 2009
Media typePrint
Pages952 pp (hardcover)
ISBN 978-0268033811

Saint Louis is a 1996 biography of Louis IX of France by historian Jacques Le Goff. The book received positive reviews for its historical detail, and was awarded the 1996 Grand prix Gobert by the French Academy. It was also a best-seller. [2]

Contents

Summary

The lengthy book contains three parts. The first section is a traditional narrative of Louis from his birth to his canonization, [3] while the second section is about the views of his contemporaries on him. The third section "locates Louis in both the spiritual and secular world of the day-to-day". [4] Le Goff discusses "contemporary views about the obligations and duty of the king, the nature of government and political power in thirteenth-century France, and contemporary religious practice." [5]

Reception

William Chester Jordan dubbed Saint Louis a "wise and ruminative study [...] his longest and most impressive book". He called the book's final question "a sincere warning against the naïveté that underlies so much of the lingering positivism of the historical profession." [6]

Gary Macy wrote that the three parts of Saint Louis "could easily stand alone as separate books [...] together they comprise perhaps the most complete historiographic study of one historical person every [ sic ] attempted." He wrote that the historian "sometimes delightfully if not historically, tells us what he feels about Louis, even if he doesn’t have evidence for that feeling. There are many repetitions, again something might expect in a study of such depth. Le Goff also seems to trust Joinville too much." However, Macy lauded the "detail and care of Le Goff’s careful study." [7]

Unlike Macy, Jennifer R. Davis claimed that "Le Goff is far from a credulous reader" of Joinville's account. She claimed that it is not a full biography of Louis as a king, centering more on his personality and the ideology surrounding his rulership than on his actual governance, but Davis called the second part of the book "a tour de force of source analysis". Davis also said that "his optimistic vision of historical biography is certainly worthy of historians' consideration". [3]

James M. Powell wrote that Le Goff "has given us a very personal account of St. Louis and has entered intimately into his life." He said the historian's picture of Emperor Frederick II was too dependent on Kantorowicz’s biography. However, Powell argued that "Louis lives and walks through these pages. What Le Goff has given us is more than a biography; it is a work of literature. [...] There is no chapter that does not contain information and ideas that deserve to be discussed further." [8] Thomas F. Madden of First Things called it "probably the most complete [history of Louis] available. [...] a work of importance, but casual readers may find other histories by William Chester Jordan and Jean Richard more appealing". [9]

Ellen E. Kittell wrote, "Le Goff has gone far beyond the mere biography of a canonized king; his history of St. Louis unfolds as the biography of France." Kittell criticized the translation but still lauded the book as "a standard against which other biographies will be measured." [4] Carol J. Williams claimed that M. Cecilia Gaposchkin, in The Making of Saint Louis (2010), is "generous in her recognition of the fundamental work of Le Goff". [10] Alexander Lee of referred to his biographies of Louis and Francis as landmarks, while still arguing that "his most dramatic contribution to scholarship was perhaps La Naissance du Purgatoire (1981)". [11]

Some reviewers were more moderate in their praise. Davis noted that there is controversy surrounding Le Goff's argument that the real Louis and the ideal models of conduct transmitted about Louis largely coincide. Jordan argued that the models obscure the view of the real Louis, comprising a refashioned ideal image. [3] In the London Review of Books , Alexander Murray praised Saint Louis as a "brilliant" biography. But Murray also stated that Le Goff "paints with a broad brush. [...] Blanche is ‘insufferable and frankly, odious’, Matthew Paris shows his ‘usual perversity’, Louis ‘held intellectuals in contempt’ (actually, he helped found the Sorbonne). This broadness of brush hides nuances which, exposed, would reveal that Louis’s reign has a long-term significance that Le Goff scarcely hints at." [12]

David Bachrach praised the second section of Saint Louis as the strongest, particularly Le Goff's treatment of Jean de Joinville's account. However, he said the historian misses opportunities to come to a closer understanding of Louis as an individual and ruler (e.g. "whether he was [...] innovative or conservative, a master of detail or delegator of authority"). Bachrach wrote that Le Goff "limits himself to stringing together series of events in which Louis played a role." [5]

Related Research Articles

<i>Annales</i> school Group of historians

The Annales school is a group of historians associated with a style of historiography developed by French historians in the 20th century to stress long-term social history. It is named after its scholarly journal Annales. Histoire, Sciences Sociales, which remains the main source of scholarship, along with many books and monographs. The school has been influential in setting the agenda for historiography in France and numerous other countries, especially regarding the use of social scientific methods by historians, emphasizing social and economic rather than political or diplomatic themes.

<span class="mw-page-title-main">Louis IX of France</span> King of France from 1226 to 1270

Louis IX, commonly revered as Saint Louis, was King of France from 1226 until his death in 1270. He is widely recognized as the most distinguished of the Direct Capetians. Following the death of his father, Louis VIII, he was crowned in Reims at the age of 12. His mother, Blanche of Castile, effectively ruled the kingdom as regent until he came of age and continued to serve as his trusted adviser until her death. During his formative years, Blanche successfully confronted rebellious vassals and championed the Capetian cause in the Albigensian Crusade, which had been ongoing for the past two decades.

<span class="mw-page-title-main">Jean de Joinville</span> French chronicler of the Crusades of Saint Louis

Jean de Joinville was one of the great chroniclers of medieval France. He is most famous for writing the Life of Saint Louis, a biography of Louis IX of France that chronicled the Seventh Crusade.

<span class="mw-page-title-main">Fernand Braudel</span> French historian and leader of the Annales School (1902–1985)

Fernand Paul Achille Braudel was a French historian. His scholarship focused on three main projects: The Mediterranean, Civilization and Capitalism (1955–79), and the unfinished Identity of France (1970–85). He was a member of the Annales School of French historiography and social history in the 1950s and 1960s. He was a student of Henri Hauser.

<span class="mw-page-title-main">Cecilia Payne-Gaposchkin</span> British-born American astronomer (1900–1979)

Cecilia Payne-Gaposchkin was a British-born American astronomer and astrophysicist who proposed in her 1925 doctoral thesis that stars were composed primarily of hydrogen and helium. Her groundbreaking conclusion was initially rejected because it contradicted the scientific wisdom of the time, which held that there were no significant elemental differences between the Sun and Earth. Independent observations eventually proved that she was correct. Her work on the nature of variable stars was foundational to modern astrophysics.

<i>The Black Book of Communism</i> 1997 book by Stéphane Courtois and others

The Black Book of Communism: Crimes, Terror, Repression is a 1997 book by Stéphane Courtois, Andrzej Paczkowski, Nicolas Werth, Jean-Louis Margolin, and several other European academics documenting a history of political repression by communist states, including genocides, extrajudicial executions, deportations, and deaths in labor camps and artificially created famines. The book was originally published in France as Le Livre noir du communisme: Crimes, terreur, répression by Éditions Robert Laffont. In the United States, it was published by Harvard University Press, with a foreword by Martin Malia. The German edition, published by Piper Verlag, includes a chapter written by Joachim Gauck. The introduction was written by Courtois. Historian François Furet was originally slated to write the introduction, but he died before being able to do so.

<span class="mw-page-title-main">Jacques Le Goff</span> French historian

Jacques Le Goff was a French historian and prolific author specializing in the Middle Ages, particularly the 12th and 13th centuries.

Eugene Dominic Genovese was an American historian of the American South and American slavery. He was noted for bringing a Marxist perspective to the study of power, class and relations between planters and slaves in the South. His book Roll, Jordan, Roll: The World the Slaves Made won the Bancroft Prize. He later abandoned the left and Marxism and embraced traditionalist conservatism. He wrote during the Cold War and his political beliefs were viewed by some as highly controversial at the time.

<span class="mw-page-title-main">Battle of Taillebourg</span> Medieval battle between France and England

The Battle of Taillebourg, a major medieval battle fought in July 1242, was the decisive engagement of the Saintonge War. It pitted a French Capetian army under the command of King Louis IX, also known as Saint Louis, and his younger brother Alphonse of Poitiers, against forces led by King Henry III of England, his brother Richard of Cornwall and their stepfather Hugh X of Lusignan.

<span class="mw-page-title-main">Thomas F. Madden</span> American historian

Thomas Francis Madden is an American historian, a former chair of the history department at Saint Louis University in St. Louis, Missouri, and director of Saint Louis University's Center for Medieval and Renaissance Studies.

Bernard Stanley Bachrach was an American historian. He taught history at the University of Minnesota from 1967 until his retirement in 2020. He specialized in the Early Middle Ages, mainly on the topics of medieval warfare, medieval Jewry, and early Angevin history. He also wrote an important article about the treatment of Jews in the Visigothic kingdom.

The term new history, from the French term nouvelle histoire, was coined by Jacques Le Goff and Pierre Nora, leaders of the third generation of the Annales school, in the 1970s. The movement can be associated with cultural history, history of representations, and histoire des mentalités. The new history movement's inclusive definition of the proper matter of historical study has also given it the label total history. The movement was contrasted with the traditional ways of writing history which focused on politics and "great men". The new history rejected any insistence on composing historical narrative; an over-emphasis on administrative documents as basic source materials; concern with individuals' motivations and intentions as explanatory factors for historical events; and the old belief in objectivity.

Robert Ian Moore is a British historian who is Professor Emeritus of History at Newcastle University. He specialises in medieval history and has written several influential works on the subject of heresy. Moore was a pioneer in the UK of the teaching of world history to undergraduate students, has published numerous papers on comparative world history, and is series editor of the Blackwell History of the World.

<i>The Ignorant Schoolmaster</i> 1987 book by Jacques Rancière

The Ignorant Schoolmaster: Five Lessons in Intellectual Emancipation is a 1987 book by philosopher Jacques Rancière on the role of the teacher and individual towards individual liberation. Rancière uses the example of Joseph Jacotot, a French teacher in the late 18th century who taught in Belgium without knowledge of their language (Flemish), to explain the role of liberation after Marxism. The work expresses Rousseauist ideas, e.g. in the state of nature humans are morally good, and emphasizes that individual change precipitates societal change. Its arguments draw heavily from the French socialist party's debates on education during the 1980s. It was translated to English in 1991 by Kristin Ross.

Josephine Dene Laffin is an Australian historian and a senior lecturer at Australian Catholic University. She is known for her research on Australian saints and clergymen, particularly Matthew Beovich.

<i>The Making of Saint Louis</i> 2010 book by M. Cecilia Gaposchkin

The Making of Saint Louis: Kingship, Sanctity, and Crusade in the Later Middle Ages is a 2010 book by historian M. Cecilia Gaposchkin. Gaposchkin draws on hagiographical, visual, and narrative material, as well as little-used liturgical sources and sermons, to discuss the process by which Louis was canonized and made a saint in the eyes of a large public. The book was praised by other scholars.

William of Chartres was a royal chaplain under King Louis IX of France from 1254 and then a Dominican friar from 1264. He took part in two crusades in 1248 and 1270 and wrote a biography of Louis. This last work contains the earliest surviving collection of miracles attributed to Louis after his death in 1270. William died between 1277 and 1282.

The Deeds of the Bishops of Cambrai is an anonymous Latin history of the diocese of Cambrai. It was commissioned around 1024 by Bishop Gerard I of Cambrai and completed shortly after his death in 1051. It is the work of two authors.

<span class="mw-page-title-main">Nivelon de Quierzy</span> Bishop of Soissons

Nivelon de Quierzy was the bishop of Soissons from 1176 until his death. He was also the chief prelate of the army of the Fourth Crusade.

References

  1. "Saint Louis". Gallimard. Retrieved 2020-12-01.
  2. Phillips, Nicholas (2020-10-21). "Long live the king? As political tensions rise, St. Louis grapples with its name". St. Louis Magazine. Retrieved 2020-11-28.
  3. 1 2 3 Davis, Jennifer R. (2010). Gaposchkin, M. Cecilia; Le Goff, Jacques; Gollrad, Gareth E. (eds.). "The Problem of King Louis IX of France: Biography, Sanctity, and Kingship". The Journal of Interdisciplinary History. 41 (2): 209–225. doi:10.1162/JINH_a_00050. ISSN   0022-1953. JSTOR   40785099. S2CID   144928195.
  4. 1 2 Kittell, Ellen E. (2011-09-01). "Saint Louis. By Jacques Le goff. (Notre Dame, Ind.: University of Notre Dame Press, 2009. Pp.xxxii, 948. $75.00.)". The Historian. 73 (3): 624–626. doi:10.1111/j.1540-6563.2011.00301_57.x. ISSN   0018-2370. S2CID   143238154.
  5. 1 2 Bachrach, David S. (2010-04-01). "JACQUES LE GOFF. Saint Louis., GARETH EVAN GOLLRAD". The American Historical Review. 115: 597–98. doi:10.1086/ahr.115.2.597 via Oxford Academic.
  6. Jordan, William Chester (1997). "Review of Saint Louis". Speculum. 72 (2): 518–520. doi:10.2307/3041026. ISSN   0038-7134. JSTOR   3041026.
  7. Macy, Gary. "Catholic Books Review: JACQUES LE GOFF, Saint Louis". catholicbooksreview.org. Retrieved 2020-11-28.
  8. Powell, James M. (2010). "Saint Louis". The Catholic Historical Review. 96 (1): 111–113. doi: 10.1353/cat.0.0621 . ISSN   1534-0708 via Project MUSE.
  9. Madden, Thomas F. (April 2010). "Review of Saint Louis by Thomas F. Madden". First Things. Retrieved 2020-12-03.
  10. Williams, Carol J. (2013). "M. Cecilia Gaposchkin: The Making of Saint Louis: Kingship, Sanctity, and Crusade in the Later Middle Ages. Ithaca, NY: Cornell University Press, 2008; pp. xx + 331". Journal of Religious History. 37 (2): 307–308. doi:10.1111/1467-9809.12047. ISSN   1467-9809.
  11. Lee, Alexander. "Twilight of the History Gods: Jacques Le Goff, 1924-2014 | History Today". History Today. Retrieved 2020-11-16.
  12. Murray, Alexander (2010-04-08). "Into Your Enemy's Stomach". London Review of Books. Vol. 32, no. 7. ISSN   0260-9592 . Retrieved 2020-11-28.