Salmonella-in-eggs controversy

Last updated
Edwina Currie caused controversy over a statement about salmonella in eggs Edwina Currie (14164689567).jpg
Edwina Currie caused controversy over a statement about salmonella in eggs

The salmonella-in-eggs controversy was a political controversy in the United Kingdom caused by the Parliamentary Under-Secretary of State for Health, Edwina Currie's claims that "most of the egg production in this country, sadly, is now affected with salmonella" in 1988. These claims led to a 60 percent decline in egg sales over the next few weeks, and angered both politicians and those in the egg production industry. [1] Currie's statement also resulted in the destruction of around 400 million eggs and the slaughter of around 4 million hens. [2] The controversy dominated Currie's tenure as Parliamentary Under-Secretary of State for Health and resulted in her resignation two weeks later.

Contents

Background

Salmonella enteritidis had grown to become a larger worldwide issue in the late 1970s and 1980s than it had been in previous decades, [3] with cases having quadrupled in the first half of 1988 alone. Poultry World reported a "sudden scourge of Salmonella enteriditis" but claimed that the attack on eggs' reputation had been "politically motivated". The magazine's editor, John Farrant, commented that it was "one of the most serious threats ever faced by the industry". [4] At the time of Currie's warning, 12,302 cases had been reported. [5]

Interview

On 3 December 1988 Currie stated in a television interview for ITN:

We do warn people now that most of the egg production in this country, sadly, is now affected with salmonella. If, however, they've used a good source of eggs, a good shop that they know, and they're content, then there sees—there seems no reason for them to stop, but we would advise strongly against using raw egg, mayonnaise and dressings and Bloody Marys and that sort of thing. They are not a good idea anymore.

Years after this statement, Currie wrote that she had misspoken and had meant to say "much of the egg production" rather than "most of the egg production". [6] Additionally, Currie had meant that the egg production flocks were infected rather than the eggs themselves. [7]

Reactions

Outrage was sparked across the United Kingdom. Egg farmers and producers called on Currie to resign, and some threatened to sue. The British Egg Industry Council called Currie's statement "highly irresponsible" and "factually incorrect" and it sought advice on whether or not it was able to sue her. The National Farmers' Union of England and Wales also sought damages. The Ministry of Agriculture, Fisheries and Food expressed anger towards Currie's comments and the Department of Health was unable to back up her claims. [1] In addition, the Ministry of Agriculture had previously tested eggs without finding any salmonella. The chance of becoming ill with salmonella was put at less than 1 in 200 million. [8]

On 3 December in the House of Lords, Robert Hunter, Baron Hunter of Newington asked the government what steps had taken to protect the poultry and egg industry. [8] The Parliamentary Under-Secretary of State for Agriculture, Fisheries and Food, Jean Barker, Baroness Trumpington replied to the question with:

We must keep this problem in perspective. The number of outbreaks in 1988 is very small in relation to the number of eggs which are eaten every day. Nevertheless, I know that the poultry industry accepts its responsibility to consumers to reduce to an absolute minimum the number of salmonella organisms present in or on food.

Result and aftermath

The controversy caused weekly losses in the egg industry of £5 million, and 5,000 of the United Kingdom's chicken farmers facing bankruptcy. In the following days and weeks, egg sales dropped 60 percent, and were still 30 percent down in January 1989. It took another 25 years for egg sales to return to what they had been before 1988. [4] An estimated 4 million layers were terminated across the UK, and around 400 million eggs were destroyed. The government paid millions of pounds worth of compensation to those affected by covering the cost of layers that had been slaughtered at a cost of £1.75 per hen, and by buying up the remaining 10 million unwanted eggs at 30 pence a dozen. [1] [4] The pressure from the industry and the lack of support from MPs from major farming constituencies resulted in Currie's resignation as Parliamentary Under-Secretary of State for Health on 16 December. [9] [10] She was nicknamed "Eggwina" after the affair.

In 1998, the Lion Quality Mark Scheme was introduced, which requires hens to be vaccinated against Salmonella enteritidis. [11] [12] In December 2001, a Whitehall report was revealed that had been produced in February 1989, two months after Currie's resignation, and covered up by the government. The report found that there had been a "salmonella epidemic of considerable proportions". However, the Chief Medical Officer for England, Donald Acheson had urged at the time that the word "epidemic" should not be used except "in a technical sense". [13]

Related Research Articles

<span class="mw-page-title-main">Beak trimming</span> Trimming of a birds beak, usually performed on domesticated birds

Beak trimming, or beak conditioning, is the partial removal of the beak of poultry, especially layer hens and turkeys, although it is also be performed on some quail and ducks. When multiple birds are confined in small spaces due to farming practices, they are more likely to hurt each other through pecking. Beak trimming aims to avoid damage done by pecking, although the practice is criticized by animal welfare organizations and banned in several European countries. Beak trimming is most common in egg-laying strains of chickens. In some countries, such as the United States, turkeys routinely have their beaks trimmed. In the UK, only 10% of turkeys are beak trimmed.

<span class="mw-page-title-main">Edwina Currie</span> Former British politician, broadcaster and writer

Edwina Currie is a British writer, broadcaster and former politician, serving as Conservative Party Member of Parliament for South Derbyshire from 1983 until 1997. She was a Junior Health Minister for two years, resigning in 1988 during the salmonella-in-eggs controversy.

<span class="mw-page-title-main">Broiler</span> Chicken bred for meat

Breed broiler is any chicken that is bred and raised specifically for meat production. Most commercial broilers reach slaughter weight between four and six weeks of age, although slower growing breeds reach slaughter weight at approximately 14 weeks of age. Typical broilers have white feathers and yellowish skin. Broiler or sometimes broiler-fryer is also used sometimes to refer specifically to younger chickens under 2.0 kilograms, as compared with the larger roasters.

<span class="mw-page-title-main">Salmonellosis</span> Infection caused by Salmonella bacteria

Salmonellosis is a symptomatic infection caused by bacteria of the Salmonella type. It is the most common disease to be known as food poisoning, these are defined as diseases, usually either infectious or toxic in nature, caused by agents that enter the body through the ingestion of food. In humans, the most common symptoms are diarrhea, fever, abdominal cramps, and vomiting. Symptoms typically occur between 12 hours and 36 hours after exposure, and last from two to seven days. Occasionally more significant disease can result in dehydration. The old, young, and others with a weakened immune system are more likely to develop severe disease. Specific types of Salmonella can result in typhoid fever or paratyphoid fever. Typhoid fever and paratyphoid fever are specific types of salmonellosis, known collectively as enteric fever, and are, respectively, caused by salmonella typhi and paratyphi bacteria, which are only found in humans. Most commonly, salmonellosis cases arise from salmonella bacteria from animals, and chicken is a major source for these infections.

<span class="mw-page-title-main">Free range</span> Method of farming where animals can roam freely outdoors

Free range denotes a method of farming husbandry where the animals, for at least part of the day, can roam freely outdoors, rather than being confined in an enclosure for 24 hours each day. On many farms, the outdoors ranging area is fenced, thereby technically making this an enclosure, however, free range systems usually offer the opportunity for the extensive locomotion and sunlight that is otherwise prevented by indoor housing systems. Free range may apply to meat, eggs or dairy farming.

<span class="mw-page-title-main">Forced molting</span> Practice of artificially provoking a flock to molt simultaneously

Forced molting, sometimes known as induced molting, is the practice by some poultry industries of artificially provoking a flock to molt simultaneously, typically by withdrawing food for 7–14 days and sometimes also withdrawing water for an extended period. Forced molting is usually implemented when egg-production is naturally decreasing toward the end of the first egg-laying phase. During the forced molt, the birds cease producing eggs for at least two weeks, which allows the bird's reproductive tracts to regress and rejuvenate. After the molt, the hen's egg production rate usually peaks slightly lower than the previous peak, but egg quality is improved. The purpose of forced molting is therefore to increase egg production, egg quality, and profitability of flocks in their second or subsequent laying phases, by not allowing the hen's body the necessary time to rejuvenate during the natural cycle of feather replenishment.

<span class="mw-page-title-main">Chick culling</span> Process of killing newly hatched chicks for which the industry has no use

Chick culling or unwanted chick killing is the process of separating and killing unwanted chicks for which the intensive animal farming industry has no use. It occurs in all industrialised egg production, whether free range, organic, or battery cage. However, some certified pasture-raised egg farms are taking steps to eliminate the practice entirely. Worldwide, around 7 billion male chicks are culled each year in the egg industry. Because male chickens do not lay eggs and only those in breeding programmes are required to fertilise eggs, they are considered redundant to the egg-laying industry and are usually killed shortly after being sexed, which occurs just days after they are conceived or after they hatch. Some methods of culling that do not involve anaesthetics include: cervical dislocation, asphyxiation by carbon dioxide, and maceration using a high-speed grinder. Maceration is the primary method in the United States. Maceration is often a preferred method over carbon dioxide asphyxiation in western countries as it is often considered as "more humane" due to the deaths occurring immediately or within a second.

<span class="mw-page-title-main">Battery cage</span> Agricultural technology

Battery cages are a housing system used for various animal production methods, but primarily for egg-laying hens. The name arises from the arrangement of rows and columns of identical cages connected, in a unit, as in an artillery battery. Although the term is usually applied to poultry farming, similar cage systems are used for other animals. Battery cages have generated controversy between advocates for animal welfare and industrial producers.

Foster Farms is an American poultry company. The company has been privately owned since 1939. It was operated by the Foster family since 1939 until recently, now operated and owned by private equity firm Atlas Holdings, after their purchase of the company in 2022. The company is based in Livingston, California. Operations are concentrated on the West Coast, but the company also maintains a small number of locations on the East Coast. The company specializes in a variety of chicken and turkey products advertised as fresh and naturally locally grown.

<span class="mw-page-title-main">Intensive animal farming</span> Branch of agriculture

Intensive animal farming, industrial livestock production, and macro-farms, also known as factory farming, is a type of intensive agriculture, specifically an approach to animal husbandry designed to maximize production while minimizing costs. To achieve this, agribusinesses keep livestock such as cattle, poultry, and fish at high stocking densities, at large scale, and using modern machinery, biotechnology, and global trade. The main products of this industry are meat, milk and eggs for human consumption.

<span class="mw-page-title-main">Poultry farming</span> Part of animal husbandry

Poultry farming is the form of animal husbandry which raises domesticated birds such as chickens, ducks, turkeys and geese to produce meat or eggs for food. Poultry – mostly chickens – are farmed in great numbers. More than 60 billion chickens are killed for consumption annually. Chickens raised for eggs are known as layers, while chickens raised for meat are called broilers.

<span class="mw-page-title-main">2008 California Proposition 2</span>

Proposition 2 was a California ballot proposition in that state's general election on November 4, 2008. It passed with 63% of the votes in favor and 37% against. Submitted to the Secretary of State as the Prevention of Farm Animal Cruelty Act, the initiative's name was amended to officially be known as the Standards for Confining Farm Animals initiative. The official title of the statute enacted by the proposition is the Prevention of Farm Animal Cruelty Act.

<span class="mw-page-title-main">Eggs as food</span> Edible animal product

Humans and their hominid relatives have consumed eggs for millions of years. The most widely consumed eggs are those of fowl, especially chickens. People in Southeast Asia began harvesting chicken eggs for food by 1500 BCE. Eggs of other birds, such as ducks and ostriches, are eaten regularly but much less commonly than those of chickens. People may also eat the eggs of reptiles, amphibians, and fish. Fish eggs consumed as food are known as roe or caviar.

<span class="mw-page-title-main">Pasteurized eggs</span> Packaged eggs pre-processed with medium heat

Pasteurized eggs are eggs that have been pasteurized in order to reduce the risk of foodborne illness in dishes that are not cooked or are only lightly cooked. They may be sold as liquid egg products or pasteurized in the shell.

The British Egg Industry Council is an organisation set up in 1986 to represent the British egg industry. It currently has 11 member organisations including the British Egg Products Association, the National Farmers Union and the British Free Range Egg Producers Association (BFREPA). The BEIC operates the British Egg Information Service, which promotes the consumption of eggs to the public.

<span class="mw-page-title-main">Poultry farming in the United States</span>

Poultry farming is a part of the United States's agricultural economy.

Wright County Egg, based in Galt, Iowa, is one of the top ten poultry farms in the United States, with a flock of more than 15 million chickens. The company also produces pork.

<span class="mw-page-title-main">Broiler industry</span> Process by which broiler chickens are reared and prepared for meat consumption

The broiler industry is the process by which broiler chickens are reared and prepared for meat consumption. Worldwide, in 2005 production was 71,851,000 tonnes. From 1985 to 2005, the broiler industry grew by 158%.

Salmonellosis annually causes, per CDC estimation, about 1.2 million illnesses, 23,000 hospitalizations, and 450 deaths in the United States every year.

References

  1. 1 2 3 "Egg industry fury over salmonella claim". BBC News . 3 December 1988. Retrieved 19 July 2022.
  2. Hickman, Martin (17 November 2006). "The Big Question: Was Edwina Currie Right About Salmonella In Eggs, After All?". The Independent . Retrieved 19 July 2022.
  3. Neuman, William (2 September 2010). "An Egg Farmer and a History of Salmonella". CNBC . Retrieved 19 July 2022.
  4. 1 2 3 Clarke, Philip (3 December 2013). "How we reported the salmonella crisis 25 years ago". Farmers Weekly . Retrieved 19 July 2022.
  5. Townsend, Lucy (2 December 2013). "Why are we more scared of raw egg than reheated rice?". BBC News . Retrieved 19 July 2022.
  6. Clarke, Philip (3 December 2013). "Edwina Currie: 'No regrets on salmonella crisis'". Farmers Weekly . Retrieved 20 July 2022.
  7. Musgrove, Sarah (13 February 2018). "How One Politician Nearly Broke the British Egg Industry". MyRecipes . Retrieved 20 August 2022.
  8. 1 2 "Salmonella in Eggs and Poultry". Hansard . 6 December 1988. Retrieved 20 July 2022.
  9. "Currie: From Parliament to print". BBC News . 28 September 2002. Retrieved 19 July 2022.
  10. Diehl, Dave (18 December 1988). "Ads crack down on egg scare sweeping Britain". NewspaperArchive . p. 46. Retrieved 9 May 2023.
  11. "British Lion Eggs". egg info. Retrieved 20 July 2022.
  12. Currie, Edwina (11 November 2017). "Eggs destroyed my political career – but then salmonella got me on Strictly". The Telegraph . Retrieved 20 July 2022.
  13. Millward, David (26 December 2001). "Currie 'was right' on salmonella". The Telegraph . Retrieved 19 July 2022.