Schurz Communications, Inc. v. FCC

Last updated
Schurz Communications, Inc. v. FCC
Seal of the United States Court of Appeals for the Seventh Circuit.svg
Court United States Court of Appeals for the Seventh Circuit
Full case nameSchurz Communications v. Federal Communications Commission and the United States of America
ArguedOctober 2 1992
DecidedNovember 5, 1992
Citation(s)982 F. 2d 1043 (7th Cir. 1992)
Case history
Subsequent historyMotion for disqualification denied, 982 F.2d 1057 (7th Cir. 1993)
Court membership
Judge(s) sitting William J. Bauer, Richard Posner, Thomas E. Fairchild
Case opinions
MajorityPosner, joined by Bauer, Fairchild

Schurz Communications v. Federal Communications Commission and the United States of America, 982 F. 2d 1043 (7th Cir. 1992), held in the United States Court of Appeals for the Seventh Circuit, was argued on October 2, 1992 and decided on November 5, 1992. The case dealt with the justification of the FCC's regulation of the way television networks are allowed to distribute and produce programs into syndication. Judge Richard Posner was the Circuit Judge for the case. This case challenged Syndication and Financial rules imposed in the 1970s, as broadcast television changed with the popularity of cable television, the rise of the FOX network, and the discrediting of the leverage theory.

Contents

Broadcast Structure

The broadcast television industry has a structure of three main role players:

The Network
The network is a vertically integrated media corporation. Vertically structured by the following reasons: networks own in-house production facilities in order to produce their own television video programming, networks own and operate television stations in major markets (such as Los Angeles and New York), networks affiliate themselves with independently owned television stations throughout the entire nation, and maintain telecommunications links among all these stations to distribute video programming. They are involved in every level: production, distribution and consumption.

The Affiliates:
Affiliates are TV stations affiliated with networks however they seek independent and original programming as well. Affiliates receive "network feeds" but also originate local news and sports programming, as well as obtain syndicators.

The Independents:
Independents are TV stations that do not affiliate with a network. An independent station is responsible for obtaining programming for the entire broadcast day on a program-by-program basis from a number of sources. Independents primarily run syndications, such as movies that have been previously shown in theatres as well as series that have previously aired. In addition, a large bulk of independent programming comes from series that have been produced originally for the independent stations.

Key Terms

Vertical Integration: The business model where one owner controls the production, distribution and consumption of a good. In this case, vertical integration specifically refers to the distribution and production monopoly of television shows by the CBS, NBC, and ABC television networks.

Leverage Theory: The theory that a company which has economic power in one market could use their power to obtain a monopoly in another market.

Television syndication : The selling of the rights to air programs to different stations.

First-Run Syndication: Programming that is broadcast for the first time as a syndicated show. Examples of first-run are talk shows, like the Oprah Winfrey and Tyra Banks shows, and game shows like Wheel of Fortune .

Off Network Syndication: The sale of a program that was originally run on network television. Examples of off-network programs are Sex and the City and Friends .

Prime Time Access Rule (PTAR) : A rule instated by the Federal Communications Commission (FCC) in 1970 to restrict the amount of network programming that network-affiliated stations may air during what it known as "prime time".

Syndication and Financial Rules

Rules were imposed in 1970 by the FCC to ensure that television networks, NBC, CBS and ABC, had limited power regarding television programming. With these rules in place, the major networks were not permitted to syndicate shows that were made by the network to be rebroadcast by other independent stations, that weren't owned by or affiliated with the network. The stations were also forbidden to purchase the syndication rights for programs produced outside the network. In 1990, the FCC at the request of FOX, initiated a notice-and-comment rule-making proceeding. Until this time, what to do with the rules remained in limbo. After this hearing and receiving numerous submissions from the various elements of the television industry, a hearing was held. The Commission held a one-day hearing after which it issued an opinion, over the dissents of two of the five commissioners. The new rules are different in several ways —one of which is that they define 'network' as an entity that supplies at least 15 hours of prime time programming to interconnected affiliates.

Brief Timeline

1970 — FCC adopts financial interest and syndication rules designed to limit power of three major networks - CBS, NBC, and ABC.

1980 — The commission orders an extensive staff study which concludes that the rules are obsolete and it is recommended that they be abandoned.

1983 — FCC issued tentative decision agreeing with the staff proposing radical revisions in the rules.

1990 — FCC at the request of FOX initiates a fresh notice-and-comment rule making proceeding

1990 — Commission held a one-day hearing, after which it disseminated a revised set of financial interest and syndication rules.

1992 — Schurz Communications v. Federal Communications Commission

Decision

Schurz Communications v FCC and USA

Decided

November 5, 1992 by Judge Posner, US Court of Appeals for the Seventh Circuit

Decision

Order is Vacated and the matter is returned to the Commission for further proceedings.

Rationale

The Commission's rules were arbitrary.

1. The Commission did not clearly define the term diversity nor distinguish among different types of diversity

2. The statute provides no guidance of authority other than to say that the Commission is to act in accordance with the public interest.

3. The rules are so complicated that it is unclear whether they are more or less restrictive than the rules they modified.

The FCC did not take into consideration changes in the media.

1. The 40% limitation on the amount of prime-time entertainment that a network can supply from its in-house production is a new restriction on the networks, having no counterpart in the original 1970 rules. The networks argue that the new rules do not increase their access to the programming market and in fact decrease it.

2.With so much of the country now having cable television and many more getting access to it, not only is programming for small audiences with specialized tastes is feasible, but there is also greater competition for the networks.

3. Whereas in the 1970s networks held 90% of prime time audiences, today it is only at 62%

4.A television station is only allowed to buy syndication rights to a program from an outside producer as long as the producer does so pursuant to separate negotiations begun at least 30 days after the network and the producer have agreed on the fee for licensing the network to exhibit the program. Even at that point the network cannot do the syndication, it must hire an independent syndicator to arrange distribution to independent stations. This discourages the entry of new producers and in so doing reduces diversity both of program sources and of program outlets.

5. The unrestricted sale of syndication rights to networks would strengthen the production industry and thereby increase programming diversity by enabling a sharing between fledgling producers and the networks of the risks of new production. A rule telling someone he may not do business with some firm believed to have market power is unlikely to make the person better off.

Related Research Articles

Broadcast syndication is the practice of leasing the right to broadcasting television shows and radio programs to multiple television stations and radio stations, without going through a broadcast network. It is common in the United States where broadcast programming is scheduled by television networks with local independent affiliates. Syndication is less widespread in the rest of the world, as most countries have centralized networks or television stations without local affiliates. Shows can be syndicated internationally, although this is less common.

Television in the United States Overview of television in the United States

Television is one of the major mass media outlets in the United States. As of 2011, household ownership of television sets in the country is 96.7%, with approximately 114,200,000 American households owning at least one television set as of August 2013. The majority of households have more than one set. The peak ownership percentage of households with at least one television set occurred during the 1996–97 season, with 98.4% ownership.

WABM MyNetworkTV affiliate in Birmingham, Alabama

WABM is a television station in Birmingham, Alabama, United States, affiliated with MyNetworkTV. It is owned by Sinclair Broadcast Group alongside Homewood-licensed CW affiliate WTTO and low-power ABC affiliate WBMA-LD ; Sinclair also operates Bessemer-licensed WDBB, which serves as a full satellite station of WTTO, under a time brokerage agreement (TBA) with Sinclair partner company Cunningham Broadcasting. However, Sinclair effectively owns WDBB as the majority of Cunningham's stock is owned by the family of deceased group founder Julian Smith.

An independent station is a type of television station broadcasting in the United States or Canada that is not affiliated with any broadcast television network; most commonly, these stations carry a mix of syndicated, brokered and in some cases, local programming to fill time periods when network programs typically would air. Stations that are affiliated with networks such as The CW, MyNetworkTV or to a lesser degree, even Fox, may be considered to be quasi-independent stations as these networks mainly provide programming during primetime, with limited to no network-supplied content in other time periods.

WNDU-TV NBC affiliate in South Bend, Indiana

WNDU-TV is a television station in South Bend, Indiana, United States, affiliated with NBC. It is owned by Gray Television alongside Elkhart-licensed Heroes & Icons affiliate WSJV. Both stations share studios on the campus of WNDU-TV's founding owner the University of Notre Dame along State Road 933 on South Bend's north side, while WNDU-TV's transmitter is located southeast of the St. Joseph County Fairgrounds on the city's south side.

KSCW-DT is a television station in Wichita, Kansas, United States, affiliated with The CW. It is owned by Gray Television alongside Hutchinson-licensed CBS affiliate KWCH-DT. Both stations share studios on 37th Street in northeast Wichita, while KSCW-DT's transmitter is located in rural northeastern Reno County.

KHME is a television station in Rapid City, South Dakota, United States, affiliated with the classic television network MeTV. It is owned by Gray Television alongside ABC affiliate KOTA-TV and low-power Fox affiliate KEVN-LD. The stations share studios on Skyline Drive in Rapid City, where KHME's transmitter is also located.

WAGT (TV) Defunct television station in Augusta, Georgia

WAGT, virtual and UHF digital channel 26, was an NBC-affiliated television station licensed to Augusta, Georgia, United States, which operated from December 1968 until May 2017.

WDBJ CBS affiliate in Roanoke, Virginia

WDBJ is a television station licensed to Roanoke, Virginia, United States, serving as the CBS affiliate for the Roanoke–Lynchburg market. It is owned by Gray Television alongside Danville-licensed MyNetworkTV affiliate WZBJ, channel 24. WDBJ and WZBJ share studios on Hershberger Road in northwest Roanoke; through a channel sharing agreement, the two stations transmit using WDBJ's spectrum from an antenna on Poor Mountain in Roanoke County.

KGHZ is a defunct television station in Springfield, Missouri, United States. Owned by Schurz Communications, the station was operated by Gray Television under a local marketing agreement (LMA) for its last four months on the air before its license was returned to the Federal Communications Commission (FCC) on May 31, 2017, as a result of the FCC's 2016 spectrum auction. KGHZ's transmitter was located on Switchgrass Road, north of Fordland. For most of its history, it served as the Springfield–Branson market's ABC affiliate, a role now served by KSPR-LD.

A weekday cartoon is the colloquial term for the animated series programming that was typically scheduled on weekday mornings and afternoons in the United States on many major television networks and in broadcast syndication since the 1960s.

Syndication exclusivity is a federal law implemented by the Federal Communications Commission (FCC) in the United States that is designed to protect a local television station's rights to syndicated television programs by granting exclusive broadcast rights to the station for that program in their local market, usually defined by a station's Nielsen Designated Market Area.

WKNX-TV Independent TV station in Knoxville, Tennessee

WKNX-TV is an independent television station in Knoxville, Tennessee, United States. It is owned by Lockwood Broadcast Group alongside Fox affiliate WTNZ. Both stations share studios on Executive Park Drive in Knoxville's Green Valley section, while WKNX-TV's transmitter is located on Sharp's Ridge, near the city's Oakwood section.

WWCP-TV Fox affiliate in Johnstown, Pennsylvania

WWCP-TV is a television station licensed to Johnstown, Pennsylvania, United States, serving as the Fox affiliate for the Johnstown–Altoona–State College market. It is owned by Cunningham Broadcasting, which provides certain services to Altoona-licensed ABC affiliate WATM-TV under a local marketing agreement (LMA) with Palm Television, L.P. Both stations, in turn, are operated under a shared services agreement (SSA) by Sinclair Broadcast Group, owner of Johnstown-licensed dual NBC/CW+ affiliate WJAC-TV.

KSPR-LD ABC affiliate in Springfield, Missouri

KSPR-LD is a low-power television station in Springfield, Missouri, United States, affiliated with ABC. It is owned by Gray Television alongside NBC affiliate KYTV and Branson-licensed CW affiliate KYCW-LD ; it is also sister to Branson-licensed tourist information–formatted station K17DL-D, channel 17. KSPR-LD, KYTV and KYCW-LD share studios on West Sunshine Street in Springfield, while KSPR-LD's transmitter is located on Highway FF north of Fordland.

The Prime Time Access Rule (PTAR) was a broadcasting regulation that was instituted in the United States by the Federal Communications Commission (FCC) in 1970 to restrict the amount of network programming that a local television station either owned-and-operated or affiliated with a television network can air during evening primetime hours. This rule was repealed by the FCC in 1996, though remnants remain.

WAGT-CD NBC/CW affiliate in Augusta, Georgia

WAGT-CD, virtual channel 26, is a low-power, Class A dual NBC/CW+-affiliated television station licensed to Augusta, Georgia, United States. Owned by Atlanta-based Gray Television, it is a sister station to CBS affiliate WRDW-TV. Both stations share studios at The Village at Riverwatch development in Augusta, while WAGT-CD's transmitter is located in Beech Island, South Carolina.

The Financial Interest and Syndication Rules, widely known as the fin-syn rules, were a set of rules imposed by the Federal Communications Commission in the United States in 1970. The FCC sought to prevent the Big Three television networks from monopolizing the broadcast landscape by preventing them from owning any of the programming that they aired in prime time. The rules also prohibited networks from airing syndicated programming they had a financial stake in.

WGTW-TV is a religious television station licensed to Millville, New Jersey, United States, owned and operated by the Trinity Broadcasting Network (TBN). It previously served the Philadelphia, Pennsylvania television market, but can now only be received in Southern New Jersey. The station's studios are located on Columbia Avenue in suburban Folcroft, Pennsylvania; its transmitter was previously located in the Roxborough section of Philadelphia, but is now shared with True Crime Network affiliate WMGM-TV along Avalon Boulevard in the Swainton section of Middle Township, east of the Garden State Parkway off Exit 13.

KNEP NBC/ABC affiliate in Sidney–Scottsbluff, Nebraska

KNEP, virtual channels 2 & 4, is a dual NBC/ABC-affiliated television station serving Scottsbluff, Nebraska, United States and the Nebraska Panhandle. Licensed to the nearby town of Sidney and owned by Atlanta-based Gray Television, it is a sister station to Scottsbluff-licensed CBS affiliate KSTF. KNEP's studios are located on 1st Avenue in Scottsbluff, and its transmitter is located in Angora, Nebraska.

References