Sealed crustless sandwich

Last updated

Sealed crustless sandwich
Smucker's Uncrustable Cut - Day 26 of 100 Project (8126561088).jpg
A sealed crustless sandwich with peanut butter and jelly filling (mass-produced)
Type Sandwich
CourseLunch, Snack
Place of origin United States
Main ingredients Bread, various fillings

A sealed crustless sandwich consists of a filling between two layers of crimp-sealed bread, with the crust removed.

Contents

Homemade variations are typically square, round, or triangular; the bread can vary, e.g., white or whole wheat; and the sandwiches can be homemade with common crimping techniques similar to pie crust, ravioli, or dumplings using readily available kitchen tools (e.g., a fork, small spoon or curved knife end to crimp the edges). A purpose-designed "cut and crimp" tool can also be used. [1]

Mass-produced varieties vary in shape, are typically individually wrapped, frozen and packaged and include proprietary brands as well as house brands. They were introduced in 1995 with peanut butter and jelly filling, followed by numerous patent [2] and trademark disputes as well as numerous competitors entering the market.

The sandwiches offer easily-frozen and thawed, ready-to-eat, portable convenience; Ethiopian-born Kamal Mohamed, founder of the Gallant Tiger brand, called sealed sandwiches "the Swiss Army knife of foods". [3] They have appeal across generations and can easily be included in a homemade lunch. In 2018, sealed crustless sandwiches were made available to firemen during the California wildfires. [4] [5]

Mass production

In the United States, mass-produced crustless sealed sandwiches were introduced in 1995, in Fargo North Dakota by David Geske and Len Kretchman [6] — at the time marketing as Incredible Uncrustables to schools in the Midwest, with fifty employees making roughly 35,000 of the sealed sandwiches daily by 1998. [6] Their company was purchased by the The J.M. Smucker Company in 1998. [6] In Japan, Yamazaki Baking has marketed Lunch Pack sealed sandwiches since 1984.

Companies have marketed sealed crustless sandwiches in square, triangular, round and even cloud shapes with an extensive range of fillings, including ham, [7] cheese, [7] chocolate-hazelnut spread, [7] almond butter and jam, [8] peanut butter and honey, [7] peanut butter and apple butter, peanut butter and banana, sunflower butter and jelly — or, prominently, peanut butter and jelly. [7] In the case of the latter, some companies apply the peanut butter to both interior surfaces of the bread, shielding the bread from the jelly engineer the bread to prevent filling leaks [9] or augment the crimping with starch to provide a tighter seal.

Mass-produced U.S. brands include:

  • Chubby Snacks
  • Crustless Cocoa CPB Sandwich by E-S Frozen Foods
  • EZ Jammers by Albie's Foods
  • Gallant Tiger
  • Good & Gather Sunbutter and Jelly Sandwiches by Target
  • Jammies by Sunbutter
  • Lunch Buddies PB Delights by Aldi, Canadian made
  • Luv Me Foods Organic Peanut Butter & Strawberry Jelly Sandwich
  • Market Pantry Crustless Sandwiches by Target
  • PB Jamwiches and PB Jamz by AdvancePierre Foods
  • Pea B&J Pockets by Annie's
  • PB&J sandwiches by Sam's Club and Welch's
  • Wowbutter & Grape Jelly, Crustless Sandwiches, by Nature's Promise
  • No Crust Sandwiches, by Walmart, Canadian made
  • PB + J Crustless Sandwiches and Charlotte's Crustoffs, by Costco
  • Sunwise sunflower butter and jelly sandwiches by Muffintown
  • Uncrustables, by Smucker's
  • Whistlin Sams by Tyson Foods

Smuckers has plants in Kentucky [10] Colorado [11] and Alabama [12] with Uncrustables sales projected at $500 million in 2021 offering numerous variations, e.g., Grilled Cheese Uncrustable (approximately 2003-2014), Ham and Cheddar Bites,Pepperoni Bites and others. In 2023, Smucker said it took about ten years to prevent "leaky sandwiches," designing the bread so it doesn't create air pockets and using round loaves. [9]

Chubby Snacks, headquartered in Colorado, [13] launched as a direct-to-consumer brand in 2020. It markets its sealed sandwiches in a "cloud" shape [14] using organic, whole wheat bread; medjool dates and monk fruit for sweetness rather than refined sugar, and having 2-3 grams of sugar per sandwich. [15] The company aimed to manufacture 30 million sealed crustless sandwiches annually by 2024. [16]

Trademark infringment

Smuckers, with $7.8 billion in net sales as of 2020, has issued cease and desist letters to any company marketing crustless sealed sandwiches in a round shape, including small businesses, arguing trademark infringement. Targeted companies have included Chubby Snacks, [6] which revised their sandwiches to a cloud shape; Albie's Foods [6] which revised their EZ Jammers to a triangular and later square shape, and Gallant Tiger [17] which markets a decidedly adult-flavored product (e.g., chai spiced pear butter and peanut butter) selling at a price-point roughly six times the cost of an Uncrustable.

The Gallant Tiger founder noted that at a time when the company had seven sales outlets, "1,000 followers on Instagram and $20,000 in sales, and [Smuckers was] telling us that not only are we infringing on their trademark, which is a circle-shaped sandwich, but we also were falsifying advertising and essentially slandering them. It was weird. It was almost like in the eyes of Smucker, [Gallant Tiger] was a criminal," adding that a consumer "can tell the difference between Domino’s and Pizza Hut [pizza] even though they’re both circular food products. So what are we really talking about here?" [17]

Patent history

The United States Patent and Trademark Office issued a number of patents for mass-produced versions of a sealed crustless sandwich, which were subsequently reexamined and cancelled for having attempted to patent obvious or well known concepts.

The sealed crustless sandwich. Sealed crustless sandwich 1.png
The sealed crustless sandwich.

The first claim of Menusaver's patent reads:

  1. A sealed crustless sandwich, comprising:
    • a first bread layer having a first perimeter surface coplanar to a contact surface;
    • at least one filling of an edible food juxtaposed to said contact surface;
    • a second bread layer juxtaposed to said at least one filling opposite of said first bread layer, wherein said second bread layer includes a second perimeter surface similar to said first perimeter surface;
    • a crimped edge directly between said first perimeter surface and said second perimeter surface for sealing said filling(s) between said first bread layer and said second bread layer;
      wherein a crust portion of said first bread layer and said second bread layer has been removed.
A cross-section of the "sealed crustless sandwich," illustrating their patent claim. Sealed crustless sandwich 2.png
A cross-section of the "sealed crustless sandwich," illustrating their patent claim.

That is, the patent described a sandwich with a layer of filling in between two pieces of bread which are crimped shut and have their crust removed. The other nine claims of the patent elaborate the idea further, including the coating of two sides of the bread with peanut butter first before putting the jelly in the middle, so that the jelly would not seep into the bread—the layers of filling "are engaged to one another to form a reservoir for retaining the second filling in between".

Many intellectual property experts and members of the general public view this patent as an example of the patent office's inability to properly examine patent applications. [18] The patent examiner cited only seven previous patents issued between 1963 and 1998, and a 1994 book called 50 Great Sandwiches that were deemed relevant to the novelty and nonobviousness of the invention. He concluded that the invention was indeed novel and not obvious and allowed the claims. [18]

Since then, many more earlier patents and publications have been found that teach some or all of the different aspects of the invention. These include a 1949 patent ( U.S. patent 2,463,439 ) that describes a device to create these types of sandwiches: "An object of this invention is to provide... a means for locating said filling in the center of the sandwich and sealing the marginal edges of the pieces by heat and pressure to preclude the escape of filling from the finished product... [and] a means for trimming the baked dough pieces". These new pieces of prior art have been brought to the attention of the patent office through a reexamination proceeding. (See below)

The J.M. Smucker Co. also attempted to patent the process of making the sandwich in 2004 (rather than just the sandwich itself) and on April 8, 2005, had its application rejected by the U.S. Court of Appeals for the Federal Circuit (CAFC)..

Patent enforcement

In 2001, a small grocery and caterer in Gaylord, Michigan, Albie's Food, Inc., was sent a cease and desist letter from The J.M. Smucker Co., accusing Albie's of violating their intellectual property rights to the "sealed crustless sandwich". Instead of capitulating, Albie's took the case to federal court, noting in their filings a pocket sandwich with crimped edges and no crust was called a "pasty" and had been a popular dish in northern Michigan since the nineteenth century. Federal Court determined that Albie's Foods did not infringe on J.M. Smucker Co. intellectual property rights and was allowed to continue, overturning Smucker's cease and desist. [19]

Patent reexamination

In March 2001, during the legal proceedings, Albie's filed a request for reexamination with the USPTO asking that the patent be reexamined in light of the new prior art. The reexamination serial number is 90/005,949.

In response to the new prior art cited, Smucker's narrowed the wording of their claims to only cover a very specific version of their sealed crustless sandwich. The more narrow claims, for example, only cover sealed crustless peanut butter and jelly sandwiches where the jelly is held between two layers of peanut butter. Nonetheless, in December 2003, the patent examiner rejected the narrowed claims in light of the new prior art.

Smucker's appealed the rejection to the Board of Patent Appeals and Interferences (BPAI). In September 2006, the BPAI reversed the examiner's reasons for rejecting the claims, but found new reasons for rejecting them. They found that the wording in the narrowed claims was too vague to clearly identify exactly what Smucker's is trying to patent. Because Smucker's failed to respond to the BPAI's rejections within the two-month deadline, the PTO mailed a Notice of Intent to Issue a Reexamination Certificate (NIIRC) in December 2006 cancelling all claims. The reexamination certificate was issued on September 25, 2007.

See also

Notes

  1. Reg Wydeven (August 6, 2005). "Smucker's in a bit of legal jam with uncrusted tradition". The Post-Crescent.
  2. Kat Eschner (November 3, 2017). "Can a Sandwich Be Intellectual Property?". Smithsonian Magazine.
  3. Joseph Lamour (December 2, 2004). "Smucker's is in a trademark fight with small business over round, crustless sandwiches". Today.
  4. Chapple-Sokol, Sam (August 29, 2018). "Fueling the Firefighters: What California's First Responders Eat". Eater. Retrieved September 8, 2018.
    Davis, Makenzie (August 15, 2018). "Away from home, firefighters give their all". Lassen County Times. Retrieved September 8, 2018.
  5. Coury, Nic (August 11, 2016). "A glance at firefighters' favorite snacks while they're on shift". Monterey County Weekly. Retrieved September 8, 2018.
    Mejia, Brittny (December 7, 2017). "What do hungry firefighters eat for breakfast? Try 10,000 eggs and 4,500 strips of bacon". Los Angeles Times. Retrieved September 8, 2018.
  6. 1 2 3 4 5 David Streitfeld for the LA Times (February 8, 2003). "Who Owns the Crustless PB&J?". The Tribune.
  7. 1 2 3 4 5 "Smucker's Products". Smuckers.
  8. "Chubby Snacks Products". Chubby Snacks.
  9. 1 2 Keith Nunes (March 15, 2023). "Smucker reveals its Uncrustables secret". Food Business News.
  10. Burneko, Albert (June 1, 2013). "Taste Test: Uncrustables. What Does The Crustless PB&J Say About Us?". Deadspin. Retrieved March 14, 2018.
  11. "The J. M. Smucker Company Announces Fourth Quarter and Full-Year Results" (Press release). The J.M. Smucker Co. June 16, 2005. Archived from the original on March 14, 2017. Retrieved January 4, 2012.
  12. Doering, Christopher (November 19, 2021). "J.M. Smucker to build $1.1B plant for Uncrustables, creating up to 750 jobs". FoodDive. Retrieved November 22, 2021.
  13. Monica Watrous (May 30, 2022). "Chubby Snacks to take on Uncrustables". Baking Business.
  14. "Chubby Snacks Announces Launch of New Shape and Flavors". PR Newswire. February 4, 2021.
  15. Lucas Cuni-Mertz (February 13, 2023). "Winning big with snack innovation". Food Business News.
  16. Monica Watrous (November 21, 2023). "'A new beginning' for Chubby Snacks". Food Business News.
  17. 1 2 Dennis Lee (January 4, 2023). "Smucker's Tells Other Crustless Sandwiches to Cease and Desist". The Takeout.
  18. 1 2 See the discussion in Jaffe and Lerner (2004).
  19. "Albie's Foods, Inc. v. Menusaver, Inc., 170 F. Supp. 2d 736 (E.D. Mich. 2001)". Justia Law. Retrieved April 23, 2018.

Related Research Articles

<span class="mw-page-title-main">Sandwich</span> Food made with bread and other ingredients

A sandwich is a food typically consisting of vegetables, sliced cheese or meat, placed on or between slices of bread, or more generally any dish wherein bread serves as a container or wrapper for another food type. The sandwich began as a portable, convenient finger food in the Western world, though over time it has become prevalent worldwide.

<span class="mw-page-title-main">Peanut butter</span> Paste made from ground peanuts

Peanut butter is a food paste or spread made from ground, dry-roasted peanuts. It commonly contains additional ingredients that modify the taste or texture, such as salt, sweeteners, or emulsifiers. Consumed in many countries, it is the most commonly used of the nut butters, a group that also includes cashew butter and almond butter.

<span class="mw-page-title-main">The J.M. Smucker Company</span> American food and beverage manufacturer

The J.M. Smucker Company, also known as Smuckers, is an American manufacturer of food and beverage products. Headquartered in Orrville, Ohio, the company was founded in 1897 as a maker of apple butter. J.M. Smucker currently has three major business units: consumer foods, pet foods, and coffee. Its flagship brand, Smucker's, produces fruit preserves, peanut butter, syrups, frozen crustless sandwiches, and ice cream toppings.

<span class="mw-page-title-main">Cucumber sandwich</span> Thin slices of cucumber between two slices of crustless white bread

The traditional cucumber sandwich is a crustless tea sandwich composed of thin slices of cucumber situated between two thin slices of lightly buttered white bread. The sandwich originated in the United Kingdom, and modern variants, largely of United States origin, introduce cream cheese, mayonnaise, chopped dill or spices, and salmon, and may substitute brown bread. One specific US variant includes benedictine, a green soft spread made from cucumbers and cream cheese.

<span class="mw-page-title-main">Dutch cuisine</span> Culinary traditions of the Netherlands

Dutch cuisine is formed from the cooking traditions and practices of the Netherlands. The country's cuisine is shaped by its location on the fertile Rhine–Meuse–Scheldt delta on the European Plain bordering the North Sea, giving rise to fishing, farming, and overseas trade. Due to the availability of water and flat grassland, the Dutch diet contains many dairy products such as cheese and butter, and is relatively high in carbohydrates and fat.

<span class="mw-page-title-main">Skippy (peanut butter)</span> American peanut butter brand

Skippy is an American brand of peanut butter manufactured in the United States and China. First sold in 1932, Skippy is currently manufactured by Hormel Foods, which bought the brand from Unilever in 2013. It is the best-selling brand of peanut butter in China and second only to the J.M. Smucker Company's Jif brand worldwide.

<span class="mw-page-title-main">Pie iron</span> Appliance

A pie iron—also called pudgy pie iron, sandwich toaster, snackwicher, toastie maker—is a cooking appliance that consists of two hinged concave, round or square, cast iron or aluminium plates on long handles. Its "clamshell" design resembles that of a waffle iron, but without that appliance's honeycomb pattern. Pie irons are used to heat, toast and seal the sandwich.

<span class="mw-page-title-main">Fluffernutter</span> Sandwich made with peanut butter and marshmallow creme

A fluffernutter is a sandwich made with peanut butter and marshmallow creme usually served on white bread. Variations of the sandwich include the substitution of wheat bread and the addition of various sweet, salty, and savory ingredients. The term fluffernutter can also be used to describe other food items, primarily desserts, that incorporate peanut butter and marshmallow creme.

In United States patent law, a reexamination is a process whereby anyone—third party or inventor—can have a U.S. patent reexamined by a patent examiner to verify that the subject matter it claims is patentable. To have a patent reexamined, an interested party must submit prior art, in the form of patents or printed publications, that raises a "substantial new question of patentability". The Leahy-Smith America Invents Act makes substantial changes to the U.S. patent system, including new mechanisms for challenging patents at the U.S. Patent and Trademark Office. One of the new mechanisms is a post-grant review proceeding, which will provide patent challengers expanded bases on which to attack patents.

<span class="mw-page-title-main">Sándwich de miga</span> Sandwich popular in Argentina and Uruguay

Sándwiches de miga, also called rafaelitos or simply sánguches, are popular food items in Argentina and Uruguay, where they are often consumed at parties. Rather than making them from scratch, Argentines usually buy them at a local bakery. They can be toasted or untoasted. The toasted version is common bar food in both countries, known locally as tostados or carlitos in Argentina, and sándwiches calientes in Uruguay.

<span class="mw-page-title-main">Fool's Gold Loaf</span> Sandwich enjoyed by Elvis Presley

Fool's Gold Loaf is a sandwich made by the Colorado Mine Company, a restaurant in Denver, Colorado. It consists of a single warmed, hollowed-out loaf of bread filled with the contents of one jar of creamy peanut butter, one jar of grape jelly, and one pound (450 g) of bacon.

Goober is a combination of peanut butter and jelly in a single jar. It is sold in US, the UK, Canada, Singapore, and other parts of the Commonwealth, and is named after a familiar denomination for peanut in American English, goober pea, from the Gullah name for the peanut, guber. Goober was introduced by The J.M. Smucker Company under the Smucker's brand.

<span class="mw-page-title-main">Peanut butter and jelly sandwich</span> Type of sandwich

A peanut butter and jelly sandwich (PB&J) consists of peanut butter and fruit preserves—jelly—spread on bread. The sandwich may be open-faced, made of a single slice of bread folded over, or made using two slices of bread. The sandwich is popular in the United States, especially among children; a 2002 survey showed the average American will eat 1,500 peanut butter and jelly sandwiches before graduating from high school. There are many variations of the sandwich, starting with the basic peanut butter sandwich or jam sandwich.

<span class="mw-page-title-main">Jam sandwich (food)</span> Beginner-level sandwich, made of jam and bread

A jam sandwich is usually composed of two slices of bread with jam in the middle. It is normally consumed at lunchtime or as a snack. In Scotland, they are also known as pieces and jam, or jeely pieces.

<span class="mw-page-title-main">Peanut butter, banana and bacon sandwich</span> Sandwich popularized by Elvis Presley

The peanut butter and banana sandwich (PB&B), or peanut butter, banana and bacon sandwich (PB,B&B), sometimes referred to as an Elvis sandwich, the Velvet Elvis, or simply the Elvis, is a sandwich with toasted bread, peanut butter, sliced or mashed banana, and occasionally bacon. Honey or jelly is seen in some variations of the sandwich. The sandwich is frequently cooked in a pan or on a griddle.

Peanut Butter & Co. is a peanut butter brand based in New York City. Founded in 1998 by Lee Zalben, from 1998 to 2016, the company operated a sandwich shop in Greenwich Village, which sold gourmet peanut butter sandwiches for $5. The company by 1999 was selling a line of peanut butter to supermarkets featuring ten "all natural" flavors and from peanuts grown by farmers in the United States. In 2005 the company published The Peanut Butter & Co. Cookbook.

<span class="mw-page-title-main">Sandwich cookie</span> Cookies kept by two thin cookies or biscuits with filling in between

A sandwich cookie, also known as a sandwich biscuit, is a type of cookie made from two thin cookies or medium cookies with a filling between them. Many types of fillings are used, such as cream, ganache, buttercream, chocolate, cream cheese, jam, peanut butter, lemon curd, or ice cream.

<span class="mw-page-title-main">Indo cuisine</span> Fusion of Indonesian and European cuisine

Indo cuisine is a fusion cooking and cuisine tradition, mainly existing in Indonesia and the Netherlands, as well as Belgium, South Africa and Suriname. This cuisine characterized of fusion cuisine that consists of original Indonesian cuisine with Eurasian-influences—mainly Dutch, also Portuguese, Spanish, French and British—and vice versa. Nowaday, not only Indo people consume Indo cuisine, but also Indonesians and Dutch people.

References

Listen to this article (5 minutes)
Sound-icon.svg
This audio file was created from a revision of this article dated 25 June 2005 (2005-06-25), and does not reflect subsequent edits.