Plot
On December 12, 1983, Teenagers Malik and Liam make out in a car when a group of men suddenly appear and brutally attack them.
On November 7, 1995, Malik, his partner, Aaron, and Aaron’s teenage daughter, Kayla, moves into a new home in a small town to begin a new life as a family. During the first night in their home, Malik hears strange noises, and a mysterious, hooded person watches them from afar. Malik bonds with Kayla and tries to adjust to life in the new house, but he is plagued with traumatic flashbacks of the attack he suffered as a teenager.
Aaron and Malik meet one of their neighbors, Tiffany, who presents them with a housewarming gift. Malik returns home later and sees a homophobic slur spray painted on the wall. He paints over it and does not tell Aaron what happened. Malik and Aaron attend a bonfire party with other the residents, including Tiffany and her husband, Marshall. Malik sees Mr. Rinehart, who lives across the street, staring at him from a distance before disappearing. Mr. Rinehart tries to break into their house later that night and gives Malik a piece of paper, informing him not to show it to anyone. Malik watches Mr. Rinehart’s house and sees him, as well other neighbors, performing a ritual in a circle. The following morning, Mr. Rinehart is discovered dead in his home by his grandson, Matthew, in an apparent suicide. Malik becomes increasingly suspicious and distrustful of the neighbors while Aaron tries fit in with them.
Kayla tells Malik and Aaron she has found a part-time job, but she secretly spends her time hanging out with Tiffany and Marshall’s teenage son, Tyler.
Malik begins experiencing a series of hallucinations and nightmares. He discovers the paper Mr. Rinehart gave him has a series of numerical dates and, after researching, learns that a same-sex couple was the victim of a murder-suicide in the same neighborhood in 1985. He finds an abandoned house, and an apparition appears and gives him a handful of video tapes.
He tries to convince Aaron that they need to leave the town, but Aaron believes Malik is struggling with paranoia as a result of his past. Tensions between them increase, and Aaron kicks Malik out of the house after finding photos of him and Matthew having sex to which Malik denies.
Malik stays in the abandoned house and watches one of the tapes, which contains home movie footage of the same-sex couple from 1985. The tape reveals they experienced similar disturbing events prior to their deaths. Malik learns that every 10 years, the neighbors perform a ritual and select a new family in the neighborhood to target. He returns home to warn Aaron and Kayla but is horrified to see all of the residents have assembled for a gathering. Believing Marshall to the leader of the rituals, he shoots him to death, and it is revealed that a party was seemingly being thrown in their honor.
Malik is arrested, and Aaron visits him in jail to inform him that he and Kayla are moving to get away from him. Aaron later discovers the video tape from 1985 and sees footage of Marshall, Tiffany, and Tyler socializing with the couple and their daughter. Suddenly, a group of hooded figures appear in the house, and Aaron discovers Tyler eating the intestines of Kayla’s body. Meanwhile, Marshall, now alive, visits Malik and tells him that Aaron and Kayla will be murdered, and he will be framed and appear to have committed suicide. Marshall explains that the neighborhood has a history of eliminating newcoming families who represent society’s fear of an evolving culture.
It it revealed that Malik documented all of the events and downloaded the information onto a CD-rom to warn the next family. Ten years later, a South Asian couple and their daughter moves into the house, and the wife finds the CD-rom hidden in the attic.
